I gulped and took another deep breath. “H-have you ever done this before?”
He looked down for a moment before his eyes met mine and he said, “Yes I have, but it’s been with women that have had anal sex and were experienced. I’ve never done this with someone that hasn’t done it before. If you don’t want to try this you don’t have to, but if you do this little plug will help you get a feel for what it will be like with me when the time comes.”
My cheeks felt hot and I reached out and took the little plug into my hand. “So, obvious question here, but how will you fit? You are a pretty big guy,” I paused and he smiled, “and most of the time you have to make me come in the middle of sex just for you to fit right. Won’t that hurt?”
He tucked my hair behind my ear and said, “I won’t lie to you…it will probably hurt and burn when I first go in, but that’s what the plug and the lubricant will help with. I can use my fingers to loosen you up and then when I slide the plug in it will help stretch you even further. Then, if you like the feel and you want to continue, we can try full anal sex. Once you get past the burn and it’s all the way in, it will be the most intense pleasure you’ve ever felt.” I shifted even more…just talking about this was making me so wet I was about to explode. “We don’t have to do anything at all, Evie, and the decision is yours. If you don’t want to, then the plug and the lube are gone and all talk of this is over and won’t be brought up again. But, if you want to try, we will start slow and ease into it. I promise I will do everything to make this as easy and pleasurable for you as possible.”
I knew beyond the shadow of a doubt that Ryder would never, ever hurt me and he was always trying to make sex incredible for me (in which he was always successful). I trusted him completely and I wanted to make him as happy as he’d made me. I bit my lip shyly and said, “I want to try.”
He raised his eyebrows. “Really? You’re sure?”
I nodded and stood up. Unzipping my jeans, I pulled them down along with my panties until I stood naked in front of him and said, “I’m sure. I’m already yours, Ryder, and I want to be in every single way. I trust you with my life and I want to try this with you.”
A feral growl escaped his lips and he pulled off his shirt. He stood in front of me and shrugged out of his pants and soon we were both naked and panting, his strong length bobbing up and down between us. He pulled me to him and I gasped at the feel of our warm bodies pressed against each other. He moved me back to the bed and I crawled backwards toward the middle, lying on my back and my legs falling apart.
He wasted no time in getting things going and he touched me around my wet folds before quickly moving his mouth down and pressing his tongue hard onto my clit. “Mmm, I’ll never get tired of the way you taste. Best I’ve ever had,” he moaned between licks.
I twisted the blanket on the bed in my fists and arched my back. I cried out as his sinful tongue kept moving faster and faster until I was on the verge of collapse. “Oh God…”
He slid two fingers into me and started to move them around. “Let go, baby. Come for me,” he said, and his words were my undoing. I exploded in a strong orgasm and he moaned loudly and lapped up every bit that erupted from me. “So responsive to me. We’re off to a good start, baby,” he said, his breath against my sensitive skin giving me goose bumps. I started to grab for him, unsure of what I wanted him to do next, but he said, “Turn over.”
My legs felt like jelly as I rolled my satisfied body over until I was lying on my stomach. I felt his hard, hot body cover mine and just as I turned my head I felt his lips kissing their way from the base of my spine all the way up until he reached my lips. He thrust his tongue into my mouth and I groaned as his body rubbed against mine, his hard cock nestling right above my ass. “Are you still sure you want to try this with me?” he asked, carnal desire in his voice.
“I’m sure Ryder,” I breathed, wiggling my hips into his body.
He moved off me for a moment and I heard him say softly, “Lift your hips.”
I did as he asked and raised my hips into the air, keeping my head down on the bed. His hands found my ass and he massaged my cheeks sensually for a few moments. “I love you so much, baby,” he said to me. He leaned down and I could feel his breath on the small of my back. “It means the world to me that you trust me so completely.”
“I will always trust you, Ryder. I love you too,” I panted.
I waited with bated breath for him to make his first move and when I felt his hot wet tongue glide between my ass cheeks my eyes rolled back in my head and I moaned so loud I almost shouted.
“You like how this feels don’t you, gorgeous?” he murmured, continuing to lick up and down around my ass.
“Y-y-yes, oh god yes,” I moaned. I couldn’t believe how incredible it felt to be tasted in such a seemingly forbidden place. It was intoxicating.
“I’m going to try and stretch you with my finger. Are you ready?” he asked, his voice husky and full of want.
I nodded into the blanket. “Yes, Ryder, I’m ready. Please,” I begged as I clawed at the bed. He must have picked up the bottle of lubricant because I heard something squirt into his hand and something warm roll down around my ass. He massaged me for a few moments before I heard him say, “Here we go,” and as his strong rough finger started to enter me in a place no one had ever been my eyes shut tight as pleasure overtook any nervousness I had.
Chapter 5
Ryder
As my finger found its way into Everleigh’s perfect ass I felt her start to shake…she was already enjoying this and we’d barely begun. I wanted this so much with her…to claim another part of her that hadn’t ever been touched by anyone but me. When she agreed to try this with me I almost came off looking like a pussy and shed a tear. For her to trust me with something this huge meant everything to me.
My dick was so painfully hard feeling her responding to my touch that I was having a hard time not coming right then and there. My finger slid in and out of her with ease and when I was bold and added a second finger, the lubricant worked well and I had no problem helping her stretch more. “Oh my fucking God, Ryder!” she screamed out as I moved my fingers in a back and forth movement.
Once I had her good and stretched out, I said, “Okay, I’m going to insert the plug. You ready, baby?”
“Yes, yes, yes!” she yelled. I smiled to myself as I put more lubricant on the plug and as soon as I withdrew my fingers quickly and slowly eased the plug into her.
Everleigh went still for a moment before she cried out and leaned into my body. I thought she would collapse down on the bed but she shot up onto her knees and brought her arm back, wrapping it around my neck and pulling me into a hard and desperate kiss. She grinded her ass into my dick as I moved the plug gently in and out of her. “This feels good, doesn’t it?”
“God yes,” Everleigh cried out. “Please, Ryder, I want you. I want to try.”
“Not this time, baby. You need to be eased into this slowly and even after this you might be a little bit sore.”
She moved and shifted, obviously needing some kind of release from the pleasure. I moved around her so I was in front of her and I lay back on the bed, taking her with me and moving her on top of me. “Ryder, please,” she begged again. “I need…I need you.”
With my hard dick in my hand I guided her closer to me. “The pleasure is building, isn’t it, gorgeous?” I roamed my hand down and skimmed my fingers across her swollen clit and she gasped.
She nodded her head and bit her lip. “Yes, I…I can’t take it, I don’t know…I need you so fucking bad!” she screamed.
I smiled at her and guided her until the tip of my dick was resting right at her entrance. I sat up and looked at her in the eye. “Then I’m going to fuck you until you come, baby. Right before you let go for me I’m going to take the plug out and you will have the most amazing orgasm of your fucking life,” I growled. Her beautiful brown eyes went wild as I thrust my hips up and slammed my cock into
her searing heat.
She threw her head back and whimpered, “Yes!” as I moved her hips with mine. Everleigh was on the verge of another orgasm already and seeing her losing control for me like this had me on the edge of my sanity. Everleigh moved and grinded around on my dick as I continued to thrust in and out of her, my fingers gripping her curvaceous hips as if I were holding on for dear life. “Please, don’t stop, I’m almost there,” she cried out.
I was about gone myself so I reached around and without warning gently slid the plug out of her. At that moment she was lost and she screamed out as I felt her orgasm flood her entrance and roll down onto me. I had never felt her have such an intense orgasm and knowing it was because of something she trusted me to make her feel sent me over the edge and I came hard inside her.
She collapsed on top of me in a boneless heap as we both came down from our orgasmic highs. “Oh lord, Ryder, that was incredible,” she said, breathing heavily and trying to catch her breath.
“Hell yeah it was. You were so fucking sexy the way you responded to everything. It’s going to be mind blowing when we finally try the real thing,” I said.
She traced one of my tattoos on my chest and said, “Why didn’t you want to try that this time? I know you talked about starting slow but I really thought we would have at least tried it.”
“As much as I want to this was your first time doing anything like this. Like I said, you might be a little sore this time and you really have to ease into something like this, especially since my dick is a little bit on the bigger side,” I said, grinning with pride.
She giggled and sighed. “Well, thank you for being considerate of me. That really felt unbelievable.”
“I’m glad you loved it, Evie. There are so many more things I want to try with you.”
She propped her head on her elbow. “Oh yeah? Like what?”
“Well, there is the blindfold and the handcuffs. I’d love to watch you get yourself off with that massager too,” I said, and she blushed. “But one thing I would love to do with you is role play.”
“Role play?” she asked, cocking an eyebrow and smiling. “Like what, me in a French maid costume?”
I laughed. “No, not like that. Kind of along the lines of you are a vixen in a bar and I am a mysterious stranger that picks you up and takes you back to my place for a night of passion. That kind of thing.”
Everleigh laughed. “Well, I don’t know about that, rock star. That seems a little strange to me.”
I smiled at her. “Well I’m sure that what we just did might have seemed strange to you at some point too but you were willing to try and you ended up loving it.”
“True,” she said, nibbling on her bottom lip and smiling.
“Look, we can talk about that later. One thing at a time, gorgeous,” I said, wrapping my arms around her bare back and rolling us onto our sides. I kept my arms around her beautiful body and just held her against me as we both drifted off into a nap, our bodies completely relaxed and sated.
I woke a while later to the sound of Everleigh’s cell phone ringing. I felt her stirring as she moved to grab the phone that was resting on the nightstand. I threw my arm over my eyes as she answered her phone. “Hello?”
Groaning, I decided to go ahead and get up, knowing I should probably get dressed since Danni would be coming to the penthouse at some point. I picked up my phone and looked at the time. Everleigh and I had been asleep for nearly four hours. Just as I was putting my phone back down and readying myself to stand, I got a text message. It was from Jude.
Bringing Danni back now. Feel like hitting the gym with me and Beau?
I ran my hand through my hair and sighed. We all worked out to keep our bodies in shape but usually if Beau did it he was working through some of his past demons with his father or sexual frustration. Knowing that he had feelings for Danni and apparently neither one was about to budge, I knew that he was probably looking to somehow calm his libido that had been on standby since we left Muncie. I also knew that Everleigh was dying for some time with her friend so I decided to meet up with them and get in a good workout. I answered him back with,
Sounds good bro. I’ll meet you there in a bit.
As soon as I put my phone back down, I heard Everleigh hanging up hers as well. “Everything all right?” I asked her, standing up and stretching.
She looked at me and smiled before standing up and grabbing her panties off the floor. “Yeah, that was Danni,” she said, sliding into them before she grabbed her bra. “She’s on her way here.”
“I figured. Jude just texted me and asked if I wanted to hit the gym with him and Beau. He probably wants to work off some of that pent up sexual energy,” I said.
As Everleigh continued to get dressed, and shook her head and snorted out a laugh. “Probably. I know Danni misses him but she won’t admit to it. ‘It was just a week long thing,’” she said, mimicking Danni’s answer. “I wish those two would get it together. She thinks that he doesn’t want her as bad as we all say he does, but she doesn’t understand what he’s been like all this time without her.”
I slid into a pair of sweat pants and pulled a tank out of my dresser. “I know. He’s been a whiny bitch.”
Everleigh looked at me, her eyes narrowing slightly. “Ryder, don’t be mean.”
“Come on, he’s been a pain in the ass, admit it. Beau could have probably any girl he wanted to take Danni off his mind but he hasn’t been with one girl since we left Muncie. Why is that? Because he’s fallen for her and he doesn’t want to take his mind off of her.”
“I think you’re right, Ryder, but there is nothing we can do about it. They have to work it out on their own,” Everleigh said, pulling on her shirt.
“I know,” I sighed. “So, are you two going to be okay here while I’m gone at the gym?”
Everleigh rolled her big brown eyes in the way I loved so much and smiled. “We will be fine. It’s just going to be the two of us talking about you and Beau,” she laughed.
“I’ll bet. Well, if you girls do decide to leave, make sure you-”
“-take John with us. I know, I know,” she answered, walking to me and giving me a quick kiss on the lips. “Have fun on your little bromantic date at the gym.”
I chuckled and kissed the top of her head. “Thanks, and you have fun hanging with Danni talking about kissing boys and make up and pantyhose and shit,” I said, and she laughed out loud.
Just as we broke apart from our embrace there was a knock on the front door. Everleigh’s face lit up and she smiled brightly. “That’s probably Danni,” she said, and I laughed to myself as she happily took off down the hallway toward the front door.
I followed her down the hall and smiled as I saw her open the door and pull Danni into a hug. “Hey girl, I’m glad you’re here!” Everleigh said, pulling Danni into a hug.
“Me too, girl!”
“How was your afternoon out with the guys?” Everleigh asked her.
“Oh well, it was…you know,” Danni said, smiling politely and shuffling her feet. The way she was looking at Everleigh meant that it was time for some girl talk, so I took that at my cue to head out.
“Okay well I’m going to go meet the guys. You have fun with Danni,” I said, pulling Everleigh to me. I leaned down and kissed her lips, making sure to shamelessly slide my tongue past her lips.
“I will,” she answered breathlessly. I loved that I could still get that reaction from her from just one kiss.
“Make sure to let me know if you girls decide to head out, okay?” I asked.
Danni smiled at me. “We will, Dad,” she laughed.
I ruffled her hair with my hand. “Bye, smartass,” I said, and I kissed Everleigh one more time. “I’ll be back soon, gorgeous.”
“Take your time, rock star,” she said and I walked out the door with a wave.
About fifteen minutes later I arrived at the gym where Beau and Jude were already working out. I placed my bag in my locker and quickly f
ound Jude lifting weights and Beau lifting barbells next to him. “What’s up guys?” I asked, sitting at the weight machine next to Beau and getting started. “You been here long?”
“Not too long. Maybe twenty minutes or so,” Jude said, grunting as he kept a steady pace with the weight machine. My eyes drifted over to how much weight he was lifting…two hundred and fifty pounds. Fuck, I better remember to always stay on his good side. He could probably knock my ass out with one punch.
“So, did you both have a good time with Danni today?” I asked, starting my weights out at one hundred pounds.
Jude laughed. “Well, I had fun with her. Beau on the other hand…” he trailed off.
“Shut up, man,” he growled, keeping pace with the barbells.
“What happened?” I asked.
“Nothing,” Jude said, shaking his head. “Beau barely spoke to her and when he did he sounded like a fucking idiot.”
I took several deep breaths as I kept up my pace. “Beau, seriously, what the hell is up with you man? I know Danni’s not some random girl but we’ve all never seen you act like a pussy over a chick. What’s going on?”
Beau stopped lifting the barbells for a second and took a deep breath. “I’m not acting like a pussy. This is just the first time I’ve been with a chick longer than a day or so and I don’t know how to do the ‘after’ thing,” he said. “It’s kind of pissing me off.”
Jude and I exchanged looks and we both stopped lifting weights. “Danni’s a great girl, bro. Why does that piss you off?” I asked.
Breathing heavily, Beau said, “I don’t know. I mean, I like Danni a lot and I’ve definitely missed hanging with her but…”
Renegade (Bad Blooded Rebel Series) Page 5