by Joan Silber
“People will be dry there this fall,” he said. “Insha’Allah.”
On the way back to the hotel she was really in quite a wonderful frame of mind. As if she had just been on a great shopping spree. Which she had. She couldn’t wait to tell Emile, who always accused her (silently and otherwise) of being shallow.
Later she wondered if she had made a mistake. She’d come to New York to forget how much money she’d lost, and she had just managed to dole out another wad. She felt preposterous, an old puppet of comic twists. He had been dogged with her, in his nice-boy way, and then she had turned around and surprised him. Which she still knew how to do. She had known how to wait before she caught him off guard.
What an odd story she had to tell, when she got back to Paris: she’d come all this way to drop a bundle of money on poor people in South Asia. People she’d never met! She’d never done such a thing in her life. Never too late! She could tell the story in a way that didn’t make her look entirely foolish. Or she could keep it to herself.
Now she was a friend to lepers: she was getting used to the idea, she liked it. So this was the end to her time in New York, an ugly and interesting city. Une histoire qui finit bien. Rudy, that awkward boy, was probably being congratulated by the staff in his office. Maybe they were toasting her with little plastic cups. To Liliane! She hoped he was leading the toast. Despite the rudeness of his not having hugged her goodbye this time.
She wanted to tell Ahmed what she had done. He would have thought well of her for it, would have gotten that look of beaming pleasure on his face—he tended to applaud people who acted rashly out of their better natures. He liked nothing better than that, and would not have allowed anyone to see anything ridiculous in what she’d just done. And who would, who in the world? She had never in her life been someone people laughed at.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
For their good advice and great generosity, I want to thank Andrea Barrett, Myra Goldberg, Kathleen Hill, Margot Livesey, and Chuck Wachtel. I am grateful, as ever, to my agent, Geri Thoma, and to my new editor, Jill Bialosky. For their helpful conversation, a thank you to Elspeth Leacock and Claudia Leacock. Special thanks once again to Sharon Captan for her friendship.
The story “Fools” appeared previously in Northwest Review, “Two Opinions” and “Better” appeared in Epoch, and “Buying and Selling” appeared in Agni. “Two Opinions” is included in The PEN/O. Henry Prize Stories 2012. "Fools" is included in New America: Contemporary Literature for a Changing Society, ed. Holly Messitt and James Tolan (Autumn House, 2013).
Additional Praise for
FOOLS
“The linked characters in Joan Silber’s collection Fools . . . go from the fiercely principled (young anarchists in 1920s Greenwich Village) to the fervently hedonistic (a newly married hotelier’s son who can’t resist temptation). But it’s those who admit their ambivalence—such as the daughter of a conscientious objector whose life detours from the wifely domesticity she envisioned—who approach true dissidence.”
—Vogue
“Elegant. . . . Timely.”
—Village Voice
“A memorable meditation on work, religion, love, and the search for personal integrity.”
—Booklist, starred review
“Powerful and moving. . . . Recalls Jennifer Egan’s A Visit from the Goon Squad in its novelistic cohesion of multiple sprawling tales.”
—Library Journal, starred review
“Joan Silber’s stories are like compressed novels. They are interlocking tales that fill in the history of revolutionary politics in the twentieth century.”
—Edmund White
“Fools is astonishing for its range, for its sweeping sense of time and place, and most especially for its deep insight into the way small choices can circle out to shape lives, and even human history. This is a beautiful book and an important literary achievement.”
—Dan Chaon
“Joan Silber’s stories charm us. And amuse us. And engage us. And move us. And even enlighten us. Fools embraces us all.”
—Amy Bloom
“Joan Silber is one of the wisest, finest, most capacious observers of the human condition writing now. We should all be as heartbreakingly foolish and beautiful as the characters in this collection. Silber understands them inside out, and brings them close to us, as no one else can.”
—Stacey D’Erasmo
“Fools is a unique and fascinating collection that celebrates not so much a place or a family or a single life as it does an idea—anarchy—as it runs through three generations of loosely connected people. The collective vision this provokes is what makes the book intellectually satisfying; the separate lives it convincingly displays are what move the heart.”
—Antonya Nelson
“In Joan Silber’s dazzling new story collection, written in elegant prose and with clairvoyant wisdom, the loves and aspirations, both spiritual and material, of six very different people reaffirm in unexpected ways the fallibility and the essential sameness of our human condition.”
—Lily Tuck
“Fools is a wonderfully winning exploration of impetuousness in all of its appalling and appealing forms, and its deftly interconnected stories are devoted to those dreamers who act rashly out of their better natures, who never quit asking the world Can’t you do better than that?—a question certain to become increasingly urgent as this twenty-first century progresses.”
—Jim Shepard
“Fools is great fiction. Here are anarchists and pacifists, protesters in causes to do with freedom and equality, causes to which these self-aware men and women devote themselves—or not. It is impossible not to be enthralled.”
—Christine Schutt
“I loved Fools. The stories always surprised me, with the narratives unfolding as if in real time, and then turning unexpected in so many ways, twisting into stories that felt like remembered history, but with such added emotion that I thought about the characters for several days afterward as if they were here in my house.”
—Susan Straight
ALSO BY JOAN SILBER
FICTION
The Size of the World
Ideas of Heaven
Lucky Us
In My Other Life
In the City
Household Words
NONFICTION
The Art of Time in Fiction
FOOLS
Joan Silber
READING GROUP GUIDE
NOTE FROM THE AUTHOR
My last three books have been linked stories, and when I give readings, often somebody in the audience asks, “Do you plan all the stories in advance or do you just make them up as you go along?” When I hear myself say, “I just make them up,” I sound very carefree and irrepressibly inspired, which is unfortunately not true.
I start with a first story and then I keep digging for routes to investigate further what it’s about. In Fools, the first story came after a trip to India, a gorgeous and very disturbing place. One consoling thing for me was seeing that every city seemed to have a Gandhi museum—Gandhi being the great figure of visionary stubbornness. I pondered whether America had anyone like Gandhi, and I thought of Dorothy Day, famous Catholic radical, who began as a Village anarchist, and I set my story in her world of anarchists in the 1920s. Anarchists were considered “fools” for their dedication to ideas—and for the next stories, I started to think harder about how people live for ideas (and why we think money or love can let us live without them). In this form I’ve come up with, characters who are hateable in one story can be humans we’re allied with in another. This is very important to me.
DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
1. In what different ways are characters in the book fools? Does persisting with their folly make them wise? The author has said that when she was working on the book, she would tell people its title and then say, “But I mean fools in a good w
ay.” What does she mean by this?
2. Many of the stories take place over a long span of time, as characters progress, fall back, and go forward again. A short story doesn’t often cover many years. What techniques does Silber use to manage time? Which stories are most striking in their use of time? Why would Silber want to do this?
3. Fools contains six linked stories. Some of the links are clear right away and others are more subtle. Which were your favorite discovered connections? How is a book like this different from a novel? Why do you think the author arranged the stories the way she did? How does this book compare to other linked story collections you’ve read?
4. Does Silber make us feel sympathy for conventionally “unlikeable” characters? If so, how does she accomplish this?
5. The stories take place at different points in history—from the 1920s to now—and are set in different parts of the world—New York, Paris, even a little of India. How did this expansiveness affect you as a reader? Was your attention better or worse for it? Do the characters in different eras and places have different belief systems?
6. The characters all think about money. Some choose principle over money, some steal and betray, some are duped, and the book ends with a surprising act of generosity. Is money often used in plots? Does the author seem to have a particular view of it here? Is this theme linked to our era of financial uncertainty?
7. In “Two Opinions,” Louise’s mother tells her, “You think you can do without ideas but you can’t.” Louise is more interested in love at that time. Can love or money let a person live without ideas? Is it a common contemporary belief that they can?
8. Gandhi suggests that people are happiest when they can act on their beliefs, which is not always easy. Which characters in Fools live under illusions? Which characters betray their own beliefs or lie to others? What happens as a result? Which characters have the most integrity, and are they rewarded or punished?
9. Many of the characters have unconventional marriages or families: Vera doesn’t really want a legal marriage, Louise lives thousands of miles from her husband, and Gerard is long separated from his wife but deeply tied to her. Are these arrangements viewed favorably? How do these characters fare?
10. The stories all use different narrators, and incidents are sometimes seen from different angles. Norman, for instance, is viewed one way by Anthony and another in his own memoir. Why did the author choose to close with Liliane? Can an untrustworthy character be a trustworthy narrator?
SELECTED NORTON BOOKS WITH READING GROUP GUIDES AVAILABLE
For a complete list of Norton’s works with reading group guides, please go to www.wwnorton.com/books/reading-guides.
Diana Abu-Jaber Birds of Paradise
Diane Ackerman One Hundred Names for Love
Alice Albinia Leela’s Book
Andrea Barrett Ship Fever
Bonnie Jo Campbell Once Upon a River
Lan Samantha Chang Inheritance
Anne Cherian A Good Indian Wife
Amanda Coe What They Do in the Dark
Michael Cox The Meaning of Night
Suzanne Desrochers Bride of New France
Jared Diamond Guns, Germs, and Steel
Andre Dubus III Townie
John Dufresne Requiem, Mass.
Anne Enright The Forgotten Waltz
Jennifer Cody Epstein The Painter from Shanghai
Betty Friedan The Feminine Mystique
Stephen Greenblatt The Swerve
Lawrence Hill Someone Knows My Name
Ann Hood The Red Thread
Dara Horn All Other Nights
Pam Houston Contents May Have Shifted
Mette Jakobsen The Vanishing Act
N. M. Kelby White Truffles in Winter
Nicole Krauss The History of Love*
Scott Lasser Say Nice Things About Detroit
Don Lee The Collective*
Maaza Mengiste Beneath the Lion’s Gaze
Daniyal Mueenuddin In Other Rooms, Other Wonders
Liz Moore Heft
Jean Rhys Wide Sargasso Sea
Mary Roach Packing for Mars
Johanna Skibsrud The Sentimentalists
Jessica Shattuck Perfect Life
Joan Silber The Size of the World
Mary Helen Stefaniak The Cailiffs of Baghdad, Georgia
Manil Suri The Age of Shiva
Brady Udall The Lonely Polygamist
Barry Unsworth Sacred Hunger
Alexi Zentner Touch
Sign up for our newsletter and giveaways at bit.ly/wwnorton-reading-group-guides.
* Available only on the Norton Web site
Copyright
Copyright © 2013 by Joan Silber
All rights reserved
First published as a Norton paperback 2014
For information about permission to reproduce selections from this book, write to Permissions, W. W. Norton & Company, Inc., 500 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10110
For information about special discounts for bulk purchases, please contact W. W. Norton Special Sales at [email protected] or 800-233-4830
Book design by Brooke Koven
Production manager: Devon Zahn
The Library of Congress has cataloged the printed edition as follows:
Silber, Joan.
[Short stories. Selections]
Fools / Joan Silber. — First edition.
pages cm
ISBN 978-0-393-08870-0 (hardcover)
I. Title.
PS3569.I414F66 2013
813'.54—dc23
2013000342
ISBN 978-0-393-24087-0 (e-book)
ISBN 978-0-393-34889-7 pbk.
W. W. Norton & Company, Inc.
500 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10110
www.wwnorton.com
W. W. Norton & Company Ltd.
Castle House, 75/76 Wells Street, London W1T 3QT