by Kate Morton
‘It keeps things running well,’ Simion continued. ‘Not so in America, I’m afraid. The fellow who shines your shoes on the street corner is as like as not to be dreaming of owning his own company. There’s little to make a man so damnably nervous as an entire population of labourers puffed up with unreasonable . . .’ he rolled the distasteful word around his mouth a moment and spat it out, ‘ambitions.’
‘Imagine,’ Hannah said, ‘a working man who expects more from life than the stench of other men’s feet.’
‘Abominable!’ Simion said, blind to Hannah’s irony.
‘One would think they’d realise,’ she said, voice rising a semitone, ‘that only the fortunate have a right to concern themselves with ambition.’
Mr Frederick shot her a warning glance.
‘They’d save us all a lot of bother if they did,’ Simion said with a nod. ‘You only have to look at the Bolsheviks to realise how dangerous these people can be when they get ideas above their station.’
‘A man shouldn’t seek to improve himself?’ Hannah said.
The younger Mr Luxton, Teddy, continued to look at Hannah, a slight smile making his lips twitch beneath his moustache. ‘Oh, Father approves of self-improvement, don’t you, Father? As a boy I heard of little else.’
‘My grandfather pulled himself out of the mines with sheer determination,’ Simion said. ‘Now look at the Luxton family.’
‘An admirable transformation.’ Hannah smiled. ‘Just not to be attempted by everyone, Mr Luxton?’
‘Just so,’ he said. ‘Just so.’
Mr Frederick, eager to leave precarious waters, cleared his throat impatiently and looked toward Mr Hamilton.
Mr Hamilton nodded imperceptibly and leaned near to Hannah. ‘Dinner is served, miss.’ He looked at me and signalled that I should return downstairs.
‘Well,’ Hannah said as I slipped from the room. ‘Shall we dine?’
Fish followed green pea soup, pheasant followed fish and by all accounts things were going well. Nancy made occasional appearances downstairs, providing welcome reports of the evening’s progress. Though working at a frantic pace, Mrs Townsend was never too busy for an update on Hannah’s performance as hostess. She nodded when Nancy announced that though Miss Hannah was doing well, her manner was not yet so charming as her grandmother’s.
‘Of course not,’ Mrs Townsend said, sweat beading at her hairline. ‘It’s natural with Lady Violet. She couldn’t host a party that wasn’t perfect if she tried. Miss Hannah will improve with practice. She may never be a perfect hostess, but she’ll certainly be a good one. It’s in the blood.’
‘You’re probably right, Mrs Townsend,’ Nancy said.
‘Of course I am. That girl’ll turn out just fine, so long as she doesn’t get swept up with . . . modern notions.’
‘What sort of modern notions?’ I said.
‘She always was an intelligent child,’ Mrs Townsend said with a sigh. ‘And all those books are bound to put ideas in a girl’s head.’
‘What sort of modern notions?’
‘Marriage will cure her, though. You mark my words,’ Mrs Townsend said to Nancy.
‘I’m sure you’re right, Mrs Townsend.’
‘What sort of modern notions?’ I said impatiently.
‘There’s some young ladies just don’t know what they need until they find themselves a suitable husband,’ Mrs Townsend said.
I could stand it no longer. ‘Miss Hannah’s not going to get married,’ I said. ‘Never. I heard her say so herself. She’s going to travel the world and live a life of adventure.’
Nancy gasped and Mrs Townsend stared at me. ‘What are you talking about, you silly girl,’ Mrs Townsend said, pressing a hand firmly against my forehead. ‘You’ve gone mad, talking nonsense like that. You sound like Katie. Of course Miss Hannah’s going to get married. It’s every debutante’s wish: to be married briskly and brilliantly. What’s more, it’s her duty now that poor Master David—’
‘Nancy,’ Mr Hamilton said, hurrying down the stairs. ‘Where is that champagne?’
‘I’ve got it, Mr Hamilton.’ Katie’s voice preceded her loping form. She emerged from the ice room, bottles clutched awkwardly under both arms, smiling broadly. ‘The others were too busy arguing, but I’ve got it.’
‘Well hurry up then, girl,’ Mr Hamilton said. ‘The Master’s guests will be going thirsty.’ He turned toward the kitchen and peered down his nose. ‘I must say it’s not like you to dawdle over your duties, Nancy.’
‘Here you are, Mr Hamilton,’ said Katie.
‘Up you go, Nancy,’ he said disparagingly. ‘Now that I’m here I might as well bring them myself.’
Nancy glared at me and disappeared up the stairs.
‘Really, Mrs Townsend,’ Mr Hamilton said. ‘Keeping Nancy here arguing. You know we need all hands on deck tonight. May I enquire as to what was so important that it required your urgent discussion?’
‘It was nothing, Mr Hamilton,’ Mrs Townsend said, refusing to meet my eyes. ‘Not an argument at all, just a little matter between Nancy and Grace and me.’
‘They were talking about Miss Hannah,’ Katie said. ‘I heard them—’ ‘Silence, Katie,’ Mr Hamilton said.
‘But I—’
‘Katie!’ Mrs Townsend said. ‘That’s enough! And for goodness sake, put those bottles down so Mr Hamilton can get them up for the Master.’
Katie released the bottles onto the kitchen table.
Mr Hamilton, reminded of the task at hand, abandoned his inquiries and began to open the first bottle. Despite his expertise, the cork was stubborn, refusing to emerge until its handler least expected and—
Bang!
It shot from the bottle, exploded a lamp globe into a hundred pieces, and landed in Mrs Townsend’s pot of butterscotch sauce. The liberated champagne showered Mr Hamilton’s face and hair with triumphant effervescence.
‘Katie, you silly girl!’ Mrs Townsend exclaimed. ‘You’ve gone and shaken the bottles!’
‘I’m sorry, Mrs Townsend,’ Katie said, beginning to giggle as she was wont to do in moments of bother. ‘I was just trying to hurry, like Mr Hamilton said.’
‘More haste, less speed, Katie,’ Mr Hamilton said, the slick of champagne on his face detracting from the seriousness of his admonition.
‘Here, Mr Hamilton.’ Mrs Townsend clutched the corner of her apron to wipe his shiny nose. ‘Let me get you cleaned up.’
‘Oh, Mrs Townsend,’ Katie giggled. ‘You’ve gone and put flour all over his face!’
‘Katie!’ Mr Hamilton snapped, swiping at his face with a handkerchief that had materialised amid the confusion. ‘You are a silly girl. Not an ounce of sense to show for any of your years here. Sometimes I really do wonder why we keep you . . .’
I heard Alfred before I saw him.
Over the din of Mr Hamilton’s scolding, Mrs Townsend’s fussing and Katie’s protestations, the rasping rise and fall of breath.
He later told me he had come downstairs to find what was keeping Mr Hamilton, but now he stood at bottom, so still and so pale, a marble statue of himself, or else a ghost . . .
As my eyes found his, a spell was broken and he turned on his heel, disappeared down the corridor, footsteps echoing on stone, through the back door and into the dark.
Everyone watched, silent. Mr Hamilton’s body twitched as if he thought to follow, but duty was ever his master. He ran his handkerchief across his face one last time and turned to us, lips pressed together so they sketched one pale line of dutiful resignation.
‘Grace,’ he said as I prepared to chase Alfred. ‘Put on your good apron. You’re needed upstairs.’
In the dining room I took my place between the chiffonier and the Louis XIV chair. On the opposite wall Nancy raised her eyebrows. Powerless to convey all that had happened downstairs, unsure what such an explanation would contain, I lifted my shoulders slightly and looked away. Wondered where Alfred was and whether he would ever be himself
again.
They were finishing the pheasant course and the air quivered with the polite tinkle of cutlery on fine china.
‘Well,’ Estella said, ‘that was—’ slight pause, ‘—just lovely.’ I watched her profile, watched the way her jaw worked as she chewed each word, wringing from it all life and vitality before pushing it out through broad, crimson lips. I remember her lips especially, as she was the only person wearing makeup. Much to Emmeline’s eternal sorrow, Mr Frederick had rather definite ideas on makeup and its wearers.
Estella cleared a valley between the leftover mounds of solidifying pheasant and laid down her cutlery. She kissed cherry splotches onto a white linen napkin I would have to scrub later, then smiled at Mr Frederick. ‘It must be difficult with the shortages.’
Nancy raised her eyebrows. For a guest to comment directly on the meal was almost unheard of. Indeed, such blatant respects verged on discourtesy, all too easily interpreted as evidence of surprise. We would have to be cautious when recounting to Mrs Townsend.
Mr Frederick, as astonished as we, launched an uneasy oratory on Mrs Townsend’s unparalleled skill as a ration cook, under which veil Estella took opportunity to peruse the room. Her gaze alighted first on the ornate plaster cornices marrying wall to ceiling, slid south to the William Morris frieze on the dado rail, before resting, finally, on the wall-mounted Ashbury crest. All the while her tongue darted methodically beneath her cheek, working some stubborn and distasteful morsel from between her gleaming teeth.
Small sociable chat was not Mr Frederick’s metier in life, and his narration, once started, became a desolate conversational island from which there seemed no escape. He began to flounder. He cast about with his eyes but Estella, Simion, Teddy and Emmeline had all found discreet occupation elsewhere. Finally, in Hannah, he found an ally. They exchanged a glance, and while he allowed his desultory description of Mrs Townsend’s butterless scones to wilt, she cleared her throat.
‘You mentioned a daughter, Mrs Luxton,’ Hannah said. ‘She isn’t with you on this trip?’
‘No,’ Estella said quickly, her attention returned to her tablemates. ‘No, she isn’t.’
Simion looked up from his pheasant and grunted. ‘Deborah hasn’t accompanied us in some time,’ he said. ‘She has commitments at home. Work commitments,’ he said ominously.
Hannah showed a resurrection of genuine interest. ‘She works?’
‘Something in publishing.’ Simion swallowed a forkful of pheasant. ‘Don’t know the details.’
‘Deborah is the fashion columnist for Women’s Style,’ Estella said. ‘She writes a little report each month.’
‘Ridiculous—’ Simion’s body shook, capturing a hiccough before it became a burp, ‘—tripe about shoes and dresses and other extravagances.’
‘Now, Father,’ Teddy said with a slow smile. ‘Deb’s column is very popular. She’s been influential in shaping the way New York’s society ladies dress.’
‘Guff! You’re fortunate your daughters don’t put you through such things, Frederick.’ Simion pushed his gravy-smeared plate aside. ‘Work indeed. You British girls are much more sensible.’
It was the perfect opportunity and Hannah knew it. I held my breath, wondering whether her desire for adventure would win out. Hoping it wouldn’t. That she would honour Emmeline’s entreaty and stay here at Riverton. With Alfred as he was, I couldn’t bear to think that Hannah might also disappear.
She and Emmeline exchanged a glance, and before Hannah had chance to speak, Emmeline said quickly, in the clear musical voice young ladies were advised to cultivate for use in company, ‘I certainly never would. Working is hardly respectable, is it Pa?’
‘I’d sooner tear out my own heart than see either of my daughters working,’ Mr Frederick said matter-of-factly.
Hannah’s lips tightened.
‘Damn near broke my heart,’ Simion said. He looked at Emmeline. ‘If only my Deborah had your sense.’
Emmeline smiled, her face blooming with a precocious ripeness of beauty I was almost embarrassed to observe.
‘Now, Simion,’ Estella placated. ‘You know Deborah wouldn’t have accepted the position if you hadn’t granted your permission.’ She smiled, too broadly, at the others. ‘He never could say no to her.’
Simion humphed but did not disagree.
‘Mother’s right, Father,’ Teddy said. ‘Taking a little job is quite the thing amongst the New York smart set. Deborah is young and she’s not yet married. She’ll settle down when the time comes.’
‘I’ve always preferred correctness to smartness,’ Simion said. ‘But that’s modern society for you. They all want to be considered smart. I blame the war.’ He tucked his thumbs beneath the tight rim of his trousers, concealed from all but my view, and provided his stomach some welcome breathing space. ‘My only consolation is that she earns good money.’ Reminded of his favourite topic, he cheered somewhat. ‘I say, Frederick. What do you think of the penalties they’re talking of imposing on poor old Germany?’
As conversation swept along, Emmeline looked sideways beneath her eyelids at Hannah. Hannah kept her chin up, eyes following conversation, face a model of calm, and I wondered whether she had been going to ask at all. Perhaps Emmeline’s earlier appeal had changed her mind. Perhaps I imagined her light shudder as opportunity disappeared in a sudden draught up the chimney.
‘One does feel rather sorry for the Germans,’ Simion said. ‘There’s a lot to be admired in their people. Excellent employees, eh Frederick?’
‘I don’t employ Germans in my factory,’ Frederick said.
‘There’s your first mistake. You won’t find a more diligent race. Humourless, I’ll grant you, but meticulous.’
‘I’m quite happy with my local men.’
‘Your nationalism is admirable, Frederick. But not, surely, at the expense of business?’
‘My son was killed by a German bullet,’ Mr Frederick said, fingers spread, light but taut, on the table rim.
The remark was a vacuum into which all bonhomie was drawn. Mr Hamilton caught my gaze and motioned Nancy and me to create a diversion by collecting the main plates. We were halfway around the table when Teddy cleared his throat and said, ‘Our deepest sympathies, Lord Ashbury. We had heard about your son. About David. Word at White’s, he was a good man.’
‘Boy.’
‘What’s that?’
‘My son was a boy.’
‘Yes,’ Teddy corrected himself. ‘A fine boy.’
Estella reached a plump hand across the table, rested it limply on Mr Frederick’s wrist. ‘I don’t know how you bear it, Frederick. I can’t think what I’d do if I lost my Teddy. I thank God every day he decided to fight the war from home. He and his political friends.’
Her helpless gaze flitted to her husband who had the decency to look at least a little discomfited. ‘We’re in their debt,’ he said. ‘Young men like your David made the ultimate sacrifice. It’s up to us to prove they didn’t die in vain. To thrive in business and return this great land to her rightful standing.’
Mr Frederick’s pale eyes fixed on Simion and for the first time I perceived a flicker of distaste. ‘Indeed.’
I loaded the plates into the dumb waiter and pulled the rope to send them down, then leaned into the cavity, listening to hear whether Alfred’s voice was amongst the distant strains below. Hoping he was back from wherever it was he’d run to in such a hurry. Through the shaft came the distant jiggling of removal, the drone of Katie and reprimand of Mrs Townsend. Finally, with a jerk, the ropes began to move and the dumb waiter returned, loaded with fruit, blancmange and butterscotch sauce, sans cork.
‘Business today,’ Simion said, straightening authoritatively, ‘is all about economies of scale. The more you produce, the more you can afford to produce.’
Mr Frederick nodded. ‘I’ve got some fine workers. Indeed, they’re fine men. If we train the others—’ ‘Waste of time. Waste of money.’ Simion thumped an open hand on
the table with a vehemence that made me jump, almost spilling the butterscotch sauce I was ladling into his bowl. ‘Motorisation! That’s the way of the future.’
‘Assembly lines?’
Simion winked. ‘Speed up the slow men, slow down the fast.’
‘I’m afraid I don’t sell enough to warrant assembly lines,’ Mr Frederick said. ‘There are only so many people in Britain can afford my cars.’
‘Precisely my point,’ Simion said. Enthusiasm and liquor had combined to bring a crimson sheen to his face. ‘Assembly lines lower prices. You’ll sell more.’
‘Assembly lines won’t lower the price of parts,’ Mr Frederick said.
‘Use different parts.’
‘I use the best.’
Mr Luxton erupted into a fit of laughter from which it seemed he wouldn’t emerge. ‘I like you, Frederick,’ he said finally. ‘You’re an idealist. A perfectionist.’ The latter was spoken with the exultant self-gratification of a foreigner who had correctly plucked an unfamiliar word from memory. ‘But Frederick,’ he leaned forward seriously, elbows on the table, and pointed a fat finger at his host, ‘do you want to make cars, or do you want to make money?’
Mr Frederick blinked. ‘I’m not sure I—’
‘I believe my father is suggesting you have a choice,’ came Teddy’s measured interruption. He had heretofore been following the exchange with reserved interest, but now said, almost apologetically, ‘There are two markets for your automobiles. The discerning few who can afford the best—’
‘Or the seething sprawl of aspirational middle-class consumers out there,’ Simion broke in. ‘Your factory; your decision. But from the banker’s point of view . . .’ He leaned back, loosened a button on his dinner jacket, exhaled gladly. ‘I know which I’d be aiming for.’
‘The middle class,’ Mr Frederick said, frowning faintly, as if realising for the first time that such a group existed outside doctrines of social theory.
‘The middle class,’ Simion said. ‘They’re untapped, and God help us their ranks are growing. If we don’t find ways to take their money from them, they’ll find ways to take ours from us.’ He shook his head. ‘As if the workers weren’t problem enough.’