I wish also to express my particular indebtedness to the following published works about Truman: his own two-volume Memoirs and Margaret Truman Daniel’s Harry S. Truman, a lively, often moving memoir by an adoring daughter; The Man of Independence by Jonathan Daniels, which though incomplete as a biography and anything but impartial (it was written while Truman was still President and Daniels served on Truman’s staff), nonetheless contains much on Truman’s early life not to be found elsewhere; Truman by Roy Jenkins, a too-brief survey of the Truman presidency, but very valuable for its insights; John Hersey’s Aspects of the Presidency, which includes his deft New Yorker profile of Truman, written after an unprecedented chance to follow the President through several crucial days during the second term; The Truman Presidency, The History of a Triumphant Succession by Cabell Phillips, who wrote from firsthand observation as a correspondent for The New York Times; and Plain Speaking, Merle Miller’s popular compilation of reminiscences by the elderly former President and others close to him. Though not altogether reliable as to fact, it has the vitality of its subject and contains much of value.
The three leading Truman scholars of our day are Alonzo L. Hamby, Robert J. Donovan, and Robert H. Ferrell, and I have benefited greatly from their work—from Professor Hamby’s many articles; from Robert Donovan’s comprehensive two-volume study of the Truman presidency, Conflict and Crisis and The Tumultuous Years, fine books by a writer who covered the Truman White House as a reporter for the New York Herald-Tribune; and from Robert H. Ferrell for his advice, friendship, and a whole shelf of Truman books, including The Autobiography of Harry S. Truman, a skillful stitching together of Truman’s own sketches about himself, and two collections of Truman letters and other writings, Off the Record: The Private Papers of Harry S. Truman and Dear Bess: The Letters from Harry to Bess Truman, 1910–1959. Everyone who writes about Truman is indebted to Professor Ferrell for these invaluable books.
My bibliography follows, with the principal sources of manuscript and published works, and includes the names of the more than 125 people who agreed to be interviewed for this book. I thank each and all many times over. A number of the interviews were done over several days, and at intervals of several years. Most of the longer interviews were taped, unless this was against the wishes of the interviewee. When a tape recorder was not used, I kept notes. And while all those who generously gave of their time contributed to my understanding of the subject—and including many who are not directly quoted in the book—I want to thank the following especially: Margaret Truman Daniel for three long interviews, including an all-day session in the Truman home at Independence done for the public television series Smithsonian World; Clifton Daniel, who talked for several hours over lunch in New York and during a thirty-block walk back uptown; Clark Clifford, who gave many hours of his time over a span of ten years and whose recollections and insights were of greatest possible value; George Elsey, who, like Clark Clifford, played a key role in the Truman administration and whose memory for details and sense of history has helped to give life and balance to my recounting of events in ways that would never have been possible otherwise; Rex Scouten, Curator of the White House, and Floyd Boring, both of whom were part of President Truman’s Secret Service detail and who not only spent hours recalling people and events, but took a Saturday afternoon to walk me through what happened at Blair House, inside and out, the day the Puerto Rican nationalists tried to kill the President; James and Martha Ann Truman Swoyer of Oskaloosa, Kansas, who, in addition to talking with me at length about their Uncle Harry, let me see and make notes from his high school workbooks, wonderful, important documents that are quoted here for the first time; the late Merle Miller, who gave me one of the earliest, most interesting of the interviews, and granted me exclusive access to his recorded conversations with former President Truman which are on file at the Lyndon Baines Johnson Library but closed to researchers at Miller’s request; the late Stephen Slaughter, who grew up next door to the Truman farm, who knew Harry Truman when he was a farmer, and whose superb book, History of a Missouri Farm Family, and personal recollections of life in Grandview helped immeasurably in recreating that vanished time and way of life; Joe Pruett of Kansas City, who helped track down former members of the Pendergast organization, who took me to 1908 Main, up the narrow stairs, to see where Tom Pendergast once ruled, and who, with his wife Catherine Pendergast Pruett, let me examine a wealth of Pendergast family letters, photographs, and memorabilia, and talked with great candor and understanding about the whole Pendergast era; and Sue Gentry, who began writing about life in Independence in the 1930s as a reporter for the Examiner and is still going strong, in her “Local Gentry” column in the paper. From the vantagepoint of her home on West Waldo, around the corner from the Truman house, she knows “the whole story.”
For their very valuable comments and suggestions on various portions of the manuscript, I thank Paul Horgan, Charlton Ogburn, Anna Loomis McCandless, John T. Galvin, John Zentay, Paul Nagel, George Elsey, Mark Beveridge, Liz Safly, Erwin Mueller, Lyman Field, the late John Oliver, Charles Guggenheim, and Richard Baker, Historian of the United States Senate.
Richard Baker also arranged for me to retrace the steps of Vice President Harry Truman at the Capitol the fateful evening of April 12, 1945, and with Capitol police officers William E. Uber and John D. Roach, we ran, as Truman did, from one end of the Capitol to the other, from what was Sam Rayburn’s hideaway back along the lower halls and corridors to the Vice President’s office. When I first inquired if it would be possible for me to make the run, Dr. Baker said, “Only if I can come too.”
Paul Nagel, Pat O’Brien, and Brent Schondelmeyer, three historians and authors who grew up in Independence and share a passion for Missouri history, gave me a wonderful day’s tour of Jackson County for which I will always be grateful. Lyman Field recalled his memorable experience with President Truman the morning after the 1948 election and introduced me to dozens of people in Kansas City who took an interest in my project.
I wish to thank also for their continuing help and interest: the staff of the Boston Athenaeum, and especially director Rodney Armstrong and research librarian Jan Malcheski; David Wigdor and others of the Manuscript Division, the Library of Congress; Carol Dage of the Liberty Memorial Library in Kansas City; the staff of the National Archives, and particularly Military Historian Edward Reese, who saved me many hours and much frustration in documenting the casualty estimates anticipated in an invasion of Japan in 1945; the staff of the Jackson County Historial Society; Norman J. Reigle and others of the National Park Service who do such an excellent job at the Truman home—the Harry S. Truman National Historic Site; Aurora Davis of the Kansas City Star Library; Ralph Graves, former Editor-in-Chief of Time, Inc., who arranged access to the Time-Life files; Harry Middleton and his staff at the Lyndon Baines Johnson Library; Helen Bergen of the Martin Luther King, Jr., Library, Washington, D.C.; the Yale University Library; the West Tisbury Public Library; the Cornell University Library; the Smithsonian Institution.
To the following I am also indebted in many ways: Henry Adams; Clarence A. Barnes, Jr., Mary Margaret Bell of the Kentucky Historical Society; the late Walter H. Bieringer; Robert Blafield; Barrington Boardman; Walt Bodine; Daniel J. Boorstin; Charles Burke; Brian Burns; the late Martin Carr; Major General William A. Carter; Carl Charlson; Bernice J. Conley, County Clerk at the Kansas City Courthouse; Paul W. Cook, Jr.; L. P. Cookingham, Frances Cottingham and the Shelby County Historical Society; Annette Curtis; Albert A Eisele; Christa Fischer; Pauline Fowler; Andrew J. Glass; Neil Goodwin and Margot Barnes Street; Katherine Graham; William and Joyce Graves; Shannon Gregory; David Grubin; Janet Helm; Thomas Hill; William F. P. Hugonin; Oliver Jenson, who let me borrow his complete bound set of Life for the Truman years; Emerson and Matilee Johnson; Alvin M. Josephy, Jr.; Chester and Joan Kerr; James Ketchum; Richard Ketchum; Arthur M. Klebanof; Jill Kneerim; the late Kathleen Moore Knight; Professor Robert Knowles; Laurelle O’Leary; Mark Maz
er; John Mayhew; Harry McPherson; Cynthia Miller; Richard Miller; Wilson D. Miscamble; James Mongello; James Morrison; Royall O’Brien; Pat O’Neill; Margaret K. Olwine; Harlene Stapf Palkuti; Arva Parks; Eleanor R. Piacenza; Monty B. Poen; Barbara J. Potts, former mayor of Independence; Henry Hope Reed; Donald Ritchie; Judge Howard Sachs; Professor William Sand; Francis N. Satterlee; Michael Shapiro of the St. Louis Art Museum; Al Silverman; Robert C. Smith; Raymond W. Smock, Historian of Congress; Richard Snow; Marie-Cecile and Alfred E. Street; Audrey Stubbart; the late Barbara Tuchman; Geoffrey Ward; Laura and Robert Wilson; Philip F. Ziedman; William Zinsser.
I am deeply grateful to: the John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Foundation for a fellowship grant that helped make possible an additional year of research; J. Gordon Kingsley, president of William Jewell College in Liberty, for the opportunity to learn about Missouri by living there, as writer-in-residence at William Jewell; Haroldine Helm, who provides welcome comforts of home for researchers at the Truman Library, even researchers and their families; the tireless, resourceful Mike Hill, research specialist, who helped through thick and thin; Shirley Mayhew, Sarah Mayhew, Lynn S. Worthington, Ed Wise, and Eric Moe, who, with Mike Hill, assisted with the source notes.
For the design and production of the book I gratefully acknowledge the work of three splendid people, Eve Metz, Frank Metz, and Sophie Sorkin of Simon & Schuster. I thank Wendell Minor for his stunning original portrait of Truman for the dust jacket. And for the immensely helpful contributions she has made as copy editor, I thank Ann Adelman.
To Richard Snyder and Peter Schwed of Simon & Schuster, for their initial enthusiasm for a Truman biography, my wholehearted appreciation. I thank especially my editor, Michael Korda. With his professional advice and good cheer, my friend and literary agent Morton L. Janklow has been a mainstay throughout, for which I am extremely grateful.
For all their efforts typing the manuscript, I thank Patricia Kendall and Kathryn Harcourt. I thank again my daughter. Melissa and her husband John McDonald, for a wealth of favors and interest; my son David, for his invaluable suggestions on the manuscript; my son Bill, for research assistance in Missouri and for traveling with me as driver, photographer, companion, and “interpreter” across France, following Captain Harry Truman through World War I; my son Geoffrey, for his help with research at the Library of Congress; and my daughter Dorie, who uncovered valuable material about the White House, who, when the end seemed near, warned, me not to let up, and to whom the book is happily, proudly dedicated.
And with all my heart I thank my wife, Rosalee Barnes McCullough, who took part every step of the way and always to the benefit of the work and the author.
—David McCullough
Washington, D.C.; Liberty, Missouri;
Ithaca, New York; West Tisbury, Massachusetts
January 11, 1992
Notes
Bibliography
Index
Source Notes
Part One
1. Blue River Country
“Lord, grant”: Gilbert, Westering Man, 21.
One side-wheel steamer: Blue Springs (Missouri) Examiner, April 26, 1989.
One traveler described: Waugh, “Desultory Wanderings…,” Missouri Historical Society, April 1950.
“The Missouri is constantly’: Parkman, Oregon Trail, 14.
in a letter from Missouri dated July 24, 1846: Nancy Tyler Holmes to Mary Jane Holmes, Harry S. Truman Library (cited hereafter as HSTL).
“As for myself’: Anderson Shipp Truman to Mary Truman, September 16, 1846, HSTL.
“grand prairie ocean”: Gregg, Commerce of the Prairies, 59.
“Mules, horses”: Parkman, Journals, Vol. 2, 419.
“To live in a region:” History of Jackson County, 73.
“rich and beautiful uplands’: Gregg, 163.
“without other warrant”: History of Jackson County, 255.
Mormons must leave or be “exterminated”: Ibid., 268.
a lone assassin: Ibid., 257.
“Awful cold”: Quoted in Slaughter, Missouri Farm Family, 45.
“a gun and an axe”: John W. Meador, Oral History, HSTL.
“She was a strong woman”: HST quoted in Miller, Plain Speaking, 62.
In 1850, his recorded wealth: U.S. Census, 1850.
at nearly $50,000: U.S. Census, 1860.
a man “who could do pretty much anything”: HST quoted in Miller, 62.
“The wagons were coupled”: Deseret News, August 15, 1860, 188.
In the spring of 1849: History of Jackson County, 96.
In 1851 cholera struck again: Ibid.
“Come on then, gentlemen”: Quoted in Oates, To Purge This Land with Blood, 80.
“enough to kill every God-damned abolitionist”: Ibid., 89.
John Brown…come to “regulate matters”: Ibid., 130.
A Jackson County physician named Lee: History of Jackson County, 272.
“They asked me”: Ibid., 300.
Quantrill struck Kansas: Monaghan, Civil War on the Western Border, 286; Josephy, Civil War, 373.
Jim Crow Chiles: Sheley, “James Peacock and ‘Jim Crow’ Chiles,” Frontier Times, May 1963.
In the formal claim Harriet Louisa Young filed: U.S. House of Representatives, 59th Congress, 1st Sess., Sen. Doc. No. 901, June 19, 1906.
Recollection of Martha Ellen Young: Berger, “Mother Truman’s Life Not All Frontier Toil,” Kansas City Times, June 30, 1946 (reprinted from The New York Times).
“It is heartsickening to see”: Brownlee, Gray Ghosts of the Confederacy, 126-27.
“I hope you have not turned”: John Truman to Anderson Truman, October 8, 1861, HSTL.
the Red Legs had arrived: Daniels, Independence, 36.
Anderson loaded his five slaves: Ethel Noland, Oral History, HSTL.
“They never bought one”: Ibid.
He was “universally hated”: Mary Paxton Keeley, Oral History, HSTL.
To black people he was a living terror: Donald R. Hale, “James Chiles—A Missouri Badman,” The West, October 1968.
“to see them jump”: Ibid.
the confrontation on the west side: Ibid.
it was said of John A. Truman: History of Jackson County, 986.
a three-drawer burl walnut dresser: Martha Ann Truman Swoyer, author’s interview.
The couple’s own first home: Kornitzer, “The Story of Truman and His Father,” Parents Magazine, March 1951.
Lamar Democrat: June 28, 1883.
a Baptist circuit rider: Steinberg, The Man from Missouri, 20.
“Baby is real sick now”: Letter of Mary Martha Truman, April 7, 1885, HSTL.
he was chasing a frog: Autobiography, 3.
his mother, for fun: Ibid.
2. Model Boy
the happiest childhood: Harry S. Truman, Memoirs (cited hereafter as Memoirs), Vol. I, 113.
The farm was “a wonderful place”: Ibid., 115.
“I became familiar with every sort of animal”: Ibid.
“there were peach butter”: Ibid., 114.
The child liked everybody: Ibid., 124.
“flat eyeballs”: Daniels, The Man of Independence, 49.
Mamma taught that punishment followed: Autobiography, 33.
enough to “burn the hide off: HST quoted in Miller, Plain Speaking, 63.
John Truman acquired a house: Memoirs, Vol. I, 115.
“I do not remember a bad teacher”: Ibid., 118.
“When I was growing up”: Ibid., 124-25.
“He just smiled his way along”: Jackson (Mississippi) Daily News, December 21, 1947.
diphtheria: Memoirs, Vol. I, 116-17.
“didn’t scare easy”: Daniels, 53.
“not once,” he said: Quoted in Miller, 48.
“It was just something you did”: Ibid., 52.
“Harry, do you remember”: Daniels, 57.
“It’s a very lonely thing”: Quoted in Miller, 277–78.
Caroline Simpson taught: Steinber
g, The Man from Missouri, 24.
“To tell the truth”: Quoted in Miller, 32.
“They wanted to call him”: Henry P. Chiles, Oral History, HSTL.
“intended for a girl” anyway: HST to EW, April 8, 1912, in Ferrell, ed., Dear Bess (cited hereafter as Dear Bess), 80.
He patented a staple puller: Original patents, HSTL.
automatic railroad switch: Parents Magazine, March 1951.
“A mighty good trader”: Ibid.
“fight like a buzz saw”: Quoted in Steinberg, 17.
“A fiery fellow”: Stephen Slaughter, author’s interview.
“No one could make remarks”: Memoirs, Vol. I, 124.
“He had no use for a coward”: Parents Magazine, March 1951,
“Our house became headquarters”: Memoirs, Vol. I, 117-18.
“Harry was always fun”: Ethel Noland, Oral History, HSTL.
“If I succeeded in carrying”: “Pickwick Papers,” May 14, 1934, HSTL.
“No! No! Harry was a Baptist”: Mary Paxton Keeley, Oral History, HSTL.
Truman Page 134