Wedding Transpires on Mackinac Island

by Cara C. Putman

  Reality grabbed her runaway thoughts. She couldn’t stay here. Definitely not work with Jonathan.

  But she didn’t want to go home.

  Jonathan stared out the window as he waited for Trevor to answer the phone before he called Brendan. He’d heard Alanna’s version of events. Now it was time to get Trevor’s. Somewhere in the middle he’d find the truth. At least that’s what he counted on.

  He’d start by clearing the date for the event. Couldn’t have the shindig without the guest of honor. Overnight his vision for the event had continued to emerge. It would be easy to craft another show. What the Painted Stone needed was a launch or introduction on a large scale. Something that drew folks to the island, causing them to hop on a ferry and venture across the lake for a couple of hours. That would take something compelling. Something out of the ordinary that made people talk before and after the event.

  Food was a given.

  Music.

  But there needed to be something … more. Something unexpected. Something fresh and unique.

  “Hello?” The groggy voice had Jonathan conjuring up the image of an artist who stayed up too late with the party scene.

  “Trevor Stone. Good morning.”

  “Morning?” There was a pause as if the phone was pulled away.

  “Do I know you?”

  Jonathan chuckled. “You probably don’t remember me. I’m Jonathan Covington.”

  “Sure. Dude on the dock with my sister every summer. She there now?”

  “Something like that. Hey, we’ve got a project for you.” Jonathan filled him in on the art. “Alanna figured out pretty quickly your mom wasn’t painting.”

  “Hasn’t for five years.” A pause, maybe a yawn, before the young man continued. “Alanna’s had her head buried in the city.”

  “Is there a reason your mom stopped?”

  “Arthritis. She can’t hold the paintbrush like she used to, but they still need the income.”

  “Alanna’s determined to get your name on your paintings.”

  “Don Quixote.”

  The image of Alanna on a horse jousting windmills settled in front of Jonathan. It fit. Too well. “You have no idea.”

  “So what’s this got to do with me?”

  “We’re going to have a launch party for you. Bring you into the light.”

  “You haven’t told Mom.” His voice was flat, like he’d already disengaged from the conversation.

  “Not yet. We need to make sure the date works for you.” The door banged open, and Jonathan turned toward it. Alanna stepped into his office, her cheeks flooded with color and a slightly wild look about her eyes. She marched up to him and started gesturing like a mad woman. “Can you hang on one second?”

  He covered the mouthpiece and queried Alanna. “What?”

  “You’ve got to help me. Now.”

  He looked from the phone to her. “Can it wait a few minutes?”

  Her eyes turned red, and she collapsed in a chair. “I’m trapped.”

  “Trevor, I’ll call you back.”

  “Whatever.”

  Jonathan hung up the phone, never taking his gaze off Alanna’s frantic features. “Fill me in.”

  “The partners just threatened my job.”

  “Okay.”

  “I have to be back in two weeks or find a new job.”

  “We’ll get you back.”

  Tears cascaded down her cheeks.

  “Alanna, what’s wrong?”

  “What if I don’t want to go back but I can’t stay?”

  “What?”

  “What if I’m trapped either way? Staying or leaving?” Her shoulders shuddered, and she turned away from him. “We have two weeks to wrap it up, and then I’m gone.”

  “Is that what you want?”

  She seemed to find something within her, because she straightened and pushed to her feet. “It doesn’t matter. I knew I shouldn’t have come back. Now I just have to leave. Again.”

  He almost didn’t hear the last word. Then he wondered if he just wished it. Maybe he’d imagined everything restarting between them. He shouldn’t assume she felt anything for him. But as he studied her, he couldn’t discount everything that had happened. It wasn’t a mistake she’d come back to Mackinac. It wasn’t a mistake they’d rediscovered each other.

  He wouldn’t let her walk away. Not this time.

  “I was on the phone with Trevor.”

  She spun around. “Why?”

  “Because you asked me to organize his launch party. I talk to the person to capture their personality. You should have told me he still has no drive.”

  “What?”

  “Sounded like he was still in bed, and it’s after eleven.”

  “Not everybody’s as accomplished as you are.”

  Her sarcasm made him snort. “I’ll remember that next time I need a shot of encouragement.” He shoved his hands in his back pockets. It was either that or pull her to him for a good, long kiss. Maybe then she’d stop fighting him long enough to hear what he said. He studied her, the war of fire and ice in her eyes. Maybe self-control wasn’t all it was cracked up to be. Maybe they both needed to lose their hold and see what happened when they let go.

  That couldn’t be easy for an attorney to do. The thought scared the spit from his mouth.

  “Jonathan, I think we’d better leave it all alone.”

  “Not happening.” He stepped closer, and she edged back. “You came back against your will because your family needed you. They still do. And so does Mr. Hoffmeister. Who’ll fight to the truth if you don’t?”

  “Police Chief Ryan. That’s his job.”

  “And when the case goes cold? And there’s another Grady kind of case? When the island decides you were involved even if it’s never proven?”

  “That won’t happen.”

  “Like it didn’t for Trevor?” He knew it was low, but he had to get her attention.

  She stepped away, back landing against the wall with a smack as her mouth opened and shut like a fish desperate for air. “You don’t mean that.”

  Jonathan didn’t say anything, letting his gaze speak for him. The truth had to be confronted. “Come on, Alanna. Let’s see this through to the end.”

  “Two weeks. That’s all the time we have.” She spun and pulled the door open. “I have to get back home.”

  Her feet pounded down the stairs with finality. He started after her but stopped when his phone blared to life. With a sigh, he opened it. “Jonathan Covington.”

  “That artist is a genius.”

  “Edward?”

  “Of course. Her work is perfect. Bonnie will love it. Promise she’ll have a piece ready.”

  “You know artists….”

  “No time for temperament. Bonnie’s treatment isn’t going well. The doctor isn’t making any promises, so this party has to be perfect from start to finish.” Edward cleared his throat. “Perfection, Jonathan.”

  “Yes, sir.” He didn’t know how, but he’d have a Rachelle Stone original painting for Bonnie Morris if he had to watch her paint each and every stroke. Mrs. Stone needed the work and encouragement as much as Mrs. Morris needed the breath of light and life. “I’m glad you like her.”

  “It’s perfect. Bonnie finished the invitation list last night. I’ll send it in an hour. We may need extra rooms, but guests can overflow in Mackinaw City if needed. Family are the key folks for the island.” A phone buzzed in the background. “Got to get that. Keep me posted.”

  “Will do.”

  Jonathan moved to his desk and made a few notes before calling Brendan. The need to have a perfect event increased with each conversation. He didn’t see a love as rich and deep as the Morrises often. Instead, most people seemed to manage only a cheap counterfeit. Someday he’d have to ask Edward the secret.

  At this point, his love life was enough of a morass he needed to get out of relationships. Maybe after he’d squared things with Jaclyn, he could relaunch things with Al
anna. If her frame of mind when she left gave any indication, he’d have a challenge convincing her to stay. She seemed intent on going back to Grand Rapids. Maybe he just hadn’t made his case yet.

  A guy could hope.

  Chapter 33

  The grill fired up with a sputter as Alanna twisted the knob. The chicken breast looked well marinated, and she longed for a quick bite before tackling the mysteries surrounding her. Jonathan had left a couple of messages for Brendan. Alanna doubted he’d return the calls. He seemed as self-centered as ever.

  Could the mess with the foundation books be the crux of the broken relationship between Mr. Hoffmeister and Mr. Tomkin? It had to be more than house plans. Surely that wouldn’t destroy a decades-long friendship.

  If the problem generated on Hoffmeister’s watch but while Tomkin’s son was bookkeeper, it would certainly make finding a resolution tricky. Could that be the real reason Mr. Tomkin had asked her to look into the problem? He knew the source but didn’t know how to confront his son? Without talking to Brendan, she had no idea what would motivate him to steal from the foundation.

  Maybe Detective Bull had looked through Hoffmeister’s books by now. Alanna placed the chicken on the grill then found his card and dialed the number.

  “Detective Bull.”

  “Hi, this is Alanna Stone.”

  “How can I help you?” His tone was ultraformal.

  “Have you looked through Mr. Hoffmeister’s books yet?”

  “Why?”

  “I wondered if you could confirm that they were copies of the Mackinac Island Foundation’s financial records.”

  “Why?”

  “Because someone has embezzled from the foundation, and I think Mr. Hoffmeister was looking into it. It happened when he was president, and I think he felt a need to figure out who did it and why.”

  “That’s a lot of theorizing. Any facts?”

  “The embezzlement is evident in the foundation books. I don’t know why someone’s been doing it. But I think Mr. Tomkin’s son, Brendan, at least knew about it since he was the bookkeeper at the time.”

  “Isn’t his father president of the foundation now?”

  “Yes. And I think it’s interesting that Mr. Tomkin hired a new bookkeeper when he took over.”

  “Thanks for the information.”

  “Are you going to do anything with it?”

  “I’ll follow up on it.” After the usual good nights, he hung up.

  Maybe it was a wasted call, but at least he could work on it now if he chose. Bet he’d have a little more luck getting Brendan to cooperate.

  The door slammed open at Jonathan’s cabin. As it bounced off the hinges, a little body propelled out and flew down the dock. Alanna watched, mouth agape.

  “Dylan, get back here.” Jaclyn’s voice sounded panicked as Dylan’s little legs kept pumping. Alanna wiped her hands on a dish towel, keeping her gaze locked on the boy. “Dylan!”

  The little body flew off the edge of the dock, and Alanna tore after him as Jaclyn screamed and Jonathan hurried out his door. Alanna kicked off her shoes and jumped after Dylan. The boy thrashed and sputtered, tears and pond water streaming down his face.

  “Mommy!” Hiccups choked off his words before he sank under.

  Alanna grabbed him and held his head above water. “I’ve got you.”

  Jaclyn reached for Dylan as Jonathan hefted him onto the dock. Alanna treaded water a moment before gathering her energy to pull onto the dock. She coughed and rolled to her side as she watched Jaclyn clutch Dylan to her.

  “Don’t ever do that again, Dylan! You scared Mommy.”

  “Jonathan doesn’t love me.”

  A stricken look crossed Jonathan’s face at the boy’s whine. “Jaclyn …”

  She turned from Jonathan and struggled to her feet with the dripping boy. “What did you expect? He’s two years old. You’re the only father he’s known.” Jaclyn swiped at tears then moved down the dock.

  Smoke poured from Alanna’s grill. There went dinner. She pushed to her feet and pulled limp hair from her eyes. She started to slip past Jonathan, who stood frozen. Now wasn’t the time to ask him what resolution he’d reached with Jaclyn. Yet the anguish on his face made it hard to walk away and leave him in his pain. She continued to the house and pulled the chicken off the grill.

  Jonathan followed her, sank into a chair on her patio, then launched back to his feet. “I need to make sure she gets Dylan home okay.”

  He hurried away. Any appetite she’d had disappeared with her dry clothes. A shiver whispered through her as she sat on the steps. Fish circles blipped across the pond, forming little punctuations on the evening.

  Utter stillness settled over her like a suffocating blanket as she remained on the patio. Her mind worked over the details. A twist in time had placed Mr. Tomkin next to Mr. Hoffmeister. The two didn’t get along, but Mr. Tomkin had a solid alibi. Still, there had to be more to the story. More that involved the embezzling Mr. Tomkin had figured out. She needed to visit him. Give him a chance to explain.

  Alanna went inside, changed, and then called Patience. The woman agreed to come in and work the following afternoon. The books still sat on the dining room table. Alanna ran a hand over the cover. She’d let Detective Bull talk to Brendan. She’d focus on Brendan’s dad.

  People didn’t go from Friday night buddies to enemies without cause. Could it have anything to do with Grady’s death? Add in Brendan and the skirmish over Mr. Tomkin’s house plans, and many seeds for conflict grew. She had to believe Mr. Tomkin wouldn’t have bought the plot next to Mr. Hoffmeister if the rift had already existed.

  She almost picked up the phone to call Jonathan and see what he thought of her approach. She shook her head. She would update him after she talked to Mr. Tomkin. He had too much to do at work, especially if he wanted to plan something for Trevor. She needed to do her part and clear her brother—and herself.

  Her thoughts turned back to the graduation party. Trevor and Grady had been the first in the water but weren’t the only ones stupid enough to dive into the frigid lake. She still remembered how Trevor had trembled, his skin bluish as he stumbled back onto the rocky beach. He’d mumbled something as he fell against her.

  “Something happened, Alanna. Something bad.” He shivered as he collapsed to the ground. Before she could clarify, a paramedic pushed her aside and went to work on Trevor.

  “Stupid kid. He could have died like the other one.”

  Alanna had stared then glanced down the beach where a couple of paramedics pounded frantically on Grady’s chest. The compressions didn’t seem to work as they kept pumping. Then the life-flight helicopter landed.

  Two or three more teen boys huddled in a group. Brendan Tomkin had been in the group along with Randy Raeder and Chuck Matthews. Despite witnessing the event, nobody ever talked about it.

  That’s what bothered Alanna. To this day, a cloak of silence dominated Grady’s death. It was as if everyone had gathered together and decided to leave it alone. What was past was history. Yet they’d all decided Trevor must have done something. Was it because he’d required the paramedics? Last time she checked, that didn’t make one guilty. Yet she’d never brought the issue back up with Trevor. He’d seemed traumatized, and Mom had spent the summer keeping him close, relieved to have her baby, unlike Grady’s mother.

  She picked up the phone. Waited for Trevor to pick up.

  “You think I’ll come to some event.”

  “Hello to you, too, Trevor.”

  “Alanna, I can’t do that.” Her brother’s voice shook. “I swore I’d never go back.”

  “Because of Grady.”

  “Of course.”

  “What if I find out what happened? Once and for all. Then you wouldn’t have to wonder what people were thinking.”

  “I can’t do that, sis.”

  “Sure you can.” Alanna tapped the counter. “I just need to hear what happened from your perspective.”

  �
�I was stupid. I let the older guys talk me into a race. I’ve never felt so cold. I really should move to Florida or Arizona ‘cause every winter when the cold slaps me in the face, I feel like I’m back in the water.”

  “Who else raced?”

  Trevor swallowed. “Grady, Chuck, and Brendan. May have been another kid or two. But those were the ones I tried to keep up with. Chuck rammed into me when I turned around to come back. When I got oriented, that’s when I saw Grady. I tried to help him, Alanna, I really did.” His voice shuddered. “I always wonder if I’d said no to that stupid race, would Grady have been okay, or would he have still jumped in?”

  The next afternoon, as soon as Patience arrived, Alanna headed to the foundation. Laura sat at the front desk filing a nail. “Is Mr. Tomkin in?”

  “Nope. He hightailed it out of here for lunch and hasn’t been back.” Laura leaned forward on her desk. “If you ask me, the man isn’t himself.”

  “Really? Any reason?”

  “Not that I can tell.” The woman checked her fingers then tapped them on the desk. “Guess it doesn’t matter. But if you need him, I’d call his cell. He’s probably up at his land. He spends all his time there. Communing with the property or some such nonsense. If you ask me, he should build already. At this rate, he’ll die before he builds.”

  “Thanks. I’ll give him a call.” As she left, her phone vibrated in her pocket. Pulling it out, she clicked it on. “Hello?”

  “Hey, Alanna.” Jonathan sounded excited. “Are you at the studio?”

  “Nope. Running around. Having Patience is a great help.”

  “Patience. Yeah, always your strong suit.”

  “Hey.” She must look like an idiot standing in the street wearing a huge smile at Jonathan’s teasing.

  “Just calling it like I see it.” He paused, and his voice sobered. “How are you doing?”

  “Okay. Headed out to talk to Tomkin if I can find him.”

  “Want company?”

  “You’ve already spent too much time helping me plan a brilliant event for the Morrises. I’ll be okay.”