Mudge smiled. “Sean is little more than a figurehead who signs the papers we put in front of him. He is also a first-class patriot, having volunteered for the secret but necessary role of government scapegoat. In Sean’s name we make all dubious, unpopular, or questionable decisions. When they turn out well, the Chiefs take the credit. When they turn out badly, Sean takes the blame. In this way, the usefulness of the many is not impaired.”
“It must be very hard on Sean,” Joenes said.
“Of course it is. But perhaps Sean would not be happy if things were not very hard on him. So a psychologist friend of mine believes. Another psychologist of my acquaintance, of a more mystical turn of mind, believes that Sean Feinstein is fulfilling an obligatory historical function, that he is destined to be a prime mover of men and events, a crucial figure in all histories, and a vital force in the enlightenment of the people; and that for these reasons he is detested and reviled by the populace he serves. But wherever the truth lies, I find Sean an extremely necessary person.”
“I would like to meet him and shake his hand,” Joenes said.
‘That will not be possible just yet,” Mudge said. “Sean is presently serving a term of solitary confinement upon a diet of bread and water. He was found guilty of stealing 24 atomic howitzers and 187 atomic grenades from the U.S. Army.”
“Did he actually steal those things?” Joenes asked.
“Yes. But he did so at our request. We armed a Signal Corps Detachment with them, and they succeeded in winning the battle of Rosy Gulch in southeastern Bolivia. The Signal Corps, I might add, had long requested those weapons in vain.”
“I am very sorry for Sean,” Joenes said. “What is his sentence?”
“Death,” said Mudge. “But he will be pardoned. He always is. Sean is too important not to be pardoned.”
Mudge looked away for a moment, then turned back to Joenes.
“Your particular work,” Mudge said, “will be of the utmost importance. We are sending you to Russia on a tour of inspection and analysis. Many such inspections have been made in the past, of course. But either they have been made from the bias of one Service, in which case they are worthless, or they have been made from a coordinated standpoint, in which case they have been marked Top Secret and filed unread in the Top Secret room beneath Fort Knox. I have my chiefs assurance, and I give you mine, that no such fate will befall your report. It will be read and acted upon. We are determined to impose Coordination, and anything you say about the enemy will be accepted and utilized. Now, Joenes, you will receive a full clearance, then a briefing, then orders.”
Mudge took Joenes to Security Division, where a colonel in charge of Phrenology felt his head for suspicious bumps. After that, Joenes ran the gauntlet of government astrologists, card-readers, tea-leaf readers, physiognomists, psychologists, casuists, and computers. At the end he was declared loyal, sane, responsible, trustworthy, reverent, and above all, lucky. On the basis of this he was given a Portmanteau Clearance and allowed to read classified documents.
We have only a partial list of the papers which Joenes read in the gray iron Secrets Room, with two armed guards standing beside him, blindfolded to be sure they would not inadvertently glance at the precious documents. But we know that Joenes read:
‘The Yalta Papers,” which told of the historic meeting between President Roosevelt, Czar Nicholas II, and Emperor Ming. Joenes learned how the fateful decisions made in Yalta affected present-day politics; and he learned of the violent opposition to those decisions which were voiced by Don Winslow, the Supreme Naval Commander.
Next he read, “I was a Male War Bride,” a devastating expose of unnatural practices in the Armed Services.
And he also read the following:
“Little Orphan Annie Meets Wolf Man,” a detailed espionage manual written by one of the most accomplished female spies who ever lived.
“Tarzan and the Black City,” an extraordinary account of commando activities in Russian-held East Africa.”
“The Cantos,” author unknown, a cryptic statement of the enemy’s monetary and racial theories.
“Buck Rogers Enters Mungo,” a documentary account of the latest exploit of the Space Corps, illustrated.
“First Principles,” by Spencer, “The Apocrypha,” author unknown, “The Republic,” by Plato, and “Maleus Malificarum,” jointly authored by Torquemada, Bishop Berkeley, and Harpo Marx. These four works were the soul and spearhead of communist doctrine, and we can be sure that Joenes read them with great profit.
Of course he also read “The Playboy of the Western World,” by Emmanuel Kant, which was the definitive refutation of the above-mentioned communist works.
All of these things have been lost to us, due to the unfortunate circumstances of their having been written on paper instead of learned by heart. We would give much to know the substance of those works which shaped the brilliant and erratic politics of the times. And we cannot help but ask whether Joenes read the few 20th century classics which have come down to our own time, Did he peruse the stirring “Boots,” cast in enduring bronze? Did he read “The Practical Man’s Guide to Real Estate,” that monumental fantasy which almost singlehandedly shaped the temper of the 20th century? Did Joenes ever meet the venerable Robinson Crusoe, his contemporary, greatest of the 20th century poets? Did he speak with any of the members of the Swiss Family Robinson, whose sculptures can be seen in many of our museums?
Alas, Joenes never spoke of these cultural things. Instead, his accounts focus upon matters which were of far greater concern to his beleaguered age.
So it was that Joenes, after reading steadily for three days and three nights, arose and left the gray iron Secrets Room and its blindfolded guards. He was now fully cognizant of the state of the nation and of the world. With high hopes and dire forebodings he opened his orders.
These orders instructed him to report to room 18891, floor 12, level 6, wing 63, subsection AJB-2, of the Octagon. With the orders was a map to aid him in finding his way around that massive structure. When he had come to room 18891, a high Octagon official known only as Mr. M. would give him his final instructions, and arrange his departure on a special jet for Russia.
Joenes’s heart filled with joy when he read these orders, for at last he had a chance to play a part in great affairs. He rushed off to the Octagon to receive his final instructions and be off. But the duty Joenes wished to perform was not so easily captured as all that.
11. THE OCTAGON ADVENTURES
(The Octagon Adventures and the four stories which comprise it are told by Maubingi of Tahiti.)
Afire with anticipation, Joenes entered the Octagon. He stared around him for a moment, never having imagined that so enormous and majestic a building could exist. Then, recovering, he walked swiftly down great halls and corridors, up stairways, through bypasses, across lobbies, and down more corridors.
By the time his first flush of enthusiasm had worn off, he was able to see that his map was hopelessly incorrect, for its various designations bore no reference to anything he saw around him. It seemed, in fact, to be a map of a different building. Joenes was now deep in the heart of the Octagon, unsure of the way which lay ahead, dubious of his ability to retrace his footsteps. Therefore he put the map in his pocket and decided to ask advice of the first person he met.
Soon he overtook a man walking down the corridor. This man wore the uniform of a colonel in the Cartography Department, and his bearing was kindly and distinguished.
Joenes stopped the colonel, explaining that he was lost and that his map seemed to be useless.
The colonel glanced at Joenes’s map and said, “Oh, yes, that’s perfectly in order. This map is our Octagon Series A443-32 IB, which my office published only last week.”
“But it doesn’t tell me anything,” Joenes said.
“You’re damned right it doesn’t,” the colonel answered proudly. “Do you have any idea how important this building is? Did you know that every top government a
gency, including the most secret ones, are housed here?”
“I know that the building is very important,” Joenes said. “But—”
“Then you can understand the position we would be in,” the colonel went on, “if our enemies really understood the building and its office. Spies would infiltrate these corridors. Disguised as soldiers and congressmen, they would have access to our most vital information. No security measures could hope to restrain a cunning and determined spy armed with information like that. We would be lost, my dear sir, utterly lost. But a map like this, which is most confusing to a spy, is one of our most important safeguards.”
“I suppose it is,” Joenes said politely.
The Colonel of Cartography touched Joenes’s map lovingly and said, “You have no idea how difficult it is to make such a map.”
“Really?” Joenes said. “I would have thought it quite simple to construct a map of an imaginary place.”
“The layman always thinks that. Only a fellow mapmaker, or a spy, could appreciate our problems. To construct a map which tells nothing, and yet which seems true, giving even an expert the sensation of versimilitude—that, my friend, requires art of the highest order!”
“I’m sure it does,” Joenes said. “But why do you bother making a false map at all?”
“For the sake of security,” the colonel said. “But to understand that, you must know how a spy thinks when he gets a map like this; then you would see how this map strikes directly at the spy’s greatest weakness, rendering him more ineffectual than no map at all would do. And to understand all that, you must comprehend all mentality of a spy.”
Joenes admitted that he was bewildered by this explanation. But the colonel said it was merely a matter of understanding the nature of a spy. And to illustrate this nature, he then told Joenes a story about a spy, and how he behaved when he was in possession of the map.
THE STORY OF THE SPY
The spy (said the colonel) has overcome all previous obstacles. Armed with the precious map, he has penetrated deep into the building. Now he tries to use the map, and sees at once that it doesn’t represent the thing he seeks. But he also sees that the map is beautifully made and expensively printed on government paper; it bears a government serial number and a countersigned stamp of approval. It is a clear, lucid map, a triumph of the mapmaker’s skill.
Does the spy throw it away and attempt to draw the bewildering complexities around him on a wretched little pocket pad, using only a ball-point pen that doesn’t work very well? He most assuredly does not. Even though ultimate success might lie in that direction, our spy is only human. He does not wish to match his puny ability at visualizing, abstracting, drawing and generalizing, against experts in the field. It would take the highest courage and self-confidence for him to throw away this magnificent map and proceed with nothing but his senses to guide him. If he had the necessary qualities to do that, he would never have been a spy in the first place. He would have been a leader of men, or perhaps a great artist or scientist. But he is none of these things; he is a spy; which is to say, a man who has chosen to find out about things rather than to do things, and to discover what others know rather than to search for what he knows. Necessarily he assumes the existence of truths external to himself, since no real spy could believe that his life work was to discover frivolous falsehoods.
This is all very important when we consider the character of any spy, and especially of the spy who has stolen a government map and penetrated deep into the closely guarded building.
I think we might fairly call this spy both genuine and excellent, and imbued with extraordinary dedication, cunning, and perseverance. These qualities have brought him past all dangers to a place of vantage within the building. But these very qualities also tend to shape his thoughts, making certain actions possible and others not. So we must realize that the better he is at his work, the more superb his guile, the stronger his dedication, the longer his experience, the greater his patience, then the less able he is to put aside these virtues, throw away the map, take pen and blank paper in hand and scribble down what he sees. Perhaps the idea of discarding an official government map sounds simple to you; but the spy finds this concept distasteful, foreign, repugnant, and utterly alien to his genius.
Instead, the spy begins to reason about the map in spy-fashion, which he thinks is the only way there is of reasoning, but which we know is merely a way he has of avoiding a discrepancy which life has made manifest, but which instinct and reason reject.
Here is a genuine government-issued map, and there are various corridors and doorways. The spy looks at the map, that document similar to otter true and valuable documents he has risked his life to steal. He asks himself, “Can this map be false? I know that it issues from the government, and I know that I stole it from an official who evidently prized it and thought it valuable. Am I justified in ignoring this document simply because it seems to have no bearing on what I see around me?”
The spy ponders this question, and at last comes up with the operative word: seems. The map only seems to have no bearing! Appearance had momentarily deceived him. He was nearly led astray by the testimony of his senses. The makers of the map almost did this to him, a master of tricks and disguises, a man who has spent a lifetime in worming out their secrets. Of course, it is all explicable now.
The spy says, “They tried to fool me with my own tricks! Clumsily, of course, but at least they are starting to think in the right way.”
By this the spy means that they are starting to think as he does, thereby making their secrets more comprehensible to him. This pleases him. His bad humor, brought on by the lack of similarity between the map and the building, has now completely vanished. He is cheerful, energetic, prepared for any difficulty, ready to pursue this problem to its ultimate conclusion.
“Let me consider the facts and their implications,” says the spy. “First, I know this map is important. Everything about it, and everything I have ever experienced, leads me to that premise. I also know that the map does not seem to represent the building which it is supposed to represent. Quite obviously there is a relationship of some kind between the map and the building. What is this relationship, and what is the truth about the map?”
The spy thinks for a moment, then says., “The implication points to a cipher, a mystification which some skilled and cunning craftsman wove into the map, which the people for whom the map is intended know about, but which I hitherto did not know about.” After saying this, the spy draws himself to his full height and adds, “I, however, have spent a lifetime in the solving of ciphers. Indeed, there is nothing I am quite so interested in as ciphers. One might say that I was shaped by destiny to solve ciphers, and that destiny has conspired with chance to put me here, now, with this crucial coded document in my hand.”
Our spy feels exalted. But then he asks himself, “Am I not being dogmatic in insisting, at the very start of my investigation, that this document is a true ciphered map and no other thing? Experience has taught me the painful lesson that men are capable of devious thinking. I myself am the living proof of that, for my cunning ways of thinking and of acting have enabled me to remain hidden in the midst of my enemies, and to discover many of their secrets. Remembering that, don’t I do them an injustice not to allow them the possibility of similar cunning?”
“Very well,” the spy says. “Even though reason and instinct tell me that the map is true in every respect, and misleading only because I do not have the key to the cipher, I must admit the possibility of it being false in part, and therefore true only in part. There are good reasons one could give for this assumption. Suppose that the true part of the map is the only part which was needed by the official I stole it from. He, armed with a prior knowledge I do not have, would follow only the part which is true and pertinent to his work. Being the dull civil servant he is, and above all being uninterested in maps and ciphers, he would simply follow the true part to his office, and would ignore the false part. Th
e map itself, with its false section joined so cleverly to the true, would not bother him. And why should it? His work has nothing to do with maps. He has no more interest in the truth or falseness of the map than I have in the details of his petty job. Like me, he has no time to worry about complicated matters which do not concern him. He can use the map without doing violence to his feelings.”
The spy is amused and saddened when he thinks of this man, using the map but having no interest in it. How strange people are! How odd that the official made mere use of the map, but never questioned its mysterious nature; while the spy knows that the only important matter is a complete understanding of the map and what it represents. From this understanding all other things will flow, and the secrets of the entire building will be accessible. This seems so obvious to him that he can’t understand the official’s lack of concern with the map. The spy’s own interest seems to him so natural, so necessary, so universal, that he is almost led to believe that the official is not human, but is instead a member of some other species.
“But no,” he tells himself. “It may feel that way, but the real difference between the official and me probably lies in heredity, or in environmental influences, or something like that. I must not let it disturb me. I have always known how strange and unknowable human beings are. Even spies, the most easily understood people in the world, have different methods and hold different attitudes. Yes, it is a strange world, and I have very little knowledge of it. What do I know of history, psychology, music, art or literature? Oh, I could hold a sensible conversation on those subjects, but deep in my heart I know that I know nothing about them.”
The spy is unhappy about this.
But then he thinks, “Luckily, there is one thing which I do understand. That is spying. No man can do everything, and I have done very well to become the expert I am in my own field. In that expertness lies my hope and my salvation. In that very narrowness lies my true depth, and my yardstick with which to test the world. After all, I know a great deal about the history and psychology of spying, and I have read most of the literature of spying. I have looked at the famous paintings of spies, and have frequently heard the well-known opera about spies. Thus, my depth gives me breadth. My deep knowledge of this one thing gives me a firm base in the world. I can stand upon that base and look at other matters with a certain perspective.”
Various Fiction Page 226