“You two, out the bed. If Tabby is up for it when I’m done with her, we can all play again. Tabitha, I want you on all fours on the edge of the bed. Gideon, into position.”
Oh, so the Horseman of Conquest was in a sharing mood. I didn’t peg him for doing anything other than just him and me. I crawled to the edge of the bed, and Chase just frowned. He ordered me to face the other way. Now I understood what all Chase’s orders meant.
Chase finally joined me in bed. I felt his hand caressing my ass, and then he gave it a hard spank. “You’ve got a beautiful ass, Tabby. I might go there later tonight if you’re up for it, but not right now. I want to watch you suck Gideon off while I fuck you.”
Kinky fuck was full of surprises tonight. Gideon slowly walked to the foot of the bed like some ginger panther. I felt Chase rubbing his cock down my slit. Chase just dove right in when I took the head of Gideon’s cock in my mouth. Chase watching Gideon and Gideon watching Chase set both of them off.
Chase was slamming into my pussy, and Gideon was fucking my mouth. Chase decided to be bossy again, but it was an order I was happy to comply with.
“Finger your pussy, Tabby,” Chase ordered.
My fingers immediately went to my clit. I rubbed it in time with Chase’s thrusts, which were getting harder and harder. Chase slid a finger into my ass, and I was coming undone. I was moaning all over Gideon’s dick. Chase was grunting and pounding my pussy.
“Yeah, suck that cock and finger your pussy, Tabitha. I can feel you enjoying it,” Chase growled.
Chase had a totally filthy mouth. I could tell he was close. He had to be. No one could possibly fuck a girl this hard and this long without coming soon. My fingers were flying over my clit. Gideon’s little noises of pleasure and Chase egging me on to suck his cock harder had my entire body on fire. I could feel from Chase he was close, but not Gideon. Gideon was enjoying himself a lot, but he wasn’t ready to come just yet. Something was holding Chase back.
I started fingering myself harder and slamming myself back on his cock. Chase dug his free hand into my hip and gave my ass another spank.
“Come, Tabitha! Hurry!”
He wanted us to come together again. I focused on what he was feeling. I focused on the feeling of his cock slamming into me and Gideon fucking my mouth. Chase gave my ass another hard spank, and my world exploded again. Chase gave out this yell worthy of a Conquest fuck, and I turned into a pile of Jell-O on the bed.
“Oh, my lord, Chase, you can make a conquest of my pussy whenever you want,” I moaned.
Chase collapsed over my back and started nuzzling my neck. “Am I going to get a boot up my ass if I ask you to take back that two-pump chump and the pity fuck comment?” I hesitated. I never took back an insult, even if Chase turned out to be a really good lay and nothing like what I accused him of the first day. I needed to be different with them. I needed to start apologizing for things.
I was just about to open my mouth to apologize, but Chase took my hesitation for me refusing. The next thing I knew, he had me pinned on my back and was tickling the mess out of me. I was shrieking and wheezing, but I wasn’t fighting all that hard to get him to stop. I liked this. I liked cutting loose and playing with the Horseman of Conquest. I hardly got to play as a child. In addition to apologizing, I needed to start just playing more.
“Mercy! Mercy!” I shrieked. “You’re definitely the Horseman of Conquest in bed.”
Chase sat back looking triumphant. “I’ve never been with a woman I had something to prove before. You threw down that gauntlet the first day, and I’ve wanted to hear that from you this entire time.”
“Chase, you don’t have to prove anything to me,” I said, kissing him gently. “I was just being mean that day, and all of you surprised me. I haven’t exactly had the best luck with men, and I just assumed the four of you were like the men at the bar I worked at. It’s something I need to work on. I’ve met so many good people in addition to the bad since I got here. I can’t just assume the worst of everyone and go into insult mode because of my past.”
Gideon was behind me rubbing my shoulders. “You had every right to insult us. We just appeared out of nowhere, and we were giving you a hard time. When we appeared, you had every right not to trust anyone and insult Chase. You have time to learn to trust people.”
I whirled around. I also had time to discuss my fucked-up feelings and the twenty-six years it took me to get there. I’d been feeling like I needed to do this with the Horsemen since I realized my twin was the Antichrist.
“How have you not come yet? You’ve been inside me twice. Am I losing my mojo?”
Gideon chuckled. “It was hard, believe me. My tribe believed delaying your orgasm made sex more spiritual. We had different gods, but that was what we believed. It also makes it a lot more intense when it does happen. Ever since that night on the couch when you came without me touching you, I’ve wanted a repeat. I knew if I ever figured out what you were and it was actually possible, even if I died, I wanted to die with you naked in my lap having sex that way.”
“You were kind of mean to me, you know,” I pointed out. “You accused me of being the Antichrist.”
“Men have been the same ever since my time. I was trying to push you away and try to pretend I was figuring out what you were because it made it easier to ignore my feelings and attraction to you. At the time, we thought you were just the Lamb, and I was conflicted. It felt wrong to have feelings for the Lamb.”
I dragged Gideon to the sofa we were on that first night and shoved him down on the seat. If it was going to be more intense for Gideon, then I was going to feel it too.
And he’d been putting it off all night. After he’d been fighting some inner war, I wanted to make Gideon feel good now that everything was going to be okay.
Chapter 36
I looked down at Gideon sprawled on the sofa with his erection just waiting for me to pounce on it. I’d always loved redheaded men, and I always thought the gingers were a little magical. Gideon had to have magical powers beyond just being a Horseman. I came in his lap without him touching me. I rode his cock like a madwoman, and he didn’t come. He fucked my mouth like the Horseman of War, and he still hadn’t come. Did he have an enchanted dick too?
Gideon threw back his head and laughed. “It takes practice, Tabitha. People do this even now with Tantric sex. We have time for me to teach you. Now, get your cute ass over here. I’ve been thinking about this for a long time. I was willing to die for it.”
I didn’t immediately climb in his lap. I wanted his cock in my mouth again. Gideon ate the cleanest out of everyone in the house. Jana had started stocking up on blueberries and cranberries because it was Gideon’s favorite thing to snack on when he was working on his computer. I’d been in front of some rank dick before and gone running in the opposite direction, but all that fruit Gideon ate made his cock delicious and he just naturally smelled good.
And he was the one that said it would be better if we dragged this out. I wanted to see how long he could wait. I sat there on my knees in front of the sofa giving him the slowest blow job in history. I was enjoying it just as much as he seemed to be. I could do this until he finally asked for what he wanted. His hand on the back of my head got a little insistent, pushing me further down his cock. I grinned to myself. I’ll hop on your dick as soon as you ask for it, Mister Horseman of War. I’d already come more times that I could keep track of tonight, and I needed a little break, or I’d explode.
Gideon never did anything without thinking it through a million different ways, and he never did anything with me without explaining everything first. So, I was a little shocked when he lifted me off the floor and onto his cock. I just sat there in his lap with his cock buried to the hilt inside me looking at him in confusion. He’d never done anything like this with me before. He always waited for me and explained himself. He never just took anything.
His green eyes had a little mischief behind him. “I said I delay, but I
don’t like mind games, Tabitha. You know I always try to tell you what you need to know, but I think you are trying to play games with War and I’m the master of games. Don’t try to force anything from me.” I met Gideon’s eye. I should have known this about him. I admitted I needed a little break and that was part of my game. Gideon had already forgiven me and was kissing my neck. “Then you should have said so. Are you ready or do you need more time?”
He could wait even longer if I needed? I knew nothing about Tantric sex, but I was definitely going more towards enchanted dick. When that thing did go off, it was probably going to plaster me to the ceiling. It was also weird as hell having four people connected to you on such a deep level, and they could read your thoughts. I didn’t hear theirs all the time because I hadn’t figured out how that worked yet to listen in. But they were devious little snoops now that they knew they could. Gideon just chuckled and started nibbling on my ear.
“I’ll have to get you a book on Tantric sex. If you want to learn, it just takes practice and patience. Nothing is magic; it was just hard work. Though, I would rather have you riding my dick than explaining all of it right at this minute.”
I started moving my hips in slow circles. Gideon’s magic dick could have potential. “How long can you put it off before you can’t anymore?”
“My personal best when I was human was twelve hours. Time is different in Heaven.”
I felt a little flutter in my belly at the possibilities of that statement. My hips sped up. “You can have sex twelve hours straight without blowing your load?”
“I have to switch up positions, or I’ll get a cramp. If you don’t want to learn, but you just want me in your bed for twelve hours, you think about what that means. Not tonight, but in the future.”
Gideon wanted me to be direct with him and not play games. “Are you ready to finish now or do you intend to keep me up all night?”
Gideon laughed and bit me. “Oh, I think all four of us are going to keep you up all night. I warned you we’re immortal and you’re still human. I told you time works differently in Heaven. I don’t quite think you realized what you were asking for when you decided you wanted all of us, but I’m glad you did. It just feels right. I want to come with you this time, Tabitha. I want the little minx in my lap who made herself come without me having to lay a finger on her.”
I groaned remembering that night — the feel of Gideon’s cock through his pants and my thin shorts. I had the real thing tonight, and Gideon wasn’t holding back like he was before. My orgasm that night was intense, even if I never took my clothes off. I knew recreating this with Gideon now was going to be something else. I kissed Gideon.
“Take a little this time, like you did when you pulled me into your lap. You have my permission.”
“Are you sure? I don’t want to be disrespectful.”
I groaned. “Gideon, get a little disrespectful. Shock me. Make us come together and show me what you mean that delaying it makes it better. Let go a little.”
Now that he had permission, I saw a totally different side of Gideon. He started nibbling on my collarbone, and his hands went around me to cup my ass. Now that I told him he could let go, he clutched my ass and started bouncing me on his cock. I just threw my head back and held on for dear life. Gideon was practically lifting me in the air with his bare hands, and his cock was plunged back into me when he would set me down again.
His mouth couldn’t figure out where it wanted to be. He was kissing and biting my neck and collarbone and letting out little growls. I dug my nails into his shoulders and just enjoyed the ride. I never pegged Gideon for any of this. Apparently, he just needed permission.
I could feel something intense coming from Gideon, and I was feeding off it. It was building a fire in my belly that had the power to consume both of us, and I wondered if this is what he meant by making sex more spiritual. It was more than just being connected to Gideon or that he had finally stepped out of his little box. It felt like we were going to bring the house down with us when we finally came.
Gideon never seemed to tire. I guess one of the perks of having four immortal boyfriends. He seemed like he could just bounce me on his cock all night. His teeth clamped down on my earlobe hard enough to pinch.
“I’m ready,” Gideon panted. “Let go with me, Tabitha. Focus on what you feel from me and my cock in you.”
I felt like I was drowning in Gideon. A huge tidal wave hit me when our orgasms hit. Either Gideon was right, and I was feeling that from him because delaying your orgasm really did make it more intense or I was right all along and he had some kind of a magic dick.
I had Santa and fairy tales ruined for me at an early age. I may be totally wrong, but for now, I was just going to choose to believe Gideon had a magic dick.
Chapter 37
When I got my grand idea for a kinky fivesome, I wasn’t even thinking about the fact that the Horsemen weren’t exactly human or how it would play out. It played out better than any fantasy I’d had. The Horsemen never got tired, and they never needed a break. Our night only ended when I got tired and asked if we could finally sleep. I asked for a break because I thought if I had one more orgasm, I was literally going to die and not get to live out the human life that was promised to me. It got to the point I thought I might orgasm again if one of them even looked at me cross-eyed.
It was nice sleeping in bed with all four of them. I felt safe, and I’d never slept that well my entire life. I woke up before them. This was my first apocalypse free day to do what I wanted with. I had a family home, money, and a bunch of cars I had no idea how to drive. I could do whatever I wanted. Right now, what I wanted was to watch the Horsemen sleep. Was that creepy? They looked so peaceful, and now they got to spend more time on Earth before they were recalled to Heaven. Did I make them happy? I wondered if they had wives they had been separated from for so long in their little private area of heaven when they agreed to become Horsemen.
They said in every life, when the Lamb was safe, they always fell in love, and it ended in disaster. They believed it was a curse, but they kept doing it. Were they so lonely as Horsemen that they sought out love every time even if they thought there was a curse and it would kill them? Would it always be like this for us and was it a solution for all our loneliness?
I didn’t want to get out of bed just yet. I wanted to stay snuggled with my Horsemen. It felt safe here. Someone was knocking on my door. It was this insistent knock like I was needed. The Horsemen all leapt out of bed, and their weapons appeared. I just held up my hand and answered the door. It was Jana, but she looked concerned.
“Miss Tabitha? I know it’s early, but Mrs. Odelia is here with the girls, and she didn’t want to come back when you were awake. She seems upset about something.”
I sprung into Heaven’s weapon mode. Lizzie and Ariel were witnesses. Maybe they had seen something that the angel didn’t mention. Maybe Drake and Mattan had a way out of hell. I didn’t bother with flashy clothes. I’d already landed the Horsemen, and they could deal with me looking frumpy if the apocalypse wasn’t over. I threw on a ratty pair of sweatpants and a tank top and went barreling downstairs. The Horsemen weren’t far behind me.
Odelia was sitting at the breakfast table with Lizzie and Ariel. Odelia looked furious, but I knew that look from Lizzie. Lizzie looked pretty damned proud of herself, and Ariel had the exact same look. I already knew whatever had happened, I was going to be siding with Lizzie and Ariel.
Gideon seemed the best at calming Odelia. He walked over and put his arm around her. “What is it?”
“Ariel just couldn’t accept the apocalypse was over. She’s gone too far this time!” Odelia yelled. “I’m grounding her for the rest of her life.”
I didn’t talk because I thought if I did, I was going to end up high fiving the runt and Odelia was going to ground me too. Lizzie looked like she was about to explode, but wasn’t saying anything because her mother was already pissed off. I had a feeling whatever Ari
el did, Lizzie was a part of it. Odelia had her hands full with those two.
“What exactly happened?” Chase asked, his brow furrowing.
“My seventeen-year-old child found out the true identity of the man Drake was trying to contact to be his false prophet. She’s also managed to find out the identity of every person on those Incel boards. She’s doxxed every single one of them. I think every person on the planet knows their real names now!”
“Good,” Chase laughed, ruffling Ariel’s hair. “Now maybe someone will do something before they start committing acts of domestic terrorism.”
“Can just one of you support me on this? I don’t want Ariel or Lizzie poking Incels. It’s going to put a huge target on their backs.”
Lizzie snorted and then totally lost it. “They are Incels because they are mad no one is poking them. If someone were actually poking them in the first place, Inceldom wouldn’t be a thing.”
I tried to hold it in, I swear. When I started laughing, it set the Horsemen off. Even Gideon, who tried so hard to calm Odelia down when she was angry with her children was wheezing. Odelia was looking at all of us like she didn’t know who she wanted to strangle first.
I was shocked when Odelia started laughing with us. “I should feel sorry for these misguided children, not make fun of them with you. Ariel, you did go too far. What if they target you?”
“I wrote a program to mass release the names. It can’t be traced, and no one will ever link me to the leak. You seem to be forgetting those misguided children think you are a slut for having children and would have helped Drake take over the new Heaven and Earth. They aren’t just harmless men posting from behind computers. They hurt people too. I did the world a favor.”
“Can you promise me now that the apocalypse is over you just be a normal teenager? No more doxing Incels and no more chatting with men with creepy fetishes. Why can’t you and your sister do normal things like shopping?” Odelia said.
My Cat is The Antichrist Page 19