by Hugh Walpole
After her demobilisation she danced a good deal, dined alone at restaurants with men whom she scarcely knew, went back to men’s rooms after the theatre and had a “last whiskey,” walked home alone after midnight and let herself into her “attic” with great satisfaction. She had the most complete contempt for girls who “could not look after themselves.”
“If girls got into trouble it was their own rotten fault.”
She had developed during her time in France a masculine fashion of standing, sitting, talking, laughing. Nothing made her more indignant than that a man should offer her his seat in a Tube. How her haughty glance scorned him as she refused him! “It’s an insult to our sex,” she would say. How she rejoiced in her freedom! “At last,” she said, “there is sex equality. We can do what we like.”
She was, however, not quite free. The war had left her a legacy in the person of an adoring girl friend, Margery Scales. Margery was an exact opposite to herself in every way — plump and soft and rosy and appealing and entirely feminine. She had been “under” Lois in France; from the first she had desperately adored her. It was an adoration without qualification. Lois was perfect, a queen, a goddess. Margery would die for her instantly if called upon; not that she wanted to die. She loved life, being pretty and healthy, and allowed by loving parents a great deal of freedom.
But what was life without Lois? Lois would tell you, if you asked her, that she had made Margery. “Margery owed her everything.” Others, who did not like Lois, said that she had ruined Margery. Margery herself felt that life had simply not begun in those years before Lois had appeared.
Lois had determined that “after the war” she would finish the Margery affair. It unsettled her, disturbed her, refused to fall into line with all the straightforward arrangements that were as easy to manage as “putting your clothes on.” The truth was, that Lois was fonder of Margery than she wanted to be. She quarrelled with her, scolded her, laughed at her, scorned her, and at the end of it all had absurdly soft and tender feelings for her that were not at all “sensible.”
Margery’s very helplessness — a quality that infuriated Lois in others — attracted and held her. She had too much to do to bother about people’s feelings; nevertheless, were Margery distressed and unhappy, Lois was uncomfortable and ill at ease. “After the war I’ll break it off.... It’s sentimental.”
Nevertheless, here she was, four months, five months, six months after the Armistice, and it was not broken off. She would dismiss Margery with scorn, tell her that she could not be bothered with her scenes and tears and repentances, and then five minutes after she had expelled her she would want to know where she was, what she was doing.
She would not confess to herself the joy that she felt when Margery suddenly reappeared. Then, as she weeks went by, she began to wonder whether Margery were as completely under her control as she used to be. The girl seemed at times to criticise her. She said quite frankly that she hated some of the men whom Lois gathered round her in the attic.
“Well, you needn’t come,” said Lois; “I don’t want you.” Then, of course, Margery cried.
There was one occasion when Mr. Nix, the manager of the flat, very politely, and with the urbanity for which he was famous, warned her that there must not be so much noise at her evening parties. Lois was indignant. “I’ll pack up and go. You’d think Nix was Queen Victoria.” Nevertheless she did not pack up and go. She knew when she was comfortable. But deep down in her heart something warned her. Did she like all the men who now surrounded her? Was there not something in what Margery said? In France there had been work, heaps of it Her organising gifts, which were very real, had had full play them The sense of the position that she had had unsettled her. She wanted to fill her life, to be still of importance, to be admired and sought after and talked of. Yet the men with whom she spent her time were not quite the right men, and sometimes that little voice of warning told her that they went too far, said things to her that they had no right to say, told stories....
But did she not encourage them? Was not that what she wanted? Perfect equality now; no false prudery: the new world in which men and women stood shoulder to shoulder with no false reserves, no silly modesties. If Margery didn’t like it, she could go....
But she did not want Margery to go.
Then “Tubby” Grenfell came and the world was changed. Grenfell was nicknamed “Tubby” by his friends because he was round and plump and rosy-faced. Lois did not know it, but she liked him at once because of his resemblance to Margery. He was only a boy, twenty-one years of age, and the apple of his mother’s eye. He had done magnificently in France, and now he had gone on to the Stock Exchange, where his uncle was a man of importance and power. He had the same rather helpless appealing innocence that Margery had had. He took life very seriously, but enjoyed it too, laughing a great deal and wanting to see and do everything. His naïveté touched Lois. She told him that she was going to be his elder brother. From the very first he had thought Lois perfectly wonderful, just as Margery had done. He received her dicta about life with the utmost gravity. He came and went just as she told him. He “ate out of her hand,” his friends told him.
“Well, I’m proud to,” he said.
Unfortunately he and Margery disliked one another from the very beginning. That made difficulties for Lois, and she did not like difficulties.
“What you can see in him,” said Margery, “I can’t think. He’s just the sort of man you despise. Of course he’s been brave; but anyone can be brave. The other men laugh at him.”
He had a good-natured contempt for Margery.
“It’s jolly good of you to look after a girl like that,” he said to Lois. “It’s just your kindness. I don’t know how you can bother.”
Lois laughed at both of them, and arranged that they should meet as seldom as possible.
Hortons was soon haunted by “Tubby” Grenfell’s presence.
“Peace Day” came and went, and Lois really felt that it was time that she “settled her life.” Here was the summer before her; there were a number of places to which she might go and she could not make up her mind.
Firstly, she knew that some of the time must be spent with her mother in Wiltshire, and she was dreading this. Her mother never criticised her, never asked her questions, never made any demands, and Lois had rather enjoyed spending days of her “leave” in that silly old-fashioned company. But now? Could it be that Lois was two quite different people and that one half of her was jealous of the other half?
Moreover, there was now a complication about Scotland. “Tubby” had begged her to go to a certain house in Northumberland; nice people; people she knew enough to want to know them more. He begged her to go there during the very month that she had planned to go away with Margery. She knew quite well that if she tried to break the Scottish holiday that would be the end — Margery would leave her and never return. Well, was not that exactly what she had been desiring? Was she not feeling this animosity between “Tubby” and Margery a great nuisance? And yet — and yet —
She could not make up her mind to lose Margery; no, not yet. Her hatred of this individual (she had never been undecided in France; she had always known exactly what she intended to do) flung her, precipitately, into that final quarrel with Margery that, in reality, she wanted to avoid. It took place one morning in “the attic.” It was a short and stormy scene. Lois began by suggesting that they should take their holiday during part of September instead of August, and that perhaps they would not go so far as Scotland.
.. What about the South Coast? Margery listened, the colour coming into her cheeks, her eyes filling with tears as they always did when she was excited.
“But we’d arranged—” she said in a kind of awe-struck whisper. “Months ago — we fixed—”
“I know, my dear,” said Lois, with a carelessness that she by no means felt. “But what does it matter? September’s as good as August, and I hate Scotland.”
“You said you
loved it before,” said Margery slowly, staring as though she were a stranger who had brought dramatic news. “I believe,” she went on, “it’s because you want to stay with Mr. Grenfell.”
“If you want to know,” cried Lois, suddenly urged on partly by her irritation at being judged, but still more by her anger at herself for feeling Margery’s distress, “it is. You’re impossible, Margery. You’re so selfish. It can’t make any difference to you, putting our holiday off. You’re selfish. That’s what it is.”
Then a remarkable thing occurred. Margery did not burst into tears. Only all the colour drained from her face and her eyes fell.
“No, I don’t think I’m selfish,” said Margery; “I want you to enjoy yourself. You’re tired of me, and I don’t blame you. But I won’t hang on to you. That would be selfish if I did. I think I’ll go now. Besides,” she added, “I think you’re in love with Mr, Grenfell.”
Suddenly, as Margery said the words, Lois knew that it was true. She was in love, and for the first time in her life. A great exultation and happiness filled her; for the first time for many months she was simple and natural and good. Her masculinity fell from her, leaving her her true self.
She came over to Margery, knelt down by her side, put her arms around her and kissed her. Margery returned the kiss, but did not surrender herself. Her body was stiff and unyielding. She withdrew herself from Lois and got up.
“I’m glad,” she said, her voice trembling a little. “I hope you’ll be very happy.”
Lois looked at her with anxious eyes.
“But this doesn’t make any difference to us,” she said. “We can be the same friends as before — more than we were. You’ll like Tubby,’ Margery darling, when you know him. Well have a great time — we three.”
“No,” said Margery, “this doesn’t make any difference. That’s quite true. The difference was made before.”
“What do you mean?” asked Lois, standing up, her agitation strangely returning.
“You’ve been different,” said Margery. “Since we came back from France, you’ve been changing all the time. It seemed right out there, your ordering everybody about I admired it You were fine. But now in London — I’ve no right to say so. But you’re trying to do all the things men do; and it’s — it’s — beastly, somehow. It doesn’t suit you. It isn’t natural. I don’t believe the men like it either, or at any rate not the nice men. I suppose it’s silly, but I don’t admire you any more, and if I don’t admire you, I can’t love you.” With that last word she was gone, and Lois knew quite well that she would never come back again.
Lois stayed in the “attic” that morning in an odd confusion of mind. Margery was jealous, of course; that was what had made her say those things. Her discovery of her love for Grenfell filled her with joy, so that she could scarcely realise Margery; moreover the uncertainty that had been troubling her for months was over, but behind these feelings was a curious new sense of loss, a sense that she refused to face. Life without Margery — what would it be? But she turned from that and, with joyful anticipation, thought of her new career.
She decided at once to dismiss Margery from her thoughts — not only partially, but altogether, so that no fragment of her should be left. That was her only way to be comfortable. She had on earlier occasions been forced to dismiss people thus absolutely; she had not found it difficult, and she had enjoyed in the doing of it a certain sense that she was finishing them, and that they would be sorry now for what they had done. But with Margery she saw that that would be difficult. Margery had been with her so long, had given her so much praise and encouragement, was associated in so many ways with so many places. She would return again and again, an obstinate ghost, slipping into scenes and thoughts where she should not be. Lois discovered herself watching the post, listening to the telephone, her heart beating at the sudden opening and shutting of a door... but Margery did not return.
She centred herself then absolutely around young Grenfell. She demanded of him twice what she had demanded before because Margery was gone. There was something feverish now in her possession of him. She was not contented and easy as she had been, but must have him absolutely. She was anxious that he should propose to her soon and end this period of doubt and discomfort. She knew, of course, that he would propose — it was merely a question of time — but there was something old-fashioned about him: a sort of naivete which, hindered him perhaps from coming forward too quickly.
She was not alone with him very much, because she thought it was good for him to see how other men admired her. She gathered around her more than before the men with whom she might be on thoroughly equal terms, as though in defiance of Margery’s final taunt to her. It was as though she said to that perpetually interfering ghost: “Well, if you will come back and remind me, you shall see that you were wrong in what you said. Men do like me for the very things of which you disapproved... and they shall like me more and more.”
She thought Grenfell understood that it was because of him that Margery had gone.
“She was jealous of you,” she said, laughing. “I’m sure I don’t know why she should have been.... You never liked one another, did you? Poor Margery! She’s old-fashioned. She ought to have lived fifty years ago.”
She was surprised when he said, “Did she dislike me? Of course we used to fight, but I didn’t think it meant anything; I didn’t dislike her. I’m so sorry you’ve quarrelled.”
He seemed really concerned about it. One day he amazed her by saying that he’d seen Margery. They had met somewhere and had a talk. Lois’s heart leapt “I’m ready to forgive her,” she said, “for what she did. But of course things can never be quite the same again.”
“Oh, she won’t come back!” Grenfell said. “I begged her, but she said, ‘No.’ You weren’t as you used to be.”
At this Lois felt an unhappiness that surprised her by its vehemence. Then she put that away and was angry. “I don’t want her back,” she cried. “If she came and begged me I wouldn’t have her.”
But she felt that Grenfell had not reported truly. He was jealous of Margery, and did not want her to return. He seemed now at times to be a little restive under her domination; that only made her more dominating. She had scenes with him, all of them worked up by her. She arranged them because he was so sweet to her when they were reconciled. He was truly in despair if she were unhappy, and would do anything to make her comfortable again. Once they were engaged, she told herself, she would have no more scenes. She would be sure of him then. She was in a strange state of excitement and uncertainty; but then, these were uncertain and exciting times. No one seemed to know quite where they were, with strikes and dances and all the “classes” upside down. Although Lois believed that women should be just as men she resented it when Fanny, the portress, was rude to her. She had got into the way of giving Fanny little things to do; sending her messages, asking her to stamp letters, to wrap up parcels. Fanny was so willing that she would do anything for anybody; but the day came when Fanny frankly told her that she had not the time to carry messages. Her place was in the hall. She was very sorry.... Lois was indignant What was the girl there for? She appealed to Grenfell. But he, in the charming, hesitating, courteous way that he had, was inclined to agree with Fanny. After all, the girl had her work to do. She had to be in her place. At this little sign of rebellion Lois redoubled her efforts.
He must propose to her soon. She wished that he were not quite so diffident She found here that this masculinity of hers hindered a little the opportunities of courtship. If you behaved just like a man, swore like a man, drank like a man, discussed any moral question like a man, scenes with sentiment and emotion were difficult. When you told a man a hundred times a day that you wanted him to treat you as he would a pal, it was perhaps irrational of you to expect him to kiss you. Men did not kiss men, nor did they bother to explain if they were rude or casual.
She had, however, a terrible shock one night when Conrad Hawke, a man whom she never li
ked, seeing her back to the “attic” after the theatre, tried to kiss her. She smacked his face. He was deeply indignant. “Why, you’ve been asking for it!” he cried. This horrified her, and she decided that Grenfell must propose to her immediately. This was the more necessary, because during the last week or two he had been less often to see her — and had been less at his ease with her.... She decided that he wanted to propose but had not the courage.
She planned then that on a certain evening the event should take place. There was to be a great boxing match at Olympia. Beckett was to fight Goddard for the heavyweight championship of Great Britain. She had never seen a boxing match. Grenfell should take her to this one.
When she suggested it he hesitated.
“I’d love us to go together, of course,” he said. “All the same, I don’t think I approve of women going to boxing matches.”
“My dear ‘Tubby,’” she cried; “what age do you think you’re living in?”
“Well, I don’t know,” he said, looking at her doubtfully.
“If that isn’t too absurd!” she cried. “Has there been a war or has there not? And have I been in France doing every kind of dirty work or not? Really, ‘Tubby,’ you might be Mother.”
His chubby face coloured. His eyes were full of perplexity.
“Oh, of course, if you want to go; I’ll take you,” he said. “All the same, I’d rather not.”
She insisted. The tickets were taken. She was determined that that night he should propose to her.
The great evening had arrived, and they had a little dinner at the Carlton Grill. Lois was wearing a dress of the very latest fashion — that is, a dress that showed all her back, that was cut very low in front, and that left her arms and shoulders quite bare. She seemed, as she sat at the table, to have almost nothing on at all. This, unfortunately, did not suit her. Her figure was magnificent, but the rough life in France had helped neither her skin nor her complexion. The upper part of her chest and her neck were sunburnt. Her arms were brown. She had taken much trouble with her hair, but it would not obey her now as it had done in the old days.