The Beginning of Infinity

Home > Other > The Beginning of Infinity > Page 56
The Beginning of Infinity Page 56

by David Deutsch


  chess 36, 114, 118, 136, 157

  choice 326–52

  apportionment paradoxes 326–33

  decision-making and social choice see decision-making

  devising an electoral system 338–40

  social-choice theory 335, 337–8, 342–3, 345, 352

  applied to an individual mind 340–41

  voters’ 342

  cholera 207

  Churchill, Winston 201, 333

  cimenti 14

  civilization

  Athenian 216–18, 224–5, 229–33, 244–51, 246

  of Easter Island 418, 419–23, 430–31

  extra-terrestrial civilizations 202–4

  Florentine 218–20

  optimism and 208–22

  pessimism and 196–203

  Polynesian 419, 421, 427

  present and pre-Enlightenment 204

  Spartan 218, 230–33, 244–51

  survival 62–3, 196–7, 202, 204–5, 206–8

  vulnerability of 201, 202–3, 207–8, 436; see also disasters, natural

  see also societies

  climate change 437–41

  Cold War 196, 205, 428

  Colossus computers 139

  common sense 266

  mistaken 5, 26, 82, 122, 262, 279, 280, 340, 397, 403

  see also reason

  complementarity, principle of 308–9

  complexity see simplicity and complexity

  computer programs 36, 115–18, 129, 414

  AI see artificial intelligence

  chess 114, 118, 157

  evolutionary algorithms 160

  and the simulation argument 453–5

  computers/computation 36, 60, 95, 107, 119, 194

  analogue 140

  Analytical Engine 136–8, 139, 140

  Colossus 139

  coloured displays 434

  computational universality 135–42, 189, 191

  computer science and mathematical proof 184

  connection between physics and computation 189–92

  Difference Engine 135–6

  DNA computer 145

  ENIAC 139

  Hofstadter’s domino computer 115–17, 118

  and physics 187, 189–92, 295–6

  programs see computer programs

  quantum computation 187, 295–6

  and the silicon chip 139

  and the simulation argument 453–5

  supercomputer simulation predictions 439

  Conan Doyle, Arthur 10

  Condorcet, Nicolas de 66

  configurational entities 266–7

  conformity 7, 217, 218, 231, 382, 402, 413

  Congress, US, apportionment 326–33

  conjecture 2, 9, 10, 17, 26, 78, 239–40

  and abstractions 119

  creative 412

  and criticism 192, 239–40, 412; see also criticism

  mathematical 185–6, 191–3

  memes as conjectural explanations 412

  conjuring tricks 10, 14–16, 17, 18–19, 29, 41, 79, 82, 113, 155, 214, 315, 324, 410

  and measurement 40, 229

  visions, perception and 229, 241–2

  consciousness 153–4, 157, 162–3, 318, 415

  test for judging claims to have understood 154

  consent 155, 266, 343

  conspicuous consumption 433

  constants of nature see physics, constants of

  Constitution, US 335

  and apportionment paradoxes 326–33

  constructors, universal 58–60, 62, 76, 429

  Continental Enlightenment 65–6, 313

  continuum 43, 140–2, 159, 164, 181, 274, 298, 450

  infinity of the 164, 170, 182, 195

  control 45, 55–6, 62, 69–71, 88, 111, 130, 134–9, 159, 241–2, 384, 391–2, 415, 459

  convergence

  between Spaceship Earth and the Principle of Mediocrity 45, 53

  convergent evolution 95

  and error correction 350

  upon the truth 231, 257, 350, 368

  Conway, John 166

  Copenhagen interpretation of quantum theory 308–10, 312, 315, 322, 324, 325

  copying

  memes not replicated by imitation 402–10

  replicators see memes; replicators

  cork 72–4

  correspondence 39, 241

  of theories with objective truth 353

  one-to-one 167, 170, 171–2, 181, 193

  tallying 128, 129, 130–31, 134, 140–41, 193, 356

  cosmic rays 68, 293–4

  cosmic significance see significance

  cosmology 68, 81, 113, 445, 450–53

  evolutionary cosmologies 178–9

  see also astrophysics

  cow, size of 35

  creation of knowledge 78–105

  and the argument from design 83–7

  impeded by bad philosophy 305–25, 448

  causing convergence 350

  creationism and 79–81, 104

  about environments 74–5

  and error correction 140–2, 147, 271, 302

  ex nihilo 104, 345

  fine-tuning of the universe and 96–103, 104, 106

  as a transition process from problems to better problems 446–7

  Lamarckism and 87–9

  and the limitation on predictability 104, 193, 197–8, 212

  neo-Darwinism and 89–96

  not affected by distance 275, 427

  open-ended/unbounded vii, 60–65, 66, 67, 69, 81, 146, 165, 175, 450–52

  optimism and 196–222, 431

  requirements for 61

  spark for 75

  spontaneous generation and 81–3

  creationism 79–81, 86, 104, 193

  fine-tuning as supposed evidence for 97

  and spontaneous generation 82

  see also Paley, William

  creativity 30

  artificial 148–63; see also artificial intelligence (AI)

  artistic 355–7; see also aesthetics

  creative conjecture 412; see also conjecture

  creatively changing the options 351

  in discovering new explanations 7–8

  as an evolutionary process in the brain 373

  evolution of 398–400, 402–15, 416

  future of 415–16

  mutual enhancement of meme transmission and 400

  needed to improve explanations 342

  puzzle of what use it was in non-innovating cultures 398–402, 410–15

  and scientific toil 41, 355–6

  as a hideous joke played on humans 416

  criterion of demarcation (Popper) 14 see also testability

  criticism 114, 119, 233

  conjecture and 58, 192, 203, 239–40, 352, 412

  immunity from 230–3, 310, 316, 324, 325, 346, 347

  suppressed by anti-rational memes 391, 393

  by testing see experimental testing

  tradition of 13, 23, 31–3, 209, 216, 220, 231, 308, 390, 431

  as variation of information 78

  crystals 83

  liquid 434

  cubes, notional, in space 47, 66–8, 74–5

  cultural evolution 369–97

  and the biosphere–culture analogy 371–2

  and dynamic societies 387–8, 424

  the Enlightenment 390–93

  ideas that survive 369–72

  living with memes 394–6

  meme evolution 372–8, 400, 413

  rational and anti-rational memes 388–90

  the selfish meme 378–9, 387

  and static societies 380, 383–6, 414

  subcultures 393

  cultural relativism 314, 356

  culture 397 see also cultural evolution

  cures 11, 153, 213, 272, 422, 437, 455

  curvature of spacetime 107, 112, 183–4, 312, 450

  dark energy 451

  dark matter 36, 46, 67

  Darwin, Charles 80, 82, 87, 91

  D
arwin, Erasmus 87, 88

  Darwinian theory 80, 89

  Marx on 371

  neo-Darwinism 89–96, 103, 104–5

  refutation possibilities 95–6

  data 15, 18, 210, 315, 323

  Dawkins, Juliet 353, 362

  Dawkins, Richard 52–3, 56–7, 92, 93, 279

  argument from personal incredulity 164

  Haldane–Dawkins ‘queerer-than-we-can-suppose’ argument 53, 56, 59, 81

  death 48, 63, 69, 436, 453, 459

  elimination of 63, 213, 455

  evil of 213

  fear of 84

  decision-making 335

  conventional model of 341

  democratic 344–5; see also voting

  and Popper’s criterion of ridding ourselves of bad governments without violence 344–51, 352

  and problem solving 341–2

  social-choice theory and 335, 337–8, 342–3, 345

  society-wide planning and 335–51

  by weighing 340–42

  decoherence 285, 303

  deconstructionism 314

  deduction 5

  deep space 47–8, 66–9, 71–2, 293

  deforestation 418, 420–21, 422

  Demeter 19–21, 24, 26

  democracy 217, 250, 333, 335

  democratic decision-making in elections 344–5

  see also voting; plurality voting 346–50

  Dennett, Daniel 117, 154

  design 44, 125, 131, 139, 144, 155, 159–162, 201, 357, 367

  appearance of 44, 50, 84–6, 87, 97, 98, 106, 357, 363–4

  Paley’s criterion for 85–7

  argument from 83–7

  creationism and designers 43, 49, 51, 73, 79–81, 97

  in the laws of physics 96–103

  determinism 277, 287, 371

  deterministic laws 263, 265, 267, 268, 270, 275, 276, 279, 305

  Deutsch, David, The Fabric of Reality 109–10, 450, 460

  diagonal argument 170–71, 172

  Diamond, Jared 425–9, 430, 442

  dictatorship see tyranny

  meaning of ‘dictator’ in Arrow’s theorem 343

  no-dictator axiom 336

  Difference Engine 135–6

  Difference Engine, The (Gibson and Sterling) 137

  differentiation

  calculus 164

  of histories in a multiverse 273–5, 276–9, 287–8

  decoherence and 285

  interference and 283–7, 291, 293

  rate of growth of distinct histories 287; see also waves of differentiation

  digital technology 139–42

  dinosaurs 162, 315

  disasters, natural 42, 49, 63, 200, 202, 206–7

  discrete variables 128, 140, 142, 274, 305, 450

  discrete/continuous dichotomy 140, 142, 274, 298, 450

  disease 59, 63, 196, 200, 213, 294, 385, 437

  Black Death 208, 385, 437

  cholera 207

  cures 11, 153, 213, 272, 422, 437, 455

  pandemics/epidemics 196, 208, 418, 436; see also Black Death above

  DNA 56–7, 62, 67, 78, 95, 162, 375, 376

  computer 145

  damage 294

  and the genetic code’s jump to universality 143–6, 162–3

  in pollen 360

  dogmas/dogmatism 13, 23, 26, 66, 122, 445, 447

  domino computer (Hofstadter) 115–17, 118, 185, 358

  doomsday argument 455–6

  doppelgangers 258, 263–4, 265, 270–72

  Doyle, Arthur Conan 10

  Dragon’s Egg (Forward) 97

  dream

  hallucination 301

  Popperian epistemology taught in a ‘dream of Socrates’ 223–54

  reality and experience as a waking dream 241–2, 252–3

  drugs 317–18

  Easter Island 418–24, 430–31

  economic forecasts 371, 437, 439

  ecosystems

  artificial/virtual 68

  see also biosphere

  Eden, Garden of 52, 63

  Edison, Thomas 36, 41, 158, 341

  see also inspiration/perspiration

  education 123, 203–4, 210, 217–18, 230–31, 244, 247, 252, 254, 311, 377–8, 382, 389, 391, 392, 393, 400, 409, 431, 435

  academic knowledge 4, 255, 369, 393, 446

  because I say so 311, 391–2, 395

  moral 230–31

  university 34–6, 158, 255, 308, 309, 403, 406, 409, 433, 446

  see also fun; Popper on instruction

  Ehrlich, Paul 431–2, 440

  Einstein, Albert 60, 104, 113, 255, 256, 307, 310, 312, 446–7, 451

  curved space and time 183–4

  explanation of planetary motion 112, 113

  general theory of relativity 29, 61, 107, 312

  and the problem of quantum gravity 449–50

  special theory of relativity 199

  Elbot program 151, 156

  electoral systems 338–40

  and democratic decision-making 344–5

  plurality voting system 346–50

  see also proportional representation

  electron(s) 70, 108, 289–91, 293, 294, 298, 324, 454

  field 291

  microscope 39

  elegance 3, 25, 32, 42, 94, 199, 355, 367, 387

  elementary particles see particles, elementary

  elements

  ancient theory of 14

  formation of 1, 2, 40, 50, 61–2, 96

  Eliza program 148–9, 161

  see also chatbots

  emergence 104, 108–11, 118–19, 123, 156, 292, 302–3, 305, 395

  causation as emergent 118

  Hofstadter’s ‘I’ and 115–18

  levels of emergence and of explanation 114, 116, 118, 123, 124, 130, 141, 293, 373, 444, 459

  and reductionism 109–10

  emotions 154, 356, 384, 389

  empiricism 4–29, 32, 119, 122, 155, 165, 311–12, 358, 361, 411

  and the deceptiveness of the senses 8, 14, 301

  failed to eliminate authority 8–10; see also justificationism

  the falseness of 7–8, 32, 39, 120, 209–10, 403

  and the history of ideas 311–12, 314–16, 325, 345, 354

  Horgan’s misconceptions based on 448

  and inductivism 5–7

  and instrumentalism 15

  mistaken idea of theory-free observation 39

  salutary role 13, 311

  see also knowledge

  end-of-the-world prophet 14, 21–2; see also Malthusian prophetic fallacy

  energy 267, 361, 439

  dark 451

  and fungibility 267, 298

  gravitational 3, 450

  law of conservation of 109

  needed for knowledge creation 61–2, 146

  of photons in different universes 297–8

  quantized 274, 291, 298, 433

  solar 50, 66, 74

  Engels, Friedrich 426, 428, 430, 442

  ENIAC (computer) 139

  Enlightenment, the 31

  British 65–6;

  and progress 12–14, 22–3, 29, 32–3, 65–6, 133, 203, 390–91

  and the scientific revolution 12, 14, 23, 32, 53

  and universality 133–4

  and the evolution of memes 390–93

  mini-enlightenments 23, 31, 216–21

  and our view of the Earth 443

  utopian (Continental) 65–6, 313

  entanglement 284–5, 293, 295, 296–7, 303, 308

  entanglement information 281, 289–90, 307

  protection of qubits from 295

  time as an entanglement phenomenon 299

  environment see biosphere

  epidemics/pandemics 196, 208, 418, 436

  see also Black Death

  epistemology 225, 412

  and ‘a dream of Socrates’ 226–43, 245, 252–3

  empiricism see empiricism

  inductivism 5–7

  see also knowledg
e

  equivocation 309, 318, 325, 448

  Eratosthenes of Cyrene 443, 458

  error correction 94, 136, 140–42, 147, 192, 209, 210, 211, 222, 271, 302, 322, 323, 328, 389, 395, 409, 411–12

  and convergence 350

  requires digital information 140–42

  in plurality voting 348

  and universality 147

  see also fooling ourselves

  Euclid

  Euclidean space 164, 183

  theory of geometry 42, 183, 184

  Euripides 216

  europium 433, 434

  Everett, Hugh 310

  interpretation of quantum theory 310

  evidence 22, 25, 27–8, 39, 49, 73, 75, 103

  circumstantial 10

  as an essential requirement for knowledge creation 61, 67

  we are inundated with 61–2, 66

  literally within arm’s reach 62

  in philosophy 209

  of our senses 4

  is the same throughout the universe 62, 67–9

  evils 199–200, 212, 213, 221, 319, 395, 435

  evil of death 213

  problem of evil 80, 199

  evolution 48–9, 52

  artificial 158–63

  and attraction 360–65

  co-evolution 360–62, 400, 414–15

  convergent 95

  of creativity see creativity: evolution of

  of culture see cultural evolution

  Darwinian 105

  of the human species 48, 55, 394, 412–13

  and knowledge 77, 78–105

  natural selection 52, 56, 78, 87,

  not necessarily adaptive 91

  of non-explanatory knowledge 94

  ‘survival of the fittest’ 91, 371

  see also adaptation; Lamarckism

  evolutionary cosmologies 178–9

  ex nihilo creation 104, 345

  see also regress, infinite

  expectations 4, 17–19

  experience, sensory see sensory experience

  experimental testing 13–14, 26

  essence of 16–18

  falsification through 26

  Galileo and 14

  principle of testability 14, 26, 111

  explanationless theories 15, 16, 158, 210, 316, 318–19, 320–23, 325

  see also philosophy, bad; inexplicability; rules of thumb

  explanations 30

  of abstractions 114–24

  bad (easy to vary) 19–22, 25–6, 29, 31, 53–4, 64, 80, 83, 97, 101–2, 150, 154, 174, 199–200, 260, 264, 282, 311, 324

  and bad philosophy 311–25

  are conjectural 2, 9, 10, 17, 26, 191–3

  creating new problems 64, 76, 350, 422

  creativity and 7–8, 342

  and decision-making 341

  discrete options between 342

  and elegance 355

  evolution of explanatory theories 94

  falsified 26

  good (hard to vary) vii, 6, 24, 25, 28, 31, 78–9, 94, 156, 209, 257, 306, 341, 342, 353

  and imagination 26, 264–5

  imitation and 410

  instrumentalist conception of 13

 

‹ Prev