I placed a second sheet next to the first, the list of Ellen’s secret destinations, and tried to still the shuddering in my chest. “This is Ellen’s. You were in the same city with her fifteen times out of a possible fifteen different occasions.” I pulled the wrinkled page from my back pocket and smoothed it on the desk. Spots appeared like raindrops as my tears fell onto the page, bleeding into the paper, smearing the black ink as I read Ellen’s note one more time.
… I feel myself going under again, and the only thing that keeps my head above water is the motion of reaching up for him. And I can’t let go. Because when I’m with him, I exist. Without him, I’m afraid I’ll disappear. Disappear to a place where God can’t save me and I can’t save myself.
I laid it on the desk in front of him. “She wrote that about you.”
He never looked at the second schedule. He never looked at Ellen’s note. He looked at me. He fixed his gaze on me and wouldn’t let go. “What are you trying to say, Alex?”
“I don’t have to say anything, Bill.” I reached across the desk to the answering machine and started the tape.
The voices had the hollow, tinny quality of a cheap answering machine, but there was no mistaking Ellen’s voice with that light Southern accent, still so unexpected to me. The tape was queued up right where I’d left it, at the point where Ellen was talking, her words tumbling out in a torrent of anguish and pain.
“Crescent Consulting. I know you remember this. We paid them hundreds of thousands of dollars. I signed the invoices. Crescent Con—”
“Crescent Consulting. I get it.” Bill’s voice was a stark contrast—calm, rational, a little irritated underneath the clicking and popping of the static. He must have been in his car. “What about it?”
“It was a sham. Nothing more than a bank account that Lenny used for kickbacks. You knew about this, Bill. You had to have known.”
“Let’s not talk about this right now. I’m on a cell phone.”
“We’re talking about this now.” She sounded panicked, almost hysterical. “Don’t you dare hang up on me.”
“All right, all right. Why would you say something like that?”
“Because of the special signature authority. All that garbage about how much you trusted me. You set me up. The only reason you had me request a higher limit was so that you wouldn’t have to sign those invoices. Every single invoice from Crescent you forwarded to me. Every one. You knew, Bill”—she was fighting back tears—“and I can’t believe you did this to me.”
Finally, she couldn’t hold on anymore, and her voice dissolved into sobs, mighty, rolling sobs. As soon as one stopped, another one started, and I knew that they had come from someplace deep because when I had cried with her this morning the first time I’d heard this tape, the pain had come out of my whole body, through every part of me. It sounded like—felt like—a thousand years’ worth of holding in.
When she’d cried herself out, there was silence, and then Bill’s voice, gentle and soothing. “I thought it was better if you didn’t know.”
“Do you think anyone is going to believe that I didn’t know?”
“Ellen, you didn’t do anything wrong. I’m the one who screwed up, and I’ll protect you.”
“Tell me what you did. Tell me what you’ve gotten me involved in.”
“Back when we were working on the Nor’easter deal, Lenny came to me with this idea that we wouldn’t have to wait for the vote … that he had some way of buying off the IBG—”
“He didn’t just buy the contract vote, Bill. He used the money to cover up this crash, this—the real cause of an aircraft accident, for God’s sake. We gave him that money, Majestic did, you and me, and my name is all over—” She stopped as if she still couldn’t believe the words that were coming out of her mouth. “That Nor’easter Beechcraft that went down in 1995 … I’ve got this surveillance tape, this … these documents that Dickie Flynn had put away in the ceiling. It wasn’t the pilots. It wasn’t their fault. It was Little Pete Dwyer, and Dickie Flynn, and Lenny—”
“Do you have this package?”
“It’s right here in my hands, and I don’t … I think I need to take it to someone. I can’t—Oh, God, Bill, don’t ask me—”
“No, you’re right, we need to get it to the right people. Let me just think for a minute. ”
“Tell me … one thing,” Ellen said, pleading. “Tell me that you didn’t know about this crash, that it was only this IBG contract business that you knew about.”
He didn’t hesitate. “I knew absolutely nothing about it. I swear to you. And if Lenny did what you’re saying he did, I’ll have his ass.”
“Thank God, Bill. Thank God.”
“We have to take this package forward. All I’m going to ask is that you hold off for a day or so until I can get out there. I want to sit down with you. I want … it’s important to me that I get a chance to explain it to you. I want you to understand. And I want you to help me figure out what to do, Ellen. We can get through this together.”
There was no response.
“Ellen, listen to me. Don’t think about what you’re going to say to me next. Just listen. Are you listening?”
I was listening, and my knees felt weak, knowing what was coming next.
“I am in love with you, Ellen. I am hopelessly, desperately, pathetically in love with you, and I don’t want to live my life without you in it. I’m not going to let anything happen to you, Ellen. Don’t you know that?”
I turned off the tape.
My hands started to shake and tears streamed down my face. I had listened to that bit of tape over and over. There was nothing on that tape that I hadn’t already heard. But listening to it with him, watching his face as he listened to himself deceiving Ellen, using the same line on her that he had used on me, was almost more than I could bear. Any expression, any reaction at all from him might have given me at least a seed of doubt, if that’s what I’d wanted. But when he looked up at me, his face was stone. When he looked at me, I felt him measuring my resolve, wondering what it would take to get me to back down, and calculating his risk if I wouldn’t. That was the moment when I knew that it was true—that it could be true. All of it.
“It was you,” I said, backing away, taking one step, then another until I was up against the opposite wall, as far away from him as I could be in the cramped office. “You were Lenny’s partner on the inside, not Ellen. You were the one who stole the money, and you used her to shield yourself, you bastard.” The words came pouring out, searing the back of my throat and making my eyes burn. “You knew about the crash from the beginning. You knew that she would eventually figure it out, and you knew that she would take that evidence forward. You were the one who had Ellen killed, not Lenny. It was you.”
His only reaction was to look down and touch Ellen’s note, brushing his fingertips across her words, thinking, perhaps, that he could make them disappear. A tiny smile formed on his lips. “Ellen always did have a flair for the dramatic.”
I felt my body begin to collapse in on itself, felt the four walls disappear and the world drop away until it was just the two of us standing in a barren wasteland, barren as far as I could see. And I knew that I was looking at the life that I’d made for myself, and when I looked again, I was alone, desperately alone.
He walked over to the window and stood with his hands deep in his pockets, rocking up and down on the balls of his feet. “That must have been some storm last night. It had mostly blown itself out by the time we landed.”
I watched him, stared at the side of his face as he squinted into the bright sun.
“Have you seen the video?” he asked, in a tone that can only be described as jaunty.
“Last night,” I whispered, leaning against the wall for support. “I saw it last night.”
“I’ve never seen it. I imagine that it is quite extraordinary. I suppose I’ll see it now. Everyone will, won’t they?”
When he turned toward me, th
e light was coming from behind him and I couldn’t see his face, but his manner was as smooth as ever and I knew that he was grinning. I could hear it in his voice. His tone wasn’t flippant exactly, just light, and very, very confident.
It pissed me off.
“Why do you suppose she left it here that night?”
“Maybe she got smart and decided she didn’t trust you after all.”
“I have some ideas about that video,” he said, “Would you like to hear them?”
“No.” I pushed myself away from the wall and slowly made my way back to my desk. When I got there, I leaned over it, using both arms to support myself.
“What did you tell the authorities?” he asked quietly.
“I told them what I knew at the time.”
“Which was what?”
“That on the night of March 15, 1995, Little Pete Dwyer worked Flight 1704 under the influence of alcohol, and his negligence caused that plane to go down. I told them that the incident had been recorded on a surveillance tape from beginning to end and that, as a part of a cover-up, Dickie Flynn, Big Pete Dwyer, and Lenny Caseaux stole that tape and altered official company documents. I told them that it was my belief that Dickie and another man, Angelo DiBiasi, were paid ten thousand dollars each to keep quiet about what they knew. I told them that Lenny Caseaux would have done anything to keep the sale of Nor’easter on track so that he could cash out his stock and become a rich man.”
I stopped for a breath, but my lungs wouldn’t fill. He was closer now and I could see his face, could almost see the wheels turning as he listened, sifting the facts, and pulling out what he needed.
“What else?”
“I told them that the money for these payoffs and others was embezzled from Majestic Airlines, that Lenny had an accomplice working inside, and that that person was Ellen Shepard.”
I paused again as I remembered talking to the troopers just hours ago, how sure I had been about Ellen, how wrong I had been.
“She threatened Lenny with exposure,” I said, my voice fading, “and he had her killed. Little Pete killed her.” I sat down in my chair, suddenly exhausted. “That’s what I told them.”
“This is why Lenny is in custody.”
“Lenny is in custody because his name is all over Dickie Flynn’s package of evidence, along with both Dwyers, Dickie himself, and Angelo.” The late Angelo. Another pang of guilt. The thought of him lying on that bag belt came back to me, and I knew that he was dead, too, because of Bill, that Bill had tipped Lenny off with information that I had given him, just as he must have told him about John McTavish. I’d told him enough that he’d figured out that John was the source. I’d blamed Dan, but I had been the leak.
“Did they believe you?”
“Why wouldn’t they? I was very convincing.”
“I’m sure you were. Is that all you’re going to tell them?”
I plucked his travel schedule off the desk and held it up. “Are you asking me if I am going to tell them that it was not Lenny who arranged Ellen’s murder? That you were the one she was expecting the night that she died? That you sent Little Pete in your place to murder her?”
His neck stiffened. “I never even met this Little Pete character.”
“Of course not. That would be stupid, and we know that you’re not stupid.” I dropped the page back on the desk. “That’s what Lenny was there for, to do all the dirty work. You gave him your key to Ellen’s house. You gave him the security code, and you made sure that Ellen would be home that night waiting for you. Then you booked yourself on a flight to Europe and waited for news that she was dead.”
“It sounds rather elegant,” he mused, “when you put it all together like that, clearly thought out.”
“You’re saying it wasn’t?”
He regarded me with a wistful smile, looking disappointed that I might think ill of him. “Do you know how much the stock price has appreciated since I started running this airline? Three hundred and fifty percent. Three hundred and fifty percent, and it was the Nor’easter deal that put us over the top. That deal was the last missing piece, and do you want to know the irony?”
He slipped onto the corner of the desk and rested there, half standing, half sitting. He picked up a dish of paper clips and seemed to find it fascinating. “All this business here in Boston, none of it made any difference. Looking back, the Nor’easter deal was going to happen anyway. Lenny takes credit for the contract failing, but it’s my bet the thing would have sunk under its own weight anyway. It was all for nothing.” He took one of the clips out and studied it, turning it over in his hand.
He dropped the clip into the bowl, put the bowl on the desk, and went back to the window, where he stood with his arms crossed. “A strange thing happens when you operate for any length of time at this level and particularly if you achieve any measure of success, which I have. You start to feel that you can’t do anything wrong, that whatever you do is right just because you want to do it.” He turned slightly. “Silly, isn’t it? And extravagantly arrogant. But you need to be to get where I am.” He waited a beat, then came back to the desk and stood across from me. “I convinced myself that I was the only one who could save this company. And Nor’easter. At one time it wasn’t clear that the contract would fail, and I thought it best not to risk it. What was a couple of hundred thousand dollars against all the jobs I saved? The tremendous wealth I created?”
“What about Ellen?”
He sniffed and with studied nonchalance glanced down and straightened the crease in his slacks. “You never plan for people to get hurt. That’s one of the variables you can’t predict. But things get … distorted. Once you’re in, you’re in. When a problem comes up, the only question that matters is, can you think your way around it? Are you smart enough?” He shrugged. “Ellen was a problem. She was going to be, anyway.”
I stared at him. His tone was absolutely flat. We could have been analyzing a business deal gone bad.
“It’s unfortunate,” he said, “but Ellen was pulled into this whole affair by that drunken bastard Dickie Flynn, the self-serving son of a bitch.” He looked at me and laughed as if he were relating a funny story that he was sure I would find amusing also. “Can you imagine saving that tape the way he did, then dumping it on poor Ellen? And Lenny, trying to cover up a damn plane crash with all those nitwits involved. The thing was flawed right from the beginning.”
“You would have been smarter about it, no doubt.”
“I never would have tried to cover up negligence. They told me after the fact, after it was too late, but in that situation you have to go public in a big way because there are too many people involved. And the risk if you’re exposed is too great. You have to deal with it head-on, diffuse the risk, take away all the leverage. That’s why this videocassette is so powerful for us. Do you see?”
“No.”
“That video will be run over and over on every newscast, every news magazine, every cheap tabloid reality program. You can’t buy that kind of exposure. So you ask yourself, how do you use that? You make an immediate disclosure, at which point you announce a very well-thought-out program of complete cooperation with the authorities, comprehensive safety reviews, and enhanced operating procedures. You prove to everyone that the people responsible have been dealt with, sternly, and—this is very important—you meet with the families of the victims face-to-face. In fact, you’d like to do that before you go public. And every time you open your mouth to talk about it, you tie the crash to Nor’easter and the response to Majestic. Pretty soon all people will remember is Majestic’s great response.” He smiled again. “Most people, Alex, are waiting to be told what to think.”
“You already have a plan.”
“I always have a plan.”
“And where am I in this plan?”
“Don’t you know?” He looked at me with those hotter-than-the-sun eyes beneath those long, lush eyelashes. Then he began to move around to my side of the desk. I stood up, b
acked away, and kept going until I felt the wall again against my shoulder blades.
“Don’t I know what? That you are hopelessly, desperately, pathetically in love with me?”
He seemed to be floating toward me, moving without walking, immune to the natural forces that tethered the rest of us to this earth. I could have moved away, but there was really no place to go. He was going to keep coming until he’d had a chance to play his final hand.
“I told you what I thought you needed to hear, that’s all. I should have told you the truth.”
The smell of rum surrounded me like a seedy cloud, but as he moved toward me, ever so slowly, his scent was stronger.
“What is the truth?”
“We’re good together. That’s the only truth there is, Alex, the only one that matters.” He was very close now, and I could feel his whisper as much as I could hear it. “You wanted me the other night as much as I wanted you, and nothing that’s happened since has changed that. I want you right now. I want you so bad I can taste it. And you want me, too.”
I needed to be angry, and I was. I needed to hate him, and I did. But I could also feel his breath in my hair. I could feel the heat through his clean cotton shirt, feel the flush beneath my own clothes. I could hear his breathing grow shallow, more ragged as he got closer.
“As far as the police are concerned,” he said, “what you told them is exactly the way it happened. Lenny paid the kickbacks on the contract with money he and Ellen stole, he took even more money to cover up the crash, Ellen was so remorseful that she killed herself, and I’m the guy who can make the whole thing make sense. All you have to do is give me that little tape.”
“What about Lenny? He knows everything.”
“Lenny’s not going to discuss his role or anyone else’s in an alleged murder. There’s still no proof that she didn’t kill herself. Besides, he’s going to need lawyers, and I can get him the best. Lenny will be all right. But to really make this work, I need you.”
He leaned in closer, and now there wasn’t much that separated us except for the smell of the rum. My back arched against just the idea of his hands on me, his long, graceful fingers touching me in ways that no one ever had before or since. No matter what else was happening, no matter what he had done or what I might do, there was something between us and it was never going away. And there was truth in that connection, if only in that its existence could not be denied. Maybe he was right. Maybe that was the only truth when you got right down to it, and maybe it was foolish to try to fight it. Maybe that’s what Ellen had tried to say in her note, that life without that connection was no life at all.
The Alex Shanahan Series Page 37