Teaching Cayden (The Sutter Family Book 4)

by Heather D'Agostino

  “Oh, I wish you would.” Dylan groaned as he scrambled out of his chair and rounded the fire.

  My stomach knotted up as I watched Dylan put his hands all over my girl. He was pawing her, and she was letting him. His hands slid up her back, and then went down to her ass. I swallowed as I stared at them. How long could I do this? How long could I pretend that it wasn’t bothering me? I got my answer when I watched his thumb slide across her ass cheek right at the edge of her suit.

  “I can’t do this,” I muttered as I leaned in next to Serena’s ear. “I’m sorry. I don’t know who you’re hiding from tonight, but I can’t do this to either of us. I’m in love with her, and she’s hurting because of this.” I waved my finger between us. “I’m sorry.” I stood and stalked over to where Dylan was now trying to kiss my girl. His lips were on her neck, and his hips were flush with hers.

  “Excuse me.” I tapped his shoulder like I was going to cut in.

  “What, dude,” he growled, annoyed with me. “I’m trying to lay some groundwork for later.”

  “Never gonna happen.” I laughed but it wasn’t funny. “Will wants you to get more firewood. Guess you’re busted.”

  “What the fuck?” Dylan turned to where Will was sitting, and I grabbed Addison, and began dragging her toward my uncle’s house.

  “What are you doing?” she squeaked as I turned and lifted her up over my shoulder. As I stormed in the direction of Uncle Nick’s pool, she began hitting my back with her fists. “Put me down, Cayden. I’m not your property.”

  “I beg to differ,” I mused as I stomped up the steps, pushed open the gate, and headed for the water.

  “What are you doing?” she shrieked as I began to lower us into the water.

  “What I should have done earlier.” I flipped her forward, letting her slide down my body until her feet landed in front of me. “Seeing you with him, letting him touch you like that… I’m sorry. I should have never asked you to be ok with me and Serena. I’m telling your brother tomorrow when he’s sober. I’m not doing this anymore. I can’t. I love you.” She stiffened, and I lifted my hand to cup her cheek. “I’ve never felt like this before. I thought things were different with you, but then after tonight, I know they are. I love you, Addison, and I want to tell the world. I don’t want to hide this anymore.”

  She stood there, blinking like she wasn’t sure what she was hearing, but then a giggle slipped out of her lips. “I love you too.” She rose up on her toes and pressed her lips to mine in a soft kiss. When she pulled back, she looked around. “Whose pool is this?”

  “Mine.” I shrugged.

  “No, really. Whose pool is this?” She glanced around, but you couldn’t see the party from here, and I hadn’t turned the lights to the deck on.

  “It’s mine.” I laughed. “This is my uncle’s house. The pool is attached to it. Where did you think the music was coming from tonight?”

  “This is the same house where the music is coming from? Can’t they see us?” She was beginning to panic.

  “No, trust me. No one knows we’re here.” I began moving us toward the deep end. There’s a bench in the side there that I’ve always wanted to try out, but I’ve never been able to get a girl over here without Uncle Nick finding us. I guess it’s a good thing he’s out of town this weekend with Aunt Leah.

  “What if someone’s home?” Addison was determined to be a buzz kill, but what she didn’t know was I’d covered all my bases.

  “No one is home. Gone all weekend. Well,” I laughed, “my parents are home, but they don’t know I’m up here. As far as they know, I’m getting drunk on the beach. Now come here.” I pulled her in front me, and held her so she could wrap her legs around my waist. “You feel that?” I pushed at her hips, causing her to rub against my hard on. “I’ve been trying to hide that since you showed me this fucking sinful suit. Did you really think I could keep my hands off of you while you were wearing this?” I leaned in and bit down gently on her ear.

  She shivered, “I hoped not.” Her hands lifted in the water as she moved them up my shoulders and into my hair. “Cayden?” She tugged at the strands.

  “Yes, baby?” I licked along her jaw, making her shiver more.

  “I need you so bad right now I ache,” she whimpered as I chuckled.

  “I’m gonna fix you right up,” I mumbled as I tilted my head and plunged my tongue deep into her mouth.

  Chapter 16

  Addison

  Cayden moved through the water all the while kissing me like his life depended on it. Suddenly, I felt the harsh concrete behind me as he placed me on a bench of sorts. He pulled back, his eyes wild with need, before reaching behind me and tugging at the tie on my top.

  “No one can see us. Trust me.” He slowly peeled it away from my wet skin before leaning in to press a kiss to the swell of my breasts. I sighed, as my head dropped back and my eyes drifted close. “Look at me, Addison. I want you to watch me.” My head snapped up in his direction just in time to see him set my top on the edge of the pool. “You are so fucking addictive,” he murmured before connecting his mouth with a nipple. He sucked, hard, before biting down gently. When he released it, it puckered from his attention, and I rubbed my thighs together. I wanted his mouth elsewhere, but the look in his eyes said he wouldn’t listen to me anyway.

  “So perfect.” He reached for the other breast, giving it the same treatment before he encouraged me to lift up onto the edge.

  “Someone might see,” I panicked.

  “I told you to trust me. No one can see. No one knows we’re here. I promise I won’t let anyone see you.” He leaned in and connected our mouths. As his tongue swirled around mine, he lifted up and set me on the edge of the pool. With cat like reflexes, he climbed onto his knees on the bench, and settled in front of me. “Trust me,” he whispered again as he broke the kiss. He reached for the tie over my right hip and tugged gently, releasing the fabric. Then, he did the same to the left side. His eyes blazed as his fingers deftly pulled the center section of fabric away, revealing my recently groomed core. I could feel it throbbing for him as his eyes zeroed in on me.

  He didn’t move, didn’t talk, just stared, and I was starting to worry that I’d gone too far. “Say something,” I whispered.

  “I don’t have words, Addison.” His voice was quiet as he kept staring. “You’re so beautiful. What made you do this?” He lifted a single finger and traced right down the center, causing me to moan. The second my head dropped back, he reminded me that I was supposed to be watching him. “You didn’t answer my question.”

  “That suit doesn’t cover much. When I went to get a wax, the esthetician suggested a Brazilian wax. Figured you’d like it.” I shrugged like it was no big deal, but I could tell it was everything to Cayden.

  “Christ, Addison!” he growled as he leaned closer. “You have to warn a man before something like this.” When he was close enough that I could feel his breath on me, he placed a kiss right at my core.

  “Oh god,” I moaned.

  “Something like that.” He chuckled before he threaded his arms under my legs, causing my knees to drape over his shoulders. “Better hold on to something,” he warned right before his chin dipped and his tongue swiped across me.

  Now, I’ve had guys do this before, but no one came close to the skills that Cayden has. I know he keeps his conquests close to his chest, and is nothing like his brother, but the guy has skills. He licked, and sucked, and swirled his tongue around like his was starving and I was his last meal. The only time he stopped was if I looked away. I’d never had a guy make me watch, but it was kinda erotic. Seeing the feral look in his eyes as he made me come, watching his tongue drift over my clit time and time again before he’d nibble it causing my legs to shake uncontrollably. The concrete beneath me bit into my ass, but the pain was worth it. Just as I was getting ready to come again, he pulled away.

  “What are you doing?” I panted before noticing him fighting with the tie on his trunks
. I watched as he wrestled a condom out of the pocket before shoving them over his hips. As they floated around his thighs, he tore open the foil package and sheathed himself. “Come here.” He motioned with his finger. As I slipped from the edge of the pool back into the water, I sighed. The cool liquid felt good where the rough concrete had chaffed my skin. Cayden shuffled closer, wrapped his arms around my middle, and lifted me onto his stiff cock. “Oh, sweet Jesus,” I moaned as I sunk down, being fully impaled.

  “I’m never going to get enough of you,” Cayden panted as he braced his feet, and lifted me slightly. The water sloshed around us as our bodies moved together, and we whispered words of praise to one another. It was the first time that we weren’t in my room, and I felt like we weren’t really hiding anything. As my body began to climb once again, Cayden’s rhythm changed. It went from steady to erratic, and I saw the look in his eyes. He was close and he was hanging on for me.

  “I’m gonna come,” I panted as I wrapped my arms around his neck. I pressed a kiss to the side of his neck, and then lightly bit his ear, causing his body to begin convulsing. He stiffened as his cock pulsed inside of me, and drained every last drop. “Fuck!” he hissed.

  We stood there, wrapped around one another for a few moments before Cayden lowered my feet to the ground. “Give me one second.” He winked as he shuffled over to the bench. I watched as he removed his trunks the rest of the way and tossed them up on the side where my bikini still laid. Then, he rose up on the bench and rolled the condom off, tying it, and tossing it to the side. When he turned back around, he swam over to me, stopping right in front, placing a kiss to my lips. “Wanna swim?” He grinned cheekily.

  “Right now?” I glanced around, suddenly shy.

  “Why not? No one’s here and we can skinny dip. Ever been skinny dipping before, Addy?” He smirked.

  “No.” I shivered as the water felt cold all of a sudden.

  “Now’s your chance to remedy that.” He laughed like a child before putting a few feet between us, and sending a splash in my direction.

  “What was that for?” I squealed.

  “Lighten up.” He splashed me again this time soaking my hair.

  “Oh, you are dead,” I warned before sending water in his direction. He ducked under the surface, causing me to miss completely. When he came up, I was ready, and got him right in the face. We went back and forth like this for most of the evening, splashing and playing like small children tucked away in our own little world. No one came up to the pool, and the darkness of the night kept us hidden. I don’t know what Cayden told his date when he left her there, and I really didn’t care. He’d told me he loved me, and at the moment I was having one of the best nights I’d had in a long time.

  “Truce?” Cayden held his hands up from the opposite end of the pool. He’d been bobbing around the deep end trying to protect himself from my wrath.

  “What’s in it for me?” I teased as he crept closer.

  “Come here and I’ll show you.” His eyes zeroed in on where my breasts were floating in the water.

  “Why don’t you just tell me?” I stopped right where the bottom of the pool sloped from the shallow end to where he was treading water.

  “I’d rather show you.” He shook water from his hair as he gracefully cut through the water, swimming to stop right in front of me. “Actions speak louder than words and all.” He chuckled just as his hand drifted between my legs. “I could do this all night.” One finger slipped inside of me, causing me to sigh. His thumb pressed against my clit as his other hand gripped my chin. “So? Truce?”

  “Mmmm hmmm.” I nibbled my lip as he curled his finger, causing goose bumps to form all over my body.

  “Come with me.” He removed his hand, and then threaded his fingers with mine. He pulled me toward the steps of the pool. As we rose from the water, the chilly night air wrapped around me, causing me to shiver.

  “It’s cold,” I whined.

  “Not for long.” Cayden chuckled as he led us over to a lounger. There were towels stacked under it and I had to wonder how they got there.

  “You planned this?” I looked up at him confused, remembering the argument that led to us being in the pool in the first place.

  “I had hopes we’d end up here at some point tonight. I didn’t know it would be as early in the evening as it was, but I knew I wanted you here.” He handed me a towel. When he unfolded his, an entire strip of condoms fell to the ground.

  “Pretty sure of yourself, huh?” I laughed as my eyes zeroed in on his semi hard cock.

  “Like I said… I had hope.” He spread a towel on the lounger, laid down, and then opened his arms to me. When I laid down next to him, he covered us with another towel. “You getting warmer yet?” His breath fanned across my neck.

  “A little.” I wiggled my hips against his crotch, causing his cock to rise to full mast. “I think you can do better though.”

  “Is that a challenge?” He shifted so I was under him. As he hovered over me, he reached for the strip of condoms, tearing one off in the process. “Challenge accepted,” he mumbled as he opened the packet and rolled it on. “Challenge fucking accepted,” he stated again as he lifted my leg to wrap around his hip, and pressed into me. We both groaned as he worked to raise both our temperatures over and over again until we both passed out from exhaustion.

  Cayden

  Last night didn’t go how I’d planned it, but it ended good nonetheless. I’d thought when Addison showed up at the party and saw Serena with me, that there was no chance in hell that she’d listen to me let alone get into bed with me. Our private night swim was perfect though. It was the perfect night with the right girl. We’d made love over and over again until we’d finally fallen asleep. If I didn’t already know that Uncle Nick wasn’t coming home for two more days, then I might be worried, but as it was I was enjoying sleeping right where I was.

  Addison was curled up beside me, just a towel covering our lower halves. She was turned so her back was exposed, her breasts pressed against my chest. If I hadn’t run out of condoms last night, I would take her again right now. My dick didn’t understand that she probably needed a break. I let my fingers trail over her back as she shifted closer, causing my dick to become painfully hard. I don’t think she knew what she was doing.

  In the back of my mind I remembered that there had been a party on the beach. I remembered that her brother was at this party, and had pretty much laid down the law to all of us about her being off limits. I really couldn’t understand it though. I mean, she was the older sibling, but whatever. Anyway, I’m sure that if I didn’t have Addison beside me I might have woken up to the footsteps that were stomping up the deck stairs, but I didn’t. That chance that I was looking for to tell Will that I was in love with his sister was going to come sooner than either of us expected.

  “I can help with that,” Addison’s sleep induced voice murmured as her palm slipped down my stomach, and cupped my dick. He pulsed, not understanding that he wasn’t going to get the play that was being dangled in front of him.

  “Like hell you will!” Will’s voice boomed, causing us both to jump. My eyes flew open as Addison’s hand reached to tug the towel over her chest.

  “What are you doing here?” she squeaked.

  “I was looking for you!” His arms flung out to the side.

  “Will, man, it’s not what it looks like.” I tried to calm him.

  “It isn’t? So, you’re not fucking my sister, you piece of shit!” He reached for me, but I stood up not caring that I was naked.

  “Leave us alone, Will!” Addison gripped the towel to her chest as she shot daggers at him.

  “Not ‘til I teach this fucker some manners!” He stormed in my direction, cocked his fist back, and connected it with my jaw, causing me to stumble back. “I warned you, and now I’m going to teach you a lesson, Sutter.”

  Chapter 17

  Cayden

  “I warned you, Sutter!” Will advanced closer as
I scrambled to grab a towel from the ground. Not that I was worried, but I really didn’t want someone else to come out because of the commotion and see me in all my naked glory.

  “You don’t get to tell me who I can and can’t date, William!” Addison shouted as she wrapped the towel around her body and stood up. She marched over to where he was fuming, and stood in front of him.

  “Move, Addy!” he gritted out as his hands fisted at his side. The vein in the side of his neck pulsed.

  “No!” She stomped her foot like a petulant child. “I’m not letting you win this one.”

  “I’m not asking you to.” He pushed his way around her, and stormed in my direction. At this point, I’d had enough time to put my trunks back on, but I hadn’t gotten away from the pool yet. “You’re a fucking asshole,” he growled again as his fist connected with my jaw. This was the second time he’d hit me in the same place, and I wasn’t one to back down from a fight, but I didn’t want to fight him.

  “Listen, man.” I backed up as I cupped my face. “We didn’t want you to find out like this. We were going to tell you.” I tried to reason with him.

  “We? So this was your idea too?” He turned toward Addison.

  “I love her,” came bursting from my lips and apparently it was the wrong thing to say in the moment because he turned and swung at me again. This time I ducked, and he fell into the pool from the momentum.

  “Will!” Addison cried as he sunk below the surface. I jumped in thinking he needed help, and he used it to his advantage.

  “You sonofabitch!” he roared as he thrashed in the water trying to continue the fight.

  I don’t know how many times he hit me, but he eventually lost steam and quit. I refused to hit back though. He was right. I was a sonofabitch for doing this behind his back. He had every right to be mad at me, and I was giving him his chance right now. After today, I wouldn’t hold back if he did this again.

  “Enough!” came a voice that I hadn’t heard in a few days.