“We didn’t come past Bruther’s place, if that’s what you mean, bailiff. We came straight home again.” He smiled, waiting for the next question.
Out of the corner of his eye Simon saw Baldwin leaving Robert. There was no point, he decided, in carrying on trying to interrogate the squire. John was clearly unworried by his questions. If he was concerned, he had learned how to hide it, the bailiff thought, staring at his openly amused expression.
“Don’t worry, bailiff, I’m sure you’ll find the murderer,” John said, a mocking tone in his voice.
Simon nodded impassively, then walked away and joined Baldwin.
“How was John?” the knight asked, peering over his shoulder at the squire.
“Insufferable, in short. If he’d made it any more obvious he thought I was a fool, I’d have had the right to strike him. As it was, I got the impression he was mocking our attempt to find out who was responsible for Bruther’s death. How about the older Beauscyr?”
“Oh, calm and reasonable for once. He didn’t even lose his temper with me,” Baldwin said, amused by the bitterness in Simon’s voice. “But he has no alibi for that evening. He was out on his own for most of the day.” He explained what Robert had told him, and then Simon summarized his conversation with John.
Finishing, the bailiff said, “So at least John has some sort of witness to the facts. Sir Ralph was with him, so he says. That means that if he can confirm what John told me, I suppose the most suspicious character must be Robert, eh, Baldwin?”
The knight was staring after the brothers. “I suppose so,” he said meditatively. “But I think I would like to confirm John’s words too. Perhaps it would be worthwhile for us to ride to this inn and try their ale.”
“Brother?”
In the blackness of night the soft, low call made Sir Robert spin, his hand gripping his sword. There was a dry chuckle, then a shadow detached itself from the wall near the stables. In the faint light from a sconce he saw that it was his brother. “What do you want?” he hissed.
John’s face was anxious. “Did the bailiff or that damned knight question you as well today?”
“Yes. So what?”
“I think you should be careful, that’s all. The bailiff seems to think you or I could be the murderer.”
Robert felt the strength drain from him. “And?” he said, experiencing a quick stab of fear.
“We may disagree about many things, brother, but this is important. Those miners killed Bruther, there’s no doubt about that in my mind, but it looks as though they’ve either bribed the bailiff – he is responsible for the tinners, after all – or have succeeded in making it look as if it was someone here, at the Manor. We can’t allow that.”
“What do you suggest?”
“This murder – it must have been the same three men who attacked Smalhobbe. What can we do to find them? Thomas Smyth is a devious old devil. I’ve no doubt he’ll have hidden them well enough. Of course, if only we could get hold of one of them, and make him admit what they did to Smalhobbe and Bruther, it would go a long way to showing the bailiff that we’re all innocent.”
“Where could he hide three men, though?” Robert said thoughtfully. “There aren’t that many places on the moors. Unless he hid them in the miners’ camp itself…”
Sir Ralph was keen to leave. The Manor held nothing but danger, and he felt that whatever he did was open to scrutiny. His only option was to get away and carry on with his journey. The enforced delay was making him fretful.
It was just after dark, and up here on the battlements near the gate the countryside seemed to have disappeared, hidden by the relative brightness of the sconces and braziers which lighted the wall and walkway. He wrapped himself up in his cloak and stared glumly to the south. Though his heart was still in the north where he had been born, he knew he had to go, and that as quickly as possible.
Hearing a noise, he peered down. In the courtyard, he could see John, his squire, and Robert, huddled together by the stables. When the door to the hall opened, he saw the brothers quickly retreat into the darkness of the stables, and raised an eyebrow in surprise. Why should they be so surreptitious, he wondered.
In the open doorway he saw the tall knight standing alone, and began to understand the pair’s desire for obscurity. The very sight of the bailiff or his friend was becoming tedious – and worrying. To be so near the coast and escape, and yet cut off here on the moors, was as frustrating as being caught in a siege, and he was nervous of speaking to the knight after his quiet hints earlier that day. Baldwin of Furnshill, he was sure, guessed more than he had let on.
There was a guard in the courtyard, and Baldwin walked down the steps and over to him. Their voices rose to Sir Ralph as a soft murmur in the still night air, and then the guard pointed up to him. Sir Ralph stared down as Baldwin glanced in his direction, and he felt the blood stop in his veins as the knight made his way to the stairs and climbed up to join him.
“Sir Ralph, I’m glad to find you.”
“I was about to go indoors. It is cold up here,” he said, pulling his cloak tighter round his shoulders.
“This will not take long. Come, let’s walk along here a little farther.”
It was impossible to refuse the calm, grave voice, and Sir Ralph soon found himself unwillingly pacing with the knight by his side. All he wanted was peace and solitude so that he could plan his future, not a continuation of the oblique conversation of earlier in the day. To his surprise, Baldwin did not want him to talk.
“I used to serve with an honorable army, you know,” he began. Smiling, he stared out over the hill before the Manor. “I fought in the last battle for Acre, back in 1291. A long time ago now, of course. All I wanted then was a chance to win renown, which is right for a young knight, isn’t it? But afterward I found myself in a position where my allegiances were called into question. It is hard, when you have taken an oath from the most honorable motives, to discover that you have been betrayed. That happened to me.”
Pausing above the main gate, Baldwin sighed. Thinking back and recalling his past had seemed a good idea earlier, but now he could sense Sir Ralph’s nervousness and distrust. When he continued, he spoke wistfully. “It still happens a lot, of course. Men swear loyalty, and then find out that their master is not honorable. And what should a man do then? Go away and find another master? Or wait until he is released from his oath? It is very difficult.”
Listening, Sir Ralph felt trapped. He would like to be able to trust this stranger. There was integrity and understanding in his dark brown eyes, a kindness he usually associated with priests which conspired with his own feelings of loneliness and danger to make him want to blurt out the truth, to share his secret. But he did not dare.
He looked lifeless, pale and sickly in the flickering light. Baldwin stood with his hands resting calmly on the wall as he peered out remembering, as though he was lost in his own thoughts and unaware of Sir Ralph’s presence.
“In any case,” Baldwin continued, “whatever may happen in the north is none of our concern down here. The marches are always in turmoil, and if the Scottish attack, men must defend themselves.” He turned, facing Sir Ralph with an eyebrow raised as he subjected the knight to a dubious stare. “But if a man was to murder, I could not condone that. If I found that a man had murdered, I would have to make sure he was held. And if I thought I knew who had killed this villein Bruther, it would not matter whether he was the son of a serf or a lord, I would hold him in jail until his trial.”
“Do you accuse me of killing the boy? What reason could I have?”
“A good question. I too wonder what reason you could have,” Baldwin said, seeing the tautness of the man’s stance. “But no, I do not accuse you, Sir Ralph. I think you know something of the affair, though, and I would like you to trust me. Perhaps you will, in time.”
Sir Ralph glanced away. He wanted to believe the knight’s words, but he could not speak. It was too dangerous. He was not from this area
, and he had no family or friends on whom he could count for protection. Suddenly he felt very alone.
After a moment Baldwin sighed. There was nothing more he could say, and the determined glower on Sir Ralph’s face spoke of his resolution to maintain his silence. Baldwin turned to leave, pausing when he faced the inner courtyard. Now what were they talking about? he wondered. Sir Ralph followed the direction of his glance and saw John and Robert standing near a wall sconce.
Alone once more, Sir Ralph gazed out to the south. Whether it was guesswork or not was irrelevant to him – all that mattered was that Sir Baldwin evidently knew about his past. How he had found out was unimportant. The fact was, he did know. And that could mean the bailiff knew as well…
That thought made him shudder.
10
Simon groaned as he hauled himself upward from the bench which had been his bed for the night. In the past, when he was younger and had not qualified for the privilege of sleeping in a hall, he had often spent nights in barns while travelling. It was preferable to this, he thought. In a barn or stable there was hay and straw to make a comfortable bed, but now he was a bailiff, his hosts always seemed to think he deserved a chance to sleep on one of the family’s best wooden benches in the main hall. Probably, he winced, because of a general dislike for bailiffs.
It would not be surprising if it was some kind of punishment. Though he himself tried to behave honorably, there were many bailiffs in the land who were known to be corrupt and dishonest. Even among the bailiffs responsible for the moors, there were some whose actions were, at best, dubious. The chief warden regularly received complaints from people claiming that bailiffs captured men of the county and held them in jail until ransoms were paid, or that juries were coerced into giving bad decisions in court in return for money. Few trusted the moor’s bailiffs.
Stretching, he glanced around. True to form, Hugh was still snoring gently in the corner by the wall. It always took the equivalent of a charge of warhorses to wake him in the mornings, no matter where he rested. There was no sign of Edgar or Baldwin. Their benches were empty.
He stood, yawned, and wandered to the fire. The large blocks of wood which had fed it the night before were almost burned through, and he had to push some glowing embers together and blow at them to restart the flames. It took some time, and he was still crouching there when he heard the door crash open. Startled, he looked round to see Baldwin stamping in, Edgar hurrying along in his wake.
“Quick, Simon, get ready to leave. I’ve ordered your horse to be saddled, and food to be prepared. There’s no telling how long this will take.” He kicked Hugh’s bench. “Damn them!”
“What in the good Lord’s name is the matter with you?” Simon asked reasonably, grinning maliciously at the sight of Hugh who, shocked into wakefulness in an instant, tried to leap up, forgetting where he was. Arms flailing, he slipped backward and disappeared.
“What’s the matter? War, bailiff. That’s what’s the matter! Those mad fools have gone to the mining camp with some men-at-arms!”
“What? Who?”
“Wake up, Simon. Hell’s teeth, you’d try the patience of a saint when you’re half-asleep! Robert and John, of course. They’ve got it into their heads that Peter Bruther’s murderers are in Thomas Smyth’s camp, and they’ve ridden there to catch them.”
Hugh’s face reappeared over his bench, his eyes massive in his alarm, though whether at falling or at the thought of a fight, Simon was in no mood to guess. “Hugh! Stop staring and get ready.”
They were on their way in a matter of minutes. Their horses were ready and waiting and it took only a moment to clamber up, snatch the reins from the ostlers, and whip their mounts through the gates, passing rapidly over the moors to the miners’ camp.
The sun was well into the sky when they approached, and Simon was reflecting with longing on the breakfast he should have been eating, had it not been for the stupid actions of the two brothers. At the Manor, he thought dreamily, there would have been cold cuts of the calf they had eaten the night before, and his belly rumbled at the memory. When Baldwin came alongside, he contemplated him sourly.
The knight ignored the bailiff’s look; he was frowning seriously. “What’s that – can you hear it?” He cocked his head, and Simon followed suit. Dimly, over the thudding of hooves and squeaking of harnesses they could make out a crashing and clanging, like an army of blacksmiths. Baldwin cursed through gritted teeth. “God! We’re too late!”
Kicking his horse to greater urgency, Baldwin fumbled for his sword hilt. Now that they were almost there, he was beginning to wonder whether it was such a good idea to have chased after the two brothers and their men. There were only the four of them, and if it came to a battle their force would be inadequate to keep the two sides apart. His sword was loose in its sheath, and he had just taken fresh hold of the reins when they came over the brow of the hill and could see down into the valley of the miners.
“Thank God!” he heard Simon say, and nodded to himself. There were no bodies on the ground, and the sides were not closed yet. They charged forward.
The crowd was thickest at the blowing-house, and it was here that Baldwin aimed his mount, thundering down the shallow incline, through the stream, the water leaping up on both sides, and then on to the yelling and swearing men.
Bellowing “Stop!” at the top of his voice, Baldwin drew his sword and pounded toward the miners. Now he could see what had created the harsh metallic ringing. It was not sword on armor, it was rocks raining down on the brothers’ shields. They were standing before the doorway to the blowing-house with three men-at-arms at their sides, while the tin workers hurled rocks, going to the stream’s banks to use its plentiful supply of moorstone. At the front Baldwin could see the sandy hair of George Harang. He appeared to be directing the attack, yelling to urge the tinners on.
A man hurled a stone which bounced from John’s shield, making him curse and stagger, but that was the last one. Even as it struck, Baldwin arrived between the two groups. He screamed at the miner who had thrown it, pointing with his sword: “I said stop! If I see another missile I’ll have your head – do you understand? ” The man nodded dumbly, aghast to find a knight suddenly appear in front of him. When Baldwin was sure he would obey, he whirled his horse round to face the Beauscyrs, and found Simon was already with him, Edgar and Hugh to either side. The bailiff’s horse was pawing at the ground, as he stared at the men, his rage clear for all to see.
“Well? What excuse do you have for this trespass?” Simon said, his voice as cold as a moorland stream.
“You are guilty of invading the King’s forest, of armed attack and threatening men of the King’s demesne – what excuse can you give? Robert? Speak!”
“We wanted to come and catch the gang who killed Peter Bruther.”
“Oh? You know who it was now, do you?”
John came forward, a bemused frown on his face.
“Bailiff, it had to be the miners. They were threatening us, as you know. It’s only a small step from extortion to murder.”
“Rubbish!”
“It’s true. And this same gang has been beating up outlying miners. What about Henry Smalhobbe? Doesn’t he deserve protection from these moor-based thugs? Or don’t you care about them, bailiff?”
Simon, white with fury, was about to kick his horse forward when Baldwin’s hand gripped his arm. The knight’s voice was calm. “John Beauscyr, you are a fool. Be silent. The bailiff is right to protect all miners, not one or another but all. You are at fault in being here, let alone in drawing weapons against those who have a legal right to be here. We will deal with you later. For now, you will come with us.”
“And what of our prisoners?” the youth sneered.
“What prisoners?” asked Simon.
John disappeared into the blowing-house, and they heard a shout, then a curse. In a moment, three men came out, all with their hands bound, blinking in the sunlight and stopping uncertainly at the sight
of the four large horses blocking their path. Following, John nonchalantly waved his sword in their direction. “Just for you, bailiff, I am pleased to present some men you wanted to meet: Stephen the Crocker, Harold Magge and Thomas Horsho. Aren’t you going to thank us for finding them for you?”
“You, bailiff, are supposed to be the protector of the rights of the miners here,” Thomas Smyth roared. “You’re not here to disrupt our work and support foreigners who decide to molest my men!”
Baldwin and Simon had ridden to his house after Hugh and Edgar had escorted the Beauscyrs and their man back to the Manor, leaving the three gang members behind. It was going to be impossible for them to be made prisoner and taken away, that was plain from the angry mutterings of the crowd of miners, but Simon had spoken to George Harang, and he had agreed, after some show of reluctance, to keep the three under guard until they had all spoken to Thomas Smyth. The bailiff had persuaded him that he would be held personally responsible to the chief warden of Lydford for them. If they escaped, he would answer for them.
The bailiff and his friend sat quietly while the master of the house thundered, stamping like a bear waiting for the baiting. Simon’s eyes followed the miner, but inwardly he was seething. It was one thing to take advantage of the Beauscyrs, but quite another to lie to the chief warden’s bailiff, and he was wary of speaking until he could control his anger. Unaffected by any legal implications, Baldwin was in a position to enjoy the encounter, and he did so, watching Thomas Smyth’s ranting with open amusement. Seeing his evident pleasure did nothing for Smyth’s temper. His face was as black as the sky in a storm, glaring at the two men. George Harang stood before them, his eyes reflecting his open contempt.
“How can we work the King’s tin if we’re to be obstructed? And if this isn’t an obstruction, God Himself only knows what is! It was madness to let them come to the mining vill. If I’d been there, the bastards wouldn’t have left alive, I promise you that. And you let them go! They should’ve been arrested immediately – by you, bailiff. It’s why you’re here, it’s your job, and if you won’t do it, someone else’ll have to. The impudence of them! They force their way into my blowing-house, beat two of my workers like a gang of outlaws, and then you let them get away! They should’ve been held – yes! Sent to Lydford Jail and held for the next stannary court, that would’ve cooled their ambitions! Two of them with men-at-arms! God in Heaven!”
A Moorland Hanging aktm-3 Page 13