The Inflamed Mind

Home > Other > The Inflamed Mind > Page 21
The Inflamed Mind Page 21

by Edward Bullmore

lack of souls 137

  research 137–8

  testing 12–13, 64, 91, 137, 137–8, 138–9, 192

  on mice 64, 91, 139–40, 192, 218

  on rats 12–13, 139, 140, 218

  tail suspension test 192–3, 195

  ankylosing spondylitis 59

  anorexia 72

  anthropomorphism 140

  anti-amyloid antibodies 211

  anti-cytokine antibody infusions 181

  anti-cytokine antibody trials 201

  anti-cytokine drugs 62, 64–6, 67, 203

  anti-depressant drugs 16, 18, 83–4, 93, 95, 157

  boosting effects of adrenaline and noradrenaline 99–100

  coupled to companion diagnostics 197–8

  lack of major new treatments 102, 111

  next generation 178

  personalised 197, 198–9

  Prozac see Prozac

  see also iproniazid; SSRIs (selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors)

  anti-inflammatory drugs 61–2, 187, 197

  causality 203

  clinical trials 187, 203–4

  inflammatory biomarkers 204

  negative results 204

  positive results 204

  effective treatment of depression 202

  licensed for depression 187

  reanalysing mental health data 202

  safety risks 187

  anti-TB drugs 90–1

  anti-TNF antibodies 64–6, 201, 203

  availability on NHS 66–7

  improved patients’ health 67

  global market 65 -6

  success of 65, 67

  testing on mice 64

  see also Remicade

  antibiotic drugs 90

  antibodies 9, 17, 22, 33, 38, 39, 41

  anti-amyloid 211

  auto-antibodies 41, 56, 57, 59, 219

  bad versus good 56–7

  see also anti-TNF antibodies; auto-antibodies

  antigens 22, 34, 38, 40

  anxiety 66, 169, 213

  aphasia 77

  Apothecaries’ Company, garden 85

  herbal remedies 85

  imported plants 85

  arterial macrophages 60

  arteries 59–60

  arthritis 44, 56, 58, 59, 61, 64, 147, 181

  see also rheumatoid arthritis

  aspirin 16, 187

  side effects 187

  Astra Zeneca 191

  atherosclerosis 59–60

  atherosclerotic arteries 152

  Auden, WH 76

  auricle 131

  auto-antibodies 41, 56, 57, 59, 219

  auto-immune disorders 56

  auto-immunity 59, 60

  auto-intoxication theory 216–17

  auxiliary lymph nodes 31

  Azoth (sword) 89

  bacteria 22, 23, 24, 26, 28, 29

  biological war with humans 36

  common biochemical constitution of 37

  LPS (lipopolysaccharide) 37, 39–40, 139, 140

  rapid reproduction of 35

  types of 36

  bacterial fragments 40

  BBB (blood-brain barrier) 9–10, 14, 124, 130, 140, 210

  cellular bricks 126

  permeability of 133

  BCG vaccination 139–40

  Behçet’s syndrome 59

  bereavement 151, 152

  counselling 151

  bio-electronics 205–6

  biology 17

  biomarkers 107–11, 189, 198, 200–1

  for Alzheimer’s disease 212

  blood 205

  CSF (cerebrospinal fluid) 109

  glucose 107

  haemoglobin 107

  of inflammation in depressed patients 113–14

  inflammatory 115–16, 152, 204

  serotonin 108–10

  see also case-control studies

  biorhythms 79

  biotech companies 178

  bipolar disorder 162, 173, 184, 185, 215

  black bile 69, 70

  blockbuster drugs 61–6, 194, 195, 197–8, 211

  blood 70

  circulation of 48

  blood-brain barrier (BBB) see BBB (blood-brain barrier)

  blood clots 152

  blood tests 107, 186, 198, 199, 220

  MDD (major depressive disorder) 72

  blood vessels 24, 48, 59, 126, 127, 152

  bodily disease see physical disease

  body fat 148

  body-shaming culture 148

  bone marrow 32, 33, 35

  Botox injections 161

  brain-scanning technologies 133–4

  see also fMRI scans

  brain, the 49–50, 51

  Berlin wall 122–32

  brain fog 44, 62

  communication with immune system 128

  defence of 126–7

  detecting emotion 133–4

  emotional brain network 134, 135, 136, 144, 163

  endothelial cells 127

  gaps between adjacent cells 127

  Hering-Breuer reflex 128

  immune privileged 126

  and the immune system 9

  inflammation of 127, 133–45

  brain scanning 133–4

  collateral damage 141

  impact of inflammatory signals 133

  scar tissue 140

  plaques and tangles 208, 209

  self-poisoning of 216–17

  serotonin imbalance 1–2, 105–6, 109–10, 124

  system of lymphatic vessels 127–8

  see also BBB (blood-brain barrier); nerve cells; neuro-immunology; psychoanalysis; serotonin

  Breuer, Josef 78

  C elegans 166, 172

  C-reactive protein (CRP) 115, 116, 117, 147, 148, 186, 204

  and new drug development 200–1

  Caenorhabditis elegans 105

  cancer 6, 122

  candidate drugs 63, 64, 104, 192, 193

  carers 152

  Cartesian dualism 10

  blind spot 66–8, 177

  Cartesian divide 54–5, 80, 83, 114, 179, 183

  endurance of 52–3

  errors in original form 52

  God and science 53–4

  influence in medicine 53

  medical apartheid 183–5

  mind and body 51, 52, 54–5

  physical domain 45

  pineal theory 51, 54

  spiritual domain 45, 54

  see also mind and body

  Cartesian reflex 184

  case-control studies

  assumed categories of depressed or healthy 116

  depression spectrum 116

  higher blood levels of inflammatory markers 116

  healthy people (controls) 115, 116, 117

  MDD (cases) 115, 116

  higher blood CRP levels 116, 117

  increased blood cytokine levels 116

  measurement of inflammatory biomarkers 115–16

  study in Copenhagen 117

  catecholamines 95, 100

  causality 8, 11–12, 16, 118–21

  anti-inflammatory drugs 203

  interferon treatment 120–1

  studies of cytokine levels

  in children in South-West England (2014) 118–19

  increased risk of depression 119

  shorter timeframes of analysis 120

  in UK civil servants 119

  cells see nerve cells

  Celsus 22, 26, 70–1

  central nervous system see nervous system

  cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) 109

  Chagas disease 160

  Charing Cross Hospital 65

  Chelsea Physic Garden 87

  chemical drugs 85

  chest disease 70

  child abuse 153

  chimney soot 122

  cholesterol 59–60

  chronic fatigue syndrome 176

  cingulate cortex 134, 136

  cirrhosis 120

  clinics, holistic assessments 220

  Clinton, P
resident Bill 17

  Clostridium tetani 26, 28, 35, 38

  co-morbid depression 147, 183, 198

  cocaine 77, 79

  cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) 73

  cognitive bias 73

  cognitive function 183

  companion diagnostics 197–8

  complement component 4 (C4) gene 217

  consciousness 80, 82

  consumption (later TB) 86

  contagious disease 169–70, 172

  counter-transference 80

  Crick, Francis 16–17

  CSF (cerebrospinal fluid) biomarkers 109

  cytokines 10–11, 12, 13, 14, 17, 22, 23, 24, 57, 58, 115, 116

  and anti-cytokines 62

  in depressed patients 113–14

  disabling drugs 63

  inflammatory effects 62

  receptors 30, 127, 128

  secretion mechanism 30–1

  Darwin, Charles 133, 134

  causes of death, hypotheses 160

  emotional facial expression 161

  eyebrow angle 163

  grief muscles 161

  sadness 163

  interest in insanity 160–1, 161–2

  clinical data 162

  marriage to cousin 162

  natural selection and depression 162

  physical and mental symptoms 159

  reclusive lifestyle 160

  stress of public speaking 160

  see also natural selection

  Darwin’s eclipse 165

  debt 152

  delusions 213

  dementia 177, 207–8

  see also Alzheimer’s disease

  dementia praecox 215

  deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) see DNA (deoxyribonucleic acid)

  depression 1

  adrenaline and noradrenaline deficiency 100–1, 105

  causes of 2

  economic cost of 2–3

  evolutionary theories of 167

  facial expressions 161, 163

  following heart attacks 60–1

  heritability of 162–4, 165, 172–3

  immunological treatment for 18

  isolation and 74, 75

  lack of major new treatments for 102, 111

  life expectancy 2, 165

  long-term medical conditions and 61

  MDD (major depressive disorder) 71–2

  “mindless” and “brainless” approaches 110–11

  moderately effective treatments 3, 111

  multiple causes of 196–7

  overweight people and 148

  personal failure and 73 -4, 75

  serotonin deficiency theory 1–2, 105–6, 109–10, 124

  silence around 2

  stigma and 74–5, 83, 110, 156, 172, 183

  survival value see genes

  talking to family and friends 75

  talking to trained experts 75, 83

  targeting with specific treatments 197

  “them” and “us” 110, 116

  see also anti-depressant drugs; causality; genes; inflammation; melancholia

  Descartes, René 10, 45–54, 110, 140

  cogitation 46, 52

  cogito ergo sum 46, 47

  comparison of human and animal life 137–8

  dreams 46

  God 47, 48, 50

  human body as machine 48, 49

  independence 50–2

  mathematics 47–8

  mechanistic theory of body and soul 49, 50

  physics 48

  pineal gland 49, 50, 51

  radical doubt 45–6, 47

  reputation as modern scientist 46–7

  soul, the 47, 49

  location of 49–50, 51

  Treatise of Man 51

  views on animals 137

  see also Cartesian dualism

  Deter, Auguste 207, 208

  diabetes mellitus 61, 107

  Diagnostic and Statistical Manual, 5th edition (DSM-5) 71–2, 215

  diclofenac 187

  digestive enzymes 40

  disability 111

  divorce 151

  DNA (deoxyribonucleic acid) 16–17, 22, 168, 170, 173, 217

  doctors see physicians

  dopamine 95, 99

  Doyle, Conan 122

  drugs

  anti-cytokine 62, 64, 64–6, 67, 203

  antibiotics 90

  blockbusters 61–6, 194, 195, 197–8, 211

  development path 104

  mind-altering 84

  new, development of 62–3

  alternative methods 63

  clinical trials 199–200

  failure rate 65, 199

  for inflamed depression 199, 200

  laboratory testing 63

  personalised tests 199

  repurposing 200

  side effects 63

  testing by robots 63, 64, 192

  purpose of 84

  testing

  on animals 12–13, 64, 91, 137, 137–8, 138–9, 192

  on humans 193

  on mice 64, 91, 139–40, 192, 218

  on rats 12–13, 139, 140, 218

  see also anti-depressant drugs; anti-inflammatory drugs; anti-TNF antibodies; iproniazid

  dualism 10, 50

  isolation of depression 75

  mental domain 7–8

  physical domain 7–8

  see also Cartesian dualism; Descartes, René

  dyspepsia 131

  early humans 166–74, 175

  ego, the 81

  electron microscopes 98

  electronic stimulators 132, 204–5

  Eli Lilly 101, 104

  clinical trials of SSRIs 101–2

  LY110140 (later Prozac) 105

  emotion 133–4

  Darwin’s views on 161

  emotional brain network 134, 135, 136, 144, 163

  endothelial cells 21, 23, 124, 126

  double agents 127

  permeability of 127

  enzymes 17

  eugenics 165, 216

  evolution, theory of 36

  Charles Darwin 164

  Jean-Baptiste Lamarck 164–5

  natural selection 165

  see also genes

  evolutionary synthesis 159

  Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals, The (Darwin) 162

  fatigue 66, 183

  Feldmann, Marc 65

  fight-or-flight response 153

  Fliess, Wilhelm 78–9

  fMRI scans 44, 72, 133–4, 144

  detecting sadness 134

  limitations of spatial resolution 136–7

  research 13 -14

  and vaccination tests 136

  foam cells 60

  Fortune magazine 102

  French disease (later syphilis) 88

  Freud, Sigmund 76–7

  career path to psychiatry 77–8

  ego, the 81

  libido 80–2

  psychic energy 79–80, 81

  psychoanalysis

  dynastic family 82

  origins of 79–80, 82

  relationship with William Fleiss 79

  scientific background 77

  synaptic connections between nerve cells 141

  gastric acid 131

  gastrointestinal disturbances 188

  genes 159

  Alzheimer’s disease and 212

  ancestral 166–7

  complement component 4 (C4) 217

  control of the immune system 167, 174

  depression

  heritability of 173

  olfactomedin 4 174

  studies on 173

  naturally selected 166

  for the nervous system 174

  predicting infectious threats 170–1

  randomly mutated 168

  schizophrenia and 217

  survival advantage of 166

  tribes of early humans

  attacks from rival tribes 169

  contagious disease 169–70, 172

  defence against i
nfection 167–9

  infant mortality rate 167

  infection 167

  innate inflammatory responses 168, 170, 175

  isolated patients 169, 170

  loss of appetite 169

  maternal death rate 167

  sickness behaviour 168, 169, 170

  survival 167, 169

  temporary withdrawal from 168–9

  see also natural selection

  genetic inheritance 14–15, 164

  genetic mutations 36, 159

  genetics 17

  germs see bacteria; viruses

  glandular fever 176

  GlaxoSmithKline 114, 191, 196

  glucose 107

  God 47, 48, 50

  science and 53–4

  gold 62

  Golgi, Camillo 96, 98

  grief 151

  grief muscles 161

  guilds 84–5

  gut, the 35

  bacterial antigens 188

  infection and 28–9

  leaky gut syndrome 188

  lining of 29

  macrophages and 29

  olfactomedin 4 174

  haemoglobin 107

  hallucinations 213

  Harvey, William 48, 122

  Hashimoto’s thyroiditis 59

  healthcare

  body and mind treatment 177

  heart attacks 60–1, 151, 152

  heart disease 61, 70

  heart rate 78

  Henry VIII 122

  hepatitis 120

  herbal remedies 85, 195

  Hering-Breuer reflex 78, 128

  Hering, Ewald 78

  high-throughput screening 63

  Hippocrates 69, 84

  collapse of Hippocratic establishment 90

  Hippocratic business model 87

  Hippocratic medicine 70, 87

  Hippocratic tradition 70, 71

  HMS Beagle 160, 164

  Hogarth, William 122

  Holmes, Sherlock 122

  Homo sapiens 36, 84, 105, 168, 172

  homoeostasis 130

  hormones 17, 22

  human body 54

  as machine 48, 49

  scientific understanding of 53

  structure of 53

  human condition 137–8

  human genome 17, 166, 173, 217

  Humera 65

  humours 69–70, 84

  hydrazine 91

  hypnosis 78

  immune cells 21, 23, 28, 30, 32, 130, 137

  see also macrophages

  immune disorders 56

  immune system 18

  adaptive learning 38–9

  anatomy of 32

  and the brain 9

  capacity for self-harm 56–7

  communication and 29–35

  defence of self 27

  inflammation and 24–6

  in winter 149

  inflammatory responses 5–6

  location 27–9

  long-term memory

  infections and vaccinations 153

  threats to self 153

  organs of 35

  physiology of 33

  rapid rebuttal function 35–9

  response to infection and injury 5

  stress and 152

  white blood cells and antibodies 9

  see also macrophages

  immuno-psychiatry 14, 15, 18, 113, 114, 185

  definition 9

  see also case-control studies

  immunology 6, 9, 20

 

‹ Prev