‘Thank you. That’s all.’ And he sat down.
There was a rustle of movement in the courtroom, the sound of feet shifting and people coughing. Lawrence Mendip was on his feet, standing with his head bent, staring down at his papers. His head came up and he was looking at me, his eyes small and very sharp. ‘You say it was a dark night. A light drizzle I think you said, yet you saw the faces of these two young men very clearly.’
‘In the light from the porch. It was only a few yards from the gate to the porch.’
‘And as they went in through the gate, did you move to get a better view of what was happening?’
‘Not immediately. Not until I heard the bulb break.’
‘But you didn’t show yourself?’
‘No, not then.’
‘And you didn’t call out. You didn’t try to stop them?’
‘I wanted to see what they were going to do. If I had known –’
‘And when the bulb was broken, it was suddenly quite dark. Then how did you know it was Claxby who broke the bulb?’
‘There was still the light of the street lamp across the road.’
‘Oh yes, the street lamp. A single bulb lamp, not a fluorescent standard. And his back towards you. Are you sure it was Claxby?’
‘Quite sure.’ I felt easier now. It was like all the courts I had been in before, the defence trying to shake the witness on matters of detail. ‘I had reached a point where I could look over the hedge as Claxby came out of the porch.’
‘Did he try the door?’
‘I don’t know. All I saw was him coming out of the porch.’
‘And going round to the window.’
‘Yes.’
‘Where was Bucknall?’
‘He was already facing the window.’
‘His back towards you?’
‘Yes.’
‘There is virtually no difference in their height. Bucknall is five foot ten and Claxby five foot ten and a half. How tall are you?’
‘Five foot eleven.’
‘And what were you wearing?’
‘A blue raincoat.’
‘And a cap?’
‘A seaman’s cap.’
‘So, according to your evidence, there were three of you there, all about the same height, all dressed roughly alike. You say you were in the road peering over the hedge and there were these two figures standing in the little garden facing the window. And you say Claxby threw the petrol bomb. How do you know it was Claxby?’
‘I saw him come from the porch. The two of them were standing together for a moment. They seemed to be arguing. Then Bucknall took something from the pocket of his raincoat and handed it to Claxby.’
‘Could you see what it was?’
‘It looked like a bottle.’
‘You’ve heard the phrase – a Molotov cocktail. Would you say it was that type of a bomb?’
‘I imagine it was something like that.’
‘A Molotov cocktail is a very simple form of petrol bomb. It has a wick in the top of the bottle. This has to be ignited. Who struck the match?’
‘I’m not certain. I think it was probably Bucknall since Claxby was holding it.’
‘But you can’t be sure?’
‘No. At that point they were crouched down.’
‘So Claxby might have set the bottle on the ground and lit the wick himself?’
‘Yes.’
‘In fact, it only needs one man to ignite and throw the thing. Is that right?’
I thought he was trying to establish Bucknall’s partial innocence and I said, ‘Yes,’ not seeing it as a trap.
‘You have identified the accused as the two figures crouched in the front garden of No. 5. Did you know their names at that point – or have you only realized who they are since you decided to give evidence?’
‘No, I knew who they were.’
‘You had seen them before, in fact.’
‘Yes.’
‘Could you tell us when you had seen them before?’
I explained that I knew Bucknall’s father and had seen them together several times, that I didn’t know Claxby, but had seen him at the meeting.
‘Was Bucknall at the meeting?’
‘Yes.’
‘What was he wearing?’
‘I didn’t notice.’
‘But he was there?’
‘Yes.’
‘And Claxby. He was there, too?’
‘Yes.’
‘What was he wearing?’
‘A leather jacket.’
‘You particularly noticed that?’
‘I saw what he was wearing.’
He began asking me about the meeting then, about the atmosphere of it and why I was there. ‘And you had a hostile reception?’
‘I was shouted down. Anybody speaking moderately –
‘In fact, you left the meeting, and went straight to Washbrook Road, thinking somebody was going to attack the Entwisles or their house. Wasn’t that a somewhat extraordinary supposition to arrive at?’
‘You weren’t at the meeting,’ I said.
‘You mean, if I had been I would have done the same?’ He didn’t expect an answer, for he went straight on, ‘There is, of course, another interpretation that could be put on your behaviour – that you went to Washbrook Road for the precise purpose you impute to the accused. That you went there with the purpose of proving you were as militant as the others at that meeting.’
I saw what he was driving at then and I said sharply, ‘Are you suggesting I had something to do with the attack?’
‘I am.’ His massive jaw thrust suddenly forward. ‘I am suggesting that you are lying, that all your life you have been trying to prove your militancy. That’s what your record suggests. Well, doesn’t it?’ And before I could think of an answer he had picked up a sheet from the desk in front of him and was reading it out. He had been very thoroughly briefed, for he had it all there, all the convictions, everything, and when he had finished, he turned to the judge. ‘Milord, I think you must accept that this is not exactly a normal witness. If he were, he would have waited for the police, or at least come forward when he knew they wanted to question him.’
The judge nodded. ‘You are, I think, suggesting that the witness had a motive in not coming forward. Is that it?’
‘That is exactly it, Milord. I am not only suggesting he had a motive. I’m suggesting his whole testimony is a tissue of lies.’ He swung round on me, his heavy jowls quivering and his finger pointing: ‘I’m suggesting that you threw the bomb, that you went to Washbrook Road with that intention, with a bottle of petrol in your pocket, that you broke the porch bulb, that you lit the wick and threw the bomb through the downstair window.’
I stood there, gripping the brass rail, shocked into numbness and remembering Fiona’s words, remembering, too, the words flung at me on the Fisher Maid in Aberdeen. I had been warned, but I still couldn’t believe it. Nor could the judge. He leaned quickly forward, his voice quite sharp as he said, ‘Am I to understand that you are accusing the witness?’
‘Yes, Milord. I’m saying the police made an error when they arrested the prisoners. They should have arrested Randall. Furthermore, I intend to prove it.’
‘Are you also saying he did not save the little girl’s life?’
‘No, Milord. I’m saying that he thought the house was empty when he threw the bomb, but the little girl heard the crash of broken glass, and when he saw her face at the upstair window he panicked. There is no other explanation of his subsequent behaviour – avoiding being questioned by the police, abandoning his job with the trawler Fisher Maid and vanishing, under an assumed name, mark you, to the remotest part of the British Isles, to Shetland.’ Most of this had been addressed to the jury, not to the judge. Now he swung round on me again. ‘Isn’t that the truth? I put it to you that you threw the bomb, saw the child, got her out and then fled.’
‘You don’t believe that,’ I said. It was such an incredible reversal of th
e truth. ‘You can’t believe it.’ But I knew my voice had failed to carry conviction. I was too appalled by the deadly reasonableness of it, the certainty that the net was closing. Sayre was on his feet. ‘You’re just trying to confuse the jury. You can’t prove that. You’ve absolutely no –’
‘Oh, but I can prove it.’ Mendip turned to the judge again. ‘Milord, since the accused were before the magistrate’s court very vital additional evidence has come to light.’
‘A new witness?’ the judge asked.
‘Yes, Milord. A man who has only recently come forward, rather like the witness here.’
The judge nodded, making a note, and counsel for the defence sat down. The courtroom stirred, and I stood there, remembering Hall’s warning about Mendip’s reputation. His cross-examination could not have ended more dramatically, and though Sayre re-examined me, trying to nullify its effect by drumming home the identity of the accused, it was obvious that the jury, everyone, were now waiting upon the defence.
My evidence closed the case for the prosecution. By then it was lunchtime, the court adjourned, and as I stepped slowly down from the witness box, I heard Sayre saying to Mendip: ‘That’s an old trick, and a very dirty one, if I may say so.’ And the other laughing and patting his shoulder as they went out together. Hall came across to me.
I was feeling slightly sick by then, the stuffiness of the place and my stomach knotted. ‘He can’t prove something that isn’t true. Last minute evidence like that …’
‘You did much the same, and the defence not sure how damaging your evidence would be.’
‘Not damaging enough apparently.’ Anger was taking hold, overlaying the nervous tension. To them it was just a game, these lawyers bustling past with their wigs and their briefcases, full of their own damned importance.
‘Wait here, will you. I’ll just have a word with counsel in the robing room.’ Hall left me and I stood there, feeling suddenly conspicuous as several members of the public came out of the courtroom. And then Fiona’s voice at my elbow. ‘I warned you, Mike. I told you they’d nail you.’
I looked at her, the high forehead, the thin crimson mouth in the pallid face.
‘I tried to warn you,’ she said again.
‘Yes, you did, didn’t you.’ My hands were clenched tight. ‘If they think they’re going to get me shut away in a bloody prison for something I didn’t do …’ And Fiona clinging to my arm and saying, ‘Mike, for God’s sake listen. Get away, now, while you can – while you’re still free.’
‘Run for it?’
‘What else? You wouldn’t listen and now they’ve got you.’ Her fingers tightened on my arm. ‘Get out now.’ Her voice was urgent. ‘Nobody is watching you. There’s nobody to stop you. But after this afternoon …’
‘Is that what you’ve been told to do – scare me, get me on the run, so that truth becomes a lie?’
‘No – no, Mike, you’re wrong. That’s not the reason. I just don’t want to see you in prison. I don’t want you convicted for something you didn’t do.’
‘If you know it, then the court will know it.’ I had to believe that.
‘Oh, my God!’ she cried. ‘You bloody intellectuals, you never understand until it’s too late, do you? Truth isn’t some sort of knightly armour. Truth is what determined people persuade others to believe.’ She looked at me a moment and I thought how that had been at the bottom of so many of our arguments. But, to believe that, was to believe that man was a soulless, servile creature without dignity.
I think she misread my silence, for she said, ‘How can I make you understand?’ Her hand was on my arm, the nails digging into me. ‘They don’t care about those two boys, they’re expendible. It’s you they’re after.’
But I didn’t believe her. ‘I’m not that important,’ I said. ‘I never was. You know that. But if those two are convicted, it’s intimidation. That’s what –’
‘You idiot!’ Her grip on my arm tightened. ‘Intimidation! Who cares whether it was intimidation. It’s that trawler they want. The target is North Sea oil now. We’re hitting at the oil companies, hitting at capitalism where it hurts, where it’s most vulnerable, and with the sort of headlines –’
She stopped there and I said, ‘Villiers?’ But her mouth was a tight-shut line. ‘Get out now,’ she breathed urgently. ‘Go while you can. You’ll be safe then.’
I laughed. ‘With the police after me?’
‘Better the police than a bomb – or a shot in the back.’
I stared at her, shocked by her words. ‘So you were in Northern Ireland.’ Why else would her mind run on bombs and murder? ‘You’re crazy,’ I said, seeing the wildness of her eyes, and the distortion of the pupils. ‘Your imagination always did run away with you when you got yourself –’
‘Oh, my imagination, is it?’ Her voice was high and strident. ‘And you accusing me of being drugged. That’s what you’re saying, isn’t it? You always accused me of that when you couldn’t think of anything else to say, when you’d lost your temper as well as the argument.’ Her tone had become venomous. God! it took me back. ‘One day,’ she breathed darkly, ‘I’ll tell you why I do it. Then, Mother of God, maybe you’ll understand.’ She was staring up at me, breathing heavily. ‘But why should I bother? Why the hell …’ And then in a quieter voice: ‘Just so long as you’re out of the way. That’s all that matters.’ She said it like somebody in a dream, but when I asked her what she meant, she shrugged and turned away. ‘Go to hell!’ she said in a choking voice. ‘And don’t say I didn’t warn you.’ And she left me then, walking listlessly down the corridor. It was almost empty now. I watched her go, thinking about what she had said. There’s nobody to stop you. But after this afternoon … I was still thinking about that, wondering how she knew and who had sent her, when Hall returned. ‘He says we’ll just have to see what the defence has turned up.’
‘But what about the other witnesses?’ I demanded.
‘I’m afraid they didn’t stand up too well under crossexamination. I told you Mendip had something of a reputation. Old Mrs Rogers from No. 7 became a little flustered and confused. She was wearing glasses and Mendip concentrated on that, finally getting her to admit her sight wasn’t all that good, especially at night. Sayre didn’t press her very hard on re-examination. He was relying on you.’
‘And what about the witness who saw them park their car?’
‘A young man standing against some railings with his girl friend. It’s not conclusive, and Mendip leaned on him heavily, getting him to admit that he was otherwise occupied. He thought they went into Washbrook Road, that was all, and he was vague about the time.’
So it was as Stevens had said – my word against that of this new witness. I asked Hall who he was, but he didn’t know. ‘Better get yourself some lunch. The court resumes at two.’
I think at that stage I still believed Sayre could dispose of a witness I knew to be lying. But when the court resumed and I saw the man in the dock I wasn’t so sure. His name was Edward Bradshaw, a pale, rather gaunt man with thinning hair and a hesitant, slightly earnest manner. He claimed he had watched it all from the front room of No. 8. Prompted by counsel, he gave his evidence in a quiet voice that had hardly any trace of a local accent, and his evidence was totally different from mine. No, he had not seen either of the accused that night. ‘There was only one man in the garden across the road.’ And he added, ‘I remember quite clearly. He stood up suddenly from a crouched position, and I saw his arm swing back, then he threw something and the window shattered. I thought it was some hooligan heaving a brick – then the flames started leaping and spreading. The curtains caught fire and I saw the little girl’s face at the upstairs window.’
Counsel stopped him there. ‘You’re certain only one man was involved?’
‘Definitely.’
‘And you saw his face?’
‘Not in the garden, but when he came up the street.’
‘You saw him in the street light?’
‘Never mind what you were thinking,’ counsel’s voice cut in quickly. ‘Do you see him in this courtroom?’
‘He’s raight there, behind you.’ He lifted his arm, his finger pointing at me.
‘Thank you. That’s all.’ Lawrence Mendip sat down.
Sayre did his best to discredit the man. Under cross-examination Bradshaw admitted he was not the owner of No. 8, or even a visitor. He had happened to be passing, had seen the gate open and had gone in out of curiosity.
‘I think you said you were actually in the house when observing what happened at No. 5 opposite. How did you get into the house?’
‘Well, the back door was open, you see.’
‘So you entered the house – out of curiosity.’
‘That’s raight.’
‘Where were you when you saw Mr Randall pass under the street light?’
‘In the front room.’
‘Doing what?’
‘Just looking round.’
‘Casing the joint would be a more accurate term, wouldn’t it?’ There was a moment’s silence, and then Sayre said, ‘This is not the first time, is it? You’ve been caught breaking and entering before.’
‘I didn’t steal anything, not a thing. You can’t pin that on me. An’ I wouldn’t be here but for a sense of pooblic duty. When I read that these two young men had been arrested for something they never did –’
‘You admit you went into that house with the intention of thieving.’
‘Just looking for some spare cash, that’s all. You’d do the same, I wouldn’t wonder, with five kids and no work because of the strike.’ He was facing towards the jury then, not Sayre. ‘All raight. I would have taken any cash left lying about. I admit that. But if some fool leaves his door open …’ He turned back to Sayre in answer to a question. ‘No, I never used force on it. The door was open, I tell you, and then I was in that room, in the dark, when I heard his footsteps. That man –’ He nodded towards me. ‘I didn’t know what he was. And then standing in the shadows opposite, naturally I watched to see what he was up to. That’s how I saw what happened, an’ that’s the man sitting there.’
North Star Page 16