by Marla Monroe
“You should have seen her face, Brody. She looked like a tormented angel when she came.”
Caitlyn moaned as Brody thrust inside of her over and over until he reached her cervix. He stilled, leaning over her to catch his breath. She looked up to see his head was thrown back and a look of intense concentration across his face. She could tell that he was trying to keep from coming too soon. She rolled her lips into her mouth and held them there with her teeth as she squeezed her cunt muscles around his cock.
“Aw, hell. Don’t do that, Caity. I’m barely holding on as it is now. I want to enjoy this, make it last.”
“Move, Brody. I need you to move.”
He slowly pulled nearly all the way out before slamming back inside of her, using his dick as a battering ram. She whimpered and raised her body to meet him. They fucked each other as Lamar sat back and watched them. Caitlyn was having none of that.
“Don’t just sit there staring, Lamar. Play with my tits and I’ll play with your balls.”
“You don’t have to do that, baby. I’ll take care of you. I just had to watch Brody take you for the first time.” He nipped at both nipples before alternating sucking on them.
This time when her orgasm began to build, she was ready for it, or so she thought. The thundering in her ears only added to the sense of the unknown. When the pleasure bordered on pain, Caitlyn threw her hands up and grabbed Lamar’s head, pulling it down for a kiss. She desperately ate at his mouth, needing that personal touch to become the catalyst to shoving her into the pleasure of coming. A tidal wave of pleasure poured over her body, making every muscle contract as she spasmed around Brody’s cock.
As her pussy squeezed his dick, she heard him shout out his own orgasm, filling the condom with hot cum. He fell over her, catching himself on his hands before he suffocated her. Lamar moved out of the way just in time. It barely registered at the time that Brody was talking until her ears stopped ringing.
“…you’re the best thing that’s ever happened to us, Caity.”
She shivered at his words, knowing that things wouldn’t turn out the way that he wanted. Then he was pulling out of her, holding on to the condom, and Lamar was taking his place.
“Please tell me you’re not too sore.”
“Just don’t expect me to come. I’m climaxed out for the night.”
“Baby, you’re going to come if I have to fuck you all night.”
She threw back her head and growled. They were going to kill her. Two times was a record for her. Hell, one time was never a sure thing, anyway. If they knew how special it was that she’d climaxed twice, they’d use it against her in their bid that she was perfect for them.
Lamar slowly entered her pussy with his sheathed cock. He didn’t hurry by any means. Instead, slow and steady seemed to be his style. He tunneled in and out of her cunt painstakingly slow until she squirmed, needing more. He grinned and began to increase the pace. It was then that she realized her body was gearing up for another round of pleasure. How could that be true? Surely there was no way she could reach that pinnacle three times in one night. It just wasn’t possible, was it?
“Hell, Caity. Your sweet pussy is dragging at me like it doesn’t want me to leave. Do you want more? I can give you more.”
“Yes! More. I want all you have, Lamar. I need more.”
He took her at her word and began to pummel her cunt with his cock, rasping over nerve endings with white-hot sensation. At the end of each shove of his dick, he bumped her cervix. She gasped at the shock of it. He stopped and looked down at her with concern.
“Don’t stop! That feels so damn good.”
“I’m not going to stop. Remember I said you were going to come even if I had to fuck you all night. I’m prepared to stick with you until you do.”
She believed him. Only she could already tell it wasn’t going to take all night. It wouldn’t even take ten minutes. Her climax crept up on her in steady steps. It seemed to rise with each kiss of his cock against her cervix. The pleasure-pain seduced her into compliance, and she shot over the top without warning, dragging Lamar with her by the sounds of the fuck ripped from his mouth.
Despite her utter exhaustion, she had to smile when he cursed again as he slowly pulled out of her pussy. He climbed off the bed after kissing the inside of her thigh and disappeared from sight. A few minutes later she heard the flush of the toilet and water running in the sink. It was the last thing she heard before she fell into an exhausted sleep.
* * * *
“She’s out like a light.” Brody yawned. He wasn’t far behind.
“Think she’s going to have regrets in the morning and try to push us away?”
“I don’t know. That’s what’s so exciting about her. You never know what to expect from her.”
“She already feels like a part of me, Brody. I don’t want her to leave Riverbend. We’ve got to convince her to at least stay and work here even if we don’t win her over right away. At least then we would have a chance.”
“Yeah, if she goes to Austin, we’ll have a much more difficult time convincing her. Plus, we’ll have competition there. No way a beautiful woman like Caitlyn will go unnoticed in a place like Austin.”
“We need some help with this. Who all do you know that takes their bookkeeping needs out of town?”
Brody rubbed a hand over his face. “I honestly don’t know offhand, but we can check around. If we come up with several names, she’ll have to really think about it.”
“I wonder how many names she needs?” Lamar mused.
“Could ask her. I don’t think that would hurt.”
“I’ll see if I can bring it up in conversation tomorrow. Then we can get to work getting the information we need.”
“That’s a plan then. In the meantime, let’s try not to push too much and let her relax. She’s going to be here for two weeks, maybe three. That should give us plenty of time to convince her that she belongs here in Riverbend.”
“I think we have all our bases covered.”
“Just as soon as you think that, something comes up to put a monkey wrench in your plans. Be careful what you say around her. I don’t want to upset her and risk her running out early.” Besides putting them in a bad situation with Brian, it would possibly ruin their chances at courting Caitlyn.
“I can’t wait till she sees our books tomorrow. Maybe that alone will convince her to stay out of mercy for us.” Brody smiled tiredly.
She had worn him out. God, she was amazing. He couldn’t stop thinking about how she looked when she came with Lamar. It had surprised her. The shocked look had been priceless. He wanted to see many more of those expressions on her face over the coming years, preferably in their bed.
“What are the odds she’ll come around, Brody?”
“I honestly don’t know.”
“I just don’t think I can stand it if we lose her. If she backs off too far or for too long, I’m going to seduce her until she agrees.”
Brody chuckled quietly. “Somehow I don’t think that will work any better. Don’t give up hope before we’ve even gotten started. We made progress tonight. She trusts us enough to let us in bed with her. That’s a big step.”
“Yeah, I know. I just hope it’s a step in the right direction. You know how women can be. I don’t want to end up the bad guy in her eyes. I want to see nothing but love there.”
Chapter Nine
Caitlyn awoke in phases. At first, she thought she was dreaming. Then she realized she wasn’t and she was lying between Brody and Lamar with a hand from each of them on her body. Brody’s was on her stomach and Lamar’s was on her breast. Confusion clouded her mind for a few seconds, and then it all came back to her in a rush.
She groaned and looked up at the ceiling. What was she going to do now? There was no going back with them. Of that she was sure. They would see having sex with them as a step toward a relationship.
Well, isn’t it? You don’t do casual sex, Caitlyn. What did you ex
pect when you let them take you to bed?
She couldn’t claim alcohol as the culprit. Certainly she’d been out of her head when she’d succumbed to their seduction, but even that was weak. No, she’d known what she had been doing. Damn.
She sighed. Not only had she had sex with them, but she’d slept in their bed all night. What would Brian say? Why hadn’t he called looking for her? She frowned. He would think of it as a positive thing, a step toward having her move to Riverbend. Did he approve of Brian and Lamar as suitable men for her?
The idea that Brian would pair her up with them on purpose took root in her mind. She frowned at the thought.
“What’s the frown for, baby?” Lamar’s still-drowsy eyes were focused on her when she turned her head.
“I’ve been kidnapped and my brother hasn’t even bothered to call looking for me.”
Lamar laughed causing Brody to wake up enough to roll over and wrap his hand around her waist. She frowned deeper at this.
“We haven’t kidnapped you and Brian knows you’re a big girl. You can spend the night with us without his worrying.”
“How does he know that something didn’t happen to me?”
“Because we would have called him if something had happened. Nothing happened though. You’re safe and sexy as hell first thing in the morning.” He winced. “Well, except for that frown.”
“I need to get up and get dressed so I can leave.” She attempted to move Brody’s heavy arm.
All she succeeded in doing was causing him to tighten his grip. He snuggled closer to her and buried his nose in her neck.
“Stop that, Brody.” She squinched up her neck in protest. His cold nose poked her warm neck, making her squeal in protest.
“Ow, that was my ear you yelled in.”
“That’s my body you’re holding down. I need to get up.”
“Not until you promise to stay for breakfast. I’ll cook scrambled eggs, toast, and bacon. How does that sound?”
“I really shouldn’t stay any longer.”
“It’s already eight o’clock. No need to be in a hurry now.”
“Don’t you have to open the shop? Won’t people be wondering where you are?”
“If they need us badly enough, they’ll call. We don’t have anything on deadline right now.”
Lamar rolled out of bed and headed for the bathroom. Caitlyn used that opening to slide out of Brody’s lax embrace to sit on the edge of the bed. She had to gather her wits about her. First things first. She needed to dress. She really needed a shower, but Lamar was probably already in the shower.
“Can I use the shower down the hall?”
“Of course, but Lamar would probably love for you to join him.” Brody had rolled over to his side of the bed and sat up.
“I’ll just use the other one.” Showering with Lamar would be an utter disaster.
She could already imagine some of the things they might do in the shower. She had to shake her head to get the images out of her mind. Leave it to her to conjure up the very thing she was trying to avoid.
She picked up her clothes, realizing that her blouse was somewhere in the living room downstairs. She’d have to deal with that after her shower. After all, they had seen her nude already. She would have her bra on.
All during her shower, she fought the images of the three of them from the night before. Then she cringed at the smug look Brian would probably give her. He hadn’t been the least surprised when she had told him that she was going out with Lamar and Brody. No doubt they had worked it out beforehand. The more she thought about it the madder she got at all of them.
She dressed after drying off, forgoing her panties, stuffing them in her pocket instead. She wasted a little time trying to tame her hair then sighed and walked out of the bathroom to find Lamar there holding out her blouse.
“Thought you would want this.”
“Um, thanks.” She looked into his eyes and saw worry and maybe just a little bit of fear. It diffused her anger at him.
She realized that she couldn’t stay mad when they had been so attentive to her. She couldn’t fault them in anything they had done while she had been with them. Brody was a bit demanding by nature, but so far he had curbed it for her benefit. She was sure that bossy bone was still there, but the fact that he was making an effort went a long way toward appeasing her aggravation with him.
“Brody is cooking breakfast. Are you about ready to go down?”
“Let me get my blouse on and I’ll be right down.” She stepped back into the bathroom and closed the door.
She guessed it was silly for her to do that when she had been standing right there in front of Lamar without it, but she felt better for having the privacy. Once again she looked in the mirror and pronounced herself as ready as she was going to get considering she’d spent the night and didn’t have her things with her.
As she walked downstairs she tried to decide if she had known deep down inside that she was going to spend the night with them to begin with. Maybe it had been in the back of her mind that it was a possibility, yet the stubborn side of her refused to admit it. She didn’t sleep around. Well, she hadn’t before now.
“Morning, Caitydid. Are you hungry?” Brody stood at the stove dressed in well-fitting jeans and a T-shirt stretched tight across his broad shoulders.
“I figured I would just have some coffee and get one of you to take me back to Brian’s.”
“Nope. You’re going to eat a healthy breakfast first. Then we’ll take you back.”
“Here’s your coffee. Do you take anything in it?” Lamar handed her a cup.
“No, thanks. I drink it black.”
Once again the bossy bone was in full view. At least he’d smiled when he’d said it, and he had gone to the trouble of cooking for her. The least she could do was eat it. Shrugging her shoulders so as not to appear that she’d given in so easily, Caitlyn sat at the bar and accepted the plate of eggs, bacon, and toast he handed her. She had to admit that it smelled good. When her stomach rumbled, she ducked her head.
The men both chuckled as they dug into their plates piled high with food. She guessed they burned a lot of calories doing what they did with welding and working with heavy materials.
As soon as they she finished, Caitlyn took her dishes to the sink and rinsed them off. She hesitated at loading them in the dishwasher. She didn’t know if they used it or not. Some men didn’t bother with it.
“Just set your plate by the sink. We’ll tend to them later.” Lamar came to her rescue.
She sat back down and waited for the men to finish eating. They each rinsed off their plates and set them on top of hers. Then Brody walked over to her and wrapped his arms around her before she realized what he was going to do. He looked down in her face and smiled.
“Last night was beautiful. Don’t overthink it, Caitlyn. We’re all adults, and you mean a lot to us.” He hugged her and kissed the top of her head.
Then he passed her off to Lamar who hugged her as well and kissed her forehead before letting her go.
“Ready to leave?” Brody pulled out his keys.
“Um, yeah. I better go if I’m going to get back here by one to work on your books.”
She almost missed their look of relief when she said that. They had obviously thought she might back out of helping them work on their books. She wasn’t going to be petty and refuse to help them with something like that. She was better than that. It hurt her that they had believed the worst.
Brody led the way out to the truck. He climbed up in the driver’s seat, and Lamar helped her up on the passenger’s side, getting in beside her. He draped his arm behind her along the back of the seat. She expected him to let it fall to her shoulders on the ride down to Brian’s house, but he didn’t.
It only took five minutes to reach her brother’s place, but it was a long five minutes to her. She kept expecting them to say something. Maybe they thought she should say something. What did she say? This was all new to her.
When they pulled up into the drive, Brody surprised her by turning off the engine and getting out of the cab. Lamar helped her down and the two men walked her to the door. She knocked, much to their amusement.
“What?”
“I wouldn’t think you would need to knock. You’re Brian’s sister and are staying with him,” Brody said.
Before she could answer him, Andy opened the door.
“Hey, you don’t have to knock. Come on in.” He backed up and held the door until all three of them had entered. “Brian is already at the store with Tish. I’m running late.”
“Oh. Okay.”
Somehow the fact that Brian hadn’t stayed at home waiting on her to be sure she was okay bothered her. The fact that she’d been dreading it and had worked herself up into telling him to mind his own business didn’t sit well with her. How could she be angry with him when she was a grown woman and didn’t need his approval? She had just had words with him for butting into her business, so how could she be angry with him for not being there, butting into her business?
She huffed out a breath and relegated herself to sucking it up and admitting that she wanted his involvement in some things. She wasn’t sure how she expected him to know which things.
“I’ll just change clothes and head over there.” She turned to Lamar and Brody, unsure of what to say to them.
“Thanks for bringing me home.”
They grinned knowing smiles and nodded. Then they each gave her a brief kiss before nodding at Andy and leaving.
“I’ll wait on you so you don’t have to take your car.”
“Thanks, but I need it today. I’m going back to their house at one to work on their books some.”
“Okay. I’ll be leaving in a few minutes. Just lock up behind you.” Andy smiled and disappeared into what she knew was the office.
Caitlyn hurried up the stairs to her room and changed clothes. She spent a few minutes in the bathroom brushing her teeth and combing her hair to make herself presentable. Then she hurried downstairs. She locked the house behind her and headed to town. When she arrived at the store, Andy was just getting out of his truck. He smiled and waved as she pulled in.