by Ron Rash
The sheriff’s eyes absorbed Pemberton’s surprise. The only sound in the room was the Franklin clock on the credenza. As Pemberton listened, the clock’s ticking seemed to gain volume. Wires the alcohol had severed reconnected. Pemberton felt something shift inside him, something small but definite, the way a knob’s slight twist allowed a door to swing wide open.
“A murder,” Pemberton said.
“A murder,” the sheriff repeated, emphasizing the first syllable. “Just one, Adeline Jenkins, an old widow-woman who never harmed anyone. Her throat was slashed. Cut left to right, which means whoever did it was left-handed.”
“Why are you telling me this, Sheriff?”
“Because whoever did it didn’t bother to step around the blood on the floor. I found two sets of boot prints. One’s just a brogan, nothing special about it except small-sized for a man, but the other is something fancy. Narrow toed, nothing you’d buy around here. From the size and shape I’m betting it’s a woman’s. All I’ve got to do is find a match, and the fact that I’m here should tell you I know where to look.”
“I’d be careful about any accusations,” Pemberton said. “I have no idea who this Jenkins woman is. She doesn’t work for me.”
“Your wife and that henchman of hers thought she’d tell them where the Harmon girl and her child were. That’s what I think. They went to the girl’s cabin first. The door was wide open this morning, and I know for a fact it was fastened last night. Cigarette butts by the barn as well. Only I don’t know which one they were after.” McDowell paused. “Which one was it, the child or the mother? Or was it both?”
“The Harmon girl and the child,” Pemberton said. “You’re saying they weren’t harmed?”
“Ask your wife.”
“I don’t need to,” Pemberton said, his voice not as assertive as he wished. “Whatever happened, she wasn’t involved. Any tramp off a train could have killed that old woman. If you’re looking for a suspect, you should go down to the depot.”
McDowell looked at the floor a few moments as if studying the grain of the wood. He slowly raised his eyes and stared directly at Pemberton.
“Do you people think you can do anything?” McDowell asked. “I went over to Asheville last week and found out more about Doctor Cheney’s killing. There were at least five possible causes of death and all of them slow. Campbell at least got killed quick, the Nashville sheriff says. Harris did too.”
“Harris fell and broke his neck,” Pemberton said. “Your own coroner said it was an accident.”
“Your coroner, not mine,” McDowell replied. “I’m not the one paying him off every month.”
The sheriff’s uniform was rumpled, as if he’d slept in it the night before. McDowell suddenly seemed conscious of this, and tucked his shirt tail tighter into his pants. As he raised his eyes, his features pinched into a rictus of loathing.
“I can’t do anything about Buchanan or Cheney or Harris, maybe not Campbell either, but I vow I’ll do something about the murder of an old woman, and I’ll not let a mother and her child be killed,” McDowell said, then more softly. “Even if it is your child.”
For a few moments neither man spoke. The sheriff splayed his fingers and ran them through hair he’d obviously not combed that morning, revealing a few streaks of gray Pemberton had never noticed before. The sheriff let the raised hand settle over the right side of his face. He rubbed his forehead as if he’d banged it against a door jamb or window sill. The hand was withdrawn, resettled on the side of McDowell’s leg.
“When’s the last time you saw that boy?”
“January,” Pemberton answered.
“Amazing how much he favors you. Same eyes, same hair color.”
Pemberton nodded at an invoice on the desk.
“I’ve got work to do, Sheriff.”
“Where’s your wife?”
“Out with the cutting crews.”
“How far from here?”
“I don’t know,” Pemberton said. “She could be anywhere between here and the Tennessee line.”
“That’s convenient.”
McDowell looked at the clock, kept his eyes on it a few moments.
“I’ll be back,” he said, and turned and walked toward the door, “and I’ll have an arrest warrant next time.”
Pemberton watched from his window as the sheriff got in his car and drove across the valley toward Waynesville. He went to the gun rack and opened the drawer beneath the mounted rifles. The hunting knife was in the same place as before, but when Pemberton pulled its elk-bone handle from the sheath, he saw that blood stained the blade. The blood was black, clotted. Pemberton scratched a fleck free and rubbed it between his thumb and forefinger. He felt a residue of moisture.
The phone rang and Pemberton almost didn’t answer it, picking up the receiver only after the eighth ring. Calhoun was on the line, asking a question about the contract Serena had shown him and Lowenstein. Pemberton’s voice felt hardly a part of himself as he told Calhoun that the paperwork was nearly done.
Pemberton did not set the receiver back on the hanger. Instead, he made a call to Saul Parton in Waynesville and left a message with the coroner’s wife. The knife still lay on the desk, and Pemberton picked it up, briefly considered taking the weapon to the saw mill and throwing it in the splash pond. But it was, Pemberton reminded himself, his wedding present. For a few moments, he allowed that scalding thought to resonate through him. Then he wet a handkerchief with his spit and wiped off the blood. Pemberton slipped the knife in the sheath and placed it back in the gun rack’s drawer. He picked up the receiver again and told the operator he wished to make a call to Raleigh.
Afterwards, Pemberton left the office and searched for Vaughn but had no luck. He did find Meeks in the dining hall, discussing next month’s payroll with the head cook. The conversation was a halting exchange, the North Carolina highlander and New England yankee struggling with each other’s dialects like two ill-trained interpreters.
“I’ve got to go to Waynesville,” Pemberton told Meeks. “Stay in the office and answer the phone. If Saul Parton calls, tell him not to send his report to Raleigh until I see him.”
“Very well,” Meeks said with exasperation, “though I’m a bookkeeper, not a linguist. If your callers speak the same barbarous parlance as this fellow I’ll have no idea what they are saying.”
“If you see Vaughn, he can spell you. I’ll be back as soon as I can.”
As he drove out of the valley, Pemberton saw Galloway sitting on the commissary steps, a half-eaten apple in his hand, enjoying a day off for working late last night. Pemberton wondered if Galloway had seen the sheriff’s car. As the Packard passed, Galloway’s gray eyes looked up, but they were as blank and fathomless as his mother’s.
McDowell’s patrol car was parked outside the courthouse, a relief since Pemberton wouldn’t have to search around town for him. Pemberton found a parking place and walked up the sidewalk, crossed the courthouse lawn. Only the desk’s lamp was on when he entered the office, and Pemberton’s eyes took a moment to adjust to the gloaming. McDowell was in the room’s one cell pulling a dingy mattress off its spring base. As the sheriff did so, dust motes floated upward, suspended in the cell window’s barred light as if in a web.
“Checking for hacksaws and files, Sheriff?”
“Bedbugs,” McDowell replied, not looking up. “I suspect you and Mrs. Pemberton have them as well. They aren’t particular about who they lay down with.”
Pemberton seated himself in a rickety shuck bottom chair set in front of the sheriff’s desk. Above, a ceiling fan stirred the air with no noticeable effect. McDowell took the mattress from the cell and down the narrow hall to the open back door and set it outside. He came back in and repositioned the regulator clock’s calendar hand. Only then did he sit down behind his desk.
“Come to turn in your wife?” McDowell asked.
“I’ve come to make an offer for your cooperation,” Pemberton said, “a final one.�
�
“You know my answer. You’ve known it for three years.”
Pemberton eased back into the chair he suspected the sheriff deliberately wanted uncomfortable, spreading his legs to better balance his two-hundred pounds.
“It’s not just money this time. It’s whether you want to continue being sheriff.”
“Oh, I’m going to continue,” McDowell replied. “I found me a fisherman who saw Galloway’s Ford crossing the bridge near Colt Ridge last night. Since Galloway doesn’t have a left hand, I’d say that kind of narrows who did the actual killing.”
“I just got off the phone to a state senator who can have you fired within a week,” Pemberton said. “You want to keep your job or not?”
McDowell looked intently at Pemberton.
“What’s interesting to me is how you were surprised this morning. I guess I can take that a couple of ways, can’t I?”
“I don’t know what you’re talking about,” Pemberton answered.
“No, maybe you don’t,” McDowell said after a few moments. “Maybe you’re such a worthless son-of-a-bitch that you wanted it done same as she did, but you were too gutless to go with her.”
McDowell stood up, his chair scraping against the wood floor as he shoved it backward. He was not nearly as big a man as Pemberton, no more than five-ten. Yet there was a visible strength in McDowell’s body, wiry but muscled in the biceps and forearms, wrists thicker than expected for his frame. No gun and holster clinched around the sheriff’s waist. Pemberton stood up as well. It would be a good fight, Pemberton told himself, because the highlanders considered it a matter of honor never to cut and run, or quit once a brawl had begun. He’d be able to pummel McDowell for ten or fifteen minutes. Adrenaline surged through his veins, and with it Pemberton felt a revived sense of his own strength that had been dormant too long. The world suddenly became simpler than it had been in a long while.
But before they could start, there was a knock on the door, another soon after, still light but more insistent. McDowell looked toward the door. Pemberton thought the lawman would walk over and lock it, and perhaps he would have, but at that moment the brass doorknob turned and the door opened. An older woman, her gray hair tied in a taut bun, entered the office, behind her Rachel Harmon, the child in her arms.
Pemberton looked at Jacob and saw the sheriff was right about his features, even more obvious now than in January. He thought about the photograph of himself and wondered if Serena had found it last night as she searched for the hunting knife. She might have opened the desk drawer and found the album, turned the pages until she came to the last two. It suddenly occurred to Pemberton then that Serena might have taken not only the knife but also a photograph with her.
Sheer lunacy to imagine such a thing, Pemberton told himself, but his mind continued to assemble its own fevered logic. Pemberton remembered the glint of the knife blade when Serena stepped onto the porch last night. He tried to recall if something had been in her right hand as well. It could have easily been there, a photograph taken to confirm a child that, as far as Pemberton knew, Serena had never seen. Taken to make sure—except it wouldn’t be the photograph of Jacob as an infant, Pemberton suddenly realized. Because even if Serena knew it was a picture of Jacob, she’d need a picture of the child the way he looked now, at two years of age. Serena would have taken the photograph of Pemberton.
Pemberton continued to stare at Jacob. It was impossible not to. The dark-brown eyes solemnly stared back at him. The Harmon girl noticed and turned the boy away. For a few moments no one moved, as if all awaited someone else to enter the office and set something yet unknown into motion. The only sound was the tick of the brass chain against the ceiling fan’s motor.
McDowell opened the desk drawer and pulled out his revolver. The sheriff clicked off the safety and pointed it at Pemberton.
“Get out of here.”
Pemberton was about to speak, but McDowell thumbed back the hammer and aimed directly at Pemberton’s forehead. The sheriff’s raised arm and hand did not tremble as the index finger settled against the trigger.
“If you say a word, one single word, I swear to God I’ll kill you,” McDowell said.
Pemberton believed him. He stepped away from the desk and walked across the room, the Harmon girl clutching the child tighter in her arms as if Pemberton might try to snatch away the boy. Pemberton opened the door and stepped blinking into the midday light.
The town was still there, the streetlamps and shops and the not quite obsolete hitching post, the clock face on the courthouse steeple. Pemberton watched as the ponderous minute hand lurched forward and nudged away another bit of time. He recalled one of the few occasions he’d attended his physics class at Harvard, the professor lecturing on an idea espoused by an Austrian scientist about the relativity of time. It seemed that way to him now, as if time was no longer brisk measured increments but something more fluid, with its own currents and eddies. Something that could easily sweep him away.
A Model T blared its horn and pulled around him. Only then did Pemberton realize he stood in the middle of the street. Pemberton walked to his car and got in, but he did not turn the key and press the starter button.
In a few minutes the office door opened. The older woman went up the street, but the girl and child got in the sheriff’s car. Pemberton let them get far enough away and then pulled out and followed the sheriff’s car west. After a while the blacktop became dirt, and gray roostertails of dust rose in the police car’s wake. Pemberton dropped farther behind, no longer following the car but the haze of dust. The dust trail soon left the main road, turned down the washout that led to Deep Creek. Pemberton knew where they were headed.
Pemberton did not follow but drove fifty yards past. He turned the Packard around and parked it on the road’s weedy shoulder. The day was warm, but he didn’t roll down the passenger window. He wanted to blame the heat for the sweat matting his shirt. Twenty minutes later the sheriff’s car came back up the secondary road and turned toward Waynesville.
There was a two-foot-long Stillson wrench in the trunk, and for a few minutes he imagined the ten pounds of iron in his grasp. It would be enough. Or he could simply make a phone call to Meeks, a few words passed on to Galloway. He turned the key and his foot pressed the starter button. Pemberton let his hand settle over the black gear shift knob. He squeezed and felt the ball of hard rubber in his grip. He pressed the clutch and paused a moment longer, then shifted the Packard into gear. When he came to the Deep Creek turnoff, Pemberton did not slow but kept on going. He drove into Waynesville, on past the hospital and elementary school and the train depot, then on toward Cove Creek Valley.
As Pemberton passed the saw mill, he remembered his father’s funeral, though “remembered” didn’t seem as apt a word to him as “recovered.” He could not recall the last time he’d thought of the funeral since his return from Boston. Or when he’d last thought of his mother or two sisters. The letters they’d written him those first months had been thrown away unopened. Partly it had been his freeing himself of the past, as Serena advocated, but it had also been a self-willed amnesia, a spell willingly succumbed to.
Pemberton was halfway to the camp when he pulled off at the summit where he’d first shown Serena the lumber company’s holdings. He stepped to the precipice and looked down at the vast dark gash they’d made on the land. Pemberton stared at the razed landscape a long time, wanting it to be enough. He looked beyond the valley and ridges and found Mount Mitchell. The highest point in the eastern United States, Buchanan had claimed, and so it appeared to be, its tip closer to the clouds than any other in sight. Pemberton gazed at the peak a long time, then let his eyes fall slowly downward, and it was as if he was falling as well, falling slow and deliberate and with his eyes open.
Twenty-seven
BEFORE SHE SAW THE LATE MORNING LIGHT, Rachel had felt it, the sun’s heat and brightness lying full on her closed eyelids. She heard Jacob’s steady breaths and something, so
mething not remembered in those first moments of waking, caused her to know the importance of his breaths, that he was breathing. She reached her arms around the child, pressed him closer. He made a soft complaint, but his breath soon soothed into the calmness of sleep. It all came back to her then—the sheriff at the cabin door, a dress and shoes quickly pulled on and a carpetbag stuffed with what Jacob would need. Maybe nothing, just a rusty, the sheriff had told her, but he didn’t want to take a chance. He’d brought her to the boarding house, given her and Jacob his own room for the night. Rachel had listened to the grandfather clock in the hallway chime the hours toward dawn, unable to sleep until first light filtered through the window and Jacob had whimpered and she’d suckled him. Only then did she fall asleep.
Now, in the early afternoon, she and Jacob were in the back seat of Sheriff McDowell’s police car, heading down what was little more than a skid trail along Deep Creek. They made another turn, the road now nothing more than a winding gap between trees. Sapling branches raked the car’s sides, the seat springs creaking and bobbing beneath her and Jacob. The road made a sharp final bend and then was simply gone. Nothing but a stand of maple trees, a foot-wide path leading into them. The sheriff backed up and turned the car around to face the way they’d come. He cut off the engine but did not make a move to get out. Rachel had no idea where they were. When she’d asked the sheriff where they were going, the only words she’d spoken since his landlady had brought her and Jacob to the courthouse, he’d just answered somewhere safe. The sheriff looked in the rearview mirror, met her eyes.
“You’ll be staying down here a few hours with a man named Kephart. You can trust him.”
“It could have been just a rusty somebody was playing, couldn’t it, like you said?”
The sheriff turned and placed his arm on the seat.
“Adeline Jenkins was murdered last night. I think the folks who killed her thought she could tell them where you and that child were.”