by Donn, KL
Watching her finally look up at them, she nodded her head and walked over to Dane. He couldn’t believe that they had screwed up so monumentally, and so soon. Ty felt a piece of his heart leave with her, when they saw her step up onto the driver’s side running board and talk to Dane for a moment, before she gave him a kiss on the cheek. As she stepped down and started walking back towards them, he felt a huge weight lifted off his shoulder. Stopping to turn and wave at Dane while he pulled away, Keeley faced them again, just staring. Scrutinizing them like one would a bug under a microscope. When she started walking forward again, they both held their breath.
“I don’t know if I can forgive you yet, you hurt me. I loved you and you both hurt me so bad. You just assumed I was nothing more than a common criminal. That what I did was because I wanted to, and it wasn’t. I live with the guilt of having taken that money from those people every day, when they did nothing but try to help a little girl in need of a safe place.” Taking a breath she continued on, with tears in her eyes and a trembling lip. “Please believe that if I could, I would pay back every cent taken, but the fact remains that I don’t even know who I stole from. My Mom chose my mark and it was completely random.”
Stepping forward Nate grabbed her up in a hug, wrapping her arms around his neck and legs around his waist. Ty then walked up to her back and pressed against her. With Nate kissing her on the left side of her neck and Ty kissing her on the right, they apologized again and just held her for a few minutes before Nate let her go, and they walked over to the truck climbing in and heading home.
Chapter 13
After such an exhausting couple of days, all Keeley wanted to do was be left alone and curl up into a ball and sleep for about a week. She understood their anger to a point; she would have been shocked to learn that about someone, too, but the accusations stung. The fact that they didn’t even want to listen to what she had to say, and the way they both looked at her, it hurt a lot. She wasn’t lying when she said that it was easier to put it all behind her and forget about it, because if she thought about it too much the guilt overwhelmed her.
Before she was old enough to work, and even sometimes after, her parents used to make her steal and con people into believing she was homeless, so they’d give her money. It worked too, for the most part. There were times when they would offer her a place to stay, and sometimes she accepted, but if she did she knew she had to steal something valuable from them or her parents would retaliate by hitting her.
Her father used to have this really thick leather belt, and he would make her kneel on the floor and whip her bare back with it, until she bled. Thankfully, she doesn’t have scars from it. Probably because the lashes never went too deep into her skin. One night when she was around eleven, she had stolen the belt and hid it the neighbor’s garbage cans, about a block away. That only angered her father more, and she ended up with her first broken nose because of it. To this day she still doesn’t regret it, because she knew that eventually her father would have killed her.
Sitting on the window bench in her room, Keeley thought about what Dane had said to her on the bus. Their anger comes from the fact that they’re mad that they weren’t there to help you, not that you did it. Maybe it was true, maybe it wasn’t. She wanted to believe it was, but she’d been so hurt that they thought she was going to steal from them and their parents, it was hard to get past. It made her think about what they really thought about her. Did they think she was white trash? Because she was, she knew that, so how could they not?
All these questions running through her mind were giving her a migraine. Getting up she walked downstairs to see if they had any Advil. Hearing hushed voices in the kitchen, she stopped just outside of it and listened when she heard her name.
“I can’t believe we almost lost her, Nate. Keeley is so much more than what she thinks. She’s perfect and we nearly screwed everything up. Fuck!” Tyler nearly shouted. He thinks I’m perfect? She thought looking down at herself, not seeing it.
“I know man, we need to cool our heads though. Her father has to pay for what he’s done to her. Twenty years of abuse and uncertainty is unacceptable. He needs to know she’s going to have a better life, and that had he treated her with respect, he would have had one, too. The selfish prick,” Nathaniel said to his brother.
“How do we make her forgive us? To believe in us again? I never want to see that look on her face, it nearly killed me. She was so lost and I couldn’t do anything to make it better.”
“Don’t worry Ty, she’ll come around. We’re just going have to show her that we worship the ground she walks on, that she is not only beautiful on the outside but the inside as well.”
Hearing them talk about her like that soothed something inside; her anger lessened and her heart melted. Clearing her throat and walking in, she whispered a quick, “Hi”.
Turning around when they heard her, huge smiles spread across their faces and she lost her breath. They were both extremely handsome men that was true, but the happiness radiating from them both at seeing her, erased any lingering doubts about whether she could move past today or not.
“You ok, Butterfly? Do you need anything?” Nathaniel asked her eagerly. Looking to Tyler she saw the eagerness to help her reflected in his eyes, as well. Not knowing where she got the bravery from, she whispered out, “You”, before walking back up to their room in the hopes that they’d follow her, migraine completely forgotten.
Hearing their pounding feet on the stairs, she slowly started to strip off her shirt and shorts. She was enticingly taking off her thong, bent over slightly with her ass facing the door, when they walked in. Taking a peek over her shoulder, she saw them both frozen in the doorway, with their gazes riveted to her exposed ass and pussy. Giving a little wiggle to shake her thong the rest of the way down her legs and stepping out of it, she heard dual groans coming from them.
Walking up to the bed, Keeley bent over and slowly began to crawl to the top. Looking over her shoulder when she was half-way up, Nathaniel and Tyler were still in the same spot, so she smiled seductively and asked, “Coming?” That got them moving; stripping their clothes off as they came closer. Nathaniel stared at her with hooded eyes and a small smirk, and told her, “Don’t move from that spot, Butterfly.”
Seeing them strip was a huge turn-on in itself for her. Nathaniel with his wide shoulders and muscles so tense his veins were popping out. His chest was a work of art; such solid and defined pecs made her want to ride him, for the sole purpose of putting her hands on them to hold. Eyes scanning further down, her breath caught at just how large his cock was. She knew it had been big when they’d made love that first time, but seeing it with the lights on, he was magnificent. It reached his belly button, and was thicker than her wrist. She didn’t think she’d even be able to wrap her hand fully around it. “Like what you see, Butterfly?” he asked with a smirk covering his sexy full lips.
Nodding her head at him, her gaze swung in Tyler’s direction. He was smaller in musculature than Nathaniel, but not by much. His muscles were just as defined and no less sexy, but he was slightly less bulky than his older brother. His abs went down into a nice V that she had heard so many women talk about and lose their minds over, and now she understood the allure. When Tyler dropped his boxer briefs and his cock sprang forward, a shocked gasp left her lips at how long he was. It reached his belly button and had the slightest curve at the end. Chuckling at her shock, he said to Nathaniel, “I think she likes what she’s seeing, big bro.”
“Oh yeah, I think she is. You ready for us, Butterfly?” Nodding her head at them, she had one gnawing question to ask. “How big are those things? That can’t be normal?” When they threw their heads back in laughter, she didn’t think she’d seen a more beautiful sight. Fully erect and naked while laughing was a very good look on them both, Keeley thought.
“Don’t think I’ve ever measured, darlin’,” Tyler finally answered, still laughing a little.
As Nathaniel clim
bed on the bed in front of her, Tyler climbed on behind. Putting his hands on her ass, he lowered his head and buried his face in her pussy from behind and just inhaled, causing her to close her eyes and let out a small moan. Opening them again when she felt Nathaniel’s hand in her hair, pulling back so he could slam his lips down on hers, he fucked her mouth with his tongue. Not leaving any spot untouched. Tangling his tongue with hers, she couldn’t help but suck on it, causing him to moan and pull her hair harder. When he had her head pulled as far back as it could go, he left her mouth to stare down at her. “Fuck you’re gorgeous laid out like this for us,” Nathaniel expressed to her while he just watched her.
When Tyler made his presence known by diving into her pussy with his fingers, and sucking her clit in his mouth hard, she came instantly. Her entire being flew apart, stars burst behind her eyelids, and her body shook in the aftershock of it all.
“Fuckin’ beautiful!” Tyler told her, reverently placing a kiss on each of her ass cheeks. “You ready for me, baby doll?” He asked her.
Still not able to move her head because of Nathaniel’s hand in her hair, she couldn’t look at Tyler to say, “Yes, please”, just as he rubbed his cock head through her pussy lips making her moan deep in her throat. When he placed himself at her entrance, she thought he was going to just slam in, but he slid in slowly. She could feel the burn in her pussy, stretching to accommodate his large girth. The veins in his dick brushed against her walls, causing her body to shiver in pleasure. Closing her eyes she tried to concentrate on the feeling of his dick continuing its slow slide in, when Nathaniel pulled her hair slightly and told her, “Eyes on me, Keeley,” with a dark look to his stare.
Watching Nathaniel, she got lost in his eyes that had gone nearly black from pleasure. Realizing how turned on he was watching her get pleasured by his brother made her wetter, and when she heard Tyler’s whispered, “Shit”, she knew he felt it too. As she went to reach for Nathaniel’s cock he shook his head and said, “Uh-uh, this is all about you, Butterfly.” Smiling slightly at that, she pushed back on Tyler and squeezed her pussy muscles tight when he pushed back into her.
“Holy fuck, she’s squeezing me like a damn vice,” Tyler said in awe, pumping into her faster and harder with each thrust. Feeling his cock grow longer and harder, Keeley knew Tyler was going to cum soon so she arched her back, sticking her ass higher in the air and squeezed her pussy muscles tighter again. On one forceful thrust he hit her g-spot, making her scream out in rapture and cum instantly. Still trying to hold Nathaniel’s stare, her eyes rolled back and glazed over in pleasure, and tingles of awareness zipped all throughout her body, making every touch sensitized. When she was coming down from her high, Tyler grabbed her hips and slammed her back on his cock, as he thrust forward as hard as he could and came long and loud inside of her.
Feeling his cock hit her cervix, and the splashes of his semen on her walls, made her have flashes of smaller orgasms jerking through her body. “Fuck woman, you’re gonna be the death of me. Your pussy is fucking hot and tight, I just can’t last inside of you,” he whispered in her ear as he bent over her body. Feeling his cock’s slight jerks with his movements had her moaning in pleasure again, from her over sensitized pussy.
When he started to pull out of her, she expected to feel a gush of liquid with it. “Hell, her greedy little cunt ate up all my cum. No dripping or anything. Fucking stunning,” he said with his eyes riveted between her legs, watching to see if any liquid flowed out. When it didn’t, Tyler bent down and stuck his tongue in her pussy, then licked from her ass to her clit before giving it a light suck, making Keeley try and pull away because she was that sensitive.
Crawling back up over her he kissed her passionately; sticking his tongue in her mouth so she could taste their combined juices, and it was heavenly. Musky, sweet, yet slightly tangy. Turning her head because she was out of breath she said, “Wow that was… wow.”
“Yeah, baby doll, it was,” he agreed.
Pushing Tyler off of her, Nathaniel grabbed her by the hair again and slowly and gently dragged her up to her knees so her chest was rubbing against his. “I think you like my hair, Nathaniel.” She smiled.
“You know it, Butterfly. So soft wrapped around my hands while you’re riding my cock, I think I can get used to that.” He smiled at her shocked expression.
Sitting back on his heels, Nathaniel used his other hand to grab her hip and help her onto his lap. Once she was sitting on his thighs, he put his hand in the small of her back, pulled her forward, and kissed her deeply. Sweeping his tongue along her lips once she opened to him, he bit her bottom one and pulled on it, causing a slight amount of pain to blend with her pleasure. Moaning, Keeley held onto Nathaniel’s biceps and squeezed, digging her nails into him.
“Please Nathaniel, please, fuck me. I need you so bad,” she whimpered against his lips.
“Oh Butterfly, you beg so pretty, you got me. Lift up gorgeous,” he instructed her while lining up his large cock to her pussy. Moaning and whimpering as she slid down, her head fell back with Nathaniel’s hand still buried in her dark locks, and gently she started to ride him. Feeling stuffed to the brim with his huge cock, she couldn’t stop the little sounds coming from her. She felt every ridge and bump on him, every pulse in his veins, the beat of his heart. Going deeper on every stroke, she picked up pace, only pausing when she felt Tyler’s hands on her ass and him whispering in her ear, “Do you want us both, darlin’?”
Responding before she could think it through, “Yes, please Tyler.” She was startled when she felt a cool gel on her rose bud. As he started pushing a finger inside her she stopped moving, dropped her head on Nathaniel’s chest and whimpered out, “Oh Tyler, that feels so weird.”
“A good weird I hope?” He asked her.
Nodding her head and waiting for him to continue, Keeley was surprised at how good it felt. How much more she wanted. When he inserted another finger, she tensed up and whimpered at the burn it caused. Once he started moving his fingers in and out and scissoring them around to stretch her, the pleasure soon followed. Lifting her head up she started kissing Nathaniel again, as Tyler slipped his fingers out and put his cock head to her opening, starting to push in. Pulling from Nathaniel’s mouth, she looked over at Tyler and smiled. “More please.” Even though there was a slight burn, she knew the pleasure would be insurmountable. Bearing down on him while he pushed in a little more after each pass, she moaned out loud once and he was fully seated, and she could feel his pelvis against her ass cheeks.
Testing the sensations, she squeezed her ass and pussy muscles and was shocked to hear them both curse and moan at the tightness. “Oh fuck! She’s so fucking tight!” Tyler growled before biting her neck, causing her to stop squeezing and gasp. Grabbing her hands behind her back, Tyler started rocking into her as Nathaniel pulled out. Fucking her in perfect symphony, they kept a slow but steady and deep pace until she was a massive mess of need and want. Feeling her fluids leaking out of her in copious amounts, Keeley needed more. She was at a precipice where almost anything would send her over the edge.
Sensing her need Nathaniel pulled her hair back exposing her slender throat, she smiled when he wrapped his other hand around it and they started fucking her harder. The harder they thrust the tighter Nathaniel squeezed. Having her air flow constricted set her body on fire, having them pound her ass and pussy harder sent her into spasms of pure delight. “Oh, fuck!” She croaked out with the little breath she had. “Please… Harder, Nathaniel,” she begged, not even sure what she was begging for, them to fuck her faster and harder, or for him to squeeze tighter?
“Say it Butterfly, tell me exactly what you want,” he whispered in her ear, before biting the lobe and giving a light tug, causing her to spasm around their cocks. Hearing them both groan was music to her ears.
“More… Everything… I just need harder, please.” She had no shame in begging. When they started pumping into her faster and harder at the same time, her body e
xploded and as she was about to scream Nathaniel squeezed her throat tighter, making her eyes roll to the back of her head. Tyler let go of her hands and she immediately grabbed onto Nathaniel’s forearm, squeezing as tight as he was.
Feeling Tyler cum in her ass, the heat from his semen had her body melting against him, as he groaned and bit her neck again. While she was leaning against him, Nathaniel started fucking her harder and removed his hand from her throat for just a second, so her body came alive again until Tyler grabbed it from behind and squeezed just a little. When she was about to orgasm again, Tyler squeezed her throat so tight he cut off all her air, making her cum harder than she ever had. Closing her eyes, stars burst, her body buzzed, blood rushed so fast through her veins it was all she could hear. Shivers wracked her body from toes to hair. Every touch was sensitized.
When he slowly let go of her feeling started to return to her limbs, and she was out of breath. With a whispered, “I love you”, to them, she collapsed in a heap of pleasure and passed out.
*******
Staring down at a passed out and completely unaware Keeley, she blew his mind. Nate said those words over and over again in his head. I love you. Unable to help the goofy grin on his face, he looked up to see an expression of awe on Ty’s. “She’s pretty fucking amazing, isn’t she?” Nate whispered to him, not wanting to wake her up.
“Yeah man, she sure is.”
When she rolled over onto her back between them, Nate saw their handprints on her throat and felt an answering twitch in his groin. “Fuck, that’s sexy as hell.” He placed his hand on her collarbone and rubbed his thumb gently along the base of her throat, completely turned on. Seeing their mark on her did something to him. It woke a primal urge in him to claim her as his. It was so intense he wanted to wake her up and love her body again, but knew she needed some rest.