A Country I Do Not Recognize

Home > Other > A Country I Do Not Recognize > Page 24
A Country I Do Not Recognize Page 24

by Robert H. Bork

judicial activism, 82, 136;

  defined, 10;

  examples of, 11;

  of Florida Supreme Court, 36;

  Roe v. Wade, example of, 21;

  as source of Supreme Court power, 53

  judicial creativity, 67

  judicial gnosticism, xi

  judicial independence, 48

  judicial legislation, 75

  judicial mischief, 168

  judicial perversity, ix

  judicial power, 72

  judicial review, from conservative force to engine of social change, 24–32;

  cultural elite’s trump card, 38–47;

  defenders of, 38;

  proposed abolishment of, 52–53, 55;

  restraining clause in democracy, 25. See also constitutional judicial review

  Judiciary Act of 1789, 160

  Junior Order of United American Mechanics (JOUAM), 88

  Kadic v. Karadzic, 162n50

  Kellog-Briand Pact of 1928, 146

  Kennedy, Anthony, xiv, 35–36, 58, 72–76, 82–83;

  on personal dignity/autonomy, xviii

  Keyes v. School District, 43n101

  Kimmel v. Florida Bde. of Reports, 36n88

  Kirkpatrick, Jeane, xxiv

  Kissinger, Henry, on international law, xxxi

  knowledge/verbal class, 3–4

  kodakers, 61, 61n14

  Kolakowski, Leszek, on sense of sacred, xxvii;

  taboos and, xxvii–xxix

  Kyllo v. United States, 34n78

  Kyoto Accords, xxxiii, 124–25

  Lamb’s Chapel v. Center Moriches Union Free School, 108

  land mines, 118, 121, 124–25, 131

  law, anticontraception, 20, 28;

  function of, 1;

  internationalization of, ix, xi, xxxi–xxxii;

  judge-made, 83;

  limitations/restrictions of, 15;

  loss of integrity in, xxv;

  meaning of, xii;

  principles of, 63n20;

  “reasonableness” of, 69;

  religion and, xxii;

  substantive validity of, 80;

  U.S. Constitution and, 7. See also constitutional law; federal common law; international law; natural law; treaty-based law; U.S. law

  law of nations, 165, 173–75;

  paradigms of 1789, 166–70;

  violations of, 165

  Law of Treaties, 123, 125, 154

  Lawrence v. Texas, xviii, 35n82, 58, 59n9, 72n58, 73–74, 76, 83

  The Law of Piracy (Rubin), 140

  Lee v. Weisman, 34n75, 96

  Lemon test, 94, 110;

  application of, 98–99, 103;

  birth of, 98

  Lemon v. Kurtzman, 28n55, 98

  Levy v. Louisiana, 15n27, 19–20, 31n68

  Ley, Robert, 144

  liberal activism, 37

  liberals, 33;

  identified in Supreme Court, 35

  liberty, constitutional language and, 63;

  of contract, 66;

  as freedom to enjoy all faculties, 66;

  meaning of, 58–59;

  ordered, 68;

  religious, 85–134

  lifestyle issues, x

  like-minded states, 114;

  make-up of, 120

  Lincoln, Abraham, on Supreme Court decisions, 7n8

  Lochner v. New York, 15n26, 75;

  substantive due process and, 66–67

  Locke v. Davey, 108–9

  Lockett v. Ohio, 28n54

  Lord’s Prayer, xv, 94

  Lucas v. S. C. Coastal Council, 36n86

  Lynch v. Donnelly, 103

  Madison, James, 6, 59, 110

  Mapp v. Ohio, 34

  Marbury v. Madison, 8, 24, 77n85

  marriage, sacredness of, xxvi

  Marsh v. Chambers, 103

  Marshall Court, Bill of Rights and, 68n42

  Marshall, John, 8, 25, 27, 77–78;

  dissent of, 63n21;

  on executive power, 169;

  Supreme Court jurisdiction and, 8n13

  Marshall, Thurgood, 24

  McArthur, Douglas, 148n25

  McCollum v. Board of Education, 90–92

  McCollum, Vashti, 91

  McCulloch v. Maryland, 77n86, 78n88

  McDowell, Gary L., xiii–xv

  McGowan v. Maryland, 102

  Meuller v. Allen, 100

  Meyer v. Nebraska, 67n38

  Michael H. v. Gerald D., 81n101

  Michel, Louis, 158

  Mill, John Stuart, xxvii;

  on sense of sacred, xxv–xxvi

  Milosevic, Slobodan, 172

  Minersville (Pa.) School District v. Gobitis, 86

  minimum wages, for women, 67

  Minogue, Kenneth, xix;

  on Olympianism, xx, xxii

  Miranda rights, 28, 33;

  Rehniquist Court and, 34

  Miranda v. Arizona, 28n56

  Mississippi University for Women v. Hogan, 31n66

  Missouri Compromise, 25

  Missouri v. Jenkins, 48n117

  Mitchell v. Helms, 100

  Montesquieu, 6

  Moore v. East Cleveland, 81n100

  morality, evolution of, xi;

  sexual, xiii–xiv

  Morganthau, Henry, Jr., 144

  Mormon polygamy, 105

  Mugler v. Kansas, 66n30, 72

  multiculturalism, xxiii

  Munn v. Illinois, 65n29

  Munoz, Vincent Phillip, 90, 108

  “mystery passage,” xix

  myth of conservatism, 32–37

  NAACP v. Button, 29n58

  national security, human security v., xxxiii

  natural justice, 63, 63n21, 75, 77–78

  natural law, 15, 38, 63, 78;

  due process and, 62n18

  Nazi Party, 144, 148–50

  Nazis and Nazi Collaborators (Punishment) Law, 150, 152n32

  Nazism, xxiii, 29, 142–43

  Ndombasi, Abdulaye Yerodia, 157

  Neuhaus, Richard, 102

  Nevada Dep’t of Human Resources v. Hibbs, 37n91

  New Deal, 25

  new diplomacy, creation of, 114;

  human rights agenda of, 121;

  new game of, 121–24;

  NGOs’ role in, 121–24;

  threats of, 113–34

  New Jersey Taxpayers Association, 88

  New Left, xvi, xix

  new sovereignty, 174–80

  New York v. United States, 37n89

  NGOs. See nongovernmental organizations

  “Nietzchean vision,” 75

  Nixon, Richard M., 27, 44, 46, 129

  Nolan v. Cal. Coastal Comm’n, 36n86

  nongovernmental organizations (NGOs), xxxii, 114;

  growth of, 118–19;

  in new diplomacy, 121–24;

  operation of, 120

  nonracial unitary system, 44

  Northwest Ordinance, 90

  nullem crimen sine lege (no crime without a law), 146

  Nuremburg Trials, xxxiv, 130;

  controversial aspects of, 145;

  legacy of, 142–49

  obiter dictum, 69

  Obligation of Contracts, 13

  O’Connor, Sandra Day, xiv, xxiii, 31, 35–36, 41, 58, 72–73, 82, 104

  Ogden v. Saunders, 63n21

  Olmstead v. United States, 59n6

  Olympianism, xx–xxii, xxxi

  “one-person, one-vote,” 31

  Operation Condor, 154

  ordered liberty, 68

  originalism, xxix–xxx

  Orwell, George, 10

  Ottawa Conference, 120

  Ottawa Convention on Land Mines, 124, 125

  Pace, William, 118

  Pacific Mutual Life Insurance Co. V. Haslip, 81n101

  Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO), 161–62

  Palko v. Connecticut, 17n34, 68, 74n66

  Papachristou v. Jacksonville, 30n64

  passive personality jurisdiction,
151, 151n29

  Peace of Westphalia (1648), 175

  Peckham, Rufus, 66, 75

  Persian Gulf War (1990–1991), 172

  personal rights, property rights v.; due process and, 69

  Pierce v. Society of Sisters, 67n38

  Pinochet Augusto, 126;

  attempted extradition of, 153–56;

  universal jurisdiction and, 153

  piracy, 165, 167

  pirates, 140;

  characteristics of, 141

  Planned Parenthood of Southeastern Pennsylvania v. Casey, xiv, xviiin13, 58, 59n9, 72–73, 76, 82

  Plato, 39

  Pledge of Allegiance, 104

  Plessy v. Ferguson, 22n43, 82

  PLO. See Palestine Liberation Organization

  Poe V. Ullman, 17n35, 69–70

  political correctness, x, xxii, xxxv

  politics, of expression, xix;

  of meaning, xvii

  pornography, xiii, xxvi, 29, 50;

  Internet and, 34;

  suppression of, 38

  Port Huron Statement (1962), xvi–xvii

  post–Cold War diplomacy, 117–20

  postmodern jurisprudence, xxv

  Potsdam Declaration, 148n25

  Powell, Colin, 158

  prayer, Lord’s, xv, 94;

  in public schools, 23, 28, 34, 50, 92–93, 95–97, 135;

  Regents, 93;

  voluntary, 95

  Printz v. United States, 37n89

  privacy. See right to privacy

  Privy Council in London, 5n4

  procedural rights, 68

  prosecutorial discretion, 178

  prosecutors, federal, 177–78;

  ICC, 179–80;

  international, 179;

  role of, 178–79;

  under Rome Statute, 177;

  state, 178

  protective principle, 151, 151n29

  public schools, emergence of, 90;

  as pervasively sectarian, 99;

  prayer in, 23, 28, 34, 50, 92–93, 95–97, 135;

  religion and, 90–97

  Punishment of Serious Violations of International Humanitarian Law, 137, 156

  R. v. Bow Street Magistrates, 155n33

  Rabkin, Jeremy, 129

  racial assignment, 43

  racial discrimination, 26, 30;

  history of law against, 42;

  U.S. Congress and, 42

  Radical Republicans, 54

  Reagan, Ronald, 99;

  Supreme Court appointments of, 51

  Reagan v. Farmers’ Loan and Trust Co., 66n32

  reason, principles of, 63n20

  reasoned judgment, 76

  Reconstruction Amendments. See Civil War Amendments

  Reed v. Reed, 33n72

  Regents of Univ. of California v. Bakke, 4n3, 45–46

  Regents prayer, 93

  Rehnquist Court, 32–35, 37, 101;

  capital punishment and, 34;

  Miranda rights and, 34;

  Roe v. Wade and, 34;

  sex discrimination and, 34

  Rehnquist, William, 75–76, 89, 104, 109

  religion, xv–xvi;

  denigration of, xxvi;

  law and, xxii;

  nondiscriminatory aid to, 89;

  public schools and, 90–97

  religious establishments, courts and, 102–5

  Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1993, 33n73, 107

  religious liberty, as first liberty, 86;

  Supreme Court and, 85–134

  religious symbols on public property, 23, 28

  Restatement (Third) of the Foreign Relations Law of the United States, 152n32

  Revolutionary War, 116

  Rex v. Dawson, 139

  Reynolds, George, 105

  Reynolds v. Simms, 31n69

  Reynolds v. United States, 105

  von Ribbentrop, Joachim, 144

  Riggirozzi, Maria Pia, 118

  right(s), ambassadorial, 165, 167;

  arising from natural law, 78;

  of association, 71n56;

  civil, xxiv, 25–26, 41–42, 44–46, 46n112;

  family, xvii;

  hierarchy of, 68;

  human, 121, 127, 130;

  judge-made, 81;

  of marital privacy, 71n56;

  Miranda, 28, 33–34;

  personal, 69;

  procedural, 68;

  property, 69;

  rights of action v., 162–66

  right to privacy, xiii–xiv, 57–83;

  constitutional expansion of, 68–69;

  foundation of, 71;

  history of, 60–74;

  impingement on, 83;

  political price of, 74–80;

  practicality of, 61n14

  Ring v. Arizona, 34n80

  Rivkin, David B., Jr., xxxiii–xxxv

  Robb, Roger, 162

  Roberson v. Rochester Folding Box Co., 61n14

  Roe v. Wade, xiv, 20–21, 21n40, 23–24, 32, 33n72, 58, 71n56, 72, 75;

  Rehnquist Court and, 34

  Rome Statute, 173–75;

  prosecutors under, 177;

  U.S. and, 180

  Rome Treaty, 123, 125, 136

  Romer v. Evans, xxi, 34n79

  Roosevelt, Franklin, 10n17, 15, 25, 144;

  on Supreme Court decisions, 7n8

  Rosenberger v. University of Virginia, 108n39

  Rubin, Alfred, 140

  rule by dead, 10

  rule of immunity, 157–58

  Rumsfeld, Donald, 127, 158

  sacramental peyote use, 107

  Salazar, Enrique Camerena, 166

  Santa Fe Independent School District v. Jane Doe, 96n16, 101

  Santería religion, 108

  Scalia, Antonin, xxii, xxx, 35, 72n58, 75–76, 83, 106–7, 168;

  due process and, 81;

  on judicial gnosticism, xi;

  Sosa opinion of, 169n66;

  substantive due process and, 81n101

  Schad v. Mount Ephraim, 29n57

  Schecter Poultry Corp. v. United States, 25n51

  school segregation, 22–23;

  prohibition of, 27;

  Warren Court and, 33

  segregation, 25

  selective nihilism, xxv

  self-government, 60

  Seminole Tribe v. Florida, 36n88

  sense of sacred, xxv–xxvii

  separation of church and state, 88–89, 99;

  Protestant version of, 91

  Separation of Church and State (Hamburger), 91

  separationist doctrine, 89, 98

  1783 Treaty of Paris, 174

  sex discrimination, xxiii, 30;

  Rehnquist Court and, 34;

  Warren Court and, 33

  Shad v. Mount Ephraim, 17n33

  Sharon, Ariel, 127, 158

  Shattuck, Charles E., 57

  Sherbert, Adell, 105

  Sherbert v. Verner, 33n73, 105–7

  sixties decade, x

  Slaughter House Cases, 14–16, 65n28

  slavery, 25

  Smith, Alfred, 106

  Smyth v. Ames, 66n33

  Snyder v. Massachusetts, 68n44

  social activists, 135

  soft power, 114

  Sosa v. Alvarez-Machain, 166, 168–69

  Souter, David, xiv, 35, 58, 72–73, 75, 82

  South Dakota v. Dole, 37n92

  Soviet Union, 30;

  history of, 113–14;

  role in Nuremburg Trials, 144

  Speer, Albert, 144

  stare decisis, 82

  state prosecutors, 178

  state sovereignty, 133

  Stenberg v. Carhart, 22n42, 34n74

  Stevens, John Paul, 35, 96

  Stevens, Thaddeus, 53–54

  Stewart, Potter, 75, 93

  Stimson, Henry, 144

  Stone, Harlan Fiske, 69

  Stone v. Farmers’ Loan and Trust Co., 65n29

  Stone v. Graham, 17n32, 95

/>   Story, Joseph, xxi, 63n21, 77–78, 140

  Strauder v. West Virginia, 54n123

  Straw, Jack, 155

  substantive due process, 15–16, 18–19;

  creation of, 62–63;

  Douglas, William O., and, 70;

  Dred Scott v. Sandford and, 65;

  Lochner v. New York and, 66;

  “reasonableness” of, 68;

  revival of, 41n96;

  U.S. Constitution and, 65

  Supreme Court, as activist court, 32n70;

  American society and, x;

  capital punishment and, 24;

  compared to Grand Council of Ayatollah, 3;

  conservatives identified in, 35;

  intellectual allies of, xx;

  justices, xii, 2–4, 8–11, 39–41, 51;

  liberal academics and, 32;

  liberal victories in, 35;

  limiting power of, 47–55;

  makeup of, 35;

  media and, 32;

  myth of conservatism and, 32–37;

  as oracle of U.S. Constitution, 48;

  overturning rulings of, 51–52;

  as perpetual censor, 15;

  personal preferences and, 41–42;

  politics of, xix;

  public’s view of, 32;

  religion and, xvi;

  religious liberty and, 85–134;

  rulings of unconstitutionality by, 2–3;

  sacredness of, xxvii;

  school racial integration requirement of, 44;

  secularizing influence of, 86–90;

  state courts and, 64;

  U.S. Congress’s power over, 49–50

  Supreme Court justices, as elites, 4;

  as final lawmakers, 2–3;

  life tenure of, 51;

  proposed election of, 51;

  qualifications of, 40–41;

  skills of, 39–40;

  U.S. Constitution and, 8–11

  Swann v. Charlotte-Mecklenburg Bd. of Educ., 22n43, 33n72, 52;

  desegregation and, 45

  taboos, xxvii–xxix

  Tahoe-Sierra Preservation Council, Inc. v. Tahoe Regional Planning Agency, 36n87

  Talmud, 12

  Tax Code, 12

  tax exemptions, for churches, 102

  taxation without representation, 116

  Tel-Oren v. Libya, 161–64

  Ten Commandments, 95

  Terrett v. Taylor, 63n21

  terrorism, 133

  Texas v. Johnson, xxvin25, 17n33, 29n59

  Thakur, Ramesh, xxxiii

  Third Reich, 144

  Thirteenth Amendment, 13–14

  Thomas, Clarence, xxiv, 35, 76, 100

  Tileson v. Ullman, 17n35

  Tinker v. Des Moines Ind. Community School District, 17n33, 29n60

  Tocqueville, Alexis de, 1, 25, 47, 110, 135

  Tokyo Tribunal, 130

  tort, 160;

  as legal wrong, 164

  tort claim, 160–61

  Torture Victims Protection Act, 162n49

  transcendental politics, xviii–xix

  transportation subsidies, for parochial schools, 88

  treaty negotiations, 123

  Treaty of Rome, xxxii–xxxiii

  Treaty of Westphalia (1648), 132

  treaty-based law, xxxii–xxxiii, 124;

  examples of, 124–25

 

‹ Prev