by Colm Toibin
The school had sacked her, and since she was not a member of a trade union, she could only go to the courts to seek redress. Counsel for the school had maintained that she was not fit to be a teacher in a religious school, that her personal life was in breach of the school’s ethos and articles of association. Her having a child outside wedlock was not the issue, counsel had maintained, but her continuing to live openly with a married man was. She had been warned, he said, but she had continued, in full knowledge of her employers’ wishes, to act against them. The parents of children under her care had complained, counsel for the school had emphasized.
Who was right? He had spent three days listening to the evidence and the arguments and then six weeks working towards a conclusion, a judgment. He remembered how calm the head nun had been when she came to give evidence, and how the teacher, too, had been direct. There was a pride, almost a nobility in the way they spoke. He realized that this was one of the few cases in which he had ever been involved where both sides were clearly telling the truth and were not afraid of the truth. Both women were sincere; neither wished to hide anything, except one had no job now, and wanted the court to right the wrong which she felt had been done to her.
He remembered their faces, the teacher much older than he had expected, the nun younger-looking. He took notes, asked questions, sought clarifications. He forced the teacher’s counsel to admit that there was no absolute right to employment and that employers had the right, under several acts, to dispose of the services of an employee. But the counsel had continued to argue that living with a married man did not constitute grounds for dismissal.
Counsel for the nuns asked the court how a pregnant teacher living with a married man in a small town could not convey some of her ethos to the students. Surely, he argued, teaching involved more than giving information to young people? Surely the ethos of the school was clear to her from the beginning? Surely she knew what she was doing? Surely the manager of the school could not have done otherwise than dismiss her?
There was no argument about facts or truth, guilt or innocence. In the end he was not the legal arbiter, because there were no legal issues at stake. Most of the issues raised in the case were moral issues: the right of an ethos to prevail against the right of an individual not to be dismissed from her job. Basically, he was being asked to decide how life should be conducted in a small town. He smiled to himself at the thought and shook his head.
As he worked on the judgment he realized more than ever that he had no strong moral views, that he had ceased to believe in anything. But he was careful in writing the judgment not to make this clear. The judgment was the only one which he could have given: it was cogent, well-argued and, above all, plausible.
He went to the window again and stood there looking out. How hard it was to be sure! It was not simply the case, and the complex questions it raised about society and morality, it was the world in which these things happened which left him uneasy, a world in which opposite values lived so close to each other. Which world was the one that could claim a right to be protected?
He went over to his bookshelves and took down his sacred text: the Irish Constitution, Bunreacht na hEireann. This contained the governing principles to which the law was subject. The preamble was clear about the Christian nature of the state, it specifically referred to the Holy Trinity. He thought about it again: to become pregnant outside marriage and to live with a man already married was clearly alien to Christian principles. It had never been accepted in any Christian society, he thought, until he realized that he had taken the argument too far. What was a Christian society? Had there ever been one?
The nuns ran a school which was dedicated to the spread of Christian principles. What right did a teacher have who was knowingly in breach of those principles?
His tipstaff came with tea. He began to think again; he wrote down three words on a notepad: charity, mercy, forgiveness. These words had no legal status, they belonged firmly to the language of Christianity, but they had a greater bearing on the case than any set of legal terms. If the teacher were merely pregnant, the nun had said, they could have forgiven her, but the fact that she continued to transgress—he wrote the word down with an exclamation mark after it—meant that they had to take action.
One other matter began to preoccupy him. The family, according to the Constitution, was the basic unit in society. What was a family? The Constitution did not define a family, and at the time it was written, in 1937, the term was perfectly understood: a man and his wife and their children. But the Constitution was written in the present tense, it was not his job to decide what certain terms—he wrote “certain terms” in his notepad, underlined it and wrote “uncertain terms” below that—such as “the family” had meant in the past. It was his job to know what these terms meant now. This woman was living with a man in a permanent relationship, they were bringing up children. Did a man, a woman and their children not constitute a family? In what way were they not a family? They were not married. But there was no mention of marriage in the Constitution.
He thought about it for a while and the consternation it would cause among his colleagues, a redefinition of the concept of the family. The teacher would have to win the case then, and the nuns would have to lose. The idea seemed suddenly plausible, but it would need a great deal of thought and research. It had not been raised as a possibility by counsel for the teacher. Lawyers, he thought, knew that he was not the sort of judge who would entertain such far-fetched notions in his court.
If he were another person he could write the judgment, but as eleven o’clock grew near he knew that the verdict he had written out on his foolscap pages was the one he would deliver, and it would be viewed by his colleagues as eminently sensible and well-reasoned. But he was still unhappy about the case because he had been asked to interpret more than the law, and he was not equipped to be a moral arbiter. He was not certain about right and wrong, and he realized that this was something he would have to keep hidden from the court.
The downstairs corridors of the Four Courts were like some vast marketplace. He had to push his way through the passage leading to the side door of his court.
“The courtroom is packed, my lord,” his tipstaff said.
“Are we ready then?” he asked.
He tried to act as businesslike as possible when he came into the courtroom and everybody stood up. He sat down, arranged his papers in front of him, put on his reading glasses and consulted with the clerk, learning that there were several barristers seeking injunctions. He tried to deal with them promptly, realizing that, if he hurried, he could be finished by one o’clock, which meant that he could be in Cush by four, or half past four, and if the weather was warm enough he could have a swim. He told the clerk that he was ready to begin the judgment. He surveyed the court for a moment: the press benches were full as he had expected, and the public benches were also full. There were a lot of young women, he noted, and he presumed that they were friends and supporters of the sacked teacher. He knew that this judgment would be news. It would be carried on the radio and there would probably be editorials in the newspapers. He would certainly be attacked in The Irish Times. As he settled down to read the judgment, sure now of his conclusions, he thought about how ill-informed and ignorant the comment would be, and how little of the processes of law the writers would understand.
He did not intend his judgment to be dramatic, but he wished to set out the facts first, clearly and exactly. The argument at times, he knew, was close and dense and it would be difficult for most people in the court to follow, but a great deal of it was clear. After half an hour, when he had set out the facts and paused for a drink of water, he was aware that no one in the court knew which side he was about to come down on. He could feel the tension; and the few times he looked up he could see them watching him carefully. He caught the teacher’s eye only once: she had the resigned look, he felt, of someone who knew that she was going to lose. People would have warned her that he was n
ot a judge who would rule in her favour.
As he read on and came near the passage which would make the result clear he found that he was enjoying the tension and noticed that he had begun to speak more clearly and distinctly, but he stopped himself and went back to the rigorous monotone which he had adopted at the beginning.
A murmur started in the court as soon as it became clear that he had decided in favour of the nuns; from the bench it sounded like the murmur in a film, and he felt that he should bang the desk with a gavel and shout “Order in the court,” but he continued as though there had not been a sound.
When he had finished, counsel for the nuns was on his feet immediately, his face flushed with victory. He was looking for costs. There was no choice, he could delay it until the new term, but it would be pointless and he wanted to have done with the case. The costs would be high, he listened to the submission from the other side and the teacher was now unemployed. It would be hard for her to find another job. When he looked over at her he saw that she had a man beside her who was holding her, and both were looking up at him as though afraid. Her counsel begged the court not to award costs against her but, according to the judgment, she was in the wrong, she had taken the case and she had lost. He ruled against her without offering any explanation. He wondered as he gathered up his papers if she would appeal, but he thought not; he had based a great deal of his judgment on matters of fact rather than law, and the Supreme Court could not dispute many of his findings. She would not have much chance of winning an appeal, he felt.
Back in his chambers he went to the telephone immediately.
“I’m ready now,” he said as soon as Carmel answered.
“We’re going to pick up Niamh in Rathmines. She’s decided to come down with us today. She’s taking the carrycot and all the things so we’ll need to collect her,” Carmel said.
“I thought she wasn’t coming,” he said.
“She’s finding it very hard,” Carmel said, as though he had complained about her coming.
“I’ll be there in half an hour,” he said. He sat down at his desk and put his head in his hands. He could feel the sweat pouring down his back and his heart beating fast. He tried to control his breathing, to breathe calmly through his nose. He tried to relax. He remembered Niamh best when she was fourteen or fifteen, when she was still growing; even then she was tall for her age and interested in sports; hockey, tennis, swimming. They had pushed her too hard, Carmel said, forced her to study when she did not want to. She had studied social science when she failed to get the points for entry to study medicine. She had become a statistician, working on opinion polls and surveys of social change. She had become independent and distant from them until she was pregnant, when she and Carmel became closer, but he did not believe that she had felt any affection for him since she was in her early teens.
He waited there as his heart kept pounding. He wondered if he was going to have a heart attack, and he waited for a dart of pain, or a sudden tightness, but none came and slowly the heartbeat eased.
Niamh was standing at the door of the small house down a side street in Rathmines. She waved when he beeped the horn and shouted that she would not be long.
“I thought she was living in a flat,” he said.
“Yes,” Carmel said, “but there are three flats in the house and she knows the other people, they’re all friends. They’re very good to her, they babysit and help out.”
Niamh came out of the front door with the baby. He noticed that she had lost weight and let her hair grow longer. She smiled at them.
“I hope there’s loads of space in the boot because I have to take the computer as well as the baby, and that’s not forgetting the go-car and the cot.” She handed the baby to Carmel. Eamon went into the hall and helped to carry out the cot and put it in the boot.
“The computer will have to go on the back seat,” he said. “Are you sure you need it?”
She went past him without answering. He carried a suitcase and put it into the boot. He stood there then looking at the baby who looked back at him sullenly and curiously, fixing on him as something new and strange. Suddenly, the baby began to cry, and continued to roar as they arranged the go-car on the roof-rack and set off through Ranelagh and Donnybrook. “He’s very big,” he said after a while when the child had quietened down. “He’s much bigger than I expected him to be.” He looked behind at the child who began to cry again.
“It’s better maybe if you don’t look at him when he’s like that,” Niamh said.
He knew as they drove past Bray that if they turned on the radio they would get the three o’clock news which would probably report on the judgment. Carmel would want to know about it, she would want to discuss his reasons for ruling in favour of the nuns, she would go away and think about it and want to discuss it further. With Niamh in the house it would be worse. He realized that he would prefer if they never found out about it. It would be difficult to explain.
“Who else is living in the house with you?” he asked Niamh. There had been silence in the car for some time. Both women told him to keep his voice down.
“The baby’s asleep,” Niamh said.
At Arklow he took a detour to avoid the traffic in the town. It was close to four o’clock, and it was only now that he became relaxed enough to enjoy the good weather, the clear light over the fields and the heat which he knew would persist for at least two more hours, despite the clouds banked on the horizon. When they passed Gorey, the baby woke and began to make gurgling sounds.
“You should teach him ‘The Croppy Boy,’” he said and laughed to himself as they passed a sign for Oulart. Niamh said that she would have to change his nappy, so they stopped the car and got out. He walked up and down taking in the heat as the two women busied themselves around the child, who had begun to cry again.
When they reached Blackwater Carmel said that she wanted to stop to get some groceries and to order The Irish Times for the duration of their stay. The baby was asleep again and he and Niamh sat in the seat without speaking. He closed his eyes and opened them again: in all the years there had hardly been any changes in the view from here up the hill. Each building was a separate entity, put up at a different time. Each roof was different, ran at a different angle, was made of different material: slate, tile, galvanized. He felt that he could be any age watching this scene, and experienced a sudden illusion that nothing in him had changed since he first saw these buildings.
* * *
They drove towards the sea at Ballyconnigar and then turned at the hand-ball alley to Cush. There were potholes on the narrow road and he had to drive carefully to avoid them.
“What’s for dinner?” he asked.
“I’m not making any more dinners,” Carmel said and laughed.
“I hope you can cook, Niamh,” he said.
“Niamh is an excellent cook,” Carmel said.
“It’s time men pulled their weight,” Niamh said drily.
There was always that moment when he saw the sea clearly, when it took up the whole horizon, its blue and green colours frail in the afternoon light. The road was downhill from then on. He drove along the sandy road, saluting a few people as he passed.
“I want to unload really quickly,” he said, as he stopped the car beside the house, “because I want to go for a swim before the sun goes in.”
“I’d love to go for a swim too,” Niamh said.
“I’ll take the baby if you both empty the car,” Carmel said.
Niamh had gone to change, and he stood waiting for her. There was a sweet, moist smell from the high grass in front of the house. He was tired and felt the burden of the day in his back muscles and his eyes. Suddenly he looked up and his eye caught the rusty red paint on the galvanized iron of the gate. He liked the colour, and it seemed familiar as he stood there and took in the scene: the rutted lane, the tufts of grass clinging to the sandy soil of the ditch; and the sound of a tractor in the distance. He stood there for a moment fixing on no
thing in particular, letting each thing in the landscape seep towards him, as he tried to rid himself of everything that had happened that day.
The light was clear; down on the strand they could see as far as Curracloe. Niamh wore only a light dress over her swimming-suit, so she was already in the water while he was still undressing. When he took off his shoes he felt an instant release as though a weight had been lifted from him. Most of the strand was in shadow. He left his clothes on a boulder of dried marl and walked towards the sunlight on the foreshore, stepping gingerly over the small, sharp stones which studded the sand.
The water was cold; Niamh waved to him from way out. He watched her long, thin arms reach up from the water as she swam parallel to the shore. He was tempted, as usual, to turn back, but he waded in further, jumping to avoid a wave, and then he dived in and swam hard out, gliding over each swell as it came. He turned and put his head back, letting it rest on the cold, blue water, and opening his eyes to stare up at the sky. He breathed in deeply and floated on the waves, relaxed now and quiet. He curled back towards the water after a while, and swam further out, each movement half instinct, half choice.
He cast his eye down the coast and noticed as he turned that a family was moving slowly up the strand towards the gap, carrying rugs and babies, struggling as they reached the cliff. He watched Niamh wading out and drying herself. She waved to him. No one else would come until the morning, except maybe a tractor using the strand as a short cut. He was tired now; the swimming would be easier the next day and the day after that. He changed to a dog paddle which consumed less energy than the breast stroke. A cloud passed over the sun and left him in shadow so that he could feel a cold wind on his face. He turned again and floated, keeping his eyes closed for as long as he could, not knowing whether the water was taking him in or out. For a few seconds he forgot himself, sustained by the rise and fall of the water and the knowledge that it would carry him as long as he relaxed and remained at peace.