by Val McDermid
At the bottom of the steps, he stood and stared at the pathetic creature pressing herself against the cold stone wall as if she expected to be able to push her way through it and so escape him. ‘God, you’re disgusting,’ he said contemptuously, taking in her matted hair, foul wounds and the dirt she’d gathered bumping into things in the dark.
He’d left her boxes of breakfast cereal and she had water from the tap on the rising main. There was no excuse for her to be in this state; she could have made an effort to clean herself up instead of sitting on the mattress in her own filth, he thought. The leg irons allowed her enough freedom of movement for that, and the pain from her arm hadn’t been enough to stop her from eating, judging by the open packets lying around her. He was glad he’d opted for a plastic-covered mattress so he could hose off her disgusting presence when he’d finished with her.
‘Look at yourself,’ he sneered, swaggering across the room towards her, unbuttoning his jacket and tossing it over a chair that was well out of her reach. ‘Why should I want anything to do with a mess like you?’
The whimpering noise that came from Donna’s bruised lips was wordless. With her undamaged hand, she grabbed at the blanket in a poignant attempt to cover her nakedness. In one swift step, Jacko was towering over her, yanking the rough woollen cover away from her. With his prosthetic arm, he smashed her across the face and she fell back on the mattress, tears spilling and mingling with the blood and mucus from her nose.
Vance stepped back and spat at her. Coolly, he stripped himself, folding his clothes and placing them neatly on the chair. He was hot and hard, ready for what he’d come there for. He’d had to wait longer than usual, longer than he’d wanted because of that inconvenient bitch Bowman. After the discovery of her body he hadn’t dared come near the place until he’d seen off the police, wary of attracting their notice. And even if Tony Hill thought he had something on him, there was no proof and no one to pay him any attention. It was safe to come back for another dose of what made life worth living, the sweet allotment of vengeance, the savour of suffering.
He dropped to his knees on the mattress, forcing the teenager’s legs apart with a rough hand, relishing her protests, her futile attempts at prevention, her sad little cries of repudiation. As he thrust into her, he let his full weight fall on her injured arm.
Donna Doyle finally produced a coherent sound. The scream that echoed round the grim little crypt was, unequivocally, ‘No!’
Chapter 22
Carol yanked open the door and practically dragged Tony into the cottage. ‘We were beginning to wonder if you’d got lost,’ she said, marching ahead of him to the dining table where a wide-mouthed Thermos of soup sat next to a couple of loaves of olive bread and a selection of cheeses.
‘Accident on the motorway,’ he said, dropping a folder on to the table and sinking into a chair. He looked disorientated and sounded preoccupied.
Carol poured two mugs of soup and passed one to Tony. ‘I need to talk to you before the others get here. Tony, this isn’t just an academic exercise any more. I think he took another one a few days before he killed Shaz.’
Suddenly she had all his attention. Whatever had been on his mind when he’d walked through the door was thrust aside and his dark blue eyes burned into hers. ‘Evidence?’ he demanded.
‘I had a hunch, so I put out a Misper request nationwide. I got a call this afternoon from Derbyshire. Donna Doyle. Aged fourteen. From Glossop. About five miles from the end of the M67.’ Carol gave him a copy of the fax the local CID had sent her. ‘The mother put this flyer together because the police weren’t terribly worried. The usual pattern, you see. She left the house to go to school in the morning, with an excuse for not being home until late. Her best clothes were missing. Premeditated runaway, case not so much closed as discreetly ignored. But I had a chat with the WPC who interviewed the mother before they lost interest. I didn’t lead her; she volunteered that a couple of nights before she went missing, Donna had been out with one of her friends at a charity do where Jacko Vance was the guest of honour.’
‘Shit,’ Tony exhaled. ‘Carol, depending on what he does with them, she could still be alive.’
‘I didn’t even want to think it.’
‘It’s possible. If he keeps them before he kills them—and we know a lot of serial offenders do that for the power charge it gives them—chances are he won’t have risked going near her since he murdered Shaz. Christ, we’ve got to find a way to locate his killing ground. And soon.’ They looked at each other with the constricting realization that another life could depend on how well they did their jobs. ‘He’s got a cottage in Northumberland,’ Tony said.
‘He’s not going to be doing it on his own doorstep,’ Carol objected.
‘Probably not, but I wouldn’t mind betting that his killing ground is a short drive from there. What have the team got?’ he said grimly.
Carol glanced up at the clock. ‘I don’t know. They’re due here any minute. They were meeting in Leeds and coming on together. They’ve all checked in, and it sounds like we’ve hit a lot of pay dirt.’
‘Good.’ Before he could say more, they both heard the sound of an engine labouring up the hill to the cottage. ‘Here comes the cavalry, by the sounds of it.’
Carol opened the door and the trio trooped in, all looking remarkably pleased with themselves. They piled into chairs round the table, pulling off jackets and coats and dumping them on the floor, eager to begin. Tony ran a hand through his hair and said, ‘We think he took a girl just before he killed Shaz. She could still be alive.’ It gave him no pleasure to watch the light bleed out of their eyes, to see their faces change from the glow of satisfaction to the pinched pale of anxiety. ‘Carol?’
Carol relayed the information she’d already given Tony, while he went to the kitchen and poured out the coffee he’d smelled brewing. When he returned, he said, ‘We’re not going to have the luxury of time to draw out a detailed profile and brainstorm all the elements of it. We’re going to have to go hell for leather to get evidence and do what we can to save another life. So. Let’s hear how we’ve all been doing. Kay, why don’t you kick off?’
Succinctly, Kay reported on her interviews with the bereft parents. ‘The bottom line is that they’re all telling the same story. There are no significant discrepancies, either with what they originally told the police, or with each other’s version of events. I managed to pick up a photograph of one of the girls with Jacko Vance, and I have established that they all went to events in their local area within a few days of their disappearance. But no stronger connection than that. Sorry.’
‘You’ve nothing to apologize for,’ Tony said. ‘You did a great job. It can’t have been easy, getting this much out of people who are still suffering because their child is on the missing list. The picture is helpful, too, because we can tie that down very specifically. Good job, Kay. Simon?’
’Thanks to Carol, I was able to track down the fiancée who chucked Jacko after his accident. If you remember, Shaz put forward the theory it was that emotional event, coupled with the shock of his accident, that tipped him over the edge into killing. Well, from what I heard, he maybe didn’t have that far to fall.
‘According to Jillie Woodrow, there was nothing normal about Jacko’s bedroom habits. Right from the start of their sex life, he had to be in control. She was supposed to be passive and adoring. He hated her touching him sexually and, on occasion, he actually slapped her for laying hands on him. He became more interested in S&M pornography and wanted her to act out fantasies from magazines and books and from his own imagination. She didn’t mind being tied up, she says, and she didn’t much mind the spanking or the whipping, but when he started on the hot candle wax and the nipple clamps and the outsize vibrators, she drew the line.’ He glanced down at the brief notes he’d made to ensure he got through his report without missing out anything crucial.
‘She reckons that somewhere around the time his athletics career took of
f and he started banking big money, he began going to prostitutes. Nothing seedy, nothing low rent or street corner. From what he let slip, she thinks he had a couple of expensive call girls that he used, women who would either go along with the more extreme stuff that he wanted, or else they’d lay on the kind of lassies that it didn’t matter if he messed up. Junkies, that sort of thing. According to Jillie, she was desperate to get out, but she was terrified of how he’d react. Outside the bedroom, he was the perfect partner. Solicitous, kind, generous, but incredibly possessive. So, after the accident, she grabbed the chance with both hands. She figured if she told him while he was in the hospital, he wouldn’t be able to react. And he’d be stuck in there long enough to cool down and get over her.’ Simon looked up and was surprised by how grim Tony looked.
‘And we all know what happened next, don’t we?’ Tony said. ‘Micky Morgan. The marriage of convenience.’
The faces around the table went from incomprehension to shocked amazement as he filled them in on what he’d heard first from Chris Devine and then from Micky herself. ‘So we’re seeing some fascinatingly aberrant behaviour here,’ he said. ‘Still hard to stand anything up that a senior officer would stake his arrest record on, but we know now, don’t we?’ They didn’t have to say anything. The answer was in their eyes.
‘There’s more,’ Simon said, launching into Harold Adams’s tale.
‘Man, the more we find out, the more incredible it is that Jack the Lad is still walking the streets,’ Leon sighed, lighting his third cigarette since he’d walked in. ‘Wait till you hear what I’ve dug up.’ He passed on the meagre information he’d obtained from Jimmy Linden in a matter of minutes. ‘Then he told me about this retired journo, Mike McGowan. This guy has forgotten more about sport than we’ll ever know. He’s got archives the British Library would kill for. I tell you, it took me half the night to get through the stuff he’s got on Jack the Lad. And then I found this.’
With a flourish, Leon produced a brittle clipping and five photocopies of the article. It came from the Manchester Evening News and dealt with the murder of Barbara Fenwick. Emphasized in yellow highlighter, one paragraph stood out. ‘“Barbara was no party girl, according to her friends. Her last Saturday night out was typical. She was one of a group who went to a disco where sports hero Jacko Vance was making a charity appearance.” This was just fourteen weeks after the accident,’ Leon pointed out.
‘He didn’t hang about, did he? Got stuck right into the charity work,’ Simon said.
‘Well, we never doubted that he was driven,’ Tony commented. ‘So, is there any evidence that Vance actually met this girl?’
‘The high point of her night out was getting his autograph.’ Leon passed round copies of the summary he’d prepared from the police evidence store. ‘They wouldn’t let me photocopy the files, so I had to do this. I reckon she was his first victim,’ he said confidently.
‘And I reckon you’re right,’ Tony breathed. ‘Oh, this is good, Leon, this is really good. He got better after this. My God, those hillwalkers must practically have stumbled over him. Look, it says they saw what they thought was a Land Rover heading off down the track just after they came over the ridge. Jack the Lad got a fright. He realized he needed a proper killing ground, a place where he wasn’t going to be disturbed. We think that might be in Northumberland, by the way. Near his cottage. But without more information…’ He rubbed his hands over his face. ‘A twelve-year-old case, though. Where’s the evidence?’
Leon looked slightly downcast. ‘They don’t know. They moved all the unsolved stuff to a new location about five years ago, and all the forensics on this case have either got lost or misfiled. Not that there was much, according to the abstract. No prints, no body fluids. Some tyre tracks, but that’s no use a dozen years on.’
‘The investigating officers. That’s who we need to talk to. But before we discuss what comes next, I’d better tell you what I’ve come up with. It’s pretty meagre compared to the huge strides you three have taken, but it does give us a handy chunk of circumstantial evidence.’ Tony opened his folder and fanned out an array of photographs. ‘I’ve done the rounds of the zealots. I have to say it was very like being back working in a secure mental hospital. At the risk of baffling you with professional jargon, they’re all a few bricks short of a wall. However, after enduring the histories of their assorted obsessions with Jacko Vance, what we’ve got is a selection of photographs of Jacko taken at events where we know our putative victims were also present. Four of the pics put him next or near to one of our missing girls. In another five or six, it’s possible that the girl in the picture is one of ours, but by no means certain without computer enhancement.’ He leaned over and began carving himself a chunk of bread.
‘With Kay’s pick-ups, that makes five. We’ve got an overlap,’ Carol said.
‘I don’t suppose it’s enough to start an official investigation?’ Tony asked without hope. He started to slice some cheese.
Carol pulled a face. ‘The trouble is, there’s no connection to my patch. If one of these girls had disappeared from East Yorkshire, I’d be willing to have a go at getting something moving, but I can’t find one. Even so, I don’t know where we could take any investigation. All we’ve got is highly circumstantial; it’s nowhere near enough to bring him in for questioning, never mind a search warrant.’
‘So you don’t reckon we could convince West Yorkshire to take another look at Vance, even with this much?’ Kay asked.
Simon snorted. ‘Are you kidding? Given what they think about me? Every time I see a cop car on the road, I start sweating. Anything we come up with is tainted because they’re convinced I’m the killer and you’re protecting me. I don’t think they’re going to believe a word we say.’
‘Point taken,’ Kay said.
‘What we need is a witness who saw him with Shaz after she’s supposed to have left his house. Ideally, someone who saw them in Leeds,’ Leon suggested.
‘Ideally, a bishop of the Church of England,’ Carol said cynically. ‘Don’t forget, it has to be somebody whose word would stand up against the people’s champion.’
The hand that was cutting the cheese slipped and Tony sliced the edge off his index finger. He jumped to his feet, blood dripping from the wound. ‘Shit, fuck and God damn it,’ he exploded. He thrust his finger into his mouth and sucked.
Carol grabbed the paper napkin wrapped round the Thermos to catch drips and bandaged it round his finger, gripping it tightly. ‘Klutz,’ she said briskly.
‘It was your fault,’ he said, subsiding into the chair.
‘My fault?’
‘What you said. About unimpeachable witnesses.’
‘Yes?’
‘The camera doesn’t lie, right?’
‘Depends if it’s digital or not,’ Carol said ironically.
‘Don’t be difficult. I’m talking cameras that are already used to convict criminals.’
‘What?’
‘Motorway cameras, Carol. Motorway cameras.’
Leon snorted in derision. ‘Don’t tell us you’ve fallen for that one?’
‘What?’ Tony said, puzzled.
‘Great myths of our time number forty-seven. Motorway cameras catch villains. Not.’ Leon leaned back in his chair, his cynical swagger full on.
‘What do you mean? I’ve seen those programmes on TV, police videos of car chases. And what about all those speeding convictions on the back of still photographs from the motorway cameras?’ Tony demanded indignantly.
Carol sighed. ‘The cameras operate perfectly. But only in certain situations. That’s what Leon’s getting at. The still cameras only snap vehicles travelling well in excess of the speed limit. They’re not going to flicker a shutter at much under ninety. And the videos are only actually turned on if there’s an incident in progress or a traffic-flow problem. The rest of the time, they’re just not running. And even when they are, you’d need state-of-the-art enhancement software to get any
thing convincing from them.’
‘Wouldn’t your brother know somebody?’ Simon asked. ‘I thought he was some sort of computer whizz kid.’
‘Well, yes, but we haven’t got anything to show him yet, and we’re not likely to have,’ Carol objected.
‘But I thought when Manchester city centre got blown to bits by the IRA, the police backtracked the route the bombers’ van took using the motorway cameras?’ Tony said persistent to the last.
Kay shook her head. ‘They thought they might have been able to pick it up on the photos of the speeders, but there wasn’t enough detail…’ Her voice tailed off and her face lit up.
‘What is it?’ Carol asked.
‘Private CCTV videos,’ she breathed. ‘Remember? Greater Manchester Police put out an appeal for any garages or food outlets with CCTV surveillance on possible routes to submit their recordings. We won’t get Vance or Shaz on motorway surveillance, but we’ll get them wherever they stopped for petrol. Logically, Shaz would have filled up before she left Leeds. She’d have got all the way to London, but she’d not have made it all the way back on a single tank. And the chances are, she would have used a motorway service area rather than come off the motorway just for petrol.’
‘And you lot can get access to these tapes?’
Carol groaned. ‘It won’t be access that’s the problem. Most companies are happy to co-operate. Usually they don’t even bother asking what it’s all in aid of. It’s the prospect of all those hours of jerky video. I’m getting a migraine just at the thought of it.’
Tony cleared his throat. ‘Actually, Carol, I was going to suggest that you come with me to talk to the police officers who investigated Barbara Fenwick’s murder.’ He gave an apologetic smile to the other three. Simon and Kay looked merely disappointed, but Leon looked mutinous. ‘I’m sorry, but this needs a senior officer to look good. And it needs to be small scale. We don’t want to give these guys the hump. We want to avoid giving the impression that they did a lousy job and we’re the crack troops coming in to clear up the mess. This is one for me and Carol. What I’d like you to do is divide up the motorway and check out all these service station cameras.’ Now all three looked deeply fed up. ‘I’d do it myself if I could,’ Tony said sympathetically. ‘But this is one for the warrant card.’