“Yeah. I know.” He let out a heavy sigh, took an audible breath. “But before I tell you anything, I need you to promise me that it stays between us.”
Hardy narrowed his eyes, cocked his head. “Do you know who killed Mooney and Laura?”
“No. But I know something. I just don’t know what it might mean, if anything. I almost told you at the end of our talk today. And maybe I should have, but then Wagner would have known, too, and he might have felt like he had to go to my parents. Anyway, then tonight I couldn’t get it out of my mind, that I should have told you. I’m not even sure it matters, but there are things about it that definitely matter a lot to other people. And to me. Personal things. Do you know what I’m saying?”
“I don’t mean to be dense, Steven. But you have my word that whatever it is, I’ll keep it between us. How’s that?”
Another sigh. “It just seemed like you really might believe that Andrew didn’t do any of this.”
Hardy finessed that admission, which was still just slightly too strong. “I believe that somebody else might have come to Mooney’s while Andrew was on his walk. If that’s true, I’m trying to find out who, or why, or both.”
“Okay. What if I told you . . . and this is the thing I was talking about, the secret. What if I told you that Mr. Mooney was gay?”
The perverse obviousness of it brought a lightness to Hardy’s head. He’d been standing by the fireplace, and now he crossed the room and sat down on the ottoman by his reading chair. “Then I’d say he did a good job of keeping it hidden.”
“Yes, he did. That was on purpose. Do you know his father?”
“I’ve met him. Yes.”
“Well, Mike loved him more . . . more than almost anything, I think. He couldn’t let him find out, his dad. It would have broken his heart. He couldn’t have dealt with it.”
“The dad, the Christian minister, couldn’t have dealt with it?”
“The Southern Baptist minister. Right.”
“How is that possible? I mean, this is San Francisco in the two thousands. Mooney’s dad must have seen hundreds of people come out.”
“Yeah, but not his own son. Not Michael. And he isn’t a San Francisco minister, putting together an AIDS quilt. He’s a nice enough man, I guess, but his church is down on the Peninsula, and his brand of preaching is, uh, more conservative. The sons and daughters of Gomorrah being turned into salt, and rightfully so. I’ve heard him.” Steve pitched his voice differently. “ ‘Homosexuality is always sin, and always a choice. It’s not a matter of genetics, as some would have us believe, but a degenerate lifestyle for those unfortunate people who can muster neither the strength nor the grace to reject it.’ Straight out of the fifties, huh? And that’s Michael’s dad. Still.”
But Michael’s dad or no, Hardy immediately saw the incalculable strategic value of this information for Andrew. If he could bring it out at the hearing—or the trial if it got to that point—then all he and Wu would have to do would be to keep their defendant from testifying, which was always the defense’s option. Meanwhile, the jury would naturally assume, especially in San Francisco, that Andrew and everyone else at Sutro knew that Mooney was gay. This would, in turn, eliminate the prosecution’s primary motive of jealousy.
It would also not only open up an alternative theory of the crime—the “soddit,” or “some other dude did it” defense—but also allow Hardy and Wu to question the original police investigation that had resulted in Andrew’s arrest. They certainly should have interviewed people from this aspect of Mooney’s life; a failure to even identify Mooney as gay must surely argue for a shoddily handled case from the outset. If Hardy could then get Salarco’s no gunshot testimony and even a hint of a hedge on the eyewitness identification, his client stood at least a chance of a hung jury, then maybe a plea on a lesser charge. This was very, very big news.
If it were in fact true.
If he could get it in front of a judge or a jury.
And, most importantly, if it wasn’t merely hearsay. “Steven,” Hardy said, “I’ve got to ask you this question, and I think I already know the answer, but in the eyes of the law there’s a big difference between someone hearing about a fact and someone experiencing that fact with their own senses. Did you and Mr. Mooney have a relationship?”
Steven needed to take a while with his answer and Hardy was content to let him. “Yes,” he finally said.
With that one word, Hardy’s entire view of Mike Mooney underwent a complete transformation. If he was in fact having sex with one of his students—male or female, Hardy didn’t care—then he was not the caring and sensitive soul most people took him for. He was a predator. “Would you be willing to testify to that in court?” he asked.
But Hardy couldn’t let his reaction slow him down. This was critical information, and though the bare fact of it filled him with outrage toward Mooney, he had no choice but to find a way to use it.
Hardy couldn’t imagine why, but the question actually seemed to both surprise and frighten him. He thought another moment, then shook his head. “No.”
“Why not?”
“I mean, not unless it’s your very last chance to save Andrew by itself, and I don’t see how it could get to be that. That’s why I asked you to promise before I told you.”
“Okay, but I’ve still got the same question. Why not?”
Randell met his gaze with a steady one of his own. “Are you bullshitting me?”
“No. What would I be bullshitting you about?”
“Why I won’t testify.” He choked off a bitter laugh. “Because I’m not out, Mr. Hardy, I’m not out.”
“Okay.”
“And I’m not going to be out while I’m still at Sutro. There’s no way.”
Hardy was leaning forward, his elbows on his knees. “Would it be that bad? I always thought if you were gay, this was the town to be in.”
“Maybe for older guys, but don’t be a gay teenager. You’ll get slaughtered. You want to hear a story?”
“Sure.”
“I had this friend, Tony Hollis, you can look him up. He came out last year and got beaten up by cruisers in Noe Valley four times in six months, whenever any prowling group of teenage straights got bored. Then I guess Tony got bored with that and took a bottle of pills.” He took a minute collecting himself. “So, no, I’m not saying anything in public. And you promised you wouldn’t, either. If you do, I’ll deny it. And that goes for Mooney, too.”
“What do you mean, it goes for Mooney, too?”
“You promised you wouldn’t tell about him.”
“Yes, but that was . . .” Hardy paused. “I’m not sure I understand why that is so important now, after he’s dead.”
“For the same reason it was while he was alive. He didn’t want his father to know. It was, like, the most important thing to him. He lived this whole secret life to keep the truth from his old man. If he didn’t want to cause him that pain, how am I supposed to let it happen? I can’t do it. When you were talking to me today, you said if I knew anything, I should come forward and do the right thing. Well, I’ve come forward, but letting you tell his father about Mike wouldn’t be right at all.”
“So then maybe you can tell me how am I supposed to use this information? If I can’t let it come out.”
“I don’t know. That’s not my problem.” He stood up, a good kid awkward with playing the heavy, and now suddenly anxious to get away from what he’d already done. “Look, I’m sorry, I really am, but I just thought it was important that I tell you, so you’d know what you were really dealing with.”
“Don’t get me wrong, Steven. I really do appreciate that, but . . .”
The young man cut him off. “But what you do with it is up to you.”
Hardy sat in his reading chair for a couple of minutes, pondering. Then he rose and walked back up through the dining room into the kitchen. In the dark and empty family room, he stopped to gaze at his tropical fish for a moment of centering and peaceful reflection.
He turned on the room’s lights, then knocked on his children’s bedroom doors at the same time—perpendicular to each other.
“Just a second!”
“I’m doing homework!”
He knocked again. “I need to see both of you right this minute please.”
The familiar grumblings ensued, but he heard movement from inside both rooms. By the time the first door opened and the Beck appeared, he was standing out in the middle of the family room, hands in his pockets, relaxed and casual. Vincent opened his own door, saw his sister pouting, looked to his dad. Having a hunch what might be coming, he wiped all traces of his own bad attitude from his face. He asked helpfully, “What’s up?”
Hardy gave them a full ten seconds of low-grade glare, then finally spoke in the calmest voice he could muster. “I don’t know if it’s escaped your attention or not, but your mother is upstairs in bed, pretty beat up. And while I realize that the critical schoolwork you’re both working on so diligently is far more important than the job I work at to keep us fed and clothed, I don’t think it’s asking too much for both of you to contribute toward the smooth running of the household when I’m, for example, busy on the telephone. And let me say I’m just a tad disappointed that I have to mention this to people of your ages, to whom it should already be, and I thought was, second nature. But clearly I was wrong.”
He paused for a moment, made eye contact with both of them. “So here’s the deal. Whenever the doorbell or the telephone rings and either your mother or I, or both of us, ask if one or even both of you could please get up and answer it, I don’t want to hear about your homework, and I don’t want to be told to wait even for a second. I want you both to jump and even race to see who can get to it the fastest.
“And whoever does get there first, I expect you to extend to whoever it is the kind of hospitality that you would expect to receive in the home of a civilized person. For example, Vincent, you don’t leave a guest who asks for someone in this house by name standing out on the porch in the cold. And beyond that, if it’s an adult you don’t know, you look him in the eye, shake his hand and introduce yourself. Then you invite whoever it is in and even—I know this can be grueling—engage that person in small talk and make him or her feel comfortable until the member of this household that he requested makes an appearance. Does any of this sound remotely familiar to you? Have we ever talked about this before?”
Rebecca tossed her hair. “If this is just Vincent, Dad, I’ve got homework I need—”
Hardy wheeled on her and cut her off. “As a matter of fact, my dear, it’s not just about Vincent. Your homework is not an automatic pass on the normal duties of citizenship around here. Vincent has homework, too. Believe it or not, even your father has homework from time to time, like tonight. Relatively important homework. Your mother never stops having homework. So homework is not an excuse to opt out of your duties as a citizen in this house. Is that clear?”
She drew a pained, audible breath. It hit Hardy very wrong. “And while we’re on these special moments of politeness, I’d really prefer not to see your theatrical sighs or, Vin, your looks of obvious displeasure. We all live here together. We’ve all got things we need to do. So we respect each other, we cooperate, we use nice manners to each other and to our guests.” He looked from his son to his daughter and back again. “Is there anything about what I’ve just said that either of you don’t understand? Vincent?”
His son was leaning against the doorjamb, downcast. He shook his head no.
“Vincent,” Hardy repeated. “Look at me. In the eyes. Good. Is there something about what I just said that you don’t understand?”
“No.”
“No what?”
“No, sir.”
“That’s the right answer. Rebecca?”
“No, sir. I’m sorry.”
“Even better.” Hardy turned as the phone started to ring in the kitchen. “Don’t either of you trouble yourselves,” he said. “I’ll get that.”
“I usually wouldn’t call this late,” Glitsky said, “but your phone was busy last time I called so I figured you might still be up. How’s Frannie?”
“Sleeping, I hope, if she’s not lacing up her track shoes. But that’s not why you called.”
“No.”
“Are you waiting for me to beg?”
“No. You’ll never believe what we think we found out about the Executioner.”
“Don’t tell me he’s a redheaded dwarf.”
“He might be,” Glitsky said. “But he may also be using a silencer.”
“Still on silencers.”
“We didn’t have anything else, so I sent out half of homicide to ask around in Twin Peaks. Between the two killings, we talked to twenty-one citizens who were nearby—just like with Boscacci—and nobody heard a thing. Elizabeth Cary’s neighborhood, too. Remember her? Nobody on the whole cul-de-sac, and all of them were home. Nothing.”
“So what are you saying. These were all this Executioner?”
“That’s the working theory. In any event, you get four shots in high-density areas and nobody hears anything, something’s a little funny.”
Hardy didn’t really agree. It was a noisy city, and people were so inured to near-constant aural assault that he thought a gunshot could easily go unremarked. Nevertheless, though he wasn’t ready to mention it to Abe yet, when the time came he might be tempted to call his friend to the stand as a witness in the Andrew Bartlett matter, where the actual sound of the gunshots was the proverbial dog that barked in the nighttime.
Another alternative theory presenting itself, another ball in the air.
But something entirely different struck him. “Wait a minute,” he said. “Did you say Boscacci? What’s this got to do with him? You think this guy shot him, too?”
“I don’t know,” Glitsky said. “But it is tantalizing, don’t you think?”
“That they all might be connected? Sure. But you’ve got to admit, it’s not much to go on—something people didn’t hear, especially a shot, which most people think is a backfire if it registers at all. I’ll bet most of ’em didn’t hear tinkling sounds either, and that doesn’t mean Tinker Bell did it.”
“You sound like Treya.”
“There are worse people to sound like.”
“Granted. But it’s not all fairy dust. I called down to the lab again, and asked them to physically check Allan’s slug. The tech couldn’t get a ballistics match with the Twin Peaks slugs—they were too deformed—but he did get to eyeball identical scuff marks on rounds of identical caliber. He couldn’t swear to it in court, maybe, but his bet is it’s the same gun, silenced.”
“Maybe,” Hardy said, “though if he couldn’t swear to it in court, which last time I checked was where we had to do these things . . .” But he didn’t mean to bust Abe’s chops. “Anyway, it does sound like you’re getting somewhere,” he said, “but if you’d told me you’d found something with the other victims about that jury the Cary woman sat on, maybe Allan was the prosecutor on the same case, then I’m thinking you might—”
“That’s it!” Glitsky’s voice crackled with a rare enthusiasm. “What I forgot. Thanks.”
“Don’t mention it,” Hardy said, but he was talking to a dial tone.
28
Though it had suddenly taken on a much higher profile, Hardy’s professional life wasn’t all, or even mostly, Andrew Bartlett. First thing Tuesday morning, he had another appointment with Clarence Jackman, so he didn’t even check in at the office, but drove directly to the Hall of Justice, parked in the All-Day where Boscacci had been shot, and was talking to the DA at 8:30 sharp.
The issue they were discussing was a theory called “provocative act murder,” where the person charged with the crime had not killed the victim. Instead, the theory went, the person charged had done something so “inherently likely to cause a violent response” that they were legally responsible for the murder.
There were two classic examples. The firs
t was when somebody goes in to rob a liquor store, pulls a gun on the proprietor, and the proprietor pulls his own weapon out from behind the counter and shoots, missing the robber but accidentally killing a bystander. The proprietor in this case is completely blameless, where the robber might be charged with provocative act murder. The second example is a scenario where two drug dealers get in a shoot-out, and one of them grabs an innocent person, using that person as a human shield, who is then killed by a shot from the other drug dealer’s gun. In this case, while the second drug dealer might be guilty of murder, too, the person who grabbed the human shield in the first place, though he didn’t fire the lethal shot, could be charged in the death.
In the case Hardy was arguing, his client was Leila Madison, the mother of a fourteen-year-old boy named Jamahl Madison, who’d gone with a gang of four of his homies to rob the apartment of one of their neighbors. Hardy had gotten connected to Leila because she was the cleaning lady of another of his clients. Besides Jamahl, she had three other children under the age of ten, all of whom lived with her own mother in Bayside. It was a horrible, all-too-common situation, now aggravated by Jackman’s initial decision to charge Jamahl as an adult with the provocative act murder of his friend Damon. Jamahl had not shot Damon. In fact, the apartment owner, while the gang was fleeing from the robbery, had taken some shots at all of them, and had wounded Jamahl and killed Damon.
And again, as had been his habit lately, Hardy wasn’t planning to take the case to trial. He was facilitating. Though his heart didn’t go out to poor Jamahl, it did to the boy’s mother, and he’d taken five hundred dollars, donated by Leila’s boss, to see if he could persuade Jackman that in this case, provocative act murder wasn’t the right call.
“. . . if he were even, say, seventeen, Clarence. But the boy’s only fourteen. He’s gotten his own stupid ass shot already and lost his best friend. I’ve got to believe that’s going to make an impression that maybe it’s not a good idea to rob people.”
Jackman, behind his desk, seemed to be enjoying the exchange. “So would thirty or forty in the can, Diz. Time he gets out, I’ll bet he’s lost his taste for it entirely.” He spread his hands on his desk. “My question to you is do you honestly think he’s going to change, ever?”
The Second Chair Page 34