by David Brin
Sara’s head jerked, but it wasn’t Jop’s statement of destructive intent that made her blink suddenly. Rather, she had glimpsed something over his shoulder: a stream of bubbles, rising to the surface of the pond.
Blade. He’s still underwater, listening to everything!
“Don’t worry, lass,” Jop assured, misconstruing her briefly dazed look. “I’ll make sure your dad gets out, before the cursed thing blows.”
Before Sara could reply, UrKachu cut in.
“Now it is (well past) time to end delays and perform actions! Let us be off!”
One of her tails switched the lead donkey’s rump, and the queue jostled forward.
Abruptly, Sara slid off her saddle and planted her feet, causing her mount to stutter in confusion, sending a ripple of jerks down the chain in both directions. One of the rough men tumbled to the ground, raising amused snorts from some Urunthai.
“No!” Sara said, with grim determination. “First I want to know where we are going.”
Jop urged in a low voice, “Miss Sara, please. I don’t even know myself—”
He cut off, glancing past her nervously as the flinty-eyed hunter approached.
“What seems to be the problem?” His deep voice seemed strangely cultured for his rough appearance. Sara met his steady gray eyes.
“I won’t mount till you tell me where we’re going.”
The hunter lifted an eyebrow. “We could tie you aboard.”
Sara laughed. “These little donkeys have enough trouble carrying a willing rider, let alone one who’s throwing her weight around, trying to trip the poor beast. And if you truss me like a bag o’ spuds, the bouncing will break my ribs.”
“Perhaps we’re willing to take that chance,” he began — then frowned as the Stranger, Kurt, and Prity slid off their beasts as well, crossing their arms.
The warrior sighed. “What difference can it possibly make to you, knowing in advance?”
The more he spoke, the more familiar he sounded. Sara felt sure she had met him before!
“My ward needs medical attention. So far, we’ve held off infection with special unguents provided by our traeki pharmacist. Since you don’t plan to bring ers chariot along with your ‘fast group,’ we had better ask Pzora for a supply to take with us.”
The man nodded. “That can be arranged.” He motioned for the Stranger to go join Pzora.
Unwrapping the rewq that had lately replaced his gauze bandages, the spaceman exposed the gaping wound in the side of his head. On seeing it, several desert-men hissed and made superstitious gestures against bad luck. While his symbiont joined Pzora’s rewq in a tangled ball, exchanging enzymes, the Stranger made a flutter of rapid hand motions to the traeki — Sara thought she caught a brief snatch of song — before he bowed to present his injury for cleaning and treatment.
She spoke again.
“Furthermore, any stock Pzora provides will stay good for just a few days, so you better figure on taking us someplace with another expert pharmacist, or you may have a useless hostage on your hands. The star-gods won’t pay much for a dead man, whether he’s their friend or foe.”
The renegade looked at her for a long, appraising moment, then turned to confer with UrKachu and Ulgor. When he returned, he wore a thin smile.
“It means a slight detour, but there is a town so equipped, not far from our destination. You were right to point this out. Next time, however, please consider simply voicing the problem, without starting out quite so confrontationally.”
Sara stared at him, then burst out with a guffaw. It seemed to cut some of the tension when he joined with a booming chuckle — one that took Sara back to her earliest days as a student, underneath the overhanging fist-of-stone.
“Dedinger,” she said, breathing the name without voice.
The smile was still thin, disdainfully bitter.
“I wondered if you’d recognize me. We labored in different departments, though I’ve followed your work since I was expelled from paradise.”
“A paradise you sought to destroy, as I recall.”
He shrugged. “I should have acted, without trying for consensus first. But collegial habits were hard to break., By the time I was ready, too many people knew my beliefs. I was watched night and day until the banishment.”
“Aw, too bad. Is this your way of getting another chance?” She motioned toward the bonfire.
“Indeed. After years in the wilderness, ministering to a flock of the fallen — humans who have progressed furthest along the Path — I’ve learned enough—”
UrKachu’s shrill whistle of impatience was not in any known language, yet its short-tempered insistence was plain. Again, Dedinger lifted an eyebrow.
“Shall we go, now?”
Sara weighed trying again to get him to name a destination, out loud. But Dedinger was insane, not stupid. Her insistence might rouse suspicions and maybe even give Blade away.
With an acquiescent shrug, she clambered back aboard the patient donkey. Watching with narrowed eyes, the Stranger remounted, too, followed by Kurt and Prity.
The remaining survivors of the ill-starred caravan seemed both pitying and relieved to be less important to the Urunthai. As the fast group rode out of the Oasis, heading south, the fading bonfire wafted bitter odors, along with dust and pungent animal smells.
Sara glanced back toward the moonlit pool.
Did you hear any of that, Blade? Were you asleep? Was it a garbled blur of uncertain noise?
Anyway, what good could a lone blue qheuen do, in the middle of a parched plain? His best bet was to stay by the pond till help came.
A mutter of beasts lifted behind Sara as the second party got under way, more slowly, following the same path.
Makes sense. The larger bunch will trample the trail of the smaller. At some point, UrKachu will veer us off, letting any pursuers keep following the main party.
Soon they were alone on the high steppe. Urunthai trotted alongside, agile and contemptuous of the awkward humans, who winced, dragging their toes as they rode. In reaction, the men began taking turns sliding off their mounts to run at a steady lope for several arrow-flights before swinging back aboard. This shut up the derisive urs and also seemed a good way to avoid saddle sores.
Alas, Sara knew she was in no physical condition to try it. If I live through this, I’m definitely getting into shape, she thought, not.for the first time.
The man with slate eyes ran next to Sara for a few duras, sparing her a wry, eloquent smile^He was so wiry and strong, it amazed Sara that she recognized him. The last time she had seen Savant Dedinger, he was a pale intellectual with a middle-aged paunch, an expert on the most ancient scrolls, and author of a text Sara carried in her own slim luggage. A man once honored with status and trust, till his orthodox fanaticism grew too extreme for even the broad-minded High Council.
These days, the sages preached a complex faith of divided loyalty, split evenly between Jijo, on the one hand, and the ancestors’ outlaw plan, on the other. It was a tense trade-off. Some solved it by choosing one allegiance over the other.
Sara’s brother gave his full devotion to the planet. Lark saw wisdom and justice in the billion-year-old Galactic ecological codes. To him, no fancied “path of redemption” could ever make up for flouting those rules.
Dedinger took the opposite extreme. He cared little about ecology or species preservation, only the racial deliverance promised by the Scrolls. Seeking pure innocence as a way to better days. Perhaps he also saw in this crisis a way to regain lost honors.
By moonlight, Sara watched the banished sage move with wiry grace — alert, focused, powerful — living testimony for the simpler style that he preached.
Deceptively simple, she thought. The world has countless ways of not being quite as it seems.
The Urunthai slowed after a while, then stopped to rest and eat. Those with pouched husbands or larvae needed warm Simla blood every midura or so, although the human raiders chafed and compla
ined, preferring a steady pace over the urrish fashion of hurry-and-relax.
Soon after the second of these breaks, UrKachu veered the party onto a stony ledge that extended roughly southeast like the backbone of some fossilized behemoth. Rougher terrain slowed the pace, and Sara took advantage to dismount, giving respite to the donkey and her own bottom. Exercise might also take some chill stiffness out of her joints. She kept her right arm on the saddle though, in case some unseen stone made her stumble in the dark.
The going went a little easier with second moonrise. Backlit by silvery Torgen, the mountains seemed to loom larger than ever. North-side glaciers drank the satellite’s angled light, giving back a peculiar blue luminance.
The Stranger sang for a while, a sweet, soft melody that made Sara think of loneliness.
I am a bar’n island,
apart in the desult sea,
and the nearest skein of land
is my stark thought o’ thee.
O’ say I were a chondrite,
tumblin’ sool an’ free,
would you be my garner-boat?
An’ come to amass me?
It was Anglic, though of a dialect Sara had never heard, with many strange words. It was problematical how much the star-man still grasped. Still, the unrolling verses doubtless roused strong feelings in his mind.
Am I the ice that slakes your thirst,
that twinkles your bright rings?
You are the fantoom angel-kin,
whose kiss gives planets wings…
The recital ended when UrKachu trotted back, nostril flaring, to complain about unbearable Earthling caterwauling. A purely personal opinion, Sara felt, since none of the other urs seemed to mind. Music was on the short list of things the two races tended to agree about. Some urs even said that, for bringing the violus to Jijo, they could almost overlook human stench.
For an auntie, UrKachu seemed a particularly irritable sort.
The man from space fell silent, and the group traveled in a moody hush, punctuated by the clip-clop of the animals’ hooves on bare stone.
The next blood-stop took place on the wind-sheltered lee side of some towering slabs that might be natural rock forms but in the dimness seemed like ruins of an ancient fortress, toppled in a long-ago calamity. One of the weathered desert-men gave Sara a chunk of gritty bread, plus a slab of bushcow cheese that was stale, but tasty enough to one who found herself ravenously hungry. The water ration was disappointing, though. The urs saw little point in carrying much.
Around midnight, the party had to ford a wide, shallow stream that flowed through a desert wadi. Always prepared, Ulgor slipped on sealed booties, crossing with dry feet. The other urrish rebels slogged alongside the humans and animals, then dried each other’s legs with rags. After that, the Urunthai seemed eager to run for a while, till the moisture wicked out of their fibrous ankle fur.
When the pace slackened again, Sara slid off her mount to walk. Soon a low voice spoke from her right.
“I meant to tell you — I’ve read your paper on linguistic devolution from Indo-European.”
It was the scholar-turned-hunter, Dedinger, striding beyond her donkey’s other flank. She watched him for a long moment before answering.
“I’m surprised. At fifty pages, I could afford to get only five photocopies cranked, and I kept one.”
Dedinger smiled. “I still have friends in Biblos who send me engaging items, now and then. As for your thesis., while I enjoyed your ideas about grammatical reinforcement in pre-literate trading clans, I’m afraid I can’t bring myself to accept your general theory.”
Sara didn’t find it surprising. Her conclusions ran counter to everything the man believed in.
“That’s the way of science — a cycle of give-and-take. No dogmatic truth. No rigid, received word.”
“As opposed to my own slavish devotion to a few ancient scrolls that no human had a hand in writing?” The flinty man laughed. “I guess what it comes down to is which direction you think people are heading. Even among conservative Galactics, science is about slowly improving your models of the world. It’s future-oriented. Your children will know more than you do, so the truth you already have can never be called ‘perfect.’
“That’s fine when your destiny lies upward, Sara. But tradition and a firm creed are preferable if you’re embarked on the narrow, sacred road downhill, to salvation. In that case, argument and uncertainty will only confuse your flock.”
“Your flock doesn’t seem confused,” she acknowledged.
He smiled. “I’ve had some success winning these hard men over to true orthodoxy. They dwell much of each year on the Plain of Sharp Sand, trapping the wild spike-sloths that lurk in caves, under the dunes. Most don’t read or write, and their few tools are handmade, so they were already far down the Path. It may prove harder convincing some other groups.”
“Like the Explosers Guild?”
The former scholar nodded.
“An enigmatic clan. Their hesitation to do their duty, during this crisis, is disturbing.”
Sara raised her eyes toward Kurt and Jomah. While the senior exploser snored atop an ambling donkey, his nephew held another one-sided conversation with the Stranger, who smiled and nodded as Jomah chattered. The star-man made an ideal, uncritical audience for a shy boy, just beginning to express himself.
“Maybe they figure they can blow it all up just once,” Sara commented. “Then they’ll have to scratch for a living, like everyone else.”
Dedinger grunted. “If so, it’s time someone reminded them, respectfully, of their obligations.”
She recalled Jop’s talk of taking Kurt somewhere to be “persuaded.” In more violent times, the expression carried chilling implications.
We may be headed back to such times.
The flinty insurgent shook his head.
“But never mind all that. I really want to discuss your fascinating paper. Do you mind?”
When Sara shrugged, Dedinger continued in an amiable tone, as if they sat in a Biblos faculty lounge.
“You admit that proto-Indo-European, and many other human mother tongues, were more rigorous and rational than the dialects that evolved out of them. Right so far?”
“According to books carried here by the Tabernacle. All we have is inherited data.”
“And yet you don’t see this trend as an obvious sign of decay from perfection? From original grammars designed for our use by a patron race?”
She sighed. There might be weirder things in the universe than holding an abstract chat with her kidnapper under a desert sky, but none came to mind.
“The structure of those early tongues could have risen out of selective pressure, operating over generations. Primitive people need rigid grammars, because they lack writing or other means to correct error and linguistic drift.”
“Ah yes. Your analogy to the game of Telephone, in which the language with the highest level of shaman coding—”
“That’s Shannon coding. Claude Shannon showed that any message can carry within itself the means to correct errors that creep in during transit. In a spoken language, this redundancy often comes embedded in grammatical rules — the cases, declensions, modifiers, and such. It’s all quite basic information theory.”
“Ffm. Maybe for you. I confess that I failed to follow your mathematics.” Dedinger chuckled dryly. “But let’s assume you’re right about that. Does not such clever, self-correcting structure prove those early human languages were shrewdly designed?”
“Not at all. The same argument was raised against biological evolution — and later against the notion of self-bootstrapped intelligence. Some folks have a hard time accepting that complexity can emerge out of Darwinian selection, but it does.”
“So you believe—”
“That the same thing happened to preliterate languages on Earth. Cultures with stronger grammars could hang together over greater distances and times. According to some of the old-timer linguists, Indo-European
may have ranged all the way from Europe to Central Asia. Its rigid perfection maintained culture and trade links over distances far beyond what any person might traverse in a lifetime. News, gossip, or a good story could travel slowly, by word of mouth, all the way across a continent, arriving centuries later, barely changed.”
“Like in the game of Telephone.”
“That’s the general idea.”
Sara found herself leaning on the donkey as fatigue prickled her calves and thighs. Still, it seemed a toss-up — aching muscles if she stayed afoot versus shivering on a bruised coccyx if she remounted. For the little donkey’s sake, she chose to keep walking.
Dedinger had his teeth in the argument.
“If all you say is true, how can you deny those early grammars were superior to the shabby, disorganized dialects that followed?”
“What do you mean, ‘superior’? Whether you’re talking about proto-Indo-European, proto-Bantu or proto-Semitic, each language served the needs of a conservative, largely changeless culture of nomads and herders, for hundreds or thousands of years. But those needs shifted when our ancestors acquired agriculture, metals, and writing. Progress changed the very notion of what language was for.”
An expression of earnest confusion briefly softened the man’s etched features.
“Pray, what could language be for, if not to maintain a culture’s cohesion and foster communication?”
That was the question posed by members of Dedinger’s former department, who spurned Sara’s theory at its first hearing, embarrassing her in front of Sages Bonner, Taine, and Purofsky. Had not the majestic civilization of the Five Galaxies been refining its twenty or so standard codes since the days of the fabled Progenitors, with a single goal — to promote clear exchange of meaning among myriad citizen races?
“There is another desirable thing,” Sara replied. “Another product of language, just as important, in the long run, as cohesion.”
“And that is?”