The 9th Judgment

by James Patterson

  The door opened again, this time no knock, and Tony Peyser, Dowling’s confident, thousand-bucks-an-hour attorney, came through the door.

  “Don’t say anything, Marc. What’s the charge?” the lawyer asked me.

  I was filled with a heady blend of fury and elation. Dowling’s statement was on tape, and the prosecution would use it to tear him apart.

  I didn’t even look at the lawyer. I said, “Stand up, Mr. Dowling. You’re under arrest for the murder of Casey Dowling. You have the right to remain silent…”

  Conklin cuffed Dowling as I finished reading him his rights. Dowling was still protesting, “It was self-defense!”

  “Who knows? Maybe the jury will believe you,” I said, looking into a face that had struck love into the hearts of untold thousands of women. “But you know what I think? You’re a bad actor. You really stink.”

  Chapter 109

  I DON’T KNOW when I’ve needed a drink more. Cindy met me downstairs at half past six, and I drove us to Susie’s in my Explorer. I was glad to have some time alone with Cindy, and I had a pretty juicy exclusive for her.

  The rain was starting to come down pretty hard, the customary evening gale. As my wipers squeegeed the water off the glass, I told Cindy how the “bomb” dropped off at the Hall turned out to be four million in jewels.

  “I think Kitty returned the jewelry because she didn’t want that ‘murder during the commission of a robbery’ charge hanging over her head.”

  “What did her letter say exactly?” Cindy asked.

  “Cindy, you can have the part about Kitty, but we’re charging Dowling with murder in the second. That’s off the record, okay?”

  “Fine,” Cindy said. “I’ll get another source on Dowling in the morning. Meanwhile, this is incredible. Hello Kitty returned the goods.”

  I grinned at Cindy as I quoted Hello Kitty’s letter, then I parked as close as I could to Susie’s. We both got out of the car and, squealing like little girls, ran a block through the sharp blowing rain.

  Walking into Susie’s is pretty much a peak experience every time. We’ve been coming here for years, so the place is packed with memories. The aroma of Susie’s special spicy fish stew was in the air. The band was tuning up, and there was a mob of singles at the bar.

  I saw Yuki sitting on a stool, and Cindy and I edged through the crowd until I could tap Yuki’s shoulder. She turned and gave both me and Cindy hugs. Then she introduced us to the bartender. She shouted over the noise.

  “Lindsay, Cindy, meet Miles La Liberte. Miles, these are my friends Lindsay Boxer and Cindy Thomas.”

  I shook hands with Miles, and as we said our good-byes, Yuki leaned across the bar and kissed him on the lips.

  She kissed him!

  “I’ve been out of the loop for too long,” I said to Yuki as we passed the kitchen on the way to the back room. “What was that I just saw?”

  “Cute, isn’t he?”

  Yuki laughed and took menus from Lorraine, and the three of us slid into the booth. I held open the seat next to me for Claire.

  “Darned cute,” I said. “And how long has this been going on?”

  “A few weeks.”

  “So is this… serious?”

  “Yeah,” she said, blushing and grinning at the same time.

  “Wow,” Cindy said. “You kept that a secret?”

  “Good for you, Yuki. A new case and a new boyfriend. A pitcher of brew, please,” I said to Lorraine. “Four glasses.”

  “I have an announcement, too,” Cindy said, clasping her hands, leaning across the table, practically falling into my lap. “Rich and I are living together.”

  “Whoa. That’s fantastic,” I said-and I felt it. A hundred percent. “He didn’t tell me.”

  “I wanted to be the one to tell you,” she said.

  The beer came along with a bowl of plantain chips, and Cindy talked about closet space and how the bed was too soft for Rich, and I thought about how long it had been-if ever-since all of us were happy at the same time. I wished that Claire was here to enjoy this.

  I turned, looked over my shoulder, and saw her barreling down the narrow passageway toward our booth.

  The look on her face could be described only as an eclipse of the sun. A thunderstorm was coming in.

  Chapter 110

  CLAIRE DIDN’T EVEN say hello.

  She slid into the booth, poured a glass of beer, and said, “Sorry I’m late. I was on the medical examiner database, still trying to break the logjam in this Lipstick Psycho disaster. Edmund says I should take the pictures of those dead babies down from the board in my office, but I want to keep them up until that devil is in custody.”

  “Did you find anything?” I asked.

  “I can’t find a pattern that matches anything in any database but ours. No other mother-child shootings. No lipstick messages. The stippling pattern is unique. What is his motivation, his trigger, his problem? I don’t have a clue. Cindy, could you pass the chips?”

  “He says he’s doing it for the money,” Cindy said.

  Claire nodded, then put her hand up, signaling that she still had the floor. She snacked and sipped, then picked up her thought.

  “Okay. It’s unusual, isn’t it, Linds? A psycho motivated by money? But anyway let’s consider that message Gordon wrote on the windshield of his car: ‘Now I want five million. Don’t screw it up again.’ What’s happening with that?” Claire asked me.

  “The FBI has the car, and it’s their case. I’m on call, but Benbow is in charge.”

  Cindy said, “What would happen if we came up with something? What if the Chronicle responds to that windshield message with an open letter to the killer, like we did before?”

  “Be specific. What are you thinking?” Yuki asked.

  “Say Henry Tyler writes the letter. He says, ‘We’ve got the five million and want to set up a drop.’ And he challenges the killer, kind of a ‘back at ya,’ and says, ‘Don’t screw it up again.’”

  “And then what?” Yuki asked Cindy. “Another trap? How would it end any differently?”

  I hoped for a trap that wouldn’t involve me. I didn’t know if I could do a repeat performance of that horrific day with the cell phone hanging around my neck, never knowing if or when Gordon would take the money and pop me.

  But I had to admit what was demonstrably true.

  I said, “You’re saying that if the FBI doesn’t do something soon, he’s going to kill more people to make his point.”

  “More mothers and kids,” Cindy said.

  “Yep, that’s what I’m thinking,” Claire agreed. “I have an interesting idea, different from the last time. I think it could work.”

  Chapter 111

  IT WAS MY third consecutive night in a surveillance van with Conklin and Jacobi. The vehicle was airless and soundproofed and connected wirelessly to two female undercover operatives near Nordstrom in the San Francisco Centre-they were pushing strollers with baby-sized dolls inside. I was listening to my designated decoy, Agent Heather Thomson, who was humming “Can’t Touch Me,” and Conklin was tracking Connie Cacase, an innocent-looking, street-talking twenty-year-old rookie from Vice.

  There were seven other vans filled with cops from three divisions and with FBI agents, each vehicle following and tracking decoys with strollers in malls all around the city.

  While the media were sounding the alarm nonstop on the Lipstick Killer, the mayor, the SFPD, and the FBI had declined to publish a message to Peter Gordon. And he had made no contact either.

  Was Gordon angry? Stressed? Biding his time? Where was he?

  If he was true to his pattern, he was overdue for a kill.

  Our van was parked on Sutter, within striking distance of the Sutter-Stockton Garage, a block from Nordstom and two blocks from the Macy’s at Union Square.

  Jacobi’s headset was tuned to SFPD Dispatch, and he had an open mic to Special Agent Benbow, who was parked two blocks away at a mobile command center.

&nbs
p; Claire’s plan made sense, but it was far from foolproof. We were all set to pounce but had no one to pounce on. Jacobi was checking in with Benbow when I heard shots through my headset. Heather stopped humming.

  “Heather!” I called into my mic. “Speak to me!”

  “Was that gunfire?” she asked.

  “Can you see anything?”

  “I’m on Stockton. I think the shots came from the garage.”

  I shouted to Jacobi and Conklin, “Gunfire! Agent Thomson is fine. Richie, do you have Connie? Is she okay?”

  “Connie’s good.”

  “I don’t know what the hell happened, but something bad. Stay tuned,” I said to Jacobi.

  I struggled into my vest, made for the back of the van, swung the doors open, and exited at the rear. Conklin was right with me.

  Had Peter Gordon surfaced?

  If so, what had he done?

  Chapter 112

  PETE GORDON HAD stalked the woman through the store, watching her cover her kiddo with a blanket up to its chin before she stepped out with the stroller into the cool of the night.

  His target was no beauty queen, but she had some mesmerizing tail action, a nice jiggle and sway. Pete gave her a name, Wilma Flintstone, which was perfect. Dotty little dress, hair twisted up, and Pebbles in the stroller. Wilma placed her handbag in the baby carriage and stepped off the curb, heading for the garage at Sutter and Stockton.

  Pete knew that garage. It was huge, tons of indoor parking, several stories with an open top floor, visible to the high-rises all around. He was maintaining a steady ten-foot distance between Wilma and himself, keeping his eye on a cluster of security guards on the corner, when a family of four jackasses got behind Wilma and consumed his safety zone.

  Pete hung back. He lowered the bill of his cap and, following his target into the garage, kept to the narrow footpath that skirted the ramp. The family blocking his sight line peeled off-and Pete picked up the pace, searching the rows of parked cars for Wilma in the dotty dress.

  There were pedestrians all around, the coughs of engines starting up, the squeal of rubber as vehicles cruised down the incline. Pete was starting to worry that he’d lost her when her dress jumped out at him. She was shoving the stroller into the elevator.

  The doors closed behind her and the lights above winked upward, then paused on three. Pete moved quickly to the stairs, loping up two flights, not even breathing hard as he reached the third floor.

  Drivers browsed the aisles for empty parking spots, but there was no foot traffic around him. Pete brushed his hand across the gun tucked in his waistband, rounded a stanchion, and got a good straight-on look at Wilma.

  And she saw him.

  Wilma’s face radiated alarm. She stared, bug-eyed, for a long moment, then wrenched the stroller around and ran toward her car, wheels making a frantic whick-whick sound.

  “Miss,” Pete called out. “Could you hang on a minute?”

  Wilma shouted over her shoulder, “Stay away from me. Stay away.”

  Wilma had made him, but there was nowhere for her to go, handicapped as she was by her kiddo.

  “Lady, you’ve got it wrong. My cell phone died. Look.”

  Her back was up against her VW Passat, one hand on the stroller’s handlebars, mouth hanging open as she looked everywhere for help. The kiddo let out a scream, and Wilma reached into the stroller, and when she straightened up, Pete saw a.22 pointing at him.

  He pulled his gun, but it snagged on his shirt. The muzzle was coming up when he heard the shot and felt the punch to his right shoulder. His gun jumped out of his hand and clattered to the concrete floor.

  He yelled, “Stupid bitch!” and dove for the weapon. A slug pinged into the floor an inch from his nose. He rolled onto his back with his gun in his left hand.

  “Don’t move, Wilma,” he said, taking aim. But his vision was blurring and lights swooped around him. He squeezed off a few rounds, but he didn’t drop her. Wilma was firing again.

  She kept firing.

  Chapter 113

  I WAS RUNNING up Sutter, Jacobi shouting into the cell phone at my ear, “It’s not one of ours!”

  “Say again.”

  “None of our people are involved. We got a nine one one call. Shots fired in the Sutter-Stockton Garage. Third floor.”

  I called ahead to Conklin over the shrill wail of sirens. We were yards from the garage and then we were inside, our feet striking metal treads as we bounded up the stairs with weapons drawn.

  We cleared the doorway to the third floor, and I heard a baby screaming. I ran toward that sound. A woman in her twenties was frozen in place, standing only yards from a man lying spread-eagled, faceup on the floor. She was holding a gun.

  I approached the woman slowly, leading with my badge, and said, “I’m Sergeant Boxer. It’s okay now. Please hand me your gun.”

  “It’s him, isn’t it?” she said, still transfixed, her baby screaming behind her. “The coroner said to carry a gun, and I did it. It’s him, isn’t it? It’s the killer, isn’t it?”

  I had to holster my weapon, shake the shooter’s wrist, and pry up her fingers until I’d secured her.22. Yards away, Conklin kicked a gun out of the limp hand of the man on the floor.

  I joined Conklin and put my fingers on the downed man’s carotid artery.

  “Rich, I’ve got a pulse.”

  Conklin called for an ambulance, and cruisers screamed up the ramp. I couldn’t look away from Peter Gordon’s face.

  This was the monster who’d executed nine people, five of them children, a killer who’d tormented his family and held an entire city hostage.

  His blood was pumping onto the concrete floor.

  I didn’t want to lose him. I wanted to see him in an orange jumpsuit, shackled to the defense table. I wanted to hear his fucked-up view of the world. I wanted him to pay with nine consecutive life sentences, one for each of the people he’d killed. I wanted him to pay.

  I pressed my hand to the well of blood pumping from his femoral artery. I nearly jumped when Gordon opened sleepy eyes and turned them on me, saying, “Sweet… meat. I think… I’m shot.”

  I leaned so close to his face, I could almost feel a breeze as he opened and closed his eyes.

  I said, “Why’d you kill them, you son of a bitch?”

  He smiled and said, “Why not?” Then he exhaled a ragged breath and died.

  Epilogue. 911

  Chapter 114

  IT WAS SEPTEMBER 25, and Joe and I were having friends over to toast one another and the good days ahead.

  A ham was in the oven, baking under a peppery mango glaze. Martha was begging for a taste and got a Milk-Bone instead. I was wearing a kimono and an avocado mask as I peeled the potatoes and Joe sliced apples for the cobbler. The 49ers were playing the Cowboys, the cheers of the crowd coming over the TV, when Joe’s cell phone rang.

  I said to him, “Don’t answer that, honey.”

  I wasn’t joking, but he grinned at me and picked up the phone.

  I hadn’t had a call in weeks that hadn’t sent me down a tunnel of horror, and frankly I was so strung out from my job, I couldn’t take even a lightbulb burning out. Or a broken fingernail. Or even a dip in the temperature. I just couldn’t take it anymore.

  Joe brought the phone into the living room, and I rinsed the potatoes and put them on to boil. I was in the bathroom washing avocado off my face when Joe said my name. I shut off the water and patted my eyes with a fluffy towel, and when I turned, I saw Joe looking at me, gray-faced and grim.

  “There’s a plane full of people on the tarmac at Dulles International,” he said. “There’s a guy on board, used to be an informant of mine years back. He smuggled C-four in with his hand luggage. He’s threatening to blow up the plane.”

  “Oh my God. And the Feds want you to advise them?”

  “Not exactly. The guy with the C-four, Waleed Mohammad, wants to talk to me and only me.”

  Joe had been deputy director of Homeland S
ecurity when we met and had become a high-level security consultant when he moved here from DC-a consultant who worked from home.

  “So you need to call the guy,” I said. “Talk him down.”

  “I have to fly to Washington,” Joe said, walking to me, enfolding me in his arms. “A car’s picking me up. I have to go right now.”

  It felt like my heart stopped in its tracks.

  It was stupid, but I just wanted to bawl in Joe’s arms and tell him he couldn’t go, and if he did, I’d keep crying until he came back.

  “Do what you have to do,” I said.

  Chapter 115

  I WAS DRESSED by the time Yuki and Miles arrived. Miles, that too-cute-for-words bartender, presented me with a bottle of wine, telling me about its special qualities. I barely heard him, but I’m pretty sure I thanked him. Yuki asked where Joe was, and I told her with my voice catching, my eyes watering up, that he had rushed off to Washington.

  I turned away so she wouldn’t have to endure my disgraceful wet-eyed funk. So she followed me into the kitchen and helped me plate the olives and cheese. “What’s going on, Lindsay?” she asked me.

  “Don’t look at me. It’s just that everything finally got to me. You know. Everything.”

  “When’s Joe coming back?”

  I shrugged and the doorbell rang, Martha yelping happily when I opened it to Edmund and Claire. Claire surrounded me in a big hug and smothered me with flowers.

  Edmund said, “Lindsay, you look gorgeous in red. Gorgeous in any way, but red’s definitely your color.”

  Edmund joined Miles in front of the TV, the two of them having a football bonding moment as Claire went into the kitchen and poked around for a vase.