This book is a work of fiction. Names, characters, places, and events are products of the author’s imagination. Any resemblance to locations, events, or people (living or dead) is purely coincidental.
Copyright © 2020 Elizabeth Bromke
All rights reserved.
Cover design by Red Leaf Book Design
The reproduction or distribution of this book without permission is a theft. If you would like to share this book or any part thereof (reviews excepted), please contact us through our website: elizabethbromke.com
COTTAGE BY THE CREEK
Publishing in the Pines
White Mountains, Arizona
Created with Vellum
Contents
Chapter 1—Clara
Chapter 2—Kate
Chapter 3—Amelia
Chapter 4—Megan
Chapter 5—Clara
Chapter 6—Kate
Chapter 7—Clara
Chapter 8—Amelia
Chapter 9—Megan
Chapter 10—Clara
Chapter 11—Kate
Chapter 12—Amelia
Chapter 13—Clara
Chapter 14—Kate
Chapter 15—Amelia
Chapter 16—Megan
Chapter 17—Clara
Chapter 18—Amelia
Chapter 19—Kate
Chapter 20—Clara
Chapter 21—Megan
Chapter 22—Amelia
Chapter 23—Kate
Chapter 24—Clara
Chapter 25—Amelia
Chapter 26—Megan
Chapter 27—Kate
Chapter 28—Clara
Chapter 29—Megan
Chapter 30—Amelia
Chapter 31—Sarah
Chapter 32—Clara
Chapter 33—Kate
Chapter 34—Clara
Chapter 35—Megan
Chapter 36—Amelia
Chapter 37—Clara
Also by Elizabeth Bromke
Acknowledgments
About the Author
For all the teachers in my life. My husband, my parents, my brother and sister, grandparents, cousins, friends… the list goes on.
Chapter 1—Clara
There was nothing worse than being the new girl at school.
And Miss Clara Hannigan wasn’t exempt.
When, just weeks earlier, Clara learned that she had to transfer from teaching eighth grade to teaching ninth, she’d balked.
And not because she was scared to teach high school or work in a new building.
Not because she was afraid to start over.
She was nervous because in reality, Clara was not starting over at all.
She would be the new teacher at Birch Harbor High, yes. But she’d have mostly the same students as she did the year before.
With one or two notable exceptions.
Now that Labor Day was firmly in the rearview mirror, summer had burned away. So too had all the fresh starts of the Hannigan sisters.
Finally, normal life was settling in. Kate with her Inn. Amelia with her lighthouse. And Megan with her matchmaking and events business.
One might say Clara also had found fresh footing in the cottage by the creek, the home that she’d nearly lost just two seasons prior. And perhaps by September, Clara also might settle into her new position, too. She’d attended the teacher in-services. She’d set up her classroom and written the bell schedule on the chalkboard (the one the maintenance staff refused to replace).
But the best thing about new beginnings, usually, was that the person who was enjoying the new beginning was enjoying it based on her own drive. The fact that she brought about a fresh start. She made a change in her life.
For Clara, though, her so-called new beginning was happening to her. In spite of her, actually.
Nevertheless, she managed to roll with the punches, taking the evenings to clean the cottage and sort through her mother’s old things. She didn’t quite have the surplus money to redecorate, but even just folding tired afghans and tucking them high up in the linen closet was a start.
So that’s what she did: stowed the past in order to make room for the future. It’s all she could do, really.
Presently, Clara unlocked the hall entry door at the far end of her wing and slipped inside. In one hand, her canvas teacher tote which read I’m silently correcting your grammar. Inside of the tote was her thin, insulated lunchbox and her daily planner. Come that afternoon, however, it would be filled with students’ first assignments, extra paperwork, perhaps a lesson-planning book, too.
In the other hand, Clara carried a rose-gold Thermos gifted to her by her department chair. Normally, she’d already had enough coffee to forgo bringing more to school. But now that she lived alone, Clara figured it’d be a good idea to change some things up. She didn’t need to worry about waking her mother, so she could set the coffee after getting up. She could blow dry her hair and unfold the rusty, creaky ironing board to press out wrinkles in her First Day of School outfit. She could pour herself a Thermos of coffee and carry it to work like a true professional, not a teenager playing schoolteacher.
Once inside her classroom, Clara popped into the supply closet she shared with the teacher next door. There, she carefully stowed her lunchbox in the mini fridge and shelved her tote.
One hour remained before the first bell, which gave her enough time to neatly lay out name cards on each desk—regardless of how old the students were or how well she already knew them, a seating chart would be Clara’s best weapon in managing the class’ behavior.
After that, she dutifully carried her roster to the front podium, then turned to the lone white board on a narrow stretch of wall space in the corner of the room. This was, no doubt, the school’s attempt to modernize. She selected a crisp, purple dry erase marker, fresh out of its package, and set about detailing her agenda for the First Day of School.
Welcome
Ice-breaker
Housekeeping (syllabus and attendance)
Story Writing
Dismissal
She paced backwards until she bumped into the first row of desks, then studied the deep, inky letters. A light sweat formed at the small of her back as Clara tried to visualize how first period would go.
There were complications, no doubt, to this new teaching assignment.
She’d have to face a couple of students she’d almost failed the year before. And their parents, too, eventually.
She’d have to prove her worth as a high school level English teacher to children-turned-teenagers who only ever knew her as the young middle school language arts teacher.
Then, when Mercy Hennings arrived, tidy leather backpack straps throttled in her nervous fists, Clara would have to pretend that she was not going on a date with Jake Hennings that Saturday. Jake, the handsome widower who just so happened to be Clara’s favorite student’s father.
And, most threateningly perhaps, Clara would be in charge of Viviana Fiorillo for an hour and a half every day. Viviana, the independent Queen Bee who needed no supervision. The ethereal, beachy beauty of Heirloom Island.
The daughter of Clara’s father, mind you.
Clara turned and tweaked the desks she’d knocked out of place, her gaze falling across the room as a stomachache settled into place.
Perhaps it didn’t matter if Clara was the one who made the changes in her life or if she was simply the victim of them. It didn’t matter if she didn’t instigate her own destiny like her older, wiser sisters.
Perhaps Clara just needed to survive the school year.
Chapter 2—Kate
“She didn’t want to take your boat?” Kate stood at the seawall that stretched across the backyard of the
Heirloom Inn, her hand shielding her eyes from the sun. Matt Fiorillo was on the other end of the phone line, waiting anxiously to get confirmation that his ninth-grade daughter Viviana was safely en route ashore.
It was early morning, the first day of school for all of Birch Harbor Unified. Kate could picture all the mothers in town—the mothers with school-aged children. That first day back was a joyous occasion, by all accounts.
Mostly, or at least for Kate’s grown sons, the return to school was a return to normalcy. Routines took their old effect, and friends and the promise of a thirty-minute lunch padded the fall for kids as their moms set about conjuring elaborate to-do lists only to fall asleep on the sofa by ten in the morning.
Now, dating a single dad, Kate could taste that excitement all over again, on his behalf… and hers.
“I guess the ferry is cooler than my Bayliner,” Matt replied.
As the sun hauled itself above the eastern horizon, Kate spotted it—the Harbor Ferry edging along placid sunny waters toward the marina. Matt had been nervous about the whole thing, but Viviana insisted he stay home and not boat over from the Island until the coast was clear.
“I’m sure she just wanted to be independent. A private boat is normally much cooler than the public school ferry.” Kate had to laugh to herself at her reply to him. In what universe did school children ride a ferry before hopping on a bus to get to school?
In Birch Harbor, Michigan, of course… at least, if the child lived on Heirloom Island and didn’t want to be homeschooled for grades nine through twelve. Which most children out there did not. They’d spent the better part of their lives cooped up on the tiny stretch of land floating on Lake Huron. They were ready for bigger things.
Even Nora Hannigan, Kate’s own mother, had been through the drill. Having attended St. Mary’s of the Isle Catholic School, she rode the ferry the other way—to Heirloom Island rather than from it.
But that was years ago.
Now the new guard was moving in, and comprising it was a set of teenage girls sure to bring a little life back into Kate Hannigan’s world.
Chapter 3—Amelia
Amelia sat at her kitchen table alone, the yearbook Clara had discovered splayed in front of her. Just the day before, she’d been sitting there, reading her sister’s text.
What it all meant was still unclear, but as Amelia carefully shuffled through the pages, she recounted everything she knew:
One: Nora Hannigan had a teenage affair with Gene Carmichael, resulting in the birth and subsequent adoption of a baby girl, now named Liesel Hart. Liesel lived in Hickory Grove, Indiana and wanted little (if anything) to do with her birth father, since she never knew Gene Carmichael was her birth father.
Which brought Amelia to number two: Liesel Hart spent her entire life under the assumption that, in fact, Wendell Acton was her birth father, on the grounds that Liesel learned Nora Hannigan was her birth mother. This complicated the Hannigan-Acton will in that the lighthouse didn’t stay in the family until Amelia (with Michael-the-Lawyer’s help) earned back the deed from a generous-if-disinterested Liesel.
Three: Gene Carmichael didn’t move on emotionally from Nora, but she moved on from him and went on to fall head over heels for local lighthouse rat Wendell. All was well in the marriage until the summer of 1992, when their eldest daughter (Amelia’s sister, Kate) fell pregnant just as Nora had years and years before. The conflict from that point was muddy. Nora wanted to completely hide the pregnancy and rear Clara as her own, which she had. Wendell had been softer about the whole thing. After all, Amelia recalled him saying, It’s 1992! Not 1942! Still, he maintained his allegiance to Nora, going so far as to bend to her will about building a hideaway house by the creek to keep the pregnancy secret for his wife and daughters and help to keep intact whatever reputation she thought they had.
Then, poof. He was gone. After Amelia and her mother and sisters came back from an extended vacation to Arizona, Wendell was gone. Police records were scant and unhelpful, and very little evidence of how local law enforcement conducted their search remained. Just the standard missing person’s report with two subsequent follow-up reports. Both devoid of new information.
His last will and testament, however, survived through Nora. And in it, he bequeathed his firearm and wedding band, both of which were still missing. Also, his watch, which they’d found by a miracle on the dock out back of the lighthouse.
But that wasn’t all that still existed regarding ol’ Wendell.
Amelia had unearthed four newspaper articles, tucked neatly in the bowels of the lighthouse.
The first: Local father and husband missing from lighthouse area.
The second: Hannigan family implicated in disappearance of local man.
The third: Wendell Acton left town. Case closed.
And the last, an apparently unrelated Op-Ed: How to nurture your marriage. Ten tips from local wives who get it right.
Nestled inside of that final column? A name that didn’t sit well with Amelia—Judith Carmichael.
And that tidbit drew her back to the fourth thing she’d learned: Gene Carmichael went as far as to move to Birch Harbor for several years, apparently in pursuit of Nora, who never did return his advances. Eventually, he met and married a fellow educator by the name of Judith Banks. Judith came from Heirloom Island, but together she and Gene bobbed between Birch Harbor, Heirloom Island, and elsewhere in Michigan until he convinced her to dock their houseboat back in Birch Harbor for the weekends, allowing them freedom to be tourist-locals, a rare combination.
Apparently, Judith enjoyed this slice of life and took up with the town council as a summer representative. Amelia didn’t quite grasp Judith’s role or how she set about fulfilling it beyond the searing recent rejection of Megan’s matchmaking and events business.
And that’s where Amelia found herself hung up. Confused.
With Judith Carmichael, who now apparently bore a deeper connection to the Hannigan women.
Because according to Nora’s dusty, water-stained yearbook, Nora and Judith had been classmates at St. Mary’s of the Isle on Heirloom Island. Long before Judith offered advice on getting it right as a wife. Long before either Nora or Judith ever met the men they would one day marry.
Now Amelia needed to figure out what that connection meant.
If anything.
Chapter 4—Megan
Megan Stevenson stood behind her seventeen-year-old daughter in front of the full-length mirror behind her bedroom door.
“You look perfect. Let’s go take your first-day photo.” A family tradition, Megan always looked forward to getting prints made of each first-day-of-school photo to add to the collage she’d started way back when Sarah began pre-K.
“I can’t believe I’m getting ready for school here,” Sarah said. Her tone was more wondrous than whiney, but it was a dart to Megan’s heart. Neither one of them would have preferred that Sarah enter her last year of high school in a two-bedroom apartment in a new town.
But there they were, a family at least, starting fresh in Birch Harbor. Megan offered her daughter a compassionate smile and replied, “I’m a little homesick, too. But Dad has the contractors out at the field this week. Who knows? Maybe by Christmas, we’ll be in our new house, and we’ll feel a little more situated.”
It was a stretch, but if weather didn’t become too big an obstacle, and if Megan’s husband (yes—husband, not ex) Brian, was able to get the ball rolling, then she could be right. They could be in their new three-bedroom house in Hannigan Field in time to host a family Christmas there.
Megan was already beginning to brainstorm the next set of matchmaking events before the first snowfall. So far, she had Faith in the Field, a mixer for religious types and Families in the Field, one for those who hadn’t always been single.
In the back of her mind, she wondered if she was straying a little from her brand, though—which was more about come one, come all.
That’s why she was tentatively
planning Fall in Love in the Field—cliché. And Flirt in the Field—a little sappy, but…
Sarah pulled her dark hair forward and cinched her jeans. “At least there’s no uniform.”
“And at least you already have a couple of friends there, remember,” Megan pointed out.
Over the course of the summer, Sarah had ingratiated herself with two upperclassmen who had already set the stage for a seamless introduction for the pretty new girl. And then there were Mercy and Viviana. The former being Clara’s teacher’s pet the year before and the latter being Matt Fiorillo’s daughter. If ever a new kid had the chance to enter immediate popular status, Sarah had that chance. The only question was whether or not she even wanted it.
More and more, as Sarah grew older, she grew moodier, broodier, and quirkier. Yes, she had gone to every single beach party she could possibly sneak away to. But as much as she had already started to fit in with Birch Harbor teens, she was also compelled to spend lots of time with her Aunt Amelia. If Kate was the leader and Clara the goody-two-shoes and Megan the dark horse, Amelia was the wild spirit of the adult women in Sarah’s life.
Of course, Sarah had stayed most of the summer with Amelia, and it only made sense that they grew close. Still, Megan sometimes worried if moving back to Birch Harbor on a whim wasn’t the best decision for her daughter.
Cottage by the Creek Page 1