A Stone and a Spear by Raymond F. Jones
(Reconstructed from Galaxy Magazine December 1950)
Given: The future is probabilities merging into one certainty. Proposition: Can the probabilities be made improbables so that the certainty becomes impossible?
FROM Frederick to Baltimore, the rolling Maryland countryside lay under a fresh blanket of green. Wholly unaware of the summer glory, Dr. Curtis Johnson drove swiftly on the undulating highway, stirring clouds of dust and dried grasses.
Beside him, his wife, Louise, held her blowing hair away from her face and laughed into the warm air. "Dr. Dell isn't going to run away. Besides, you said we could call this a weekend vacation as well as a business trip."
Curt glanced at the speedometer and eased the pressure on the pedal. He grinned. "Wool-gathering again."
"What about?"
"I was just wondering who said it first — one of the fellows at Detrick, or that Lieutenant at Bikini, or—"
"Said what? What are you talking about?"
"That crack about the weapons after the next war. He — whoever it was — said there may be some doubt about what the weapons of the next war will be like, but there is absolutely no doubt about the weapons of World War IV. It will be fought with stones and spears. I guess any one of us could have said it."
Louise's smile grew tight and thin. "Don't any of you ever think of anything but the next war — any of you?"
"How can we? We're fighting it right now."
"You make it sound so hopeless."
"That's what Dell said in the days just before he quit. He said we didn't have to stay at Detrick producing the toxins and aerosols that will destroy millions of lives. But he never showed us how we could quit — and be sure of staying alive. His own walking out was no more than a futile gesture."
"I just can't understand him, Curt. I think he's right in a way, but what brought him to that viewpoint?"
"Hard to tell," Curt said, unconsciously speeding up again. "After the war, when the atomic scientists were publicly examining their consciences, Dell told them to examine their own guts first. That was typical of him then, but soon after, he swung just as strongly pacifist and walked out of Detrick."
"It still seems strange that he abandoned his whole career. The world's foremost biochemist giving up the laboratory for a truck farm!" Louise glanced down at the lunch basket between them. In it were tomatoes that Dr. Hamon Dell had sent along with his invitation to visit him.
FOR nearly a year Dr. Dell had been sending packages of choice fruit and vegetables to his former colleagues, not only at the biological warfare center at Camp Detrick but at the universities and other research centers throughout the country.
"I wish we knew exactly why he asked us to come out," said Louise.
"Nobody claims to have figured him out. They laugh a little at him now. They eat his gifts willingly enough, but consider him slightly off his rocker. He still has all his biological talents, though. I've never seen or tasted vegetables like the ones he grows."
"And the brass at Detrick doesn't think he's gone soft in the head, either," she added much too innocently. "So they ordered you to take advantage of his invitation and try to persuade him to come back."
Curt turned his head so sharply that Louise laughed.
"No, I didn't read any secret, hush-hush papers," she said. "But it's pretty obvious, isn't it, the way you rushed right over to General Hansen after you got the invitation?"
"It is hush-hush, top-secret stuff," said Curt, his eyes once more on the road. "The Army doesn't want it to leak, but they need Dell, need him badly. Anyone knowing bio-war developments would understand. They wanted to send me before. Dell's invitation was the break we needed. I may be the one with sufficient influence to bring him back. I hope so. But • keep it under your permanent and forget your guessing games. There's more to it than you know."
The car passed through a cool, wooded section and Louise leaned back and drank in the beauty of it.
"Hush-hush, top secret stuff," she said. "Grown men playing children's games."
"Pretty deadly games for children, darling."
IN THE late afternoon they bypassed the central part of Baltimore and headed north beyond the suburb of Towson toward Dell's truck farm.
His sign was visible for a half mile:
YOU ARE WHAT YOU EAT
Eat the Best
EAT DELL'S VEGETABLES
"Dr. Hamon Dell, world's foremost biochemist — and truck farmer," Curt muttered as he swung the car off the highway.
Louise stepped out when the tires ceased crunching on the gravel lane. She scanned the fields and old woods beyond the ancient but preserved farmhouse. "It's so unearthly."
Curt followed. The song of birds, which had been so noticeable before, seemed strangely muted. The land itself was an alien, faintly greenish hue, a color repulsive to more than just the eyes.
"It must be something in this particular soil," said Curt, "something that gives it that color and produces such wonderful crops. I'll have to remember to ask Dell about it."
"You want Dr. Dell?"
They whirled at the sound of an unfamiliar voice. Louise ut tered a startled cry.
The gaunt figure behind them coughed asthmatically and pointed with an arm that seemed composed only of bones and brownish skin, so thin as to be almost translucent.
"Yes," said Curt shakenly. "We're friends of his."
"Dell's in back. I'll tell him you're here."
The figure shambled away and Louise shook herself as if to rid her mind of the vision. "If our grandchildren ever ask about zombies, I can tell them. Who in the world do you suppose he is?"
"Hired man, I suppose. Sounds as if he should be in a lung sanatarium. Funny that Dell would keep him around in that condition."
From somewhere behind the house came the sound of a truck engine. Curt took Louise's arm and led her around the trim, graveled path.
The old farmhouse had been very carefully renovated. Everywhere was evidence of exqusite care, yet the cumulative atmosphere remained uninviting, almost oppressive. Curt told himself it was the utter silence, made even more tense by the lonely chugging of the engine in back, and the incredible harsh color of the soil beneath their feet.
ROUNDING the corner, they came in sight of a massive tank truck. From it a hose led to an underground storage tank and pulsed slowly under the force of the liquid gushing through it. No one was in sight.
"What could that be for?" asked Louise.
"You've got me. Could be gasoline, but Dell hasn't any reason for storing that much here."
They advanced slowly and amazement crept over Curt as he comprehended the massiveness of the machine. The tank was of elliptical cross section, over ten
feet on its major axis. Six double wheels supported the rear; even the front ones were double. In spite of such wide weight distribution, the tires were pressing down the utterly dry ground to a depth of an inch or more.
'They must haul liquid lead in that thing," said Curt.
"It's getting cool. I wish Dell would show up." Louise glanced out over the twenty-acre expanse of truck farm. Thick rows of robust plants covered the area. Tomatoes, carrots, beets, lettuce, and other vegetables — a hundred or so fruit trees were at the far end. Between them ran the road over which the massive truck had apparently entered the farm from the rear.
A heavy step sounded abruptly and Dell's shaggy head appeared from around the end of the truck. His face lighted with pleasure.
"Curt, my boy! And Louise! I thought you weren't going to show up at all."
Curt's hand was almost lost in Dell's enormous grip, but it wasn't because of that that his grip was passive. It was his shocked reaction to
Dell's haggard appearance. The fierce eyes looked merely old and tired now. The ageless, leathery hide of Dell's face seemed to have collapsed before some overpowering decay, its bronze smoothness shattered by deep lines that were like tool marks of pain.
Curt spoke in a subdued voice. "It's hard to get away from Detrick. Always one more experiment to try — "
" — And the brass riding you as if they expected you to win another war for them tomorrow afternoon," said Dell. "I remember."
"We wondered about this truck," Louise commented brightly, trying to change the subject. "We finally gave up on it."
"Oh, that. It brings liquid fertilizer to pump into my irrigation water, that's all. No mystery. Let's go on to the house. After you're settled we can catch up on everything and I'll tell you about the things I'm doing here."
"Who's the man we saw?" asked Curt. "He looks as if his health is pretty precarious."
"That's Brown. He came with the place — farmed it for years for my uncle before I inherited it. He could grow a garden on a granite slab. In spite of appearances, he's well enough physically."
"How has your own health been ? You have — changed — since you were at Detrick."
Dell raised a lock of steel-gray hair in his fingers and dismissed the question with a wan smile. "We all wear out sometime," he said. "My turn had to come."
INSIDE, some of the oppressiveness vanished as the evening passed. It was cool enough for lighting the fireplace, and they settled before it after dinner. While they watched the flickering light that whipped the beamed ceiling, Dell entertained them with stories of his neighbors, whose histories he knew clear back to Revolutionary times.
Early, however, Louise excused herself. She knew they would want privacy to thresh out the purposes behind Dell's invitation — and Curt's acceptance.
When she was gone, there was a moment's silence. The logs crackled with shocking pistol shots in the fireplace. The scientist moved to stir the coals and then turned abruptly to Curt.
"When are you going to leave Detrick?"
"When are you coming back?" Curt demanded instead of answering
"So they still want me, even after the things I said when I left."
"You're needed badly. When I told Hansen I was coming down, he said it would be worth five years of my own work to bring you back."
'They want me to produce even deadlier toxins than those I gave them," Dell said viciously. 'They want some that can kill ten million people in four minutes instead of only one million — "
"Any man would go insane if he looked at it that way. It would be the same as gun -makers being tormented by the vision of torn men destroyed by their bullets, the sorrowing families — "
"And why shouldn't the gunmakers be tormented?" Dell's voice was low with controlled hate. "They are men like you and me who give the t^r-makers new tools for their trade."
"Oh, Dell, it's not as simple as that." Curt raised a hand and let it fall wearily. They had been over this so many times before. "Weapon designers are no more responsible than any other agents of society. It's pure neurosis to absorb the whole guilt of wars yet un fought merely because you happened to have developed a potential weapon."
Dell touched the massive dome of his skull. "Here within this brain of mine has been conceived a thing which will probably destroy a billion human lives in the coming years. D. triconus toxin in a suitable aerosol requires only a countable number of molecules in the lungs of a man to kill him. My brain and mine alone is responsible for that vicious, murderous discovery."
"Egotism! Any scientist's work is built upon the pyramid of past knowledge."
"THE weapon I have described exists. If I had not created it, it would not exist. It is as simple as that. No one shares my guilt and my responsibility. And what more do they want of me now? What greater dream of mass slaughter and destruction have they dreamed?"
"They want you," said Curt quietly, "because they believe we are not the only ones possessing' the toxin. They need you to come back and help find the antitoxin for D. triconus."
Dell shook his head. "That's a blind hope. The action of D. triconus is like a match set to a powder train. The instant its molecules contact protoplasm, they start a chain reaction that rips apart the cell structure. It spreads like fire from one cell to the next, and nothing can stop it once it's started operating within a given organism."
"But doesn't this sense of guilt — unwarranted as it is — make you want to find an antitoxin?"
"Suppose I succeeded? I would have canceled the weapon of an enemy. The military would know he could nullify ours in time. Then they would command me to work out still another toxin. It's a vicious and insane circle, which must be broken somewhere. The purpose of the entire remainder of my life is to break it."
"When you are fighting for your life and the enemy already has his hands about your throat," Curt argued, "you reach for the biggest rock you can get your hands on and beat his brains in. You don't try to persuade him that killing is unethical."
For an instant it seemed to Curt that a flicker of humor touched the corners of Dell's mouth. Then the lines tightened down again.
"Exactly," he said. "You reach for a rock and beat his brains in. You don't wipe human life off the face of the Earth in order to reach that enemy. I asked you to come down here to help me break this circle of which I spoke. There has to be someone here — after I'm gone — "
Dell's eyes shifted to the depths of shadows beyond the firelight and remained fixed on unseen images.
"Me? Help you?" Curt asked" incredulously. "What could I do? Give up science and become a truck gardener, too?"
"You might say that we would be in the rock business," replied Dell. "Fighting is no longer on the level of one man with his hands .-about another's throat, but it should be. Those who want power and domination should have to fight for it personally. But it has been a long time since they had to.
"WHEN in the old days, kings — and emperors, hired mercenaries to fight their wars. The militarists don't buy swords now. They buy brains. We're the mercenaries of the new day, Cart, you and I. Once there was honor in our profession. We searched for truth for its own sake, and because it was our way of life. Once we were the hope of the world because science was a universal language.
"What a horrible joke that turned out to be! Today we are the terror of the world. The warmakers built us fine laboratories, shining palaces, and granted every whim — for a price. They took us up to the hills and showed us the whole world and we sold our souls for it.
"Look what happened after the last war. Invading armies carried off prize Nazi brains like so much loot, set the scientists up in big new laboratories, and these new mercenaries keep right on pouring out knowledge for other kings and emperors.
"Their loyalty is only to their science. But they can't experiment for knowledge any more, only weapons and counter-weapons. You'll say I'm anti-war, even, perhaps, anti-American or pro-Russian. I am not against just wars, but I am against unjust slaughter. And I love America too much to let her destroy herself along with the enemy."
'Then what are we to do?" Curt demanded fiercely. "What are we to do while enemy scientists prepare these same weapons to exterminate us? Sure, it's one hell of a mess. Science is already dead. The kind you talk about has been dead for twenty years. All our fine ideals are worthless until the politicians find a solution to their quarrels."
"Politicians? Since when did men of science have to wait upon politicians for solutions of human problems?" Dell passed a hand over his brow, and suddenly his face contorted in pain.
"What is it?" Curt exclaimed, rising.
"Nothing — nothing, my boy. Some minor trouble I've had lately. It will pass in a moment."
With effort, he went on. "I wanted to say that already you have come to think of science being divided into armed camps by the artificial boundaries of the politicians. Has it been so long ago that it was not even in your lifetime, when scientists regarded themselves as one
international brotherhood?"
"I can't quarrel with your ideals," said Curt softly. "But national boundary lines do, actually, divide the scientists of the world into armed camps."
<*"7"OUIl premises are still inJL correct. They do not deliberately war on each other. It is only that they have blindly sold themselves as mercenaries. And they can be called upon to redeem themselves. They can break their unholy contracts."
'There would have to be simultaneous agreement among the scientists of all nations. And they are men, influenced by national
ideals. They are not merely ivory-tower dabblers and searchers after truth."
"Do you remember me five years ago?" Dell's face became more haggard, as if the memory shamed him. "Do you remember when I told the atomic scientists to examine their guts instead of their consciences ? ' '
A Stone & a Spear Page 1