by Louise Penny
Maureen shook her head, then nodded. “I agree. It’s ridiculous. Just a passing fancy.”
She fell into thought, while Joan watched the people strolling by on rue St.-Paul.
They’d all started the day, she was sure, fresh and well turned out. But now most were wilted in the heat. Judge Corriveau could feel perspiration on her neck, and her underarms were clammy.
She was not looking forward to getting back into her robes, and sitting in the oven of a courtroom all afternoon. But at least she wasn’t being grilled.
“Monsieur Gamache quoted Gandhi this morning,” she said. “Something about a higher court.”
Joan tapped on her iPhone. “Got it. There is a higher court than courts of justice and that is the court of conscience. It supersedes all other courts.”
Maureen Corriveau gave a short, sharp inhale. “I just got the chills.”
“Why?”
“The head of the Sûreté proclaiming his conscience overrides our laws? Doesn’t that frighten you?”
“I’m not sure he meant that,” said Joan, trying to calm her partner. “It seems a sort of blanket statement, not a personal credo.”
“You don’t think that’ll be the headline in the news? ‘Head of Sûreté Follows His Conscience, Not the Law’?”
“As long as it isn’t ‘Judge Goes Berserk in Courtroom.’”
Maureen laughed and got up. “I have to get back. Thanks for lunch.”
But after taking a step away from the table, she came back.
“Do you believe it?”
“That personal conscience overrules our collective laws?” asked Joan. “Aren’t our laws based on a good conscience? The Commandments?”
“Like the law forbidding homosexuality?”
“That was years ago,” said Joan.
“Still in force in many places. That law is unconscionable.”
“Then you agree with Monsieur Gamache?” asked Joan.
“If I agreed with anyone, it would be Gandhi, not Gamache. But can a judge really believe in the court of conscience? That it supersedes all others? It sounds like anarchy.”
“It sounds like progress,” said Joan.
“It sounds like the end of a promising career on the bench,” said Maureen with a smile. She kissed Joan, then leaned down and kissed her again, whispering, “That one’s for Gandhi.”
CHAPTER 17
The two men squared off again.
While always attentive, the spectators now leaned even further forward, drawn into the square at the front of the room, like a boxing ring, where the case was being fought.
There was now an electricity in Judge Corriveau’s courtroom. One she did not welcome. It was already hot enough. And as far as she was concerned, electricity and justice did not go together.
She could at least track down its source. These two men crackled with antagonism.
Bull elephants, Joan had called them.
More like rogue elephants, thought Judge Corriveau. Shitting all over her first murder trial.
But even that was wrong.
The Crown Prosecutor, Monsieur Zalmanowitz, was lithe, walking with the sinewy movement of a panther. He paced his territory, occasionally making forays past the defense table, but always keeping his eyes on the man in the witness box.
A predator sizing up his prey.
And Gamache? Sitting so calmly, as though this were his home. As though he owned the chair he sat in, the box that surrounded it, the entire room. Polite, attentive, thoughtful.
His extreme quietude was a stark contrast to the ever-pacing Crown.
Here was a patient man. Who had the good sense to wait until his attacker showed a weakness.
This was no elephant. This was no panther.
This was an apex predator, she realized. The top of the food chain.
Judge Corriveau watched as Monsieur Zalmanowitz circled closer to Gamache, and she almost gestured to the Crown, waving him away.
Warning him that the sort of composure and control Chief Superintendent Armand Gamache exhibited only came from those with no natural enemies. It would be a potentially fatal error to mistake his calm for lethargy.
An apex predator who quoted Gandhi, she marveled. And she wondered if that made Monsieur Gamache more, or less, dangerous.
And she wondered if his only real enemy was himself.
Maureen Corriveau then remembered that passing fancy, as she’d walked down the cobblestone street to meet Joan for lunch. That these two adversaries were actually allies, and only pretending to be at each other’s throats.
But what could make them do such a thing?
She knew the answer, of course. There was only one reason they were acting as they were.
To trap an even bigger predator.
Judge Corriveau looked over at the defendant.
Was it possible someone who looked so very weak, so beaten, was something else entirely?
“Before we broke for lunch, you were telling us, Chief Superintendent, about bringing the news of Katie Evans’s murder to her husband,” said the Crown. “We left you in the restaurant.”
“The bistro, oui,” said Gamache, and saw, with satisfaction, Zalmanowitz bristle at the small correction.
For his part, Barry Zalmanowitz watched the head of the Sûreté, sitting so comfortably in the witness box, and was grateful it wasn’t difficult to attack the man.
Despite their cordial lunch, he didn’t have to pretend to loathe Gamache. He actually did. And had for many years. How many times had they argued about a prosecution? Sometimes the Crown refused to lay charges against a person Gamache believed was a killer. But Zalmanowitz argued there wasn’t enough, or strong enough, evidence.
Your fault, Gamache, Zalmanowitz had said.
And Chief Inspector Gamache, then the head of homicide for the Sûreté, had all but called him a coward, who wouldn’t risk a prosecution unless there was absolutely no chance of losing.
Yes, it was ironic that this whole plan rested on everyone believing they detested each other. The beauty of the plan was that they actually did.
As he paced the courtroom and watched the still man in the witness box, he couldn’t detect any outright rancor on Gamache’s part. Though there was wariness.
So great was the threat that Armand Gamache had been forced to approach a man uniquely situated to help. But one he didn’t like and didn’t trust.
It had been the most extraordinary meeting of Zalmanowitz’s career.
Gamache had flown to Moncton and driven to Halifax, while Zalmanowitz had flown directly there.
They’d sat in a diner at the waterfront. A dive even by the questionable standards of the dockworkers and fishermen who surrounded them.
And there, in the shadow of ships bound for ports around the world, the Chief Superintendent of the Sûreté had outlined his plan to the Chief Crown Prosecutor.
And when he’d finished, and was completely and utterly exposed, Armand Gamache had waited. A very slight tremble in his right hand the only hint of stress.
The head of the Crown Prosecutor’s office had sat there, stunned. At the hubris of the man. At the scope of the plan. At his stupidity, bordering on brilliance, to come to the last person on earth likely to help him. And ask not just for help.
“You’re asking me to end my career.”
“Almost certainly. And I’ll end mine.”
“Yours has barely begun,” Zalmanowitz reminded him. “You’ve just come out of retirement. You’ve been the Chief Superintendent for a nanosecond. I doubt you even know where the toilet is on your floor. I have thirty years in the Crown’s office. I’m the head of the whole fucking thing. And you want me to not only throw it all away, but risk imprisonment? At the very least, humiliation? You want me to bring shame on my whole career and family?”
“Yes, please.”
Gamache had looked so sincere when he’d said that, before breaking into a smile. But for just a moment Zalmanowitz had wondered if this was s
And have him not simply fired, but ruined.
But looking into those eyes, searching that face, Zalmanowitz realized that Gamache was many things, but he was not cruel. And that would have been cruel.
Armand Gamache was serious.
“I need to go for a walk,” said the Crown, and when Gamache started to get up, Zalmanowitz forcefully put out his hand. “Alone.”
He’d walked and walked and walked, up and down the pier. Past the huge container ships. He smelled the seaweed, the rust, the fish.
Up and down, Zalmanowitz paced.
If he did this, he couldn’t tell anyone. Not even his wife. Not until it was over.
And who knew? Maybe people would understand. Would see that the why overrode the how.
But walk as he might, he couldn’t escape the reality. If he did this thing, if he threw in with Gamache, it would be the end. He’d be pilloried. And rightly so.
It went against everything he believed in. Everything he stood for. Everything Gamache believed in too, to be fair.
So great was the threat that both men had to be willing to compromise their deepest beliefs.
Would he regret joining Gamache? Would he regret not?
What were the chances of success? Pretty low, he knew. But the chances were zero if he didn’t try.
And Gamache had no other options. He was it, Zalmanowitz knew. Because of his position. Because of the respect he commanded in his profession. He would use it all up, empty the well of goodwill. In this one act.
Zalmanowitz stopped and watched the boats in Halifax Harbour, and felt the bracing sea air on his face.
Charlotte had loved going down to the old port of Montréal, to stare at the ships. Wide-eyed. She’d ask her dad where each was going and where each was from. Barry, of course, didn’t know, so he made it up. Choosing the most exotic-sounding places.
Zanzibar.
Madagascar.
The North Pole.
Atlantis.
St.-Crème-Glacée-de-Poutine.
“You made that up,” said Charlotte, laughing so hard she’d started to cry.
Well, he thought, if he could make up a story for his little girl, he could make up one for everyone else in Québec.
“Come along,” he whispered. “We’re going on a journey.”
He’d walked back to the diner, where Gamache was waiting. A tall, quivering slice of lemon meringue pie in front of each of them.
Zalmanowitz sat down.
While Armand Gamache hadn’t mentioned Charlotte, Zalmanowitz suspected he knew. And he both hated the man across from him for asking this thing. And almost loved him, for asking this thing.
“I’ll do it.”
Gamache had nodded, holding his eyes. “We have to move quickly.”
And they had.
That had been months ago, in November.
Charges were laid, preliminary hearings were held.
And now it was July and they were into the second day of the murder trial.
It was almost impossible to tell if things were going their way. It seemed like such a long shot, and yet they’d made it this far. Still, the plan could fail. The ground could fall out from underneath them.
If it did, they’d go down together. But the consolation for Zalmanowitz was that at least his hands would be around Gamache’s throat when they hit bottom.
“How did Patrick Evans take the news of his wife’s death?” he asked the Chief Superintendent.
CHAPTER 18
“Tell me here,” said Patrick Evans, as his friends closed ranks beside him.
Not unlike, Gamache thought, what they had done the evening before, when protecting the cobrador.
“Non, monsieur,” said Chief Inspector Lacoste, gently but firmly. “Please come with us.”
She pointed to what she knew was a back room, reserved for private functions. Like birthdays. And homicide investigations.
“May we?” asked Lea.
“Yes, of course,” said Lacoste, allowing Matheo and Lea to stay with their friend.
They walked into the back room and Beauvoir closed the door.
There was no fireplace here to spread both warmth and cheer. The bank of French doors looked out over a bleak back garden and the Rivière Bella Bella beyond, in full flow.
The air outside seemed to have congealed, forming a heavy mist that almost obscured the forest beyond.
Beauvoir found the light switches and turned them all on, then he turned up the heat, to take the chill off the room.
Lacoste looked at Patrick Evans and saw him brace. As did Matheo Bissonette. As did Lea Roux. As though she were the firing squad and they the target.
Without preamble, she broke the news. Quietly, softly, with compassion but also with clarity.
“I’m sorry, sir, but your wife is dead.”
Isabelle Lacoste had learned long ago that simplicity was best. A short, sharp declaration of the fact. So that there could be no doubt, no back door through which denial could slip.
There was no gentle way to break news. To break hearts. And doing it slowly simply added to the trauma.
Matheo took a step closer to his friend and, placing a hand on his arm, he squeezed.
Despite the fact Patrick Evans must’ve known, it still came as a shock. Apparently.
He sat down slowly, his mouth opening as his body lowered.
There was a tap on the door and Beauvoir opened it. Olivier was there with a bottle of scotch and some glasses. And a box of tissues.
“Merci,” Jean-Guy whispered and, taking the tray, he closed the door.
Lacoste pulled a chair over so that she was sitting directly across from Patrick, their knees almost touching.
His hair was dark, short, cut in the manner of a much older man. He was clean-shaven and handsome, but his personality wasn’t strong. Even in grief, some people emanated confidence. Or, at least, a core. This man seemed hollow. Pale in every way.
“She was found in the church,” Lacoste said, holding his blue eyes, though she wasn’t sure how much he was taking in.
“How…?” he asked.
“The coroner needs to investigate, but it seems she was beaten.”
“Oh, Jesus.”
Patrick lowered his eyes, then dragged them back up. But not to Lacoste.
“How could this happen?” he asked Matheo.
“I don’t know.” Bissonette shook his head and looked incredulous.
Beside him, Lea looked sick. Physically ill.
Patrick’s lips moved, but either there were too many words, tripping over each other to get out, or no words at all.
Just a chasm in this already empty man.
“When was the last time you saw your wife?” asked Chief Inspector Lacoste.
“Last night,” he said. “Outside.”
“She was outside?” asked Lacoste. “She didn’t come to bed?”
“I thought she had. I went to sleep, and just assumed she’d come back.”
“But she didn’t,” said Lacoste, and Patrick nodded.
“What was she doing outside?” asked Lacoste.
“Katie liked to go for walks in the evening,” said Lea.
“What time did you get back from dinner?” Lacoste asked.
“Don’t know,” said Patrick.
“They were back by the time we left your place,” Matheo said to Gamache. “About ten, right?”
Gamache nodded.
“Did you see her out for her walk?” asked Lacoste.
Matheo and Lea shook their heads.
“Was the cobrador there when you walked back to the B&B?”
“The cobrador,” said Patrick, suddenly waking up. “Oh Christ, this’s because of the cobrador, isn’t it?”
He’d turned to Matheo, then looked at Lea. His eyes wide with panic.
“I don’t know,” said Lea, leaning in to him. Embracing him, awkwardly. Patrick’s arms didn’t return the hug.
“How could this happen?” he mumbled, his voice muffled by Lea’s solid body. “I don’t understand.”
But now his eyes were on Isabelle Lacoste.
There was a lot not to understand, she thought, watching them. But before this was over, she’d have answers.
She glanced at Beauvoir, who was watching Patrick Evans with those shrewd eyes of his. Then her gaze moved on to Monsieur Gamache.
His hands were clasped behind his back and he was staring out the window. A less astute observer might think he’d lost interest. But Lacoste could see, even in profile, the intense focus of the man. Listening closely to every word, every inflection.
He often said that words told them what someone was thinking, but the tone told them how they felt.
Both vital.
Yes, facts were necessary. But frankly, anyone could be trained to collect a bloodstain or find a hair. Or an affair. Or a bank balance that didn’t balance.
But feelings? Only the bravest wandered into that fiery realm.
And that’s what the chief explored. Elusive, volatile, unpredictable, often dangerous feelings. Searching out that one raw, wild emotion. That had led to murder.
And he’d taught her to do the same thing.
Gamache shifted his gaze now, from the dense forest, to Patrick, Matheo, Lea at the front of the room.
And the deep brown, thoughtful eyes came to rest. Not on Patrick Evans but on Matheo Bissonette.
“Where did you go for dinner last night?”
He shrugged, what little energy he had seeping away.
“I think it was a place in Knowlton,” said Matheo. “Le Relais. Right?”
But Patrick didn’t react.
“Were you worried when you didn’t see your wife this morning?” asked Lacoste.
He roused himself. “Not really. I thought she was with her.” He pointed to Lea.
Her.
His words were coming slower, thicker.
“And we thought she was with Patrick,” said Matheo.
“It wasn’t until the police showed up that we realized no one had seen Katie all day,” said Lea.
-->