‘But how far?“ Dame Frevisse asked. ”Who’s to say he wasn’t lying up in the woods, waiting for you to quarrel with Matthew and bar him out of his house, both of you knowing Matthew would refuge in the byre as he always did, but this time for Tom Hulcote to come and kill. Or Tom and you. Did you help in your husband’s death? Or merely plan it?“
‘That’s filthy!“ Mary cried.
‘There would have been blood in the byre if he was killed there,“ Walter protested.
‘Was anyone looking for blood?“ Dame Frevisse retorted. ”No one even looked for Matthew, let alone his blood, and on a byre’s dirt floor, with a little shovelling and some treading down, it’d not likely to be found, especially with no one looking for it.“
‘I mind Tom wasn’t back until three days at least after Matthew was gone,“ Bert said consideringly. ”Three days. Four nights. Time enough for shifting Matthew’s body around and all the rest you said.“
‘You old fool!“ Mary snapped. ”I suppose Tom killed himself, too? Or did I kill him? The only love I had in the world, and I might as well be dead now he is?“ Her voice scaled up and broke and she hid her face in her hands.
The lie of that was enough to stop Simon’s breath, but Dame Frevisse said in her hatefully cold voice, “Was it easier the second time to smash a man’s head in, Mary? From killing Matthew you knew to hit Tom from the side, didn’t you? And the stabbing. Once wasn’t enough? Were you just that angry with him because he wouldn’t leave when you wanted him to so you had to stab him and stab him again?”
Mary’s hands dropped from her face as she sprang to her feet. “You lying bitch! You don’t know anything about any of it. So shut yourself up!”
‘Here now!“ Walter said, but to Dame Frevisse, ”By your pardon, my lady, but it doesn’t make sense, all that you’re saying. About killing Matthew to start with. Why would Tom go to all that trouble of moving the body, stealing and selling the horse, moving the body again? If he’d killed him, why not just hide the body and be done with it?“
‘Because it wasn’t enough to have Matthew dead,“ Dame Frevisse answered. ”They needed it known he was dead. Otherwise Tom Hulcote couldn’t bid to have his holding and his widow.“
Walter started to say something to that, but she cut him off, saying to Mary, “How hard was it, waiting for word that his body had been found but it never coming? You finally sent Tom Hulcote to… what? Make sure it was still there, probably, and then go into Banbury and start a rumor that someone had seen a body out Wroxton way.”
‘You’re mad,“ Mary scorned.
Dame Frevisse looked to Bert. “Do you remember Tom was gone a few days at St. Swithin’s?”
‘Aye, I mind Gilbey was swearing that was the last he’d put up with Tom’s going off without a word.“ He elbowed John in the ribs. ”You mind that.“
John nodded that he did, and so did Walter and Hamon, who said for good measure, “Gilbey was right angry about it, aye.”
‘That doesn’t mean he was in Banbury,“ Mary said, her voice daggered with fury.
‘Gilbey Dunn saw him there,“ Dame Frevisse answered.
‘You’re lying!“
‘The trouble was that you couldn’t wait longer for Matthew’s body to be found. There had to be enough of it left to tell who it had been. Did you tell Tom, when you sent him off, to be sure of it? Rotted as it had to be by then, you had to have been worried there wasn’t enough of it still there…“
‘Stop it about Matthew’s body!“ Mary slammed her fists down on the tabletop. ”I don’t want to hear about his thrice-damned body, rotted or otherwise!“
‘You’ll hear about it for as long as I choose to talk about it,“ Dame Frevisse said, cold with authority.
‘I won’t! I’m going.“
‘Master Christopher,“ Dame Frevisse said, and as Mary started to pull back from the table, he rose and took hold of her nearest arm. For an instant she looked about to strike him, but Dame Frevisse said, ”Sit,“ and Master Christopher pulled her down so that she sat, albeit with the gracelessness of an outraged cat who, baffled though it might be for now, is only waiting to have its own way.
‘But even so,“ said Bert, ”even if that’s all anything like true…“
‘Fool!“ Mary flung at him. ”It’s none of it true. It’s all lies she’s making up because she’s ugly and a nun and I’m not!“
‘… what’s Tom dead for?“ finished Bert.
Dame Frevisse fixed her cold eyes on Mary. “Why don’t you tell us how Tom came to be dead, Mary? You struck him in the head first, to bring him down, then stabbed him. He’d not have stood there to be stabbed without fighting back. You’d never have put two knife thrusts into him if he’d been conscious. But you’d learned from killing Matthew what to do. That’s what the blow to the head was for, wasn’t it? To be sure he didn’t fight back while you finished killing him.”
Mary was drawing sharp, shuddering breaths through her set teeth, her hot-eyed, hating glare fixed on Dame Frevisse who went on, still coldly meeting her hatred, “And after you’d killed him, in that while until you could haul him out to dump him in that ditch, where did you keep his body, Mary? Under your bed? Or maybe in your bed, for old times’ sake?”
‘Simon!“ Mary shrieked, finally tearing her gaze away to him. ”Make her stop!“
But it was Walter who said, “That’s not going to work. Even if she did kill him…”
Mary’s head whipped toward him. “I didn’t kill him!”
‘… she’d not be able to move Tom’s body far, and we know it was moved. And even if she could have moved it, where’s the sense in her killing him anyway? I can see her doing for Matthew…“
Mary made a sound like a spitting cat.
‘… and I can see Tom helping her at it,“ Walter went on despite a startled glance at her, ”because he stood to gain by Matthew being dead. He was counting on having Matthew’s holding…“
‘By marrying her,“ Dame Frevisse agreed. ”Because he didn’t know she was Father Edmund’s paramour as well as his.“
Mary sprang up again at that, screaming, “Liar! You liar!” And at Simon, at all of them, “Make her stop! Shut her up! Make her stop it!”
Surprised how far he was from having any feeling for her except disgust, Simon said, “I can’t. She’s only saying what someone else has said.”
Mary swept a look of derision around the table. “Who?
Someone of you who couldn’t have me, so you’re making up lies about me instead?“
‘No.“ Dame Frevisse made a small hand movement toward Dickon without taking her eyes from Mary and, as he stood up, said, ”He saw you with Father Edmund and so did other boys, more than once and in ways they couldn’t mistake.“
A distant part of Simon willed Mary to answer that— deny it, disprove it, show it wasn’t true, say something to change her back into a sister he need neither fear nor be ashamed of.
Instead she stood staring at Dickon, struck to silence, and into her frozen failure to say anything, Dame Frevisse said remorselessly, “It was the one thing needed to make sense of everything else. You used Tom Hulcote to rid you of Matthew, and meant to be rid of Tom after that, to leave you free to your other lover. To Father Edmund.”
‘You don’t believe her, do you?“ Mary whispered, turning a hunted look to Simon.
‘I believe Dickon.“ All feeling was dead in his voice. ”I believe Adam. I doubt there’s anyone who’ll believe you.“
Mary drew sharp breath through her teeth, flung back her head with an angry cry, and bent to pound her fists on the tabletop, crying out, her voice scaling up to break with cornered fury, “Damn Tom! Damn him! If he’d just left…”
‘Mary,“ Father Edmund said from the doorway.
Chapter 21
Fear and dismay twisted tightly together inside of Frevisse. Her carefully used cold anger’s purpose and her desperate hope had been to break past Mary’s lies before she need deal with Father Edmund
. Because whatever Mary was, he was worse.
But Mary was already crying out to him, “They know!” And he was crossing the room, saying back to her, “They only know what you’ve been telling them,” his voice and look warning her to silence. “I haven’t told them aught!”
‘Then they know nothing.“ Circling the table to her, sure of himself, he was set on making sure of her.
‘We know you’re lovers,“ Frevisse said with the ice-edge scorn she had been using against Mary, not able to think of better weapon against him.
Father Edmund faltered slightly, lost a margin of his smile as he made a swift look around the table at the other men’s faces, but took Mary’s out-held hand anyway and said, “Are we?” Matching Frevisse’s scorn. Daring her to prove it.
Guessing desperately from that that he had heard nearly nothing before he came in, she jibed back, “You were seen. In the woods and other places. You’ve been careless with your lovemaking.”
She twisted the word to ugliness and his smile left him. He looked longer at the men around the table this time, taking in that they believed her, and with disregard for the shame he should have shown, he laid his hand over Mary’s clinging to his arm, scorning them all as he said, “So our sin is known and you’re offended. What pity you’re such cowards you couldn’t face us both with it.”
Mary started to say something. His hold on her tightened, silencing her as he readied to say more, showing his displeasure at them, but Frevisse, her anger rising past her cold control, said back at him, returning his disgust, “The worse pity is that your sins of the flesh are the least of what you’ve done.”
‘The least?“ Father Edmund put a quantity of scorn into that, too sure of himself to think he could lose ground. ”There’s more?“
‘I told you…“ Mary started at him.
‘The thing is not to tell them,“ Father Edmund snapped.
‘Her husband’s death for a beginning,“ Frevisse said.
Father Edmund dismissed that sharply. “He was killed miles from here by thieves.”
‘He was killed here by Tom Hulcote. And by his wife. Who’d plotted it with you beforehand.“
Mary tore a hand free of Father Edmund’s hold to grab the front of his surcoat and demand up at him, “You see?”
Ignoring her, his harsh gaze fixed at Frevisse, he said with contempt, “You’re being foolish, Dame.”
Ignoring his contempt, she answered, “And then the two of you killed Tom.”
‘We never…“ Mary started shrilly.
‘Be quiet!“ Father Edmund snapped. ”She’s nothing more than guessing.“
‘It’s gone past guessing,“ Frevisse thrust back. ”It must have been troublesome, Mary having a husband and two lovers all at once. Was that why you decided to be rid of two of them, Mary? Or was it Father Edmund who thought out how to be rid of them? Or the two of you together?“
Goaded, Mary cried out, suddenly fierce, “You’re guessing! You’re lying!”
With a certainty weighted by her anger, Frevisse said, “The ‘clever’ part was having Tom kill your husband for you first of all. You told him that if he did, he’d have you and the holding both, didn’t you? That’s how you brought him to it, isn’t it? But how did Matthew come to be both clubbed and stabbed? Tom on his own wouldn’t likely have needed to do both. One or the other, but not both. What happened? Did Tom balk at the last or did Matthew put up more fight than you thought he would and you had to club him down for Tom to stab?”
With a snarling ugliness, all beauty stripped from her, Mary let loose of Father Edmund to turn fully toward her, starting to answer that, but Father Edmund caught her by the shoulders, pulled her back against him, said over her head, fierce now in his turn, “Say nothing, Mary. Nun, on peril of your soul, be silent.”
‘I doubt it’s my soul is in peril,“ Frevisse answered and thrust on, ”Clever, too, to put Tom to all that trouble of making it seem Matthew wasn’t killed here at all. Having him ’leave‘ the day before your deliberate quarrel with Matthew, then steal and sell the horse and dump Matthew’s body well away, all so there’d be no suspicion on either of you. He did all that so he’d be able to have you openly, have Matthew’s place in every way, and all the time you meant that he’d have nothing.“
‘No! None of that happened! None of it!“ Mary cried.
His arms around her, holding her to him, Father Edmund said contemptuously, “Let her say what she wants. It’s the only thing will satisfy them. Hearing her lies. It makes no difference. There’s nothing proved, however much she says.”
Because that was too true, Frevisse said with contempt to match his own, as if she had proof in plenty, “And while Tom was seeing to Matthew, you went about to be rid of Master Naylor.”
Perryn and the other men—save Christopher, who didn’t know about it—roused to that, Perryn demanding, “How?”
‘He simply sent word to Lord Lovell that he thought he recognized Master Naylor as villein born,“ Frevisse said, as confidently as if now she were not making an outright, utter guess. ”He knew that on your own, Perryn, you’d never give the Woderove holding to Tom Hulcote. Therefore he saw to Master Naylor being out of the way, lest he persuade you otherwise.“
Father Edmund’s hesitation to deny that told Frevisse, to her relief, that she had guessed rightly. In all of this, his accusation to Lord Lovell against Master Naylor was the one thing of which there would be firm proof. If he denied it and somehow she had the proof in hand, then everything else he had denied would be suspect, too, and while the advantage was still hers, Frevisse said at him, “It’s the other reason you couldn’t wait over-long for Matthew’s body to be found. Tom had to be refused his bid for the holding before Master Naylor was released.”
‘And that’s why Tom was in Banbury at St. Swithin’s time!“ Bert exclaimed. ”To spread rumor of Matthew’s body so someone would find it!“
Walter, John and Hamon were at last looking more grim than confused, beginning to see how the pieces, proof or no, all held together damningly. Father Edmund, able to read the shift and trying to regain lost ground, said with new fierceness, “What are you gaining by these lies, Dame? Who set you to them?”
‘My brother!“ Mary cried. ”He hates me!“ Refusing to be turned, Frevisse said bitingly, at Mary again, ”That left you only Tom to be rid of. As planned, he was refused the holding and you set to urging him to leave, telling him there was nothing left for him here. But he wouldn’t go. He meant to stay. Is that why you killed him? Because he wouldn’t leave you? Because he loved you too much? Or did he find you and Father Edmund together in a way he couldn’t mistake and was so angry that all you could do was kill him to keep him quiet?“
There was nothing beautiful about Mary now. Eyes hating, she strained forward against Father Edmund’s hold, snarling, “You dirt-mouthed bitch!”
Frevisse leaned toward her in return, not caring what her own face showed, demanding, “Was it you he went for in his anger, and Father Edmund struck him down? Or did he go for Father Edmund first, and you did for him? The way you did for your husband. Did Tom have time to know it was you killing him? Did he have time to know just what your ‘love’ is worth?”
Mary screamed then, wrenching against Father Edmund’s hold, too furious even for words, wanting only to come at her. Hamon shifted hurriedly off the bench and away while Father Edmund, struggling to hold her, said, “Mary, no! She’s guessing. It doesn’t matter what she says! She doesn’t know anything!”
Frevisse, ignoring him, leaned farther forward, tauntingly near to Mary’s reach, and sick though the words made her, said goadingly, “And when you’d clubbed him down, Mary, was it you who stabbed him twice over to be sure he was dead? Or was that something you managed to leave to your other lover to do?”
‘Dame!“ Father Edmund said with a fury that brought Mary to sudden stillness in his hold. ”Enough! On your obedience, Dame, be silent!“
Frevisse straightened, slowly, her
eyes locked to his, letting him see everything she thought of him and what he could do with his priestly “obedience” before she said, cold and deliberate, “And then you hid his body while you remade your plans to cover what you’d done. It took you Sunday to think it out, Monday to accomplish it, and that night, finally, you were able to take him—how? by wheelbarrow, its wheel well greased to go unheard in the night?—out by the back way to dump him in a ditch the way that he’d dumped Matthew.”
‘Guessing,“ Father Edmund said.
‘The pieces fit,“ Frevisse returned. ”Every one of them. Down to Gilbey Dunn’s belt and Simon Perryn’s hood.“
‘What…“ Father Edmund faltered on that, not shifting swiftly enough to follow where she had gone.
‘The belt and hood you told these men to say nothing about,“ Frevisse said. ”The belt and hood stolen from Gilbey’s house and here.“
Mary gave a vicious, desperate laugh at that. “There! There’s your lie! I’ve never been at Gilbey’s house this half year and more, and anyone will say so!”
‘No one says you’ve been at Gilbey’s house,“ Frevisse said sharply back at her. ”You came here and took your brother’s hood. It was Father Edmund who went to Gilbey’s and took the belt.“
Mary stared, while Father Edmund’s face went tightly shut, with thoughts racing behind it, but Frevisse gave him no time to sort them out, saying quickly at them both, “I’ve asked. The belt and hood were where they should have been on Monday morning. After that they were gone. Someone took them. The only person both here and at Gilbey’s that day is Esota Emmet, and there’s nothing against her in any of this. The only others possible are Walter Hopper and Hamon Otale. Walter came here, and Hamon as his man was at Gilbey’s.”
‘There then!“ Mary cried. ”It could have been them!“ And at Perryn, ”It could have been! Make her admit it could have been them!“
‘Save that there’s nothing—nothing“ Frevisse said in sudden, open, blazing anger, ”to tie them to either Matthew’s death or Tom’s, but everything to tie you and Father Edmund. Beginning with your lust.“
9 The Reeve's Tale Page 24