by Marla Monroe
He looked over at Caitlyn as she watched the movie. He needed to put it out of his mind while they had her there with them. She was obviously picking up on his stress. She naturally would think it had to do with her. Having her there with them was soothing in a way. He just had to concentrate on the time they had with her. He had no doubt she was going to leave. Lamar still had hope, but he was more realistic. No matter how hard they tried to convince her she belonged with them, her past was in the way. She was probably right. It was too soon for her to have put it behind her.
Right now, they had her sitting between them on the couch. He had his hand on her thigh because he had to touch her. Lamar seemed to be the same way since he had his arm across her shoulders. Brody was drawn to her like a moth to a flame. She seemed to lift some of the darkness he often felt was inside of him.
Now that they’d had her with them, he wondered how he would be able to handle losing her presence in their lives. Sure, they could see her occasionally in Austin when they drove over there, but it wouldn’t be the same, and it wouldn’t last long.
The movie was coming to an end. He waited until the last possible minute to move his hand to grab the remote to the DVD player.
“That was a really good movie.” She stretched, dislodging Lamar’s arm from her shoulders in the process.
Brody turned off the DVD player and changed the channel on the TV to one that had something besides paid advertising on it. He looked back at her and couldn’t help but smile because she was smiling.
“Yeah, it was a good movie. Both of them were.”
“It’s close to midnight. I’m ready for bed.” Lamar stood up before reaching down and grabbing Caitlyn’s hand.
“Sounds good to me.” Brody took her other hand, and they pulled her to her feet.
“Slow down, you two. Your legs are longer than mine.”
They both slowed down, making sure not to pull her along anymore. Brody hadn’t thought about anything other than getting her in bed. No doubt Lamar had been thinking the same thing.
Once they were upstairs in the bedroom, he turned and reached for her. She smiled and took a step back. He liked the playful side of her. He was usually all business, but it was nice to loosen up some.
He stalked her as she backed away from him until he had her pinned to the wall. Her eyes widened when he stepped into her personal space and cupped her cheek in his hand. There was nothing that he wanted more than to bury himself so far inside of her that she couldn’t imagine him not being there.
“I want you, Caity. I want you so badly I can’t think right now.”
“Yes.” Her voice came out breathy. His cock, already hard, tightened more behind the zipper of his jeans.
He was vaguely aware of Lamar pulling the covers to the end of the bed and throwing the pillows to the floor. Brody wanted both of them to take her at the same time tonight. Something told him that the timing was important. He felt like she was on the cusp with her emotions concerning them.
“We want you.” He clarified his statement. “Both of us want to make love to you at the same time. Will you let us?”
He watched her eyes widen then darken with arousal. He had his answer. She wanted the same thing.
“I’ve never done that before.”
“Have two men at the same time?” he asked.
“That or had anal sex. I don’t know if I can.”
Lamar spoke up from where he was waiting at the side of the bed. “We’ll go slowly. We would never hurt you, Caity. If you say stop, we’ll stop.”
“Give us a chance to show you pleasure like you’ve never felt before.” Brody held his breath as she thought about it.
When she said yes, he let it out in a whoosh. He made short work of ridding her of her clothes. Lamar was busy undressing himself. Only Brody still had his clothes on when he picked her up and carried her to the bed. He gently laid her down then backed away to pull off his clothes. His brother took that opportunity to zero in on her breasts. He watched him lick and suck at her nipples as he finished undressing. The sight had his already rock-hard cock jumping with his heartbeat.
He wanted to make her come first, but knew that would leave her swollen, making it more difficult for them to work their way inside of her. Instead, they would play with her until she was on the verge so that she would need to come so badly that the slight pain she would feel wouldn’t matter.
“Lamar, get a condom on.”
Caitlyn whimpered when his brother let go of her nipple with a soft pop. She reached for him as he pulled away to reach a condom in the bedside table drawer. He pulled out two and fished out the lube while he was in there. Tossing one of the condoms and the lube to Brody, Lamar tore open the condom and quickly rolled it on his thick dick. He ran his hand up and down it a couple of times as he watched Caitlyn’s face.
“Caity, climb on Lamar and ride him. I want to watch your hot pussy suck him inside of you.” Brody smoothed down his condom over his cock and grasped the base and squeezed as Caitlyn crawled over Lamar’s prone body.
He drew in a deep breath as she slowly lowered her body over Lamar’s dick. Her pussy lips separated as she inched down the thick cock, stretching her slit wide to accommodate Lamar’s extreme width. The sight of her cunt spreading wide for Lamar had him swallowing and grasping his cock tighter as he pumped up and down it. He stopped before he lost it.
“Your pussy is so pretty and pink wrapped around Lamar’s dick.”
“He fills me up inside. It almost hurts, he’s so big.”
“Just wait until I get inside of you, too. You’re going to be so full of cock you won’t know what to do.”
Brody took the lube and pressed lightly on her back to get her to lie flat on top of Lamar. She obeyed without asking. He reveled in her acceptance of his dominance.
“You’re going to feel something cold back here, baby. Just relax and let me work you open. I’m going to play with this little hole back here.”
She wiggled her ass, much to Lamar’s frustration by the sound of it. His brother groaned and reached up to hold her still.
“Don’t move, Caity. I don’t want to come yet.”
Brody suppressed a chuckle. He knew his brother wouldn’t appreciate it. Instead, he dribbled a small amount of lube on the little pucker of her ass. She stiffened for just a second, and then relaxed again. He spread the jelly around her back hole before applying a little pressure until just the tip of one finger breached it. He moved it in and out the tiniest bits before withdrawing it and applying more lube.
This time he pressed against the dark rosette until she was taking him to the first knuckle. She moaned when he pressed a little deeper to his second knuckle. He waited for her to adjust to him. Then he pumped his finger in and out until she was easily accepting him to the webbing of his hand.
“How are you doing, Caity?” He wanted to be sure she was all right.
“I’m fine. It’s not really hurting. It just feels weird.”
“Good. I’m going to add another finger.”
She shivered all over. Lamar groaned.
Brody added more lube before adding a second finger to the first. She resisted him at first, but when he massaged her lower back and talked to her, she slowly relaxed and let him in.
“Good girl. Just relax. Push out when I push in.”
“Oh, God, it stings. I need to move, Brody.”
“Don’t move, baby. You’ll set Lamar off. Just concentrate on relaxing and letting me in.”
He felt her relax her ass as he carefully slid both fingers all the way in. Then he carefully moved them in and out of her until she was trying to push back to meet him. He figured she was as ready as she was going to get now. He removed his fingers earning him a moan.
After applying a liberal amount of the jelly to his sheathed cock, Brody positioned himself at her back hole and slowly pushed. She whimpered but he could tell she was pushing back against him. She didn’t ask him to stop. Pressing a little harder
, he finally breached her tight ring with the head of his dick.
“Oh, God! You’re so big.”
“Are you okay, baby?” Lamar asked in a strained voice.
“Yes. How much more?”
“I’m just barely inside of you, Caity. Do I need to stop?”
“No. I’m okay. Just hurry.”
Brody pulled back a little then surged forward into her tight hole. After a few more pushes, he was all the way inside of her and stopped moving to give her time to adjust to his being inside of her at the same time Lamar was. He knew she would feel full of cock.
“Please, Brody. You’ve got to move. I can’t stand it. Move!”
Brody smiled. He pulled out and pushed forward as Lamar pulled out and returned. They set a rhythm so that one of them filled her at all times. She tried to rock with them, but Brody stopped her.
“Easy, baby. Let us do the work. Just feel. Feel us loving you. God, you’re squeezing my dick so hard it almost hurts.”
“It burns. I need more, Brody, Lamar. Faster.” Her breathy voice was music to his ears.
They sped up until each of them tunneled in and out of her, rushing toward their climax. He wanted her to come first. He needed to hear her reach hers before they did. She was all that mattered in that instant. Everything rested on her pleasure. Brody broke out in a sweat as he staved off his orgasm, praying that Lamar would be able to hold on just a little longer. She had to come first.
* * * *
Caitlyn mewed as the pressure built inside of her. The pleasure-pain of Brody fucking her in the ass only added to the sweet pressure that was growing deep inside her cunt, spreading out to the rest of her body with each stroke of their cocks inside of her.
Lamar’s dick rasped over her sweet spot with each plunge, sending tentacles of warmth throughout her bloodstream. Her cunt was alive with sensation.
Brody’s cock had awakened nerve endings inside her ass that she never knew existed before that moment. Her ass was on fire as every stroke of his dick built her pleasure until she thought she would explode with it. She tried to push back against him to urge him faster, harder, but he wouldn’t change his rhythm. Frustrated, Caitlyn whimpered as she curled her hands tighter over Lamar’s shoulders. She squeezed down on both men in an effort to speed up their orgasms, anything to end the need burning inside her bloodstream.
“Fuck, baby. Don’t do that. I want you to come before I do.” Lamar grunted when she did it again.
“You’re playing with fire, Caity.” Brody pulled her ass cheeks farther apart as he stroked his cock in and out of her back hole.
Now the pleasure was growing too fast. She didn’t think she could handle it. It would kill her if she came like this. It was too much, too soon.
“I can’t do it. Please, it’s too much.”
“It’s not. Let it happen. Fly for us, baby.” Brody slammed into her over and over.
Lamar reached up and pulled on her nipples, sending sparks flying through her body. She ignited into pleasure so intense that it was almost painful. Explosions rippled through her cunt and fire raced through her veins sending wave after wave of sensation pounding into her as hard as the men were thrusting inside of her.
Even in the throes of her orgasm, she knew when they lost their rhythm and began to fill their condoms with scalding hot cum. Together they rode the waves of pleasure until they all collapsed. In that instant, Caitlyn knew she had lost the fight and had fallen in love with them. They had filled her body with their cocks, but they had also filled her heart with their loving.
She gasped for breath even as tears slid from her eyes to wet Lamar’s chest. A sweet pain burned her soul with the knowledge that they had no real future together. She would be leaving in the next two and a half or three weeks. They might come see her for awhile, but eventually they would tire of the trips and stop altogether.
All of this drifted through her mind as she lay there listening to the rapid beat of Lamar’s heart. Brody slowly pulled from her body and her sweat-soaked skin cooled in the night air. When he returned, it was to clean her up with a damp cloth. Then they lifted her off of Lamar and settled her under the covers between them. Their tender care was almost more than she could handle. Thank goodness they hadn’t realized she was crying. She let the tears flow until sleep finally claimed her.
Chapter Fourteen
Caitlyn stood outside at her brother’s house while he, Andy, and Tish said their vows to each other. It was a beautiful ceremony made even more so by the fact that the two men were obviously in love with Tish. She was equally in love with them by the soft glow on her face and the smile in her eyes.
They had already had the legal wedding between Tish and Brian. Andy had been Brian’s best man. It all seemed so surreal to Caitlyn. Before Brian had announced he was living in a ménage relationship, she’d never heard of such a thing. Sure, she knew about ménages, but she had always assumed they were just a sex thing. Now she knew better.
Even as the three exchanged their promises, she thought about Brody and Lamar who were standing just behind her among the select guests. She loved them. Nothing had prepared her for the real deal. Her supposed marriage to Harold had been a farce in more ways than one. She’d believed herself in love with him but soon realized that it wasn’t love. Now she knew what love felt like. Right then, it hurt.
The ceremony came to an end with Brian and Andy exchanging kisses with Tish. Caitlyn pasted a smile on her face because she didn’t want Brian to worry about her. They would leave on their honeymoon after the reception and she would be able to relax her guard. She would return to their home to house-sit and handle their business until they returned. Then she would move to Austin like she had planned and get on with her life. People lived with a broken heart all the time. So could she.
“What’s wrong, Caity?” Lamar whispered in her ear.
“Nothing.”
“Yes, there is. You may have a smile on your face, but your eyes are sad.”
“Brian, Andy, and Tish are happy together. Don’t worry about them.” Brody leaned in on the other side of her.
“I know they are. It’s obvious they’re in love by the look on their faces.”
“Then what’s making you sad?” Lamar asked.
She struggled to think of something to say that would placate them. Nothing came to mind.
“I guess too much has happened lately. My baby brother is married. He’s all grown up.”
“Feeling sentimental?” Brody watched her closely.
“I guess so.”
“I’m not buying it. Something else is wrong.”
Caitlyn looked to Lamar for help, but he looked at her with an odd expression on his face. He looked disappointed for some reason. He sighed and shook his head.
“She’s already thinking about leaving,” he said.
“You’re still here for three weeks. Don’t think for one minute that we’re going to let you push us away.” Brody’s anger was a palpable thing.
The heat of it burned along her skin, leaving a trail of sadness in its wake. She felt tears stinging the back of her eyes and worked to keep them from falling. She wouldn’t ruin her brother’s reception by crying.
“Brody, don’t do this here. I can’t deal with it right now.”
“We will talk, Caitlyn. As soon as they leave on their honeymoon we’re going back to the house and deal with it there.”
She couldn’t say anything. She was afraid she would burst out crying if she did. She nodded and hurried over to Tish to hug her and wish her well. She could pass her tears off as tears of happiness for them.
Relieved that Brody and Lamar didn’t follow her, she pulled her sister-in-law into a brief hug.
“The ceremony was beautiful, Tish. I’m so happy for you and the guys.”
“Thanks. Don’t cry, silly.” She brushed away Caitlyn’s tears and laughed. “If Brian sees you crying he’s going to think something is wrong.”
“I always cry at wedd
ings, and this one is my baby brother’s.”
“Thank you for taking care of everything for us.” Tish squeezed her hands.
“I don’t mind at all. You know that. It will be fun to wrap things up and mail them. It will be almost like Christmas.”
“Still, it takes a lot of pressure off of Brian. He and Andy need this vacation after all the hard work they’ve put into everything.”
“Well, don’t forget it’s your honeymoon, too.”
“Don’t worry, we won’t let her forget.” Brian and Andy walked up. They each wrapped her in a hug.
Brian looked at her and frowned. “Are you crying?”
“I can’t help it. The ceremony was so nice.”
He grinned and draped his arm over her shoulders. “You could have one, too, sis.”
She stiffened before she could stop herself. He looked at her with speculation. Then he changed the subject.
The afternoon grew late as everyone helped Tish, Brian, and Andy celebrate their marriage. Caitlyn helped with the refreshments and watched as her brother and his new family danced and circulated among their friends.
After a while Brian pulled them over to where she was standing.
“Looks like we can make our getaway, guys. I’m ready to get out of this monkey suit and get on the road.”
Andy took Tish’s hand and the three of them slipped inside the house, leaving the guests milling about in the yard. They would all gather at the drive in an hour and throw birdseed at them as they made a mad dash to get in the truck and leave. They had already packed their belongings in it.
She grabbed another glass of champagne and sipped it as she waited for the three newlyweds to emerge from the house. Time seemed to stand still. She began to worry that they would never come out when the front door finally opened and they ran for the truck. Despite catching many of the guests off guard, it didn’t save them from handfuls of birdseed raining down on them. She had little doubt they would find it in their hair, clothes, and the car when they arrived at their destination.
As their car drove away, she began to help Rita clean up and thank the guests for coming. She was surprised to see Brody and Lamar helping to straighten up the backyard, carrying the folding tables to their truck to return to the rental store. Once everything was loaded that had been rented, Brody and another man she didn’t know took it back.