“Are you going to let us love you for a little bit before we get naked?” asked Jon.
She was too naïve to know what they meant so she simply nodded.
Jon lifted her up in his arms and took her to the bed where he sat her on the edge.
“Slide back and get comfortable.”
She did just that, putting a pillow under her head as both of them got on the bed and made their way toward her.
They laid on their sides facing her, hands coming toward her and then each of them touched her breasts, rolling its nipple between their fingers and thumb.
Her pussy pulled just like it had yesterday. It felt good even when they gave it a little tug. Then their mouths went on each nipple and sucked. That felt even better. She was already beginning to like the idea of two men lavishing this sort of pleasure on her at the same time.
She began to relax a little.
Jon removed his mouth and looked at her. “You’re going to need to be slick or it’s going to hurt you, so we have a special treat for you.”
Slick? Did he mean the moisture she’d felt yesterday bubbling from inside of her pussy?
Jon moved his hand down her belly while Shaun parted her thighs.
“Hang on baby,” said Shaun.
Jon put his finger down deep into her curls and rubbed a part of her folds above her pussy opening.
What he was doing she had no idea, but she didn’t want to seem ignorant and ask.
Shaun ran his hand back and forth over her belly as Jon moved his finger faster, each touch getting harder.
She groaned a little not because it hurt, but because she was starting to get a strange feeling. A heightened sense of awareness. Every nerve ending in her pussy took notice. And then dear lord, she felt really good and her legs shook and she groaned like never before.
“I think our girl has enjoyed her first experience with the pleasure of sex,” said Jon.
“What did you do to me?” asked Sarah.
“I played with your clit and it’s the nicest one I’ve ever fondled,” said Jon.
Shaun parted her legs some more.
“Honey doll, you feel that pumping from you?”
He swiped his finger across her pussy and held it up to show her. It glistened.
“That’s proof you got excited and you’re getting ready for the big event,” said Shaun, pushing his finger gently inside her.
She groaned because she was ready for him.
“Sorry, but you have to try and relax.”
“I’ll try.”
The deeper he pushed the more tense she grew.
“Just take me, take me and get this over and done with,” said Sarah, knowing what was coming but she’d grin and bear it.
“You sure?” asked Jon.
Sarah nodded.
He got off the bed as did Shaun and both men undressed before her.
Now she really was scared.
“Okay honey doll, I’ll comfort you and you just think of pleasant things and it will be over before you realize it. You might even have a good time.”
Shaun got behind her lifted her upper body and placed it gently on his lap. His cock brushed against her spine.
Jon got back onto the bed, crawling toward her. She looked down at him, at his cock, hard and long. She shook so hard the bed began to rock.
“You’ll going to be just fine, just fine,” Shaun whispered in her ear.
“Just relax as best you can,” said Jon pushing her legs wide apart.
Shaun leaned over and gave her an upside down kiss, his lips masking her whimper as Jon’s cock entered her opening. She made fists willing herself to get through this without any fuss, but it hurt so much as he pushed and went deeper. Shaun rubbed her nipples, kissing her hard, her tiny screams muffled as Jon began thrusting in and out of her.
A tear ran down her cheek as she looked up, the room spinning and then feeling Jon’s cock jerk inside her and him groaning, and then seconds later pulling out of her.
Their voices telling her it was okay, her first time was all over, sounded miles away.
“We’ll fill the bath and you can wash yourself,” said Jon.
She sat up seeing some blood smeared on her thighs and another tear ran down her cheek.
“Honey doll, the next time’s going to be so, so different for you. You’re going to think you’re in Heaven,” said Shaun.
Chapter Six
Jon hadn’t wanted to say much after he’d had sex with Sarah. They’d insisted she sleep in the bed and he and Jon took the chairs out in the main room. A storm was moving in and Shaun could hear the distant thunder. He couldn’t sleep and not just because he wasn’t in a bed. He couldn’t believe how excited he’d been holding Sarah, kissing her, and playing with her nipples while Jon fucked her.
He felt guilty, morally corrupt almost. But at the same time, he couldn’t wait for it to be his turn to be buried deep inside her.
“Something bothering you?”
Jon’s voice startled him. He hadn’t been aware that his buddy was also awake.
“No, I was just thinking about tonight.”
“You have any regrets?”
“No, do you?” asked Shaun.
“None.”
Shaun leaned toward Jon and whispered.
“You haven’t said anything about it.”
“I’m being a perfect gentleman but I can say I’ve never reached my release as quickly as I did tonight. I’m not sure if it was because she was a virgin or because her pussy is naturally tight and welcoming to a man.”
Just hearing that made Shaun grow hard.
“Her pussy is beautiful just like the rest of her,” whispered Jon.
A crack of thunder broke the silence of the night and then a flash of lightning illuminated the room. Seconds later a heavy rain fell.
“Guess we should get some sleep if we’re going into town tomorrow,” said Shaun.
****
Sarah was restless, turning from one side of her body to the other. The storm had woken her and rattled the windows and doors for an hour before moving on east. Her body was sore, but she believed what Shaun had told her about the next time and her thinking she was in Heaven. These two men had already found a place in her heart and she trusted and believed whatever they told her. She found them waiting by the wagon when she headed out the next morning. Shaun held her hand and helped her get into the back. She hadn’t ridden in it since the day she’d arrived. Today she’d sit back and look at the scenery.
“You sleep okay?” Jon asked her. “The storm was pretty wild.”
“It woke me but I got back to sleep.”
She didn’t want him to know she’d thought about what had happened between them last night and how sore her pussy was after he’d made love to her. Today she felt better, and refreshed. The first day as a real woman.
The wagon hit a bump and she held on to her hat as some mud that had formed in the night splashed upward.
They passed other homesteads and soon crossed over a stream. The town of Grantsville came into view. It was obvious it hadn’t rained hard there because the streets were dusty with not a puddle in sight.
“We’ll let you roam the general store while we load up on supplies for the horses,” said Jon.
She knew what they wanted and that they’d need double amounts now that Shaun would be eating with them every day.
The bell over the door rang and several women turned to look at her.
“Good morning,” she said.
“Morning to you. Are you new in town?” asked an older lady.
“I am. I arrived last week. I’m living at the Nolan homestead.”
“You and your husband is it?” asked another lady.
“Yes, that’s right.”
She’d never told a huge lie like that ever, but she didn’t think people would be prepared for hearing that she was living with two men, neither of whom she was married to.
“There’s a ladies' social club if
you care to join us. We have a sewing night once a month.”
“I do love to sew.”
“Well, then we’ll probably see you there.”
They both left, talking and glancing over their shoulder at her as they went out of the door.
“And what can I get for you Mrs. Nolan,” said the storekeeper.
Mrs. Nolan, if they only knew.
“I need some flour, some dried beans, and sugar if you have them.”
“I most certainly do. If you’d like to follow me I can get that order for you straight away.”
Sarah glanced out the window of the store. The two women she’d just met were now standing there with two more ladies, all four of which were peeking inside at her.
“Curious bunch the ladies of Grantsville. They can smell a newcomer miles away,” said the storekeeper.
****
Jon put his face up to the sky and leaned against the wagon. He felt good this morning. His body was in a relaxed state of mind, probably because he’d had sex for the first time in forever. He’d forgotten how good it made a man feel to be inside a woman and find a pleasant release.
It had been that and a whole lot more with Sarah. He heard footsteps and looked up to see Sarah on the other side of the street. She looked more beautiful than she had the first time he’d set eyes upon her at the station. Today she had her hair piled up on her head and a straw hat perched on the front. She had a certain glow to her. She’d have a permanent glow once she got to enjoy sex. The pleasures of the flesh and her own joyful release.
Shaun ran up beside her. Jon smiled. He’d been surprised how open he’d been to the idea of sharing Sarah. She was supposed to be his wife and only his, but the day by the lake had changed all that. It was obvious the three of them were supposed to be together in a wonderful relationship. He doubted there were other such unions around town, but somewhere in the world other trios were enjoying the same thing. He was sure of it. What did the French call it? Ménage a trois. That sounded so sexy, so romantic.
“And what are you smiling at?” asked Shaun when they arrived back at the wagon.
“Just thinking what a perfect day it is.”
Sarah handed him the grocery supplies which he put in the back of the wagon before helping her up into the back. Shaun jumped up into the front and soon Jon was steering it back along the trail to their houses.
“I’ve been invited to join the women’s social group and to go along to their sewing evening,” said Sarah.
“I have some pants that need mending if you want to take those,” said Jon.
“I don’t think it’s that sort of sewing, is it?” asked Shaun.
“I’m not sure but I guess I’ll find out. You two could ride with me into town and enjoy a boy’s night out at the saloon while I sew.”
“I like the sound of that,” said Jon.
Yeah, he liked the sound of it a whole lot.
****
Sarah washed the last of dinner plates and felt both Jon and Shaun creep up beside her. One stood to her left, the other to her right. They both kissed her neck and side of her face.
“You have been working so hard since we got back from town,” whispered Jon. “We think you deserve a treat.”
Jon began to unbutton the top of her dress while Shaun went to the floor and put his hands under its hem. As Jon reached inside the top of her petticoat, and ran his fingers over her right nipple, Shaun worked his hands up her calves and then to her inner thighs. She instinctively parted them, sensing what he was going to do. He pulled down her undergarments, allowing them to drop onto her boots and then walked his fingers up her legs and into her folds.
Jon pulled on her nipple and kissed her as Shaun circled her clit. She drew in her breath, feeling herself growing wet and excited. He pressed harder as Jon pushed his tongue over her lips. It dueled with her own, masking a slight murmur that escaped her mouth as Shaun applied more pressure and speed.
It felt so good that it was borderline sinful and she almost bit Jon’s lip when she found her release. Quickly holding on to the edge of the table she felt Jon picking her up and carrying her with Shaun by his side. He placed her on the bed and before she knew what had happened she was naked and Shaun and Jon were stripping off and joining her.
“We’re going to lavish so much love on you, you won’t be able to stand it,” said Shaun, running his hand over her curls as Jon buried his finger deep within her. She felt more relaxed tonight, no longer scared. He tickled her pussy, making her want to bring her legs up.
“You want Shaun to be inside you tonight?” Jon asked her.
She glanced down at him kneeling on the bottom of the bed, his cock hard, pulsing, and so beautiful.
She nodded and soon he was between her thighs about to enter her. She waited for the pain, but tonight there was none as he slipped deep within her. Jon lay beside her holding her hand as Shaun began thrusting inside her.
“Just relax, honey doll and I know you’ll have lots of pleasure,” said Jon pulling her hand up to his mouth and kissing the back of it.
Pleasure is what she sought tonight. She squeezed Jon’s hand, sensing that she needed to lift her body off the bed to press into Shaun’s hips. He thrust harder as she did so and the room began to spin. Her pussy quivered, feeling something similar to the sensation she’d had when they’d touched her clit.
She mumbled something even she didn’t understand as her thighs shook and her pussy pulled, and she sensed she was growing wetter. And then it happened. She cried out at the top of her voice.
Dear lord, oh my.
Jon raised her hand and kissed it again.
“You’ve had your first taste of pleasure,” he said as she felt warmth spreading within her pussy. She guessed that Shaun too had found his release.
He pulled out, flopped onto the side of the bed beside her, his breathing labored, perspiration dripping down the side of his face.
Jon pulled her up on top of him before lifting his cock.
“Sit down on it and go for a ride like you would when you’re on a horse.”
Her legs wobbled at first and she finally managed to get him inside her and sat down on his thighs. He was deep within her and it felt so good.
“I’ve never ridden a horse before,” she said.
“Then it’s something we’ll have to teach you along with lots of other stuff. For now just raise your buttocks up and down so you slide on my cock,” said Jon.
She did exactly what he said, eyeing Shaun. She knew he was checking out her breasts as they bounced up and down.
Jon lifted his body upward, making her bounce faster and harder. Her breasts beat against her body, her nipples growing hard as her pussy squeezed Jon’s cock.
They’d been right, this did seem like Heaven. She cried out as her climax washed over her and she fell on top of Jon as he too found release.
He wrapped his arms around her and then let her slide over to his side where he and Shaun sandwiched her, wrapping their arms tightly around her, making her feel special. Making her feel safe.
Chapter Seven
Shaun woke up to find Sarah’s leg entwined with his. Both she and Jon were still asleep. The bed wasn’t really big enough for all three of them, but they’d somehow made it work. The sun was up and peeking through the curtains which meant they’d slept later than usual.
Sarah had beautiful porcelain skin. He couldn’t help himself. He reached out and touched her thigh. Felt soft and silky too. She stirred, twitched her nose, and then opened her eyes.
“Good morning,” he said.
“Morning.”
“It’s going to be a lovely day. Sun’s up already.”
He ran his fingers down her thigh making him suddenly hard. He turned onto his back hoping she could see what she did to his body.
She glanced at his cock, wrapping her hand around it without being asked.
“That feels mighty nice,” he said.
Jon chose that moment to wake u
p. He glanced at Sarah and then where her hand was.
“You getting a lesson on how to please us with your hands?” he asked, rolling onto his back.
“That sounds like a good way to start the day,” said Shaun.
Sarah knelt between them and grabbed Jon’s cock too.
“Okay, just run your hands up and down our shafts,” said Jon.
Shaun put his hand behind this head and relaxed. He glanced over at Jon, who was doing the same.
“You want to have a contest, see who can come first?” asked Shaun.
“Sure. I bet I do.” Shaun saw him wink at Sarah.
“And I bet I do, my cock’s been harder longer than yours, and that sweet left hand of honey doll’s is edging me closer to heaven.”
“Boys will be boys,” said Sarah.
“She’s a quick learner because those hands know how to thrill me,” said Jon.
“Stop talking, I’m trying to concentrate so I can beat you.”
“In your dreams,” said Jon.
Shaun focused on Sarah’s breasts as they bobbed up and down as she moved her hands faster over their shafts.
Lordy lordy, she had some strong fingers on her. Just right for loving a man. His cock twitched, his balls grew heavy, and oohwee, he came big time.
“I’m the winner,” he said.
“Come on Jon, you have some catching up to do,” said Sarah, moving her hand faster until he too finally found release.
“Guess neither of us will be any good to our honey doll for a while, so I think we should return the favor,” said Shaun.
He grabbed Sarah and turned her over onto her back, spreading her legs apart as both he and Jon pressed their fingers inside her.
“Getting us all excited like that must have been thrilling for you too,” said Shaun, feeling how tight and wet she was.
She rested her legs over each of their calves, opening herself up some more for them.
“Whose finger’s going to make you come faster?” asked Jon.
“Okay, guys that’s enough competition for the day,” she said.
Shaun pressed deeper, harder, making her squirm. Jon matched him causing Sarah to groan and then cry out when she came.
“Which one of us caused that?” asked Shaun.
Shaun and Jon Page 4