by Alli Frank
PRAISE FOR
TINY IMPERFECTIONS
“Offers a delightful view inside the cutthroat world of private school admissions that is hilarious, cringe-worthy and all too relevant in today’s ultra-competitive educational landscape. I ate this book up like a box of candy; you will too.”
—Tara Conklin, author of The Last Romantics
“Over-eager parents are just one of the many things heroine Josie Bordelon has to deal with as head of admissions for a tawny private school in San Francisco. These two authors are brave enough to expose the insanity and hilarity that happen during application season. . . . A really funny read.”
—Laurie Gelman, author of Class Mom
“Youmans and Frank manage to tackle a woman’s journey through work, race, and motherhood beautifully in their debut. Tiny Imperfections is laugh-out-loud funny and full of heart. I can’t wait to see what they bring us next!”
—Alexa Martin, author of Fumbled
“Youmans and Frank’s deep-dive into private school culture sets the stage for a dishy, charming story of West Coast elitism and parenting at its pushiest. But it’s the characters, especially the marvelous Bordelon women, who give this delightful novel its heart and humor—and who make you long to be part of the family even after the last page.”
—Amy Poeppel, author of Small Admissions and Limelight
“Perfectly captures the absurdist bubble of San Francisco’s tech upper class. A rollicking good read that reminds us that money, power and influence will never be enough to make someone truly happy.”
—Jo Piazza, author of Charlotte Walsh Likes to Win
“Tiny Imperfections is a funny, heart-warming take on finding love in a most unexpected place.”
—Anissa Gray, author of The Care and Feeding of Ravenously Hungry Girls
“With a heroine to cheer for and laugh-out-loud delicacies on every page, Tiny Imperfections is perfect entertainment! You’re in for such a fun ride. I loved it!”
—Lisa Patton, author of Rush
“A smart and savvy take on the competitive world of elite kindergarten admissions, Tiny Imperfections offers a delightfully refreshing narrative on ambition, family, and love.”
—Robinne Lee, author of The Idea of You
G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS
Publishers Since 1838
An imprint of Penguin Random House LLC
penguinrandomhouse.com
Copyright © 2020 by Alli Frank and Asha Youmans
Penguin supports copyright. Copyright fuels creativity, encourages diverse voices, promotes free speech, and creates a vibrant culture. Thank you for buying an authorized edition of this book and for complying with copyright laws by not reproducing, scanning, or distributing any part of it in any form without permission. You are supporting writers and allowing Penguin to continue to publish books for every reader.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Names: Frank, Alli, author. | Youmans, Asha, author.
Title: Tiny imperfections / Alli Frank and Asha Youmans.
Description: New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons, [2020] | Summary: “The Wedding Date meets Class Mom in this delicious novel of love, money, and misbehaving parents. ‘Delightful . . . Hilarious, cringe-worthy, and all too relevant. I ate this book up like a box of candy; you will too.’ —Tara Conklin, author of The Last Romantics” —Provided by publisher.
Identifiers: LCCN 2019050896 (print) | LCCN 2019050897 (ebook) | ISBN 9780593085028 (paperback) | ISBN 9780593085035 (ebook)
Classification: LCC PS3606.R3758 T56 2020 (print) | LCC PS3606.R3758 (ebook) | DDC 813/.6—dc23
LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2019050896
LC ebook record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2019050897
This is a work of fiction. Names, characters, places, and incidents either are the product of the authors’ imagination or are used fictitiously, and any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, businesses, companies, events, or locales is entirely coincidental.
pid_prh_5.5.0_c0_r0
For my Dad, who was a champion of women long before it was in vogue.
EAF
For my Father who inspired my learning. For my Husband who inspires my love. For my Sons who inspire my life.
APY
CONTENTS
Cover
Praise for Tiny Imperfections
Title Page
Copyright
Dedication
Open SeasonChapter One
Chapter Two
Chapter Three
Chapter Four
Chapter Five
Chapter Six
Chapter Seven
Chapter Eight
Chapter Nine
Chapter Ten
Mid-SeasonChapter Eleven
Chapter Twelve
Chapter Thirteen
Chapter Fourteen
Stress SeasonChapter Fifteen
Chapter Sixteen
Chapter Seventeen
Chapter Eighteen
Chapter Nineteen
Chapter Twenty
Chapter Twenty-one
Chapter Twenty-two
Chapter Twenty-three
Chapter Twenty-four
Chapter Twenty-five
Chapter Twenty-six
Chapter Twenty-seven
Chapter Twenty-eight
Chapter Twenty-nine
Next SeasonChapter Thirty
Acknowledgments
A Conversation with Alli Frank and Asha Youmans
Discussion Questions
About the Authors
OPEN SEASON
ONE
FROM: Meredith Lawton
DATE: September 24, 2018
SUBJECT: Introduction to our son, Harrison Rutherford Lawton
TO: Josephine Bordelon
Dear Josephine,
I’m Meredith Lawton, close friend of Beatrice Pembrook, who I’m sure you know is a past board chair of Fairchild Country Day School and fourth generation Fairchild alum. It was so good of Beatrice to honor her parents, Ginger and Alfred, after their untimely death by building the school a state-of-the-art black box theatre and a rooftop Olympic swimming pool. Beatrice is such a gem and she should be reaching out to you shortly on behalf of our son, Harrison.
I know admissions season just opened, but last spring we worked on our essays with a Stanford writing coach and have spent the summer perfecting them with our editor from Golden Gate Books so we may be the first to submit our application on the WeeScholars website. I would particularly like to draw your attention to paragraph #4 of essay question #5. I believe it to be a wonderful representation of how worldly and culturally competent Harrison already is at four years, ten months:
“At almost five years of age Harrison has glamped in huts in the Indian Himalayas, cruised down the Mekong in Laos, ridden on a Sherpa’s shoulders to Paro Taktsang (the Tiger’s Nest Monastery) in Bhutan, been recognized as a reincarnated lama in Nepal, and fed exotic fish all over the world from Mexico to the Great Barrier Reef (thank goodness Harrison got to experience THE REEF before it died completely from environmental hazard—terrible tragedy).”
We will be seeing a lot of each other t
his year and I look forward to meeting you on our school tour in the beginning of October. If there is anything you would like to learn about Harrison and our family beforehand please do not hesitate to e-mail or call (just not before 10:30 a.m. as I am most likely in yoga, Barry’s Boot Camp, or at my weekly cryotherapy appointment).
With much gratitude,
Meredith Lawton
P.S. I couldn’t resist sending this adorable picture of Harrison celebrating Chinese New Year in Shanghai. Christopher had to be there for work so OF COURSE we brought Harrison along; one is never too young to be exposed to Mandarin!
I finish reading globe-trotting-mom’s e-mail, shift my weight onto one leg at my standing desk—an ergonomic no-no—and look up to a God I’m not 100 percent sure exists because if She did, She certainly wouldn’t let people like Meredith Lawton procreate. Or do yoga. Nothing worse than a karmic salutation that screams, I’ve found mind body bliss and I’m now superior to you in this life and in the next.
“Tiger moms are so 2011,” I say to a silent, still-empty school campus, except for my own seventeen-year-old daughter, Etta, stretching her enviably smooth mocha, I-can-eat-Slim-Jims-and-Flamin’-Hot-Cheetos-for-lunch, ballerina body on the other side of my office. She doesn’t bother to acknowledge my deeply profound thought, her sound-canceling headphones to blame.
PRIVATE SCHOOL ADMISSIONS ARE NOW OPEN. Subtext: Let the freaking out, sucking up, buying in, overstating, underlistening, overselling, calling in of favors, pushing boundaries, and, in general, appalling parental antics begin. There should be a torch I light every Monday after Labor Day that stays lit until March 15—since urban private school admissions really are the Olympics of parenting. Instead, I’ve created a tasteful banner at the top of the Fairchild Country Day School website announcing: NOW ACCEPTING APPLICATIONS. With a single click on the link, parents are invited to learn more about Fairchild admissions and embrace the truth that their upcoming year will be lost to an abyss of essays, interviews, veiled dinner party conversation, stressful pillow talk, and heavy self-medication, all in the name of kindergarten.
Let’s call private school admissions what it is, an obsession for all those families who desperately want a spot on the private school crazy train. In San Francisco, it’s a bit different than the famed stories of cutthroat manipulation and desperation that define the Upper East Side of New York City. Don’t get me wrong, San Francisco has its overabundance of the rich and anxious, too, but here they’re well concealed behind a dirty SUV with a surfboard on top, HOKA running shoes, retro T-shirts, ripped jeans, flip-flops, and a shitload of stock options. The more Bay Area parents feign “It’s all good, everything will work out,” my stats show what a higher pain-in-the-ass quotient they are.
I actually welcome the occasional New York transplant family who comes into parent interviews owning their perceived superiority in head-to-toe Prada and gray banker suits attempting to establish their dominance through the traditional where they went to school, what they do, and where they work (usually someplace with three last names) introduction. With upfront elitism you immediately know with whom you’re dealing and where you stand. When elitism hides behind a white ribbed tank top, aviator sunglasses, and a messy bun it’s much more difficult to figure out from where an ambush may come. That’s why you can’t be fooled by the San Francisco mom in her 24/7 painted-on yoga pants who looks like your best friend or the 100 percent organic lady right out of Goop’s weekly online newsletter. Sometimes she’s as sweet and detoxed as she looks, but just as often behind that barre-class bod is a momster so determined to get her child into the best school she would toss you off the Golden Gate Bridge while sipping her green juice if she thought your kid was in direct kindergarten competition with hers.
Over the years I’ve learned the cultural subtlety of West Coast admissions. The first lesson came early in my career when my baby, Etta, was in first grade at Fairchild and I was in my second year as an admissions assistant. I made my first and only mistake of slipping from business English into what Aunt Viv calls “home speak” and getting a little too chummy with an applicant mom who was sweatin’ it because her son was channeling mini-Mussolini meets Donald Trump during his kindergarten visit.
“I know how you feel, Charlotte, I’m a mama, too, and sometimes our babies can bring us to our knees.” I gave her a big smile in motherly solidarity, but thinking back on it I probably showed too much tooth as this hundred-pound Barbie popped back, “Why you shore is, honey!” and patted my forearm to seal our new “sistahood.” Since that moment, I’ve had to endure Charlotte’s ridiculous banter as her son has moved through the grades at Fairchild and her warped sense of our friendship has grown. Luckily, I’m a quick study and I’ve never slipped into anything resembling black speak again without being related to my audience. Well, except for Lola. I also never told my aunt Viv about my early career slip. She would have skinned me alive.
“Can we go yet? I’ll freak if I’m late,” Etta yells, to hear herself above her headphones as she rolls her upper torso up from the hideous, stained maroon industrial carpet, her legs split east to west. My office is budgeted for a remodel next year.
I glance at Etta over the top of my computer. After seventeen years it still shocks me that I birthed a child who goes apoplectic if she’s not ten minutes early to everything. I didn’t even notice when my period was six weeks late eighteen years ago. Time and I have a very loose relationship. “Two Josie minutes,” I yell back, holding up a peace sign. Etta’s trained to know that means “ten real-time minutes.”
FROM: Josephine Bordelon—[email protected]
DATE: September 24, 2018
CC:
BCC:
SUBJECT: RE: Introduction to our son, Harrison Rutherford Lawton
TO: Meredith Lawton
CONGRATULATIONS, Meredith! You indeed were the first family to submit your application for this coming fall with a post time of twenty-eight seconds after the WeeScholars common application website opened. Our 110-year-old bylaws state that ruthless competitiveness, punctuality, and lama reincarnation are three of the four criteria to qualify Harrison for the golden ticket (YAY! Envision 24K gold confetti raining down, the confetti being compostable, of course), which means he’s automatically accepted into the Fairchild Country Day School class of 20-and-who-fucking-cares. No need to tour, attend an open house, or show up for the admissions visit date and parent interview. In fact, you don’t even have to wait until March 15 to find out Harrison’s elementary school fate like all the other die-hard parents out there.
Fairchild has been waiting years for a family as touched by perfection as yours to attend our school. Please let me know how I can best serve what I can only imagine will be endless, relentless needs and wants every step of Harrison’s educational path.
With complete ambivalence that you know Beatrice,
Josie Bordelon
DIRECTOR OF ADMISSIONS
FAIRCHILD COUNTRY DAY SCHOOL
“I’ve never worked in a school, but I’m pretty sure you’ll get fired if you swear in a work e-mail.” I didn’t even notice Etta hop off the carpet to come snoop over my shoulder. “And you should have a comma after . . .”
DE-LEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE-TE.
Grammar show-off.
Etta certainly did not get her punctuality from me, but her sarcasm—100 percent Bordelon.
As director of admissions this has become my free therapy to keep all the over-the-top parents from chipping away at my sanity. I say my piece and I erase. Then I move on.
“I’m having a hard time rallying for the ridiculousness of the entitled this year. I just want to find some old-school families who parent like it’s 1986: roof, food, clothes, water, manners, and if you don’t get good grades your ass will get whooped ’cause you gotta earn your keep. I’m looking for black-to-basics parenting.” That’s my knee-jer
k reaction. When I grow weary of the rich, I fall back on my Nawlins Ninth Ward background. Or really Aunt Viv’s, since I can only kinda claim my Southern black Baptist roots.
“You’re not helping the cause with that e-mail.” Etta points to my now-empty screen.
“Yeah, I know, but sometimes it feels good to type the conversation that’s going on in my head instead of official director of admissions missives. If only once I could push send on my real thoughts, maybe I could save a privileged child from a life of indulgence and complete cluelessness about the other 99.9 percent of the world. It could be my own act of social justice—to help a rich kid lead a normal life. It’s got potential, don’t you think?”
“Nope, not at all.”
“I’d give my firstborn for the chance to point out to one parent, any parent, when they’re in the early stages of ruining their child.”
“I’m your firstborn.”
“Right, and if I give you away before next August someone else can pay your college tuition.” I blow Etta a kiss with a wink. She knows I’d never abandon her; we’d be lost without each other.
“Tell me again why you work in a school? Seems to me at forty you should like what you do. Especially since I’ll be gone next year and the only reason you’ll have to come to Fairchild is to work hard and watch Headmistress Gooding take all the credit.” Etta raises her eyebrows at me.
“Clearly I work here for the fame, money, close relationship with my boss, and, of course, the lice. And because I’ll still have to feed you in college—it’s called a meal plan. And I do like what I do, sort of, mostly, kind of.” Etta turns and pretends to barf in my wastebasket. “And I’m not forty.”
“Yet.”
Daughters are the worst.
With one Josie minute to spare to get Etta to ballet, I chop out the e-mail that will allow me to pay the bills and keep my kid in leotards.