by Susan Moon
All my life I have felt this longing. I guess it’s how I travel in the world; it’s what takes me where I’m going.
The longing for connection calls forth a life of connection. The longing that took me to the secret place in the bayberry bushes is the same longing that has taken me, as an adult, to spending months in a monastery; joining a voter registration drive; and setting the table for family and friends. My small self continues to reach for something beyond myself. The girl practicing handstands in that secret place is still with me, keeping me company. If that little kid can bear the longing, I can bear it. I remember that this is who I am, the one who wonders.
Talking to My Dead Mother
WHEN MY EIGHTY-FOUR-YEAR-OLD mother was in the hospital after a car accident, I flew to Chicago to be with her. In my hasty departure, I took no other shoes but the ones on my feet, and they fell apart the day I got there, as I hurried across the hospital parking lot. The next day, oddly, a new pair of shoes arrived at my mother’s apartment. She had ordered them for herself from a catalog. The black leather walking shoes fit me well; sturdy and comfortable, they were just what I needed. I told my mother that I was borrowing her new shoes until she got better, but she never did.
I’ve been wearing them almost daily ever since she died. I’ve taken them twice to my local shoe repair shop in Berkeley to have the Velcro fastenings replaced. I feel superstitious about them. I don’t want them ever to wear out, but of course they will.
When my mother died, I became an orphan. At sixty-three, I was too old to feel like a waif, and yet I did. When I was a child, my friends and I played orphan games; we were playing, I now suppose, at what we feared the most. We were brave and strong. Shipwrecked without any parents on the desert island that was my back yard, we lived in imaginary tree houses, tamed palomino horses, made hammocks out of vines, gathered wild bananas and raspberries to eat—it was a great life. But being an orphan isn’t like that at all; since my mother’s death, I haven’t done any of those things.
And, in a strange contradiction, the very event that turned me into an orphan also turned me into a matriarch. At my nephew’s wedding, with our large extended family, I was the oldest person there. How could this have come to pass?
I’m the first of four siblings, and now both parents are gone, as well as all the aunts and uncles. The generations have rolled over: two months before my mother died, my granddaughter was born, the first of her generation in my family. For many years, the word Grandma was synonymous with my mother, who adored and was adored by her nine grandchildren. Yet I’m the grandma now. Everyone has to get up out of their chair and move over one notch. I’m sitting in my mother’s seat, sometimes literally. I have her beloved “steamer chair” on my back porch, and I like sitting in it on warm days.
I’m also wearing some of my mother’s clothes. When my sisters and I were going through her closet after her death, I took shirts and sweaters that would have been too Mother-Hubbardish for me before: a blue denim shirt, for example, with daisies embroidered on the bodice. Some impulse of loyalty to my mother makes me like it, and besides, it’s comfy, and comfort trumps style these days. I also took a pair of black leather gloves, and a black wool jacket with brass buttons, made by Tibetan refugees. Sometimes, walking down the street in Berkeley on a chilly day, I look down to see that my body is embraced by my mother’s coat, my mother’s gloves, and my mother’s shoes.
As an adolescent, I used to resent being closely identified with my mother. I went to the same small girls’ high school that she had attended twenty years before me. Two of my teachers—an English teacher and a Latin teacher—sometimes called me by my mother’s name, “Alice.” In my senior year, I was glad to be chosen as the editor of the high school literary magazine, except that my mother had also had that job, and I was afraid that I might be under some kind of spell to live her life over again. But hadn’t I come into the world to be a different person?
After high school, through various adventures and misadventures of my own, I clearly established that I was not my mother, and I stopped worrying about it. But now again my identity overlaps with my mother’s. Sometimes people tell me I look like her, and now that she’s gone I don’t mind it as much as I used to. I’m not happy, though, about all the food stains I’ve been getting on my shirts, just as my mother did—spots of yogurt on the front and smears of chocolate ice cream on the cuffs.
It’s strange how family likeness rises to the surface later in life, especially after a parent dies. My sisters, too, increasingly resemble my mother, and after my father died, my brother quite suddenly came to look startlingly like him. After my paternal grandmother died, my aunt took on my grandmother’s face and form. She even seemed to foster the likeness, cutting her hair in a short gray wave as my grandmother had done and wearing what could have been the very same navy blue skirt and matching jacket my grandmother wore. Once, seeing her at a family gathering after an absence of a couple of years, I thought for a frightening moment that she was my dead grandmother. Perhaps our DNA is a time-release capsule, and at a certain stage the genes kick in to say: this is how the people in your family look when they get old.
I miss my mother more than I expected to. I’m also sad that she died because of an accident, before she was quite ready to go, and that her last three weeks were spent in the hospital, painfully encumbered by machinery that tried, and failed, to save her life. I want my sadness to be erased—for her to stop being dead, or for me to stop minding—but no such tidiness is likely to come while I’m alive.
And I’m finding out something surprising: even after my mother’s death I still have a relationship with her, and it’s a relationship that can change, even though she keeps on being dead. How I relate to her now is up to me.
I have a friend who used to take her father to a waterfront park in Berkeley and sit with him on a particular bench to look at the view. He died fifteen years ago, and she still goes there to sit on “Bubba’s bench” and talk to him. After my mother died, I hung a photo of her in the stairwell of my house so that I meet her face to face every time I come downstairs. Sometimes I hear myself saying out loud, “Hi, Mom.”
My mother had published several books of poetry with small presses, and at the end of her life, she wanted to publish a collection of her autobiographical short stories. She asked me to be her editor, which I was glad to do, so I helped her choose which of her stories to include, and I made suggestions as to how she might revise them. She also wrote some new stories for the collection. We had a good time working on this project together; I respected her writing and was moved by the life she told of in the stories, and she trusted my editorial responses.
A year before my mother’s death, I took her to a writing workshop taught by an old friend, at Glenstal Abbey, a Benedictine abbey in the west of Ireland. It was our last big adventure together. There were only seven students: my mother and myself, four literary monks from the abbey, and a woman from Dublin. My mother worked on her last story there, about her painful marriage to my father, and she bravely read a piece of it aloud to the group each day when it was her turn. It was brave because the story told of intimate marital unhappiness, and the group included both celibate monks and her daughter. Everyone listened hard and gave her helpful feedback, and all that week she threw herself into her work, rewriting by hand because she didn’t have a computer there, cutting and pasting with scissors and tape. One of the monks, with whom she fell quite in love, made photocopies for her in the library. It was a good story, and she made it better.
At mealtimes I pushed her in her wheelchair down the gravel path to the refectory—it was slow going, crunching through the gravel—for blood pudding, brown bread, and tea in bowls with the monks. Evenings, in the late sunlight of the Irish summer, I took her to the walled garden, and she sat on the stone edge of the raised lavender bed and leaned into the smell.
The only moment of tension between us came one morning when my mother said, “I like your hair
so much better when you brush it back.” It was a familiar refrain, but this time I took it as a compliment, as I had just finished brushing my hair in the bathroom.
“Thank you,” I said.
“No,” she said, “not like that. Can’t you just brush it back?” I was outraged, but later, looking at photos of myself on that trip, I saw that my hair was indeed unruly. I didn’t cut my hair short and neat, getting it out of my face as she always wanted me to, until after her death. It must have been unconscious filial perversity that made me withhold this satisfaction from her. If she could only see my hair now, she would finally approve.
I was in her room in the abbey guesthouse when she received a call from an old man in Chicago who had shortly before become attentive to her. From across the room I could hear his voice at the other end of the line, on the other side of the Atlantic Ocean, shouting, “I love you!”
“Me, too,” she said, too embarrassed in my presence to say the words back. She didn’t know I’d heard his words, or that I was pleased by them, for her sake.
Soon after the trip to Ireland, my mother finished her revisions of all the stories, and it was left for me to do the final editing. I was making slow progress, because I was working on another editing project.
“When are you going to finish editing my book?” she asked me, every time we spoke.
“As soon as I finish this other project,” I told her.
And then I did finish editing the other book, and I turned my full attention to my mother’s book. I had just sent her my final edits when she was in the car accident that caused her death three weeks later.
I felt terrible that I hadn’t finished the book in time for her to see it in print. But this is what happens when people die. Death interrupts life. Some process is going on, some piece of business, large or small, is unfinished, some words still unspoken, a letter unsent, a cup not yet washed, a shirt on the bed waiting to be folded.
I promised my mother in the hospital that I would finish the editing and publish the book, and so I did. When it came back from the printer, I opened the box with excitement and pulled out a copy, with a painting by a friend of my mother’s on the cover. I held it, and it was perfect. My hands ached to complete the gesture—to put the book in my mother’s hands.
I reassure myself that the pain of not finishing this project before she died is more mine than hers, for she had finished her work on the book, and she seemed to be focused on other concerns as she was dying: on her family and close friends, on breathing. Besides, putting the book together and getting it published gave me a way to work closely with my mother even after her death. She was a quieter collaborator than she had been when alive, but I continued to feel her presence as my siblings and I gave readings and sent the book out into the world, where people appreciated it.
My mother stopped taking care of her children in the ordinary sense long before she died; we have been grown-ups for a long time now. But she encouraged me and gave me comfort. She always wanted to hear from me, she always wanted to see me, and she admired whatever I did. As long as she was alive, I could keep on hoping that when I was having a hard time she could somehow make it better. Now that I’m an orphan I have to admit she isn’t going to step in anymore.
I wish I had been better able to offer her comfort in return. She didn’t ask for it often, but it was hard for me to listen to her when she was unhappy about something. As the mother, she was the one who was supposed to comfort me. I jumped too quickly to “Oh, it couldn’t be that bad, I’m sure he didn’t mean to hurt your feelings,” and this made matters worse because she felt dismissed.
As I experience some of what my mother went through when she grew old, I sympathize with her in a new way. I realize in retrospect how little she complained, in spite of serious problems like the disabling pain in her back that limited her walking. Paradoxically, she got tougher as she got frailer.
But she did complain that I didn’t visit her enough. I used to go to Chicago to see her a couple of times a year, for about a week each time. My stepfather died two years before my mother, and after his death it was more intimate, visiting her. I felt some awkwardness as the two of us sat in her living room, and I crocheted, and she stroked her cat, or tapped her forefinger against her upper lip, hoping for confidences from me that I didn’t offer—how I felt about my life and the people in it. She didn’t ask, but I could feel her wondering: Did I have a lover? What was I writing about? Damn! How hard would it have been to let down my guard? But I was relieved when it was 10:00 P.M., and we could turn on the BBC news, as was her habit. “I don’t need to watch the news while you’re visiting,” she’d say. “I can watch the news any night.”
“Oh, that’s OK,” I answered. “Let’s find out about those forest fires in California.”
My fear that my mother’s needs would become too great for me made me keep a certain distance from her, out of a misguided self-protection. Now that she’s dead, I have more distance than I want.
I used to call her every Sunday. We chatted about the weather, what we were reading, movies, news of her grandchildren, and she would tell me what she was seeing out of her sixth-floor window overlooking Lake Michigan. “Men in yellow hats are spreading sand, making a beach at the edge of the lake—they look like yellow ants.” Or, “There’s a fat woman jogging along the lake—I can’t understand why such a fat person would ever go jogging. It’s ridiculous!” One time she told me with great enthusiasm about the newly elected senator from Illinois who came from Hyde Park, her neighborhood of Chicago—Barack Obama.
A few years before she died, I started telling her I loved her, the last thing before I hung up the phone. I was over sixty and she was over eighty—an old daughter telling an old mother a simple thing that she was glad to hear. It was true, so I don’t know why it was hard to say when I first began the practice, but it got easier as I got into the habit, and in the last couple of years it rolled right off my tongue.
Lots of things have happened that I would tell my mother about if I could call her next Sunday. I’d like her to know that people are crazy about her book of short stories. I’d like her to know that her great-granddaughter can talk in both English and Spanish. She would have loved to be at my nephew’s wedding last summer, with the extended family all around. And she would be thrilled about Obama. I wish I could tell her—“Guess who’s your president!”
The more time that goes by, the more events she’ll miss: graduations and weddings and births, and she’ll slip further into the past, and her grandchildren will marry people she never met, and take up interests she never knew they had, and her children will get old and feeble, and have joints replaced and troublesome organs removed.
I can appreciate my mother more now that I’m not reacting defensively to her criticisms of my unruly hair or feeling guilty that I’m not visiting her enough. As long as she was alive, she was Mom, and I, being her child no matter my age, became childish.
She birthed me twice: the first time when I was born, and the second when she died. Now that she’s gone, there’s no person on earth whose child I am. So I have to grow up, at this late date. It takes so long to grow up.
A year after my mother died, I was sitting in my parked car in the California countryside. My cell phone rang on the seat beside me. I fumbled for it and barely managed to answer it in time. “Hello?”
“Hello, it’s your mother.” That’s how she always identified herself when she telephoned me, saying the words “your mother” with ironic emphasis, as if it was our private joke. Nobody ever reaches me on my cell phone, not even the living, because I never leave it on, so this was truly a miracle.
“Mom!” I said, overjoyed to hear her voice, “how wonderful that you’ve found a way to reach me even though you’re dead! Thank you so much for calling.”
“Please take good care of yourself, Susan,” she said with affection. That was all, but when she said it, I knew it was exactly what I wanted to hear. Then I lost the connecti
on.
It was enough. I was overcome with gratitude that she had contacted me from the other side. And when I woke up and realized it was just a dream, it was still a miracle. She had found a way to reach me.
For the Time Being
The self is time . . . Do not think that time merely flies away . . . If time merely flies away, you would be separated from time.
—Zen Master Dogen, “The Time Being”
WHEN I WAS FORTY-NINE and my sons were more or less grown, I kept a promise I had made to myself to go on a long retreat before I turned fifty. I arranged a leave of absence from my job, had a set of robes sewn for me, and went to a “practice period” at Tassajara Zen Mountain Center, deep in the coastal mountains of California. For three months I followed the strict monastic schedule: meditating, studying Buddhist teachings, and working in silence at whatever I was assigned to, whether it was chopping carrots or cleaning kerosene lanterns. I didn’t get in a car or hear a phone ring the whole time.
Zen monks are called to zazen by the striking of the han, a heavy wooden block that hangs from a rope beside the temple entrance. The han is hit with a wooden mallet in an intricate pattern that lasts for fifteen minutes, and at Tassajara, where the monks’ cabins stretch out along a narrow valley, a second han, known as the echo han, hangs partway down the path, to pass the signal along. You can tell how much time you have left to get to your cushion in the zendo by listening to the pattern.