“Alice.”
“Yes,” she said softly. “And you.”
Max lay beside her, holding her naked body close, and stared up at the ceiling. It had been a long time since he’d felt this way. He wanted to spend the night with Julia, to wake up beside her, to kiss her good morning and talk about whatever came to mind.
In ordinary times that might have been possible; these were far from ordinary times. A part of her was breaking apart right now; she was holding herself together by sheer force of will.
He rolled onto his side and looked down at her. “You’re so beautiful,” he said, tracing her full lower lip with his finger.
“You, too,” she said with a smile. Her nose brushed his chin. When she smiled, her pale green eyes made him think of misty rain-forest mornings. Cool and deep and somehow magical.
“You’re turning me into a romantic,” he said.
“Then you already were one.”
He smiled at that. “You shrinks always know what to say, don’t you?”
She stared at him a long time before she answered. “Don’t lie to me, Max. That’s all I ask, okay? Don’t pretend to feel something if you don’t.”
“I’ve never pretended with you, Julia.”
“Then tell me something real.”
“Like?”
She glanced over at the bureau along the wall. There were several framed pictures displayed. Images from his life Before. “Like about your marriage.”
“Her name was Susan O’Connell. We met in college. I loved her from the first moment I saw her.”
“Until?”
He looked away for a second, then realized it was useless. Her keen eyes saw everything; certainly, he couldn’t hide this pain by looking away. “Believe me, now isn’t the right time for this conversation.”
“Will there be a time for it?”
“Yes,” he said softly.
She kissed him gently, then drew back. “I better go. Alice has trouble sleeping. She’ll panic if she wakes and I’m gone.” As she said the girl’s name, her voice wavered.
“The courts will see you’re best for her.”
“The courts,” she said with a heavy sigh.
“You don’t believe they’ll do the right thing?”
“The truth is, I can’t think about all that right now. If I do, I’ll fall apart. For now, I’m going to focus on proving that he’s an unfit parent. One step at a time.”
“You’ll need me.”
The smile she gave him was slow and steady. It released something in his chest, made breathing easier somehow. “I certainly will.”
The night passed for Ellie in a river of black dreams and frightening images. When she woke—at dawn—she was edgy and nervous. The first thing she did was pull out the file. Already, she’d read the words so often she’d almost memorized them. In the last twenty-four hours she’d personally spoken to every single police officer who’d worked the Azelle case. In addition, she’d spent nearly an hour on the phone with the best private detective in King County.
Every person she spoke to and every report she read said the same thing.
He was guilty.
And the state hadn’t proved it.
Ellie paced the living room. The dogs followed her everywhere, running into her every time she turned. They were upset by her energy. It was on her shoulders to prove that Azelle was a bad guy, an unfit parent, but so far all she could find was a layer of innuendo, a fog of accusation.
He was an adulterer; that was a fact. The only one she’d been able to nail down. Neighbors thought he hit his wife. Jurors believed he’d killed her, but on the basis of nothing concrete. And the media . . .
Every journalist she’d spoken to was certain he’d done it. Guilty son of a bitch was the label most often used to describe him. But not one story had uncovered previous bad acts. No drug charges, no DUI, not even a Drunk and Disorderly.
With a curse, she grabbed her files and left the house.
She drove straight to the Rain Drop. The diner was the only place open this early in the morning. As usual, it was full of loggers and fishermen and mill workers having breakfast before work. She stopped and talked to people in every booth as she made her way to the cash register.
Rosie Chicowski was behind the hostess desk, smoking a cigarette. Blue smoke spiraled upward, joined with the hazy cloud that was always there.
“Hey, Ellie, you’re in early,” she said, pulling the cigarette from her mouth and stabbing it out in the ashtray. Patrons had been smoking in the Rain Drop for fifty years. No state law was going to change that.
“I need some caffeine.”
Rosie laughed. “You got it. How about one of Barb’s marionberry muffins to go with it?”
“Thanks. Only one, though. Shoot me if I try to order another.”
“Flesh wound or kill yah?”
“Kill me.” Laughing, Ellie turned around, heading back for a booth in the empty nonsmoking section of the diner.
It was a moment before she saw him.
He sat sprawled across the burgundy vinyl booth, an empty coffee cup in front of him. He saw her and nodded.
Ellie walked over to him. “Mr. Azelle,” she said. “Hello, Chief Barton.”
He did not look pleased to see her. His gaze flicked over the heavy manila folder she carried.
“Can I join you? I have some questions to ask you.”
He sighed. “Of course you do.”
She sidled into the booth across from him. She looked at him, trying to really see him, but all she saw were tired eyes and deep frown lines. As she was marshaling her thoughts into a question, he said, “Three years.”
“Three years what?”
Leaning toward her, he looked deeply into her eyes. “I was in prison for a crime I didn’t commit. Hell, I didn’t even know about it. I thought Zoë had left me for one of her lovers and taken our kid.” The intensity in his eyes was unnerving. “Imagine how it would feel to be convicted of something terrible—horrific—and put in a cage to rot. And why? Because you made bad choices and let passion rule your life. So I had affairs. So I lied to my wife and family about that. So I sent her flowers after a knock-down and drag-out fight. It doesn’t make me a killer.”
“The jury—”
“The jury,” he said with contempt. “They couldn’t see past my life. Every newspaper and TV station called me guilty within five minutes. No one even looked for Zoë and Brit. Two eyewitnesses saw a strange van on my street the day my family went missing—and no one cared. The police didn’t even bother to search for a white guy in a yellow slicker and Batman baseball cap who drove a grayish Chevy van. When I offered money for information, they compared me to O.J. For the last month I’ve been waiting every day for the DNA analysis that would give my daughter back to me. I had to get a court order to compare her DNA to the blood found at the scene. And when I get it, I race up here . . . only to find that your sister is going to fight me for custody.”
Rosie showed up at the table. “Here’s your coffee and muffin, Ellie. I put ’em on your tab.” She grinned. “Along with a healthy tip.”
When Rosie left, Azelle leaned across the table. “Do you believe me?”
She heard a crack in his voice, an uncertainty that bothered her. “You want me to see an innocent man,” she said slowly, watching him.
“I am innocent. It’ll be easier on all of us if you believe that.”
“It would certainly be easier on you.”
“How is she? Can you at least tell me that? Does she still suck her thumb? Does she—”
Ellie stood up quickly, needing distance between them. She didn’t want to hear what he knew about their girl. “Alice needs Julia. Can you understand that?”
“There is no Alice,” he said.
Ellie walked away, not daring to look back. She was almost to the door when she heard him call out to her: “You tell your sister I’m coming, Chief Barton. I won’t lose my daughter twice.”
The next forty-eight hours unfolded in a kind of faded slow motion. The snow stopped falling. In its wake, the world was sparkling and white. Julia spent every hour working. During the day, she was with Alice, teaching her new words, taking her outside to make snow angels in the backyard. Several times during the day Alice asked about her wolf and pointed to the car. Julia gently turned her attention back to whatever they were doing. If Alice wondered why she kept kissing her cheek or holding her hand, she showed no sign of it.
But it was the nighttime hours that mattered most right now. She and Ellie and Peanut and Cal and the private detective worked all night long, poring through police reports and newspaper accounts and archived videotape. After a long shift at the hospital, Max showed up to help. They read or watched everything they could find on George Azelle. By Monday morning, when the meetings were over, they knew every fact of his life.
And none of it would help them.
“Read Girl?”
Julia drew her thoughts back in and glanced at the clock. It was nearly two o’clock. “No reading now,” she said softly. “Cal is bringing Sarah over to play with you. Do you remember Sarah?”
Alice frowned. “Jewlee stay?”
Such an ordinary question. “Not right now, honey. I’ll be back, though.”
Alice smiled at that. “Jewlee back.”
Julia dropped to her knees. Before she could figure out what exactly to say, the front door opened. Ellie, Cal, and Sarah walked into the house.
No one bothered to say anything.
Sarah showed Alice a pair of Barbie dolls.
Alice didn’t respond, but she couldn’t look away from the dolls. After a few moments the girls wandered into the living room, where they played separately side by side. Alice still didn’t know how to interact with other children, but Sarah didn’t seem to mind.
Ellie touched Julia’s arm. “You ready?”
Julia forced a smile and reached down for her briefcase. On the way out she stopped to talk to Cal. She meant to say, When Alice feels comfortable, she’ll talk to Sarah, but when she opened her mouth, nothing came out.
“Good luck,” he said softly, squeezing her arm for comfort.
Nodding, she followed Ellie out to the cruiser.
In a silence broken only by the thump-thump of the windshield wipers, they drove to the county courthouse. It was a tall gray-stone building set on a hill above the harbor. The wild blue Pacific made a stunning backdrop; today, the gray sky blurred the horizon, made everything appear watery and indistinct.
Family Court was on the main floor, at the very end of a hallway. Of all the courts Julia had once frequented, Family was her least favorite. Here, hearts were broken every day.
Julia paused, straightening her navy suit, then she opened the door and went inside. Her high heels clicked on the marble floor. Ellie matched her step for step, looking ultraconfident in her gold-starred uniform. They passed Max and Peanut, who were seated together in the back row of the gallery.
George Azelle was already seated in the front of the courtroom, with an attorney beside him.
He saw them and rose from his seat, moving toward them. He wore a charcoal-gray suit and a crisp white shirt. His hair had been tamed into a smooth ponytail. “Dr. Cates. Chief Barton.”
“Mr. Azelle,” Ellie said.
Behind them the courtroom doors banged open. Julia’s attorney, John MacDonald, bustled in, carrying a worn leatherette briefcase. He looked tired, which was hardly surprising, given that they’d all been up until four o’clock that morning, looking for anything to use against Azelle. “Sorry I’m late.”
George looked at the opposing counsel, no doubt noting John’s brown corduroy suit and pilled green shirt. “I’m George Azelle,” he said, reaching for the man’s hand.
“Oh. Hullo,” John said, then herded Julia and Ellie to their desk.
The judge entered the courtroom and took her seat. From there, she stared down at all of them. Without preamble, she began. “I’ve read your motion, Mr. Azelle. As you know, Dr. Cates has been temporary foster parent for your daughter for nearly four months and had recently begun adoption proceedings.”
“That was before, Your Honor, when the child’s identity was unknown,” his attorney said.
“I’m well aware of the time sequence, and I understand the procedural history of this case. The question for this court is placement of the minor child. Obviously, public policy favors the reunification of biological families whenever possible, but these are far from ordinary family circumstances.”
“Mr. Azelle has a history of domestic violence, Your Honor,” John said.
“Objection!” Azelle’s attorney was on his feet again.
“Sit down, Counsel. I know he’s never been formally charged with that.” The judge took off her reading glasses and set them on her desk, then looked at Julia. “The white elephant in this courtroom is you, Dr. Cates. You’re hardly the average foster parent seeking permanent custody. You’re one of the preeminent child psychiatrists in this country.”
“I’m not here in that capacity, Your Honor.”
“I’m aware of that, Doctor. It would represent a conflict of interest. You’re here because you won’t withdraw your petition for adoption.”
John started to stand up. Julia stopped him with a touch. No one could plead for Alice better than she could. She looked up at the judge, said, “In any other instance, Your Honor, I would have withdrawn if a family member had come forward. But I’ve read the records in this case and I’m deeply concerned for the child’s safety. The mother’s body has never been found and there’s no finding of not guilty on the record. Mr. Azelle claims to be innocent, but in my experience most guilty people do. I just want what’s best for this poor child who has already suffered so much. As you can see from my report, she’s an extremely traumatized child. Until recently, she was completely mute. I’m making progress with her because she trusts me. To remove her from my care would cause her irreparable harm.”
“Come on, Your Honor,” Azelle’s attorney said. “She’s a psychiatrist. My client can afford to replace her. The truth is, my client has already suffered a tremendous loss of time with his daughter. Justice demands that he be given immediate custody.”
The judge put her glasses back on and looked at them all. “I’m going to take this under advisement. I’ll appoint a guardian ad litem to assess the child’s special needs and current condition and let you know when I’ve reached a decision. Until then, the child will remain with Dr. Cates. Mr. Azelle is to be granted supervised visitation.”
The attorney shot to his feet. “But, Your Honor—”
“That’s my ruling, Counselor. We’re going to proceed with the utmost care here. This child has already suffered enough. And I’m sure your client only wants what’s best for his daughter.” She hit the bench with her gavel. “Next case.”
It took Julia a moment to process what had just happened. She still had custody of Alice—for now, at least.
She heard John talking to Ellie about the logistics of visitation.
Julia knew all that. She couldn’t count the number of times she’d been appointed guardian ad litem to protect a child’s interests.
She eased away from the desk and started to leave the courtroom. In the back, by the doors, she saw Max waiting for her.
Then someone grabbed her arm. The grip was a little too tight.
George Azelle pulled her aside. His Hollywood smile was gone, watered down now by failure. In his eyes was a sadness she hadn’t expected. “I need to see her.”
She had no choice but to agree. “Tomorrow. But I won’t tell her who you are. She wouldn’t understand, anyway. We’re at 1617 River Road. Be there at one.” She pulled free of his arm and began to walk away.
He grabbed her again.
She looked down at his long, tanned fingers, wrapped possessively around her bicep. He was a man used to taking what he wanted; he didn’t care much about crossing personal space boundar
ies, either. “Release me, Mr. Azelle.”
He complied instantly.
She expected him to back away—cowards who were called out usually did, and men who beat their wives were always cowards and bullies—but he didn’t. He stood there, towering over her and yet cowed somehow, bent.
“How is she?” he asked finally.
She would have sworn there was a fissure in his voice, that the words hurt him to say. Murderers and sociopaths were often great actors, she reminded herself. “It’s about time you asked that.”
“You think you know me, Dr. Cates. The whole world does.” He backed away, sighing, shoving a hand through his hair and pulling his ponytail free. “Christ, I’m tired of fighting a war I can’t win. So just tell me: How’s my daughter? What the hell does developmentally delayed mean?”
“She’s been through hell, but she’s coming through. She’s a tough, loving little girl who needs a lot of therapy and stability.”
“And you think I’m unstable?”
“As you’ve pointed out, I don’t know you.” She reached into her briefcase and withdrew a stack of videocasette tapes, which she handed to him. “I made these for you. They’re tapes of our sessions. They will answer some of your questions.”
He took them cautiously, as if he were afraid the black plastic would burn him. “Where has she been?” he finally asked. This time his voice was velvety soft; she was reminded of his Louisiana roots. According to the trial transcripts, he’d been raised dirt poor in the bayou.
“We don’t know. Somewhere in the woods, we think.” Julia wouldn’t let herself be fooled by the concern in his voice. He was playing her; she was sure of it. He wanted her to think he was a victim in this, too. “But I suspect you know that.”
Ellie came up beside Julia, touched her arm. “Everything okay?”
Wild Page 32