by E. F. Benson
Nadine had a favorite nook on this steep hillside below the house, reached by a path that stretched out to the south of the bay. It was a little hollow, russet-colored now with the bracken, of the autumn, and carpeted elsewhere by the short-napped velvet of the turf. Just in front, the cliff plunged sheer down to the beach, where they had so often bathed in the summer, and where the reef of tumbled sandstone rocks stretched out into the waveless sea, like brown amphibious monsters that were fish at high tide and grazing beasts at the ebb. Down there below, a school of gulls hovered and fished with wheelings of white wings, but not a ripple lapped the edges of the rocks. Only the sea breathed softly as in sleep, stirring the fringes of brown weed that had gathered there, but no thinnest line of white showed breaking water. Along the sandy foreshore of the bay there was the same stillness: heaven and earth and ocean lay as if under an enchantment. The sand dunes opposite, and the hills beyond, lay reflected in the sea, as if in the tranquillity of some land-locked lake. There was a spell, a hush over the world, to be broken by God-knew-what gentle awakening of activity, or catastrophic disturbance.
* * * *
The two had walked to this withdrawn hollow of the hill almost in silence. He had offered to carry her books for her, but she had said that they were of no weight, and after pause he had announced a fragment of current news to which she had no comment to add, but had noticed the windless, unnatural calm of the day. Something in this unusual stillness of weather had set her nerves a-quiver, and perhaps the position she was in, bound as she was to Seymour, not struggling against it, but quite accepting it, made ordinary intercourse difficult. For she had it all her own way, Hugh was behaving with exemplary discretion, Seymour was behaving with admirable tolerance, and just because they both made her own part so easy for her, she, womanlike, found the smoothed-out performance of it to be difficult. Had she instructed each of them how to behave, her instructions were carried out to the letter’s foot: they were impeccable as lover and rejected lover, and therefore she wanted something different. The situation was completely of her own making: her actors played their parts exactly as she would have them play, and yet there was something wanting. They weretoo well-drilled, too word-perfect, too certain to say all she had designed for them from the right spot, and in the right voice. True, for a moment just now Seymour had shown signs of individualism when he called attention to the fact that he was behaving very nicely, and that he would be glad when the scene was over, but Hugh had shown none whatever, except for the fact that he had been asked to be allowed a few days like the old days agone before he left England. He had assured her in the summer that he would never seek to get back into the atmosphere of unthinking intimacy again, but, poor fellow, when there were to be so few days left him, before the situation was sealed and made irrevocable, his heart had cried out against the edict of his will and, foolish though it might be, he had asked for this week of Meering days. But from his point of view, no less than from hers, they had been but a parody of what he had hoped for, they had been frozen and congealed by the reserve and restraint that he dared not break. Below that surface-ice, he knew how swiftly ran the torrent in his soul, but the ice quite stretched from shore to shore. It was this which disappointed Nadine: for she equally with Hugh had expected that he could realize the impossible, and that he, loving her as he did and knowing that she was so soon to give herself to another man, could cast off the knowledge of that, and resume for a space the unshackled intimacy of old. The Ethiopian and the leopard would have found their appropriate feats far easier, for it was Hugh’s bones and blood he had to change, not mere skin and hair, and the very strength of the bond that bound him to her made the insuperableness of the barrier. He felt every moment the utter failure of his attempt, while she, who thought she understood him so well, had no notion how radical the failure was. Not loving, she could not understand. He knew that now, and thought bitterly of the little fireworks of words she had once lit for him on that same text, believing that by the light of those quick little squibs, she could read his heart.
So, when they were settled in their nook, once again she tried to recapture the old ease. She pointed downwards over the edge of the cliff.
“Oh, Hughie, what a morning,” she said. “Quiet sea and gulls, and bees and gorse. What a summer in December, a truce with winter, isn’t it? I’ve brought a handful of nice books. Shall I read?”
“Oh, soon,” said he. “But your summer in December isn’t going to last long. There is a wind coming, and a big one. Look at the mare’s-tails of clouds up above. Can’t you smell the wind coming? I always can. And the barometer has dropped nearly an inch since last night.”
He put back his head and sniffed, moving his nostrils rather like a horse.
“Oh, how fascinating,” said Nadine. “If I do that shall I smell the wind?”
It made her sneeze instead.
“I don’t think much of that,” she said. “I expect you looked at the barometer before you smelt the wind. Besides, how is it possible to smell the wind before there is any wind to smell? And when it comes you feel it instead.”
“It will be a big storm,” said Hugh.
Even as he spoke some current of air stirred the surface of the sea below them, shattering the reflections. It was as if some great angel of the air had breathed on the polished mirror of the water, dimming it. Next moment the breath cleared away again, and the surface was as bright and unwavering as before. But some half-dozen of the gulls that had been hovering and chiding there, rose into the higher air, leaving their feeding-ground, and after circling round once or twice, glided away over the sand dunes inland. Almost immediately afterwards, another relay followed, and another, till the bay that had been so populous with birds was quite deserted. They did not pause in their flight, but went straight inland, in decreasing specks of white till they vanished altogether.
“The gulls seem to think so, too,” said Hugh.
“Then they are perfectly wrong,” said Nadine. “The instincts Nature implants in animals are almost invariably incorrect. For instance, the Siberian tigers at the Zoo. For several years they never grew winter coats, and all the naturalists went down on their knees and said: ‘O wonderful Mother Nature! Their instincts tell them this is a milder climate than Siberia.’ But this winter, the mildest ever known, the poor things have grown the thickest winter coats ever seen. So all the naturalists had to get up again, and dust their trousers where they had knelt down.”
“Put your money on the gulls and me,” said Hugh. “Look there again, far away along the sands.”
To Nadine, the most attractive feature about Hugh was his eyes. They had a far-away look in them that had nothing whatever spiritual or sentimental in it, but was simply due to the fact that he had extraordinarily long sight. She obediently screwed up her eyes and followed his direction, but saw nothing whatever of import.
“It’s getting nearer: you’ll see it soon,” said Hugh.
Soon she saw. A whirlwind of sand was advancing towards them along the beach below, revolving giddily. As it came nearer they could see the loose pieces of seaweed and jetsam being caught up into it. It came forward in a straight line, perhaps as fast as a man might run, getting taller as it approached and gyrating more violently. Then in its advance it came into collision with the wall of cliff on which they sat, and was shattered. They could hear, like the sound of rain, the sand and rubbish of which it was composed falling upon the rocks.
“Oh, but did you invent that, Hughie?” she said. “It was quite a pretty trick. Was it a sign to this faithless generation, which is me, that you could smell the wind? Or did the gulls do it? Prophesy to me again!”
He lay back on the dry grass.
“Trouble coming, trouble coming,” he said.
“Just the storm?” she asked. “Or is this more prophecy?”
“Oh, just the storm,” he said. “I always feel depressed and irritated before a storm.”
“Are you depressed and irritated?” s
he asked. “Sorry. I thought it was such a nice, calm morning.”
Hugh took up a book at random, which proved to be Swinburne’s “Poems and Ballads.” At random he opened it, and saw the words:
“And though she saw all heaven in flower above, She would not love.”
“Oh, do read,” said Nadine. “Anything: just where you opened it.”
Hugh sat up, a bitterness welling in his throat. He read:
“And though she saw all heaven in flower above, She would not love.”
Nadine flushed slightly, and was annoyed with herself for flushing. She could not help knowing what must be in his mind, and tried to make a diversion.
“I don’t think she was to be blamed,” she said. “A quantity of flowers stuck all over the sky would look very odd, and I don’t think would kindle anybody’s emotions. That sounds rather a foolish poem. Read something else.”
Hugh shut the book.
“‘Though all we fell on sleep, she would not weep,’ is the end of another stanza,” he said.
Nadine looked at him for a long moment, her lips parted as if to speak, but they only quivered; no words came. There was no doubt whatever as to what Hugh meant, but still, with love unawakened, and with her tremendous egotism rampant, she saw no further than he was behaving very badly to her. He had come down here to renew the freedom and intimacy of old days: till today he had been silent, stupid, but when he spoke like this, silence and stupidity were better. She was sorry for him, very sorry, but the quiver of her lips half at least consisted of self-pity that he made her suffer too.
“You mean me,” she said, speaking at length, and speaking very rapidly. “It is odious of you. You know quite well I am sorry: I have told you so. I cried: I remember I cried when you made that visit to Winston, and the cow looked at me. I daresay you are suffering damned torments, but you are being unfair. Though I don’t love you—like that, I wish I did. Do you think I make you suffer for my own amusement? Is it fun to see my best friend like that? Is it my fault? You have chosen to love this heartless person, me. If I had no liver, or no lungs, instead of no heart, you would be sorry for me. Instead you reproach me. Oh, not in words, but you meant me, when you said that. Where is the book out of which you read? There, I do that to it: I send it into the sea, and when the gulls come back they will peck it, or the sea will drown it first, and the wind which you smell will blow it to America. You don’t understand: you are more stupid than the gulls.”
She made one swift motion with her arm, and “Poems and Ballads” flopped in the sea as the book dived clear of the cliff into the high-water sea below.
More imminent than the storm which Hugh had prophesied was the storm in their souls. He, with his love baffled, raged at the indifference with which she had given herself to another, she, distrusting for the first time, the sense and wisdom of her gift, raged at him for his rebellion against her choice.
“Don’t speak,” she said, “for I will tell you more things first. You are jealous of Seymour—”
Hugh threw back his head and laughed.
“Jealous of Seymour?” he cried. “Do you really think I would marry you if you consented in the spirit in which you are taking him? Once, it is true, I wanted to. You refused to cheat me—those were your words—and I begged you to cheat me, I implored you to cheat me, so long as you gave me yourself.
“I didn’t care how you took me, so long as you took me. But now I wouldn’t take you like that. Now, for this last week, I have seen you and him together, and I know what it is like.”
“You haven’t seen us together much,” said Nadine.
“I have seen you enough: I told you before that your marriage was a farce. I was wrong. It’s much worse than a farce. You needn’t laugh at a farce. But you can’t help laughing, at least I can’t, at a tragedy so ludicrous.”
Nadine got up. The situation was as violent and sudden as some electric storm. What had been pent-up in him all this week, had exploded: something in her exploded also.
“I think I hate you,” she said.
“I am sure I despise you,” said he.
He got up also, facing her. It was like the bursting of a reservoir: the great sheet of quiet water was suddenly turned into torrents and foam.
“I despise you,” he said again. “You intended me to love you; you encouraged me to let myself go. All the time you held yourself in, though there was nothing to hold in; you observed, you dissected. You cut down with your damned scalpels and lancets to my heart, and said, ‘How interesting to see it beating!’ Then you looked coolly over your shoulder and saw Seymour, and said, ‘He will do: he doesn’t love me and I don’t love him!’ But now he does love you, and you probably guess that. So, very soon, your lancet will come out again, and you will see his heart beating. And again you will say, ‘How interesting!’ But there will be blood on your lancet. You are safe, of course, from reprisals. No one can cut into you, and see your blood flow, because you haven’t any blood. You are something cold and hellish. You often said you understood me too well. Now you understand me even better. Toast my heart, fry it, eat it up! I am utterly at your mercy, and you haven’t got any mercy. But I can manage to despise you: I can’t do much else.”
Nadine stood quite still, breathing rather quickly, and that movement of the nostrils, which she had tried to copy from him, did not make her sneeze now.
“It is well we should know each other,” she said with an awful cold bitterness, “even though we shall know each other for so little time more. It is always interesting to see the real person—”
“If you mean me,” he said hotly, “I always showed you the real person. I have never acted to you, nor pretended. And I have not changed. I am not responsible if you cannot see!”
Nadine passed her tongue over her lips. They seemed hard and dry, not flexible enough for speech.
“It was my blindness then,” she said. “But we know where we are now. I hate you, and you despise me. We know now.”
Then suddenly an impulse, wholy uncontrollable, and coming from she knew not where, seized and compelled her. She held out both her hands to him.
“Hughie, shake hands with me,” she said. “This has been nightmare talk, a bad thing that one dreams. Shake hands with me, and that will wake us both up. What we have been saying to each other is impossible: it isn’t real or true. It is utter nonsense we have been talking.”
How he longed to take her hands and clasp them and kiss them! How he longed to wipe off all he had said, all she had said. But somehow it was beyond him to do it. It was by honest impulse that the words of hate and contempt had risen to their lips; the words might be canceled, but what could not be quenched, until some mistake was shown in the workings of their souls, was the thought-fire that had made them boil up. She stood there, lovely and welcoming, the girl whom his whole soul loved, whose conduct his whole soul despised, eager for reconciliation, yearning for a mutual forgiveness. But her request was impossible. God could not cancel the bitterness that had made him speak. He threw his hands wide.
“It’s no good,” he said. “I am sorry I said certain things, for there was no use in saying them. But I can’t help feeling that which made me say them. Cancel the speeches by all means. Let the words be unsaid with all my heart.”
“But let us be prepared to say them again?” said Nadine quietly. “It comes to that.”
“Yes, it comes to that. I am not jealous of Seymour. I laughed when you suggested it; and I am not jealous, because you don’t love him. If you loved him, I should be jealous, and I should say, ‘God bless you!’ As it is—”
“As it is, you say ‘Damn you,’” said Nadine.
Hugh shook his head.
“You don’t understand anything about love,” he said. “How can you until you know a little bit what it means? I could no more think or say ‘Damn you,’ than I could say ‘God bless you.’”
Nadine had withdrawn from her welcome and desire for reconciliation.
“Nei
ther would make any difference to me,” she said.
“I don’t suppose they would, since I make no difference to you,” said he. “But there is no sense in adding hypocrisy to our quarrel.”
Nadine sat down again on the sweet turf.
“I cancel my words, then, even if you do not,” she said. “I don’t hate you. I can’t hate you, any more than you can despise me. We must have been talking in nightmare.”
“I am used to nightmare,” said Hugh. “I have had six months of nightmare. I thought that I could wake; I thought I could—could pinch myself awake by seeing you and Seymour together. But it’s still nightmare.”
Nadine looked up at him.
“Oh, Hughie, if I loved you!” she said.
Hugh looked at her a moment, and then turned away from her. Outside of his control certain muscles worked in his throat; he felt strangled.
“I can say ‘God bless you’ for that, Nadine,” he said huskily. “I do say it. God bless you, my darling.”
Nadine had leaned her face on her hands when he turned away. She divined why he turned from her, she heard the huskiness of his voice, and the thought of Hughie wanting to cry gave her a pang that she had never yet known the like of. There was a long silence, she sitting with hand-buried face, he seeing the sunlight swim and dance through his tears. Then he touched her on the shoulder.
“So we are friends again in spite of ourselves,” he said. “Just one thing more then, since we can talk without—without hatred and contempt. Why did you refuse to marry me, because you did not love me, and yet consent to marry Seymour like that?”
She looked up at him.
“Oh, Hughie, you fool,” she said. “Because you matter so much more.”
He smiled back at her.
“I don’t want to wish I mattered less,” he said.
“You couldn’t matter less.”
He had no reply to this, and sat down again beside her. After a little Nadine turned to him.
“And I said I thought it was such a calm morning,” she said.