by Jayne Rylon
At least that’s what he kept telling himself. He still jumped when Everly’s signature knock sounded on the door right before she used her code to let herself in as usual. She peeked inside as she called his name.
When he yelled hello, she entered then smiled as he approached the grand entryway from the other end of the adjoining living area. This time she wasn’t alone. A tall guy, who wore an excellently tailored suit, trailed behind her. His spiky blond hair and bright green eyes were only outshined by his killer smile. When Everly did something, she really went all the way.
If there was a guy Gabriel could be attracted to, this man was probably the one.
Despite his trepidation, he felt instantly at ease. He should have realized any friend of Everly’s would be the kind of person he would get along with, too.
Things could easily have been awkward given the situation.
They weren’t.
As if it was an everyday occurrence to be introduced to someone your friend had arranged a hookup with, the guy strode straight to Gabriel. He extended his hand. “Hey, I’m Colton. Everly told me you’re trying to figure some shit out. I’m down for some sexy times with you both.”
New life goals. Gabriel immediately wanted to be more like that—straightforward, unashamed, confident. Open and ready for new experiences. Bold.
That was attractive.
So he simply stood there and let Colton use their lingering grip to draw him in. He didn’t flinch when Colton laid his lips on Gabriel’s, then proceeded to kiss the shit out of him. Unlike Everly, he wasn’t soft. Or gentle. He took…and gave.
For a few moments Gabriel was too shocked to do more than kiss him back. Their exchange was intense and a little violent. It thrilled him when Colton let him know by example that he didn’t have to be careful. He could let loose all the passion inside him. It was so weird, like he was watching himself from outside his body.
Did it feel good? Shit, yes.
Did he want to keep doing it? Not so much.
He’d rather make out with Everly, even if their contact was sweeter and slower than this frantic blast of infatuation and wonder he exchanged with Colton.
As quickly as it had exploded, it fizzled out.
Where kissing Everly impacted both Gabriel’s body and his soul, this was a pleasure that floated on the surface. Something critical was missing. It only took an instant for him to be certain of that. He blinked a few times, then whispered, “Sorry.”
“Well, damn.” Colton licked his lips as if he’d like another taste of Gabriel. “I guess this is going to be an early night for me.”
“What do you mean?” Everly tipped her head as she studied the men in front of her. “That was hot as hell.”
“Your boy isn’t into me.” Colton brushed the pad of his thumb over Gabriel’s swollen mouth, letting him know it was okay. There were no hard feelings. His acceptance restored another sliver of Gabriel’s faith in his fellow humans. “Not like he’s into you.”
“I’m not sure if I should be glad or disappointed, to be honest.” Everly chuckled, her voice already full of the husky quality Gabriel had come to associate with her arousal.
Had she been looking forward to this? The last thing he wanted to do was let her down.
“Wait.” Gabriel grabbed Colton’s sleeve as he turned to go. “Do you want to stay anyway?”
Everly and Colton both asked, “Why?”
“I could use a tutor.” Where the hell had that suggestion come from? Gabriel realized then that some things about himself would always remain the same. He enjoyed caring for others. He got off on bringing people pleasure.
Everly’s enjoyment would increase his own, and Colton could coach him. It seemed like something Colton might get off on, too. So why not let him watch? Win-win-win.
“How do you feel about that?” Colton asked Everly. “I’m getting the feeling this isn’t like other times we’ve fooled around. This means something to you. Am I going to mess that up?”
“How do I feel?” Everly released an animalistic sound that had Gabriel half-hard in a flash. “I feel really fucking horny. I’ve been thinking about this all day, and if someone doesn’t fuck me soon I’m going to burst into flames.”
She reached out and gripped each man by the hand before dragging them toward the nearest guest bedroom. Gabriel wondered if she’d chosen it because it was closer or because she preferred to keep his personal space just for them.
Either way, he approved.
Colton started stripping the second he crossed the threshold. Everly and Gabriel followed his lead. Things were happening so fast he didn’t have time to process them. This wasn’t like the slow unfolding of his previous encounters with Everly.
This was about scratching an itch.
He did his best to keep up, but he’d be lying if he said he didn’t miss the scenic route they had taken before.
“How do you want to do this?” he asked them.
“Why don’t you show me what you’ve got and then I’ll make some suggestions?” Colton smirked as he rubbed his chest and then took his stiffening cock in his hand. He stroked himself idly, waiting for them to agree.
Everly nodded. “I like that plan.”
She reached for Gabriel’s cock and pumped him a few times until he was good and hard. More than ready, like she had told them she was, too.
“It helps if you get on the bed, babe.” Colton shoved her lightly so that she half-flopped, half-tumbled onto the mattress. He crawled on beside her. They both looked at Gabriel.
So he joined them, making Everly bounce as he leapt over her like a hunter falling on its prey. Should he kiss her first? Go down on her like he had the night before?
“Don’t make me wait anymore, please.” She reached up and drew him to her.
Colton wrapped his fingers around Gabriel’s wrist, guiding their hands to Everly’s pussy. “I can already tell you it’s not a problem, but why don’t you check to see how wet she is? If she’s turned on enough, you can skip a few steps without making her uncomfortable.”
It reassured Gabriel to have someone there who knew what to do, who understood his concerns. He wanted to take what Everly was offering but not at the expense of her comfort or enjoyment.
He prodded her with his index finger. It slipped across her waxed pussy and nudged her clit. She moaned.
Gabriel tried again, this time pressing steadily until his digit poked through the muscles guarding the entrance to her body. They admitted him more freely as he began to stroke her, loving the feel of her on his hand.
“Did you forget what you’re doing?” Colton grinned. “Don’t get distracted. You have the answer.”
Everly was more than prepared for him.
He withdrew his hand and licked her cream from his fingers.
Colton cheered him on. “That’s right, get nasty. Show her how much she turns you on. Better yet, give her your cock. Watch her face as you stretch her around your shaft. You’ve got a nice fat dick—I bet that’s going to feel fantastic.”
“It does.” She winked at Colton.
So Gabriel gave her what she clearly wanted. He levered up on one elbow and reached beneath himself to guide his hard-on to her. With far less caution than he’d used previously, he fit himself to her and pushed.
At first her pussy resisted.
“Back up a little and go at her again.” The steady stream of Colton’s instructions spurred Gabriel to action. “Work your cock into her. Open her up to you.”
Gabriel did as he was told. Soon the tip of his dick was notched in Everly. She gasped as he penetrated her bit by bit.
“That’s not a bad sound. Keep going.” Colton spoke for her when she had no words.
Everly nodded, though, so Gabriel did until he’d given her every inch he had.
He could have spilled inside her right then, before they’d even really got going. It was tempting. She had the power to affect him that intensely, that fast. So he stopped, locked togeth
er with her.
A while passed before Colton chuckled, though it wasn’t mean-spirited. “You have to move sometime.”
“I don’t have a lot of stamina yet.” Gabriel cleared his throat as he began to fuck. Truth was, Everly pushed him to the edge of his control within moments. Every single time.
“That’ll come with time. Try to distract yourself as you get close. Think of anything other than how hot and tight her pussy is on your cock.”
Gabriel grunted. He nearly came on the spot. “Not helping.”
Colton laughed. “Sorry about that. Take a break when you need to. Here, pull out.”
Though it went against every instinct he had, Gabriel did as directed. He gripped the base of his shaft and left the paradise he’d found between this gorgeous woman’s legs.
She whimpered and arched toward him. Leaving her unfulfilled wasn’t what he wanted either.
“You have two options…” Colton swallowed hard.
“Yeah?”
“Eat her pussy while you take a time out.” He stared at Gabriel, hesitating for the first time since he’d arrived.
“Or?”
“Let me get in there and keep her entertained while you’re cooling off a little. If we take turns, we can keep her coming without crossing that line ourselves. We can make this last all night long.”
All. Night.
Mind blown.
“What do you want?” Gabriel asked Everly.
He hadn’t meant to tease her, but she practically roared, “Someone fuck me. Now!”
“Go ahead.” A nod in Colton’s direction had the man leaping into action as if he’d been tapped in a tag-team fight. He took a condom from the nightstand, rolled it on, then positioned himself between Everly’s creamy thighs.
“It’s been a while, huh?” He smiled at her as he fit himself to the opening of her body.
Gabriel stared, fascinated, as he used the tip of his cock to rub the sensitive flesh there while also coating himself in Everly’s arousal. Smart.
She seemed to enjoy the glide of his cock over the exterior portions of her pussy. A gasp escaped her reddened lips as she grinned up at Colton. “You’re such a jerk. Please, fuck me.”
Hearing her beg, even a little, did strange things to Gabriel. Something inside him responded to her plea. Although he knew he’d shoot deep inside her if he penetrated her tight rings of muscle now, he couldn’t wait to return to her. To make her want him like that.
The things he was learning—about himself, mostly—were fascinating. Addicting.
“While I’m doing this, you should kiss her,” Colton encouraged. It wasn’t a spectator sport, after all. “Play with her tits. Rub her clit. Touch her everywhere while I fill her pussy.”
As he spoke, Colton pressed inside Everly. He slid in deep and steady until his balls tucked tight against her body.
Damn.
Though it was tough to look away, even for a moment, Gabriel focused on Everly. It shocked him when he realized that although Colton fucked her, her attention was riveted on him. When they exchanged heated looks, her eyes rolled back. She gripped his hand as she flew into an unexpected orgasm.
Colton rode her through it, pulling out when she’d finished quaking. “You’re up. Too much more of that and I’m done.”
Gabriel gladly took his turn. He pumped into Everly longer this time, lazily as she recovered from the first of many, many peaks they would lift her to.
They traded places so many times, Gabriel should have been dizzy.
He’d never get enough of seeing Everly unravel between them though. Eventually, each round got shorter and shorter. Even switching off wasn’t keeping his arousal in check.
Sweat rolled down Colton’s brow and his jaw clenched tight each time he thrust into Everly’s welcoming body. They hadn’t exactly made it all night long, but it was becoming obvious that they’d reached the limits of their bodies.
Everly had stopped responding with coherent replies. Now she relied on gasps, moans, and whimpers to encourage them.
As if he had the same thought, Colton called out to Gabriel. He lifted his head from Everly’s chest where he’d been sucking on her tight nipple. “You two are too sexy together. I’ve got to come.”
Everly made a strangled noise Gabriel had begun to associate with an early warning of her impending climax. “Are you going to come, too? Show him how much you appreciate what he’s done for us tonight. Make it good for him. Go ahead.”
Her eyelids flew open. Her gaze whipped to his then to Colton.
Everly froze, then bucked, nearly dislodging Colton as he ramped up the speed and force of his movements until his cock drilled into her hard enough to make Gabriel wince. She seemed to have no complaints.
With a scream, she climaxed. The rhythmic flexing of her channel triggered the other man’s release as well. He embedded himself in her fully before his ass clenched repeatedly in time to his grunts and curses.
It was surreal to watch his lover share that moment with another man. Except not. Because he could see a difference between the physical relief Colton and Everly gave each other and the outpouring of emotion that amplified her and Gabriel’s lust when their bodies did the same thing together.
Colton slid from Everly as he finished. She sighed but held her arms open to Gabriel.
“Are you sure?” he asked. “That looked pretty satisfying. You’re so tired.” He brushed sweat-dampened hair from her brow as he cuddled her, making sure she knew he was fine if she was done.
“I’m sure.” She smiled and lifted her face toward him for a kiss. “I need you. I need this.”
Who was he to argue?
Gabriel worked himself inside her one final time for the evening. He started slow, rebuilding her pleasure even as he paced himself for one final wild ride. The motion of his hips felt so natural now, he couldn’t believe he had worried about his ability to fuck just a day ago.
It took a while, but before too long, Everly was meeting him thrust for thrust.
She sucked on his tongue, humming around it as he held her close while he plunged into her over and over. Long, liquid glides of his cock through her pussy drove them both insane.
The affection in the stares they exchanged sped the beating of his heart.
Everly touched all of him. Cared for all of him.
Beyond speaking, he hoped she understood that he felt the same for her.
Only her.
With that certainty, Gabriel’s cock jerked within her. He couldn’t say what possessed him, but he leaned in and bit her neck. Not too hard, just enough so that she knew he planned to claim her, now and forever.
That he was giving all of himself in return.
The instant his teeth latched onto her skin, Everly stiffened. She screamed his name as she unraveled in his arms. The firm massage of her pussy triggered his own orgasm. It drew the come from his balls. He flooded her, only realizing once it was far too late that he’d fucked her bare, with nothing between them.
Everly didn’t allow him to retreat. She locked her legs around his waist and dug her heels into his ass. She hugged him with her limbs and her spasming muscles. Her restless hands clutched him, pulling his hair, scratching his back, showing him in every way possible that she had to be connected as tightly as possible to him.
He needed the same.
When Gabriel could think again, he kissed Everly’s cheek and slipped from her body.
A noise from beside them startled him. It was Colton, clearing his throat. The man knuckled a drop of moisture from the corner of his eye. It could have been sweat.
“I think it’s time for me to head out. You two have this under control on your own. There’s a lot of porn on the internet if you need some more tutorials. You don’t need me.” He smiled somewhat sadly at them. “Maybe someday I’ll find what you’ve got.”
Gabriel sat, stunned. He thought back to when Colton had arrived and how he’d wanted to be more like the man. And now the guy was e
nvying Gabriel.
Holy shit.
He rolled to his back and stared up at the coffered ceiling, thinking hard while Colton got dressed and Everly saw her friend out. In addition to his sated body, his mind settled, finding some peace for the first time in years—since he’d started questioning his faith.
Ironic since he’d swear finding Everly had been some sort of divine intervention.
He must have drifted off because the next thing he knew, daylight was brightening the windows and the splash of the shower was making him have to piss.
It was the first uninterrupted night’s sleep he’d had since he’d been kicked out of the church. That had to mean he was getting his life on the right track.
Gabriel stretched and rolled from bed. He finished up in the separate toilet room just as Everly shut off the blow drier and fluffed her hair.
He kissed her good morning and tried not to mess up her makeup too badly. Then he leaned his hip against the counter as she put on the elegant lace bra she’d worn the day before, leaving her ass bare. When she finished, she looked over her shoulder at him and smiled slow and wide. “What? It won’t be the first time I’ve gone without panties.”
“You’re gorgeous. But that’s not what I was thinking about. I just wanted to say thank you.” He rested his forehead on hers feeling a spark of unease as she prepared to leave him for the day. She was so damn wonderful. Gorgeous, smart, and kind. He couldn’t possibly compete with what she had to give him.
“That’s not necessary.” She kissed him lightly before saying, “I’m the one who will benefit from your education. Besides, I had just as much fun as you did. More, I think.”
Gabriel’s glow soured. It hadn’t been amusing to him. It had been serious shit. Life changing. It didn’t shock him that the evening hadn’t held the same importance to her. It still kind of stung, though.
“But it was a risk, doing this with me. I admire you for taking it so we could see if we were a perfect fit.” Unfortunately, they weren’t. He was still learning to walk. She flew.