‘What did you get out of it?’ she asked aloud. ‘Did you enjoy seeing dogs being ripped to shreds?’
‘No, not really,’ Langley admitted. ‘Sometimes it got so bloody that I had to turn away. But once the fighting was over – once the blood had been spilled – ah, that was bliss!’
‘What happened then?’
‘That was when they had the loyal toast. Everybody there – and I mean every single man-jack of them – would raise his glass or his can of beer in the air and shout, “To the Master!” They were drinking that loyal toast to me!’
‘They were laughing at you, just like the men in the Country Club and the hunt,’ Paniatowski thought. ‘They were taking your money, and laughing at you.’
‘How did Andy Adair come into the picture?’ she asked.
‘Adair had only just moved to Whitebridge, but Edward Dunston knew him from dog fights they’d both attended in other parts of the country, and he said that with Adair’s experience, he would be the ideal chap to run things for us.’
‘And even though Adair was already working for Forsyth, he couldn’t resist the opportunity to make a little bit extra on the side,’ Paniatowski thought.
‘One of my bright young officers pointed out that there were no Catholics amongst your members,’ she said. ‘Was that Adair’s doing?’
‘Yes. He hated Catholics with a vengeance, and he’d only agree to take on the job if we promised to keep them out.’
‘Tell me about Simon Stockwell.’
Langley looked puzzled. ‘There’s not much to tell. He was just an ordinary member.’
‘So why did the killer single him out for execution?’
‘I don’t know. I didn’t give it much thought. Some maniac had killed a member of the club and left his body in my grounds. That alone was more than enough to think about, thank you very much.’
‘And Len Gutterridge?’
‘Why are you asking about him?’
‘Because he was killed last night – and so was Edward Dunston. We found them both in the Whitebridge Rovers’ stadium this morning – naked and on all fours, just like the others.’
‘Oh, my God,’ Langley moaned. ‘This is terrible.’
‘Yes, you’re probably right,’ Paniatowski agreed. ‘At any rate, Dunston and Gutterridge didn’t look too pleased about it. But you still haven’t answered my question.’
‘What question?’
‘I can understand why the killer chose Adair and Dunston as his victims – Dunston set the club up, and Adair ran it – but what reason did he have for singling out Stockwell and Gutterridge?’
‘I don’t know,’ Langley admitted. ‘Unless it had something to do with the dog.’
‘What dog?’ Paniatowski demanded.
Len Gutterridge walks into the club with a Staffordshire bull terrier on a lead. The dog seems bemused by the whole situation, yet eager to please the man who brought it out for a walk – and, even to Langley’s untutored eye, it doesn’t look like the usual fighting dog at all.
Gutterridge brings the dog over to where Langley and Dunston are standing.
‘You’re never planning to enter that thing in the fight, are you?’ Dunston asks. ‘It’s not got the instinct. It’ll not last five minutes’
‘It’s a good dog, this,’ Gutterridge protests. ‘Full of fighting spirit. But no, I wasn’t planning to enter it into the fight myself.’
‘Well, then?’
‘I thought the club might like to buy it off me. I thought the club might like to enter it.’
Dunston and Langley exchange glances. Neither of them wants the club to buy the dog, but Gutterridge – for all that he is as guilty as anyone else in the room – is still a policeman, and it might be wise not to cross him.
‘How much do you want for it?’ Dunston asks finally.
Gutterridge shrugs. ‘Thirty quid?’
Dunston pays him the money, and fifteen minutes later the dog is sent into the pit. It puts up a poor show, and the fight is over even quicker than Dunston guessed it would be.
The badly injured animal is dragged away.
‘What do you want us to do with your useless bloody dog, Len?’ Simon Stockwell calls out mockingly.
‘It’s not my dog,’ Gutterridge says. ‘It’s the club’s dog. Do whatever you bloody well want with it.’
Stockwell brings a rope and throws it over a large hook, which has been set in place for just this purpose.
And even as he is putting the noose around the badly mauled animal’s neck, Langley notices the dog is looking up at him, with hope in its eyes that it will yet be shown some kindness.
Stockwell begins to haul on the rope, and Langley has to turn away. Behind him, he can hear the other men shouting and jeering as the dog gasps and struggles as it tries to hold on to its life.
‘This is horrible,’ the Master thinks. ‘This is the worst thing I’ve ever seen.’
‘But you didn’t try to stop it?’ Paniatowski asked.
‘No, I . . . I was the Master. I didn’t want to seem weak in front of men who had so much respect for me.’
Paniatowski sighed. All the hints she had been given throughout the investigation had finally slotted into place, and though she didn’t know everything yet – though there were a few pieces of information to collect before the picture was complete – the case was as good as over.
‘What happens now?’ Langley asked.
‘When my inspector gets here, he’ll take you down to police headquarters where you’ll be formally charged, photographed and fingerprinted.’
‘Like a common criminal,’ Langley said mournfully.
‘Not like one – you are a common criminal,’ Paniatowski pointed out.
Langley’s lip quivered. ‘Will I . . . will be let out on bail, once I’ve been charged?’
Paniatowski nodded. ‘Unless, of course, the magistrate refuses bail – and there’s no reason why he should.’
‘But I will go to prison?’
‘Yes, you will.’
‘And what about when I come out of jail?’
‘What about it?’
‘No one who matters in this town – who matters anywhere – will want to have anything to do with me, will they?’
Paniatowski laughed. ‘Oh, I don’t know about that,’ she said. ‘You might be something of a hero with the dog-fighting set.’
Langley bowed his head. ‘My life is over,’ he pronounced mournfully.
‘It doesn’t have to be,’ Paniatowski told him. ‘Not if you show a little backbone – not if you finally start acting like a man!’
‘Could I ask you a small favour?’ Langley asked.
‘What is it?’
‘Before you actually arrest me, I’d like to spend a little time by myself, in my trophy room.’
‘In where?’
‘My trophy room. It’s where I keep the heads of all the animals I’ve shot. I’ve got a very fine elk, and a stag with antlers that . . .’
‘I’m not interested in hearing about all the helpless creatures you have slaughtered,’ Paniatowski said harshly. ‘But I would like to know where you keep the guns you used to carry out that slaughter.’
‘They’re . . . they’re safely locked in a cabinet.’
‘And is that cabinet in the trophy room?’
‘Yes, it is,’ Langley admitted, looking down at the floor.
‘In that case, I can see no objection to you spending a few minutes with some of your victims,’ Paniatowski told him.
The guard at the gatehouse of Ashton Court was still, in theory, on duty, but he gave Beresford’s warrant card no more than the most cursory of glances before waving the inspector through.
It was amazing how quickly word got around, Beresford thought, as he drove up the driveway towards the house. It was like throwing a stone into a pond, and watching the circles spread out from it. Already – though Monika had probably not even arrested the merchant banker yet – his security staff knew
that he was finished. And by the afternoon, when the circles had spread almost to the edges of the pond that was Whitebridge, there wouldn’t be a single person in the town with a good word to say about Sir William Langley.
He parked in front of Ashley Court, and was shown into the study by the same uniformed maid who Paniatowski had barged past earlier. He had expected to find Langley there, but the only person occupying the vast, pretentious room was his boss, who was gazing out of the window with a preoccupied air about her.
‘Where’s Langley?’ he asked.
Paniatowski turned to face him. ‘Langley is elsewhere,’ she said. Then, more crisply, she added, ‘What have you got to report, Colin?’
‘We’ve sealed off the farm, and the forensic boys are getting to work on it even as I speak,’ Beresford said. ‘In addition, I’ve arranged a press conference for this evening, but I’ve warned the hacks that you may have to cancel it if . . .’ He paused. ‘I’m sorry, boss, what did you mean by “elsewhere”?’
Paniatowski smiled, though it was not a happy expression. If anything, Beresford thought, he would have called it tortured.
‘The Lord of the Manor is in his trophy room,’ she said.
The words exploded inside Beresford’s head.
In his trophy room!
‘But good God, boss, there are probably guns in there,’ he said.
‘There are guns in there,’ Paniatowski replied calmly.
‘And don’t you think there’s a danger he might . . .’
‘Blow his own head off?’
‘Well, yes.’
‘That course of action must certainly have an appeal for him. With that last final gesture, he’d confirm – at least to himself – that he really is an English gentleman.’
‘Then how could you . . . what ever possessed you to . . .?’
‘Let’s go and see how he’s getting on, shall we?’ Paniatowski suggested.
The doors to the gun case in the trophy room had been thrown wide open, and several expensive customized shotguns were there for the taking by anyone who cared to reach into the cabinet. But Sir William Langley couldn’t take advantage of the opportunity, for though he could almost touch the guns with the fingertips of his left hand, his right wrist was firmly manacled to one of the substantial heating pipes.
It had been a fine calculation on Paniatowski’s part, Beresford thought. There was no way that Langley could actually get his hands on one of the guns, but she had tethered him close enough for him to still live in the desperate hope that – with a little more effort – he just might.
Langley noticed them looking at him from the doorway.
‘So you’ve brought your underling to observe me in my humiliation, have you, Chief Inspector?’ he asked angrily.
‘That’s right,’ Paniatowski replied, in a cheery voice. ‘I thought he could use a good laugh.’ She turned to Beresford. ‘Seen enough, Colin?’
‘More than enough,’ Beresford said, sounding troubled.
They walked back down along the corridor in uneasy silence, and it was not until they were back in Langley’s study that Beresford said, ‘Why did you do that, boss?’
‘You’re supposed to be a detective,’ Paniatowski replied, in a tone he couldn’t quite pin down. ‘You work it out.’
‘You wanted to make him suffer?’
‘Full marks – go to the top of the class.’
There had been a frown on Beresford’s face since he’d first seen what she’d done to Langley, and now that frown deepened even further.
‘This isn’t like you, boss,’ he said. ‘It isn’t like you at all.’
‘Isn’t it?’ Paniatowski demanded – and now he had her tone pegged as anger, a deep, boiling anger he’d never seen in her before. ‘Why shouldn’t I want him to suffer, after what he’s done? Why shouldn’t he pay for standing by while poor dumb suffering animals were ripped to shreds? But that’s nothing compared to what else he’s done. Through his vanity and his insecurity, a good man has been destroyed – and there can never be enough punishment for that!’
‘A good man?’ Beresford repeated, mystified. ‘Who are you talking about?’
‘Oh, for God’s sake, who the hell do you think I’m talking about?’ Paniatowski countered.
TWENTY-EIGHT
Paniatowski found Cousins in her office, sitting in Beresford’s chair.
‘Sorry to have come in here without asking your permission first, ma’am,’ the sergeant said.
‘That’s all right, Paul,’ Paniatowski said, seating herself down opposite him.
‘I wouldn’t normally have done it,’ the sergeant continued, ‘but when I heard that you’d been out to Moors’ Edge Farm I suddenly felt so tired, and I knew I had to find a place where I could be on my own for a while.’
‘I understand.’
Cousins reached into his wallet, took out a photograph, and slid it across the desk to Paniatowski.
‘I’d like you to take a look at that,’ he said.
The picture had been taken in a garden, and in the background Paniatowski could see honeysuckle climbing a trestle. The two people in the shot were sitting down on plastic chairs. The woman was smiling at the camera, but even though she was making a great effort to hide the fact that she was in pain, she was not being entirely successful. The man was smiling too, but his eyes, filled with concern, were fixed not on the camera but on the woman. A ginger cat sat on the woman’s knee, and a dog – a Staffordshire bull terrier – was curled up contentedly at her feet.
‘That’s us,’ Cousins said. ‘That’s the family.’
Paniatowski smiled. ‘I guessed as much.’
‘We always thought Mary would be the first to go. But she wasn’t. A few weeks before she died, Ginger was run over in the street. It was nobody’s fault but his own – he was always a reckless bugger – but it hit Mary hard. She said there seemed to be a curse on the family.’ Cousins paused. ‘You have to laugh, don’t you, ma’am? There she was, dying of cancer herself, and the first time she mentions a curse is when the bloody cat gets killed!’
‘It must have been awful for her,’ Paniatowski said, sympathetically.
‘But she was right – as usual,’ Cousins continued. ‘We were cursed.’ He paused again, as if this was all very difficult for him. ‘Mary had always been close to Davie, but she grew even closer to him after Ginger was killed.’ He laughed. ‘Davie! Funny bloody name to give a powerful animal like a pit-bull terrier, isn’t it?’
‘I think it’s a nice name,’ Paniatowski told him.
‘But my Mary was most insistent that was what we call him. She said he’d got “Davie” written all over him. That was the thing about her. She had her own way of looking at everything and everybody, and she saw qualities in them which other people didn’t. She certainly saw qualities in me I never knew I had, but because she’d seen them, I believe I actually did start to develop them. Does that make any sense at all?’
‘It makes a lot of sense.’
‘When she first got ill, I did everything I could to help her. I took medical books out of the library, to see if I could find a cure that her doctor had somehow missed. But of course there wasn’t one. I got her to take some of those “alternative” medicines, but they either had no effect at all, or they made her feel sick. I hadn’t prayed for years, but I prayed then – down on my knees until it hurt so much that I could hardly stand up again. None of it did any good. I failed her.’
‘You didn’t fail her,’ Paniatowski said softly. ‘You loved her and you cared for her right to the end – and that’s all anybody can ask.’
‘She was worried about what would happen to Davie after she’d gone,’ Cousins said. ‘She’d had him from a pup, you see. She loved him with all her heart, and one of the last things she did before she died was to make me promise I’d look after him.’
‘But you couldn’t cope,’ Paniatowski said. ‘You were having a mental breakdown, so you were forced to give him to you
r old friend Len Gutterridge to look after.’
‘You know about that, do you?’
‘Yes. His widow confirmed it, not half an hour ago. And I also know that Gutterridge used to go to Moors’ Edge Farm on Thursday nights.’
‘If Len had thought there’d be a possibility I’d be coming out of the nut house soon, Davie would have been quite safe,’ Cousins said sadly. ‘But he believed I’d be in there for the duration, so he took the dog to the fight. He sold our Davie – and then he stood there and watched him being ripped to shreds.’
‘How did you find out what had actually gone on?’ Paniatowski asked.
Cousins shrugged. ‘It wasn’t difficult. The first time I spoke to Len after I’d been released, he seemed very nervous. When he told me that Davie had died of distemper, I knew he was lying, so I checked with all the vets in Whitebridge, and none of them had treated my dog. You can fill in the rest for yourself, can’t you, ma’am.’
‘I think so. You started watching him closely, and one night you followed him out to Moors’ Edge Farm?’
‘And once I saw what was going on there, I knew what had happened to Davie. There were still a few details that needed to be filled in, but Andy Adair was most forthcoming, once I’d given him the blow-lamp treatment.’
‘You decided that the four men most closely connected with Davie’s death had to die themselves.’
‘That’s right, ma’am. Len had betrayed Davie – and me – for thirty pieces of silver, Dunston had paid the money, Adair had managed the fight, and Stockwell . . .’ A sob came to Cousins’ throat. ‘. . . Stockwell had hanged my poor, sweet little dog when it was all over.’
‘You led this investigation on a merry dance,’ Paniatowski said. She paused for a second. ‘When Stockwell’s van burst into flame, you weren’t even there. How did you manage that? A timer?’
‘That’s right, ma’am.’
‘And it was you who first introduced the idea of IRA involvement, and sent us off in entirely the wrong direction.’
‘I didn’t like doing it, ma’am, because I respect you as a bobby. And, as a member of your team, I wanted to do all that I could to help you. But I needed time to finish my work.’
The Ring of Death Page 25