I finish my glass of champagne before making some polite excuses and heading back to my waiting limo. I give the driver Caspian's address and tighten my fists as we start on our journey.
It's time for the toy to pay.
* * *
"What the fuck are you doing?"
I can hear her cries from all the way outside, and a moment later, Caspian, Julian and Lai appear, holding her firmly. I smirk at her, and her eyes shoot daggers at me as they meet mine.
"Why did you bring me here?" she barks. "I want to go home. Now!"
"Well well well," I say, crossing my arms. "If it isn't the birthday girl."
"Fuck you," she snarls. "I don't want to spend my birthday with you."
"Unfortunately, that's not your choice."
I come up to her, touching my fingers to her chin. She raises it defiantly, making me chuckle.
"You really think you're the gamemaster here, don't you?" I ask her. "You want to be treated like Lily Anna? Be my goddamn guest."
"What d-do you m-mean?" she stutters. "Let me go, or I'm going to scream."
"No one will help you," I tell her cruelly, taking a step back and addressing the guys next. "I'll be back in three hours. I don't give a shit what you do with her as long as she's still a virgin when I get back."
"Dexter!" Pandora cries out. "Don't do this, please..."
"You don't tell me what I can or can't do," I tell her. "Obey, if you want it to hurt less. Oh, and one last thing..."
I shake hands with Lai, winking at him as she dissolves into whimpers, begging me not to leave her there. But I have no mercy for her. Not after everything she's done to fuck with me. I head out of the room, the wailing sound of her crying following in my footsteps. She does look so very pretty when she cries. It makes it almost impossible not to make her do it every second of every day.
With one last look over my shoulder, I smile at the predicament my toy has found herself in and throw out one final order.
"Leave her tied up for me.”
Seventeen
Pandora
I knew getting dressed as Lily Anna was a risky idea, but I couldn't help myself. I wanted to see their faces when they saw me walking down that staircase, every one of them responsible for my fate. Of course, I didn't count on them making me pay for it.
I'm terrified, and I have no idea where Dexter is. My whole body is shaking as I kneel in front of the three other boys - Caspian, Lai and Julian.
"Please don't hurt me," I beg them.
"Why wouldn't we?" Lai speaks up. "You've been nothing but a disobedient bitch."
"Because you just treat me like property!" I speak up, enraged. "You act like you own people!"
"This is so boring," Julian whines. "I want to fuck her mouth already."
"Fine, do it," Lai shrugs. "And get her clothes off."
I can't believe this is happening. Julian reaches me in three quick steps, grabbing a pair of scissors from the desk in the office, and slicing through my dress until I'm left in my pale pink bra and thong.
"No!" I snarl, kicking at him yet missing every time.
He attacks my panties next, and I'm forced to stay still as he cuts through the fabric. I'm left exposed and panting.
"Whose cock do you want to suck first?" Caspian speaks up for the first time. "I'm hoping me, because man am I fucking excited to fuck that throat of yours."
I scream at the top of my voice. Caspian reaches me in two steps and slaps me across the face, hard as hell, enough to send me flying back.
"Don't you dare make any noise," he warns me. "You'll only make matters worse for yourself. Understood?"
I nod, staring at him with a contempt-filled gaze.
"You don't have to suck dick yet," he murmurs, touching his fingertips to my burning cheek. "But I do want to make you come."
There seems to be a natural hierarchy amid the boys, and the other two follow Caspian's voice instead of Dexter's this time. I’m a helpless toy ready for the slaughter with them around.
I stare up at them, my eyes lowering to meet Caspian’s as he kneels next to me.
“Now tell me, Pandora,” he says. “Do you like your pussy licked, your clit toyed with, or do you prefer fingers in that pretty cunt?”
“None of the above,” I grit out.
“That just can’t be true!” His eyes widen in mock horror. “We’ll have to see, won’t we? How about each one of us gives you one of those things, help you figure it out?”
I just glare at him without giving him a response, but truth be told, my heart is hammering faster than ever and my pussy is leaking between my legs. I’m embarrassed, ashamed of my reaction to the cruel things they do. Yet I can’t seem to stop myself.
“I’ll go fist,” Lai steps forward, grabbing me by the hair and pulling me to my feet. “And I pick her clit.”
The other two boys move aside, allowing him full access to me as he slams me down on the desk in the room. He stands behind me as I whimper, his fingers spreading my pussy lips open. I breathe out when the air hits my sensitive clit, and he laughs, touching his fingers to the now exposed button.
“It really is fucking pretty,” he mutters. “Let’s see how long it takes to make you sing.”
He toys with me relentlessly, without any sign of stopping. His fingers pinch, tug, caress me, and I start seeing stars in front of my eyes from the sensations he’s making me feel. Before I can stop myself, I’m moaning, begging for more with my eyes locked on his.
“So easy,” he mutters, but it seems to make him even more eager.
He touches my cheek to the wood of the desk, holding me down as he brings me closer and closer to an orgasm. I’m building up to it when he pulls his fingers back, and I cry out in protest as he leans down next to me.
“Come,” he whispers in my ear.
I don’t want to follow his orders, but my body does. I arch my back, eager for him to do so much more to me. My back arches and I come like a gun going off, loud.
“My turn.”
I’m still gasping when Julian comes to me. “Fingers in her cunt. That looked too good not to try.”
I want to beg him not to but I’m still coming. He takes Lai’s place, carefully touching his fingertips to my soaked, exposed pussy.
“Look at that,” he mutters. “Goddamn, Dexter’s a lucky man.”
He slides his finger around my opening.
“I think I’m not supposed to go in there…” he mutters, and I cry out when he tests my pussy for resistance. “I so easily could, though. It would be so much fun.”
I mewl as he fucks his fingers as deep as they go, so eager for more I’m embarrassed by the sounds coming out of my mouth.
“She’s so close already,” Caspian speaks up. “Just make her come already, I want my turn.”
Julian doesn’t need to be told twice, and he expertly massages my pussy until I’m gasping for more. In moments, I’m coming apart yet again, my cheeks flushed and wet from the tears I don’t remember crying.
Caspian shoves Julian out of the way before kneeling behind me.
“I’ve wanted to do this for so long.” He parts my folds and examines me from up close. “Your pussy is so perfect. Wish I could stare at that all day long instead of your face.”
Shame burns through my body as he buries his tongue in me, licking, flicking and torturing every inch of my sensitive flesh. His orgasm takes barely any effort – or maybe he’s so skilled in doing this, he knows how to bring me to the brink in mere seconds.
“Save that one.”
He pulls back and slaps me on the ass.
“W-What?” I mutter.
“Save it for Dexter,” he says. “Time to go.”
He motions to Lai and Julian, and they take out the belts out of their pants. Before I can object, they manhandle me, strip me of my bra and tie me up with their belts. They leave me like that, on the office chair, gasping in disbelief.
“You can’t do this!” I cry out. “You can’t
just leave me here!”
“Watch us,” Caspian shrugs. “Hope you’re ready for your punishment. Dex was pretty pissed.”
The door closes to the sound of my outraged scream.
Eighteen
Dexter
When I come to a stop in front of Caspian's father's office, it's dark outside. A single lamp is on in the study, casting long shadows down the quiet hallway I'm standing in.
I push the door open with my pointer finger, smirking to myself when I hear it creak. Her gasp follows right after, followed by a sweet moan that makes her sound like a trapped animal.
And once I walk in, I realize she is in a trap indeed.
"Oh my, my, my," I mutter, clicking my tongue as I walk toward her. "You've found yourself in a bit of a predicament, haven't you?"
"Fuck you," she spits out, thrashing violently against the belts holding her in place. "I want you to get me out of here. Now!"
I wrap my fingers around her throat. Pandora gasps against them, and I can feel her throat moving beneath my knuckles. I touch her bare pussy with my free hand.
She shivers beneath me, crying out in protest. Caspian did well. Her arms are tied with a belt at the wrists, firmly placed on the small of her back so her chest arches out provocatively. He's tied her legs over her head. And she's naked.
My blood boils at the thought of any of the guys seeing her this way. I'm jealous as fuck, but I'll never admit that to her. I unzip my pants slowly, watching her hungry eyes devouring me. I pull out my cock. I'm fucking throbbing, my tip vibrating, the shade a deep red. Pandora swallows thickly.
"I hate you more than ever,” she whispers. “You may marry me. You may think you own me. But no matter how many of your family diamonds you put on me, I'll never be yours. You can't control me. You can hurt me. Rape me. Make me crawl for you. But I will never like you.”
"You already like me,” I remind her.
“Never.”
“Really?” I laugh in her face. “Let’s see. You come for me. You obey me. You’re still here, aren’t you?”
“Because you tied me up!”
“Because you want this.” I smirk. “It’s adorable. I can do whatever the hell I want to you and you’ll keep coming back for more. You really are a glutton for punishment, Pandora.”
“You’re really dumb if you think that’s it,” she hisses.
“Then please, enlighten me. What’s the actual reason you keep letting me do this to you?”
She grits her teeth.
"Because you think breaking girls gives you power. You think if you steal something, and lock it away, it'll never belong to anybody else. But what you're forgetting is, it'll never belong to you, either. And I’m going to prove that to you. When I leave, I’m going to make sure your heart is broken.”
“You really think you’re capable of hurting me like that?” I ask thoughtfully.
“I know it,” she says defiantly. “And I can’t wait to see you as broken as you’ve tried to make me-”
"Shut the fuck up," I growl at her, slapping her pussy so hard she jumps in the restraints. "Seriously, Pandora. I don't have time for your nonsense. You dressed up as my girl today. You made fun of her memory. You made her a fucking mockery. You know you need to be punished for that, don’t you?”
She pouts, glaring at me.
"I'm gonna take that as a yes," I go on. "You're going to suck my dick now so I can see if you learned anything from Audra's lesson."
"Never," she hisses.
"Open."
She shakes her head no, her jaw firmly set in place. I sneer at her, grabbing her by the forehead and pressing my soaked tip to her lips. I don't have to say a word. Her instincts take over, and her lips part, allowing me to slip into her mouth all the way into her throat.
"Goddamn," I mutter. "Your fucking mouth is a tight as that untouched pussy."
She licks me, her whimpers and cries a sharp contrast to the desperation with which she sucks my dick. I want to laugh at her, but I'm preoccupied by burying my fingers in her hair and allowing her to bob her head on my cock. I tilt my head back, groan by groan tearing itself from my lips as she pleasures me.
"You need to go slower," I tell her, pulling my cock free with a warning glance. "I'm going to fucking burst if you don't."
"Fuck me."
I look at her like she's crazy. Her glazed eyes tell me everything I need to know.
"Fuck me," she repeats, a sob escaping her lips. "Please. Fuck me. End this torture. Just take it."
"Why do you want me to fuck you?" I narrow my eyes at her.
"I just want it to be over,” I whisper. “I just want this… this freaking torture to end.”
"You do?" I rub my precum over her lips. "I’m gonna remember you said that, toy."
I take a step back, enjoying her desperate attempts to get closer as I pull a rubber out of my pocket. I look at her as I tear it open, her eyes widening with a mix of horror and delirious expectation. I'm half expecting her to tell me not to do it, to forget the condom, and just fuck her like that.
"You know I can't fuck you, Pandora." I roll the condom on my cock, never taking my eyes off hers. "You know your father would kill me if I did that. It's tradition, and we don't go against tradition in Eden Falls."
She's about to speak up, but I don't let her.
"Be quiet," I warn her. "Or I'm going to gag you. See this cock?"
She nods, frozen to the spot.
"You're going to watch it cum now."
She's barely blinking as she stares me down.
I make sure to step a little closer, just out of reach of her mouth, but close enough so her tied fingers can touch my leg. She digs her nails in, her eyes fluttering with silent pleas for more, and I start jerking off.
I know I'm going to burst, but I prolong the moment as long as I am able to. I stroke my cock, pull it, show it off to her. She's a fucking mess by the time I know I'm going to fill that condom up.
I come with a groan. I come so much I'm convinced the condom will just... pop. I want to fucking collapse on the floor, but instead, I carefully peel it off, making sure every drop is left inside. I show it to Pandora, inches away from her lips. She doesn't say a word. I smirk, putting it on her belly. She's shivering, her skin on her navel covered in goosebumps.
"You wanted my cum, didn't you?" I ask her, and she just keeps staring, her chest rising and falling alarmingly fast.
"Not like t-that," she whispers.
"No? You think you have a choice?" I keep toying with my cock, using my free hand to touch her reddened cheek. "Where did you want it?"
"In..." Her bottom lip wobbles. "In my pussy... I want to know what it feels like."
"Stupid toy. How am I supposed to put it there if it hasn't even been fucked open yet?"
"You know you can't," she reminds me. "Not until..."
"Yeah, yeah, yeah," I interrupt. "Not until we’re married.”
She's trembling as I take the condom off her, carefully handling the cum inside.
"I mean, I could certainly try to do something to satisfy your craving, but who knows if it would be enough for a dirty little girl like you."
The first heavy tear slips down her cheek. She’s obviously ashamed of breaking down like this, but I fucking love it.
"Let's see," I mutter, holding the condom over her pussy. "You want me to try, toy?"
"Okay," she whispers, and I turn the rubber upside down, using two fingers to squeeze it.
Pandora cries out loud when drops of cum start to rain on her body.
"Don't!" Her voice is loud and shrill. "Don't do that, are you fucking crazy?"
I ignore her, muttering her name under my breath as a warning.
"Dexter, stop it, stop!"
"Why would I stop, toy? You love it so much," I smile at her. "Look at that, look at it soak your pretty pussy."
"F-Fuck, no," she stammers. "Don't, don't, don't."
Her little hands strain against the belt, but to no av
ail. I look into her eyes as I empty the condom, placing what's left of it on her belly. I start rubbing my seed over her pussy, taking care to massage it deep into her as far inside her as I can go. She starts to cry. She looks so fucking pretty.
"Oh my god," she repeats over and over again. "You're so fucked up, you're so sick, I hate you so much."
"Shhh, toy, you need this as much as I do. Look at that, your pussy's just drinking me up. Come on, toy, look down, right here between your legs. Just watch it soak me up. Watch how it wants me."
I gently tilt her head down, and she gasps, opening her eyes and watching me take it with tears slipping down her cheeks.
"See that?" I whisper gently. "See, toy, you were fucking made for this, made to take all my loads. You know what? I wish I could get you pregnant like this. My little innocent toy. Never fucked, and you'd already have my baby in your belly..."
I feel her skin under my fingertips, and she dissolves in whispered no's as I massage it with my fingers smeared with cum.
"Goddamn, I could just break it right now," I mutter. "Just take the choice away from you, put the rest of this inside you. You want it, don't you?"
"I... I... I..." She's hiccupping, and it makes me smile. "I do, I want it."
"You do?"
"I do, I do, please, I do."
"It would be so easy." I try the skin, pushing, not quite hard enough to break through. "Just push a little bit deeper and I'd be in..."
Pandora's eyes close and I can see her lips moving in a silent prayer, probably something she picked up at St Cecile.
"But I think I'm going to leave that pleasure for my cock." I pull out of her and she cries out in protest. "We have to keep playing, don't we, toy? Don't want you getting bored."
I take the condom again, using it to wet my cock with my seed from before.
A Hurt So Sweet Volume One: A Dark High School Bully Romance Page 16