by Daphne Dawn
“I love her,” Scott blurts out.
I blink at him, trying to make sure of what he’s saying. “What?”
He nods. “I’ve fallen I love with her. With all the sex and spending time with her and everything we’ve been doing… I love her.”
I shake my head. Of everything we’ve been through the last few days, hearing that Scott, of all people, has fallen in love with her is the most unexpected.
“Why are you telling me this?” I ask.
“Because you’re my friend. I want to tell you. I feel it would be fair to tell you.”
I shake my head. “You can’t love her,” I say.
“What?” Scott asks. “What the hell?”
I get up from me seat and pace the room, unable to sit down anymore. My blood boils beneath my skin and I struggle to contain myself.
“I was there first,” I say.
Scott’s eyes widen. “So, she’s off limits?”
I nod. “Yeah, in fact, she is.”
Scott shakes his head. “That’s not fair. She’s an adult. She’s not a toy that we’re fighting over.”
I laugh and it isn’t a friendly laugh. “That’s because there’s nothing to fight over. You can’t have her. Forget the bet – she’s mine.”
Scott is getting angry. I can count on one hand how many times Scott and I got angry with each other. This is the worst I’ve ever seen him. His muscles bulge and he looks dangerous, his green eyes blazing.
“Just because she works for you doesn’t mean you own her. I didn’t come here to ask your permission to be with her. I came here to tell you what I feel so that you don’t hear it from someone else. I’m being a good friend.”
I shake my head, clenching my hands into fists. “A good friend? Good friends don’t steal their friends’ women.”
Scott frowns. “What are you talking about? She’s not your woman.”
“Don’t go there, Scott. I’m the one that met her, that told you about her. If it wasn’t for me, you wouldn’t even have anything with her. And I fucked her, first.”
“Well, isn’t that mature,” Scott says. “Finders keepers, like we’re back in grade school. Is that it?”
“Fuck you, Scott,” I say. “Fuck you very much.”
Scott stands up. His face is carefully expressionless. He is in control of his anger which is more than I can say about mine.
“Maybe we should talk about this later,” I say.
“Or maybe, we don’t talk about this at all,” Scott says. “Because I’m going to pursue her. I want her, Kevin. Don’t stand in my way.”
He turns around and storms out of the office before I have a chance to respond to his threat. I am angry. I pace around, feeling like I’m coming undone at the seams. How did this happen? It must have been the same for Scott as for me.
It’s ironic, after everything we’ve been through and talked about, after all the women we’d been with, the only thing we never considered is that we would fall for the same woman. It worked so well until now because neither of us cared about them.
Now that we met someone worth our while, it’s a different story. I’m in love with Carly. Apparently, Scott is, too.
If we aren’t careful this will pull our friendship apart. If it isn’t already doing that. We never had a problem with women getting between us no matter how many we shared, how many he pulled that I couldn’t get and the other way around. It was all fun and games. But now? Now it’s pulling us apart.
I had to choose between my company and Carly. The last three days, that was been on my mind. This time, it’s between Scott and me. Seeing how close we used to be, it’s a whole different game.
One that wouldn’t have any winners.
When Scott leaves my office, it feels like all the air is sucked out of the room. I struggled to breathe. Am I going to lose my best friend over this? How have we never considered that a woman might come between us? Maybe it’s because nothing like this has ever happened before.
I let out a deep sigh.
Carly knocks on my door and opens it. “Can I come in?”
I beckon her in and she closes the door behind her. She looks down at her file and is about to tell me something – probably work related – when she sees my face. She frowns.
“Are you okay?” she asks.
I shake my head.
“Scott and I got stuck.”
“Oh, wow. About what?”
I take a deep breath. “You.”
Carly frowns and sits down in the chair Scott vacated a moment earlier. Her dark hair is back in a braid and that makes me think of the first time we fucked. Her hair hung down her back in a thick braid the same way it is now, before we undid it.
I push the images away. I must focus on what’s going on.
“He loves you,” I say.
Carly looks surprised but she doesn’t fish for details. Instead, she keeps control.
“And that bothers you?” she asks.
I nod. “We were never supposed to fall in love with you,” I say. “That isn’t the plan. You know that, right? That it isn’t about that?”
She nods slowly. I wonder if it comes across wrong, but she doesn’t seem offended.
“So, you’re unhappy that he broke the rules,” Carly says.
I shake my head. “It’s not that,” I say.
“Then what is it?” Carly asks.
“It’s because I love you, too.”
There, it’s out there. The confession is in the air between us. Either, Carly can take it to heart, catch it and make it her own. Or, she can leave it hanging until it drops dead at her feet.
“Kevin… I don’t know what to say.”
I’m sure it’s a hell of a compliment, that two men will feel like that about her. If she feels it she doesn’t show it. It’s a good move.
“Who will you choose?” I ask her.
“Kevin…”
“No, Carly. I’m sorry but this is driving me crazy, now. I’ve been thinking about it for a while, but now that Scott confessed… I need to know.”
Carly sighs. “We can’t really talk about this here at work,” she says. She is right, of course. “Why don’t you rather come to my place tonight and we can talk about, take all the time we need?”
It’s a reasonable request. I nod. Going to her place is like being invited into her intimate parts. Every time, save for one, we had sex when I was there. Scott was involved, too, which feels a little bittersweet, but that’s beside the point.
“I’ll be there just after seven,” I say.
Carly nods. “That’s great,” she says. “I am sorry to change topics on you like this now, but we need to look at these beta tester reviews before I can confirm the second manuscript.”
She’s all business again. It’s a good trait and highly annoying that she can switch off just like that. But I guess that makes her the clever one, the strong one. She doesn’t let anything cripple her. Not even two men.
Carly
On the way home, I call Scott. I don’t want the two men to fight. The last thing in the world I want is to get between two friends. That was never the plan when they approached me for a threesome.
I fell for both and that wasn’t the plan, either. But the heart wants what it wants.
“Carly,” he answers, recognizing my number.
“Are you doing okay?” I ask.
He sighs. “Yeah, I’m doing okay.”
“Kevin told me,” I say.
He hesitates. “I don’t know what to say. I would rather you heard it from me, of course, but Kevin and I aren’t in the best place, now.”
I nod even though he can’t see me. “I know, I know. Will you come over to my place, tonight? So, we can talk about it? I don’t want to leave things up in the air like this.”
“Really?” Scott asks. “You want to see me?”
“Of course,” I say. “I really care for you, Scott. I don’t want to leave things the way they are. Come over, we’ll fix this.”
“Okay,” Scott says and I can hear him smiling. His face flashes before me and I can just see the kind of smile he will give – charming, boyish, irresistible.
“Be there at seven?”
“Yeah, sure,” he says and we hung up. I take a deep breath and let it out slowly. I invited both guys to my place. I’m playing with fire, I know that. But I don’t want to lose either of them and I can’t stand the two men fighting over me.
When I get home, I change into something more comfortable – shorts and a tank top – and pull the place together a bit. I don’t have time for a good clean but I tidy up enough to host. I make sure my bedroom is neat as well, the sheets on the bed clean, the curtains drawn and the lamp on the bedside table already on.
I’m nervous. This can very easily go in the wrong direction and I’m scared that I will end up in the middle of a fight, the break between two very good friends. My stomach is a knot of nerves and my heart beats in my throat. I have no idea how controlled they will be when they see each other, knowing that they were tricked into being here together.
When men fight about a woman, all logic disappears. It’s an animalistic thing, dating back to the very start of existence. When a male wants a female, it becomes primal.
I don’t want that. I want them to be able to talk about everything, to sort it out, to save the relationships that have been created here.
A knock sounds on my door and I open it. Scott stands in front of me, smiling down at me.
“You’re early,” I say.
He nods. “I’m over eager.” He leans down and kisses me. The smell of his cologne is thick in the air and it makes me feel weak at the knees. His chin is freshly shaven and he looks good. He dressed up for this.
It makes me feel underdressed with my shorts.
Scott walks in and sits down on my couch. I sit down next to him. I consider telling him that Kevin is coming, too. I open my mouth, but just as I do another knock sounds at the door.
Scott frowns. “Are you expecting someone?”
“Actually, I am.”
I leave Scott in the living room, walking to the door.
“Hello, beautiful,” Kevin says when I open the door. He pulls me close for a tight hug and kisses me on the cheek.
“Come in,” I say. My chest is tight. This is it – the moment of truth.
Kevin walks into the living room.
“Oh,” he says, stopping dead when he sees Scott.
“What the fuck is he doing here?” Scott asks and he is angry immediately. This is exactly what I expected from the two of them.
“I’m not going to stay if he’s going to be a part of it, babe,” Kevin says.
“Who are you calling babe?” Scott asks and his voice is threatening.
“Please, guys,” I say, physically putting myself between them, even though it hasn’t come to blows yet. “Don’t fight. I want the both of you here, together.”
Kevin hesitates. Scott looks furious. But they are both looking at me, focusing on what I’s saying and that’s a good start.
“We can’t do this,” Scott says. “I don’t want to do this. I love you. I want you.”
Kevin glares at Scott. He’s still standing, still looking like he would rather be aiming for the door.
“That’s the point. I love her. I want her.”
“Well, you can’t have her,” Scott says. He stands up and they are chest to chest. Scott is bigger than Kevin is – he isn’t much taller but he’s more muscular although they are equally defined. “She’s mine.”
“Yeah? I was with her first, asshole.”
Scott pushes his face right up against Kevin’s, so close that if the atmosphere isn’t so electric it would look like they are going to kiss.
“No!” I shout.
Scott turns his head to me, eyes angry. “If you won’t let me fight it out with him, then you choose.”
“Yeah,” Kevin says, turning to me. At least the fight is averted. “You choose.”
I shake my head. “Why does it have to be like this? Why can’t we just be the way we were?”
Scott frowns. “What do you mean? You want to be with both of us?”
I nod. Scott looks at Kevin before he shakes his head.
“I don’t think so,” he says.
“Yeah,” Kevin says. “I don’t think that’s going to work.”
I step closer to them. They are still almost chest to chest and with me this close, I can easily touch them both. I put my hand on each of their arms.
“It’s worked until now,” I say. “We have fantastic sex. And you guys are best friends. I’ve never seen two friends this close. Don’t let this, me, come between you.”
They’re both looking at me. Scott’s green eyes are still angry but it’s getting better. Kevin’s eyes are a deep blue, pensive. He’s considering it.
“I don’t know if I can do this,” Scott says.
I put my hand on his chest and slowly slide it down. “It’s not hard, Scott,” I say. My hand slides over his stomach, tracing his hard muscle. I move lower, still, my hand going for his cock. He takes a deep breath and shudders when I touch him, already hard through his jeans.
When I look at Kevin he glares at Scott with jealousy.
I put my hand on his chest, as well, and do the same I did to Scott, slipping my hand over his body until it rests on his cock.
“This is how we do it.” I rub them both through their pants, both shafts hard through the thick material. Kevin glances at Scott but the anger is replaced by lust. His eyes are hungry when he looks at me again.
When I look at Scott I see the same in his face. He wants sex.
We all want sex, we all want each other, and that’s what I’m aiming for.
I lean into Kevin and kiss him, first. I do it because I touched Scott, first, but I’m sure not to let up on Scott when my lips are against Kevin’s and I open my mouth so Kevin can slide his tongue inside of me. Scott grinds himself against my hand, gripping my wrist and pushing himself against me.
I sigh into Kevin’s mouth.
When I break the kiss, I turn to Scott and kiss him, too. It’s deep and sensual. He is a lot more eager than Kevin, kissing me like he’ll never be able to kiss me again.
Kevin runs his hand up my arm and onto my shoulder. I shiver, his fingertips light on my bare skin. From my shoulder, he moves to my breast and cups it, massaging. I’m not sure if Scott is keeping an eye on Kevin, but he does the same, mirroring Kevin’s action. His hand is on my breast and the two of them massage my breasts, rubbing fingers over my hardening nipples as I take turns kissing them, rubbing their cocks.
It doesn’t take very long before someone tugs my shirt up and I let go of them to let them pull it off me. Kevin reaches for my shorts and unbuttons them and the two men work together to remove them, Scott lifting me up and Kevin pulling my shorts and my panties off. Scott takes care of my bra and in no time at all I’m naked in front of them.
The men both take off their shirts, undo their jeans and pull out their cocks. They are both thick and hard, eager.
I wrap my fingers around their naked cocks and the flesh is hot in my hands. Scott grips my wrist again and pumps himself up and down in my fist, his hard flesh thick under the smooth skin. The tip is wet with lust and it makes me hotter just looking at his cock.
Kevin turns toward me, pressing his body against me and rubbing himself up and down against my hip. It doesn’t take long before Scott makes a point of getting rid of his pants, too. When he’s naked, he palms his own flesh and jacks his hand up and down a couple of times, looking me in the eye while he does it. There is something so damn hot about a man handling his own sex. I don’t know what it is. Scott’s shoulders are large, his stomach tightens to reveal his six pack and he pumps that monster dick in his hand.
Kevin’s hand moves to my pussy and I shiver when he touches me. He kisses me again, fingering me and I am distracted, my attention taken away from Scott’s dick. Scott step
s closer to me and puts a hand on my breast. He pinches my nipple between thumb and forefinger and rolls it back and forth. I moan as Kevin pays attention to my clit and Scott moves in to suck on my nipple. I’m so wet, so horny, I can barely contain it. Getting attention from two men at the same time will never get old, and these guys know exactly what they’re doing.
They are so incredibly tuned into my body, into what I need and how I feel. This is why I can’t choose. I must be with them both. They are both amazing men, both fantastic in bed and they both care for me. I’m not sure if they will be completely happy with a threesome-like relationship, but we will talk about that later. After a couple of orgasms and dick filling every one of my holes, we can negotiate.
For the moment, I’m relieved they aren’t fighting, they both want me and they are both set on pleasuring me until I can’t take it anymore. The rest will come later.
Scott
This isn’t exactly how I would have liked it. I want Carly all to myself, there’s no doubt about that. She isn’t just fucking hot and good in bed – a good start for any woman – but she’s a great person. I want to get to know her better for who she is. I want to do non-sexual things with her, like movies or dinner. Or making a home.
With Kevin here, that picture doesn’t quite work out. But I can’t deny that a threesome is hot and that this – sex and love and all that entails – is great with him involved. He’s my best friend, he’s always been, and it will suck to lose him.
So, what if this works?
I don’t allow myself a hell of a lot of time to think about it. Carly is naked and so wet I can smell her scent. It makes me want to lose control, to ravage her. And she’s working fucking wonders with her hands on my body.
Yeah, I want her and I want her, hard.
When I can’t hold it anymore, I grab her wrist and pull her to me, away from Kevin. Yes, there’s still jealousy, a powerplay, at hand. I don’t care. I pull her against me, her breasts mashing against my chest, and I kiss her hard. I push my tongue into her mouth and she gasps. My hand goes to her tit and I tug at her nipple until she whimpers.