by John Casey
Elsie told herself she would have one more grumpy thought and then she’d be a good sport.
The curtain went up on a bright room with white wicker furniture. A genuinely middle-aged man with a full head of white hair—a faculty member?—and a girl made up to be his middle-aged wife were quarreling. It was nothing like what Elsie had read. No “prithee,” “fie,” or “I protest, sir.” All right—it was 1923, not 1773.
A boy in plus fours breezed through to say he was off to a roadhouse. His mother held on to his jacket and was dragged to her knees. The audience laughed. Elsie was reminded of another thing she didn’t like about theater. Not just what if they forgot their lines, but what if they hurt themselves taking a pratfall? It was an annoying anxiety.
Elsie’s mood changed when the father said, “And here comes my darling daughter.” As Rose made her entrance, Elsie went cold with fear. Rose wasn’t tucked away out of sight at the back of a church, she was under a giant eye. And then the audience was laughing at her. Rose trotted onstage with tiny steps. She came to a stop with a little hop and a shimmy that made her short beaded dress sparkle under the lights.
Elsie recovered when she saw that Rose wasn’t undone. She thought, She’s meant to be a dizzy flapper—headache band, her mouth lipsticked into a Betty Boop cupid’s bow. And the father was getting a laugh—his eyes goggled, he put his hands to his head and sank into his chair.
“Oh, Daddy,” Rose said. “It’s what all the girls are wearing.” She twirled her yard-long strand of pearls and caught it neatly.
The father sang a bit about girls these days. Rose knelt at his knee, looking sweetly submissive to this fictitious father.
At first Elsie didn’t know what this new sound was. Rose joined in the father’s song so softly it sounded like a single voice. As they went on singing, Elsie heard Rose’s voice more clearly. She seemed to be singing more notes than the man, but they ended together. The audience clapped, and there were a few cheers. Elsie looked at Mary. She was sitting completely still. Mary closed her eyes for a second, then made a note on her program.
Then came the setup: the gentleman caller and his pal were sent to the father’s house but were told that it’s an inn, and then a female cousin told Rose about the gentleman caller—he was so bashful that he stuttered. “With girls like you and me,” the cousin said. “With other girls, it’s a different story.”
“You mean … floozies?” Rose said.
“I mean anything in skirts to whom he has not been properly introduced.”
And indeed when the cousin introduced him—properly—to Rose, the boy stuttered and stared at his feet. They sang a duet, the boy doing scales with his “Wha-wha-wha what was I trying to say?” while Rose trilled a tune. The boy left, and Rose did one of the other things that Elsie found unbelievable about theater—she made a speech to herself, the upshot of which was that she thought the boy handsome and she’d find some way to get him to behave like the roguish charmer he was said to be.
After another scene of folderol among the father, the mother, the cousin, and her beau, there was a blackout. The lights came up on a bedroom and the gentleman caller complaining about the inn’s service—his bed wasn’t even made. Rose came in carrying a load of bedclothes. She set about making the bed, more tidily and quickly than at home. But Elsie was struck by how good she looked in her maid’s uniform—black dress and white bib apron belted tight around her small waist. She sang another duet with the boy. Elsie cocked her head, pleased that she recognized that it was the same song as before, but this time the boy tenor sang the melody and Rose chirped the in-between bits: “Oh, no, no, no, you stay on your side.” Elsie wondered just where and how Rose had come by this nimble coyness, the not knowing that their hands touched as they tucked in the sheet, the exact length of time to let his hand linger on her shoulder before it became a yes but not slipping away so quickly that it was a cold no. Rose’s hair was tucked up into a maid’s cap. Two broad ribbons hung down her back, bobbing and swirling as she flitted around the bed, apparently breathless but still singing.
They stopped singing. There was applause, which unsettled the boy in the middle of a spoken line. He stood openmouthed, looking panic-stricken. Rose curtsied to him and said, “I’m sorry, I didn’t hear you. Something about my palm.”
“Oh, yeah,” he said. Rose held up her hand. The boy clutched it and said, “I’m a palm reader. Your left hand shows what gifts you’re born with. Any fool can see you’re beautiful and charming, but the right hand shows how generous you’ll be with your gifts in the future.”
Rose tucked her hands behind her back and said, “I’m smaht enough to know the fu-cha you have in mind.” The audience laughed. Elsie jerked back in her seat. It was broad swamp-Yankee. It was May’s accent. It was May’s hitched vowels, May’s deliberate rhythm. How could she do that to May? And to Dick. To her whole other family. Elsie burned. She was afraid of what May must be thinking. She was ashamed. And then she was angry again.
She had to sit through the rest of the damn play, her anger congealing during the subplots, reheating when Rose did it again: “An inn? Whatevah gave you that idea? It’s Mr. Hahdcastle’s house.” The audience brayed their laughs. Elsie wanted to slap them silly.
And then all was revealed. Rose was really the daughter of the house, the boy tenor was cured of his stutter, the cousin got her beau, everyone onstage for the finale, all singing how happy they were. The audience applauded, the curtains closed, more applause. The curtain opened, the singers took a bow all in a row, then two by two, then the white-haired father led Rose forward and stepped back to let her curtsy by herself. He took her hand again, and together they leaned forward and pointed, palms open, to the little orchestra. The curtains closed.
Over at last. Elsie wasn’t furious anymore. She was pressed into a cold gloom so thick she couldn’t move.
chapter fifty-three
Mary took one look at Elsie and knew there was no talking to her. Mary had no idea what was wrong. She considered the possibility that Elsie was so pleased that she was overcome, but dismissed it after a second look.
Mary herself was so bursting with things to say that she got up and bumped across people’s knees to get to the aisle away from Elsie. Of course, there were one or two little moments Rose could work on, but those could wait. What couldn’t wait was seeing Rose, Rose still flushed and anxious, believing and not believing with every breath, wanting to hear that she was good from someone she could trust.
Jack was holding court in the hallway outside the greenroom. Mary would have slid by, but she saw Sally—she always made a point of being nice to Sally in front of Jack, the easiest way of reminding him to keep his hands to himself. When she held out her hand to Sally, Sally hugged her and kissed her on the cheek and said, “Wasn’t Rose terrific! And I know how much she owes to you.”
Mary’s face grew hot with the pleasure of it. She took a breath and said, “Oh, she was born with that voice, it’s a gift from God. But surely some of it must be from you, somewhere on your side of the family, though your sister has a tin ear. It’s not from Dick, God knows.” Mary heard herself taking off, as full-voiced as her father at a Christmas dinner after a drink or two—even the hint of a brogue he had retrieved from his boyhood. “Now, when it comes to the acting,” Mary went on, “that’s where you get a glimpse of Elsie, whether she’s setting her cap for a man or pinning his ears back.” And poor Sally had just wanted to say something nice in passing, not get reminded of the graft in Rose’s family tree. “And that’s just what the part needed—that clear soprano voice plus a bit of mischief.” If only Sally would say something, Mary would be on her way, but Sally stood there, a pretty portrait against the wall, not nodding, not even blinking. If this was what the poor dear was like when Jack climbed into bed, no wonder Jack had a roving eye. “So she’s in there, is she?” Mary said, pointing to the greenroom door. “I’ll just poke my head in. She gets so … After she sang the ‘Ave Maria’ … We
re you there at Sylvia Teixeira’s wedding? She was more undone afterward than she was before. I mean Rose, not Sylvia. So she needs someone calm.” Mary laughed at herself and rolled her eyes. She unplanted her feet and tipped herself through the door, saying, “Well, musically reassuring,” to no one in particular.
There was hardly room to move, but everyone was moving. Mary backed away from a boy carrying a tray of pizza slices. The boy tenor. She said, “Great job.”
He held the tray out to her. “Have some. You somebody’s mom?” She shook her head, and he spun away. She fended off the cousin soprano who was avoiding the pizza tray. Mary said, “Good job.”
The girl threw off a “Thanks,” then took another look at Mary. “Sawtooth? I’ve seen you … You’re not Rose’s mother, are you?”
“Just a friend.”
“Sweet. She’s over there.” The girl slanted her eyes toward the far corner. “Our wunderkind.”
Rose was sitting on a folding chair surrounded by all the Pierces. She’d already changed; she had her maid’s uniform draped over her arm, the cap in one hand. A shame she hadn’t something prettier than a sweatshirt and jeans. May took the costume and said, “You don’t want this smashed around in some big machine, somebody giving it a lick and a promise with a heavy iron. All those pleats in the skirt. I’ll put a little starch in the apron and the hat. No starch in the ribbons. Starch’ll make them too heavy to fly out.”
A large man moved past Mary and planted himself in front of Rose. The white-haired baritone father. “What did I tell you? Old but true—a shaky dress rehearsal makes for a good opening night. And you were absolutely alive.” He took in Dick and May. “And these must be your proud parents …”
Mary saw the man’s elbows flap once—he was in the same state of prattle she’d been in with Sally. Rose said, “This is Mr. Callahan.” Mary suspected he knew he’d got something wrong—he looked a little flummoxed. She was about to join in to distract everyone, but they were all dazzled by a camera flash. It was the cousin soprano. She snapped another picture and whirled away without a word. Rose stood up. “And this is my father, Dick Pierce. His wife, May. And these are my brothers, Charlie and Tom.” Rose saw Mary and said, “And behind you is Mary Scanlon. She and I sang at Miss Perry’s funeral together.”
Mr. Callahan swung around eagerly. “I’ve heard it was glorious. Of course, a sad occasion. I didn’t mean … I didn’t know Miss Perry, I know of her.”
Mary got a grip on his shoulder to settle him. She said, “As soon as I heard your voice tonight I knew we were in good hands.” She turned him round, gave him a good, sensible pat, and looked at May to see how she was taking all this backstage blather. Mary said, “Reminds me of Saturday night at my old place.” But May was staring at Rose with the same look as when she’d got down on the floor to give baby Rose a teddy bear.
And Rose? Although it had pleased Mary to see Rose handle a small awkwardness so smoothly, it also pained her to see Rose so perfectly self-possessed. She should be running around the room with the other kids, enjoying the last bit of buzz. The only one of the cast who had a word for her was this middle-aged baritone. Though, fair’s fair, he knew what he was up to onstage, and he had the right word for Rose.
Charlie excused himself, saying he had to get up early. Tom cocked his head, about to make one of his remarks. Charlie shook his head once to shut him up. Rose followed Charlie for a few steps. Mary heard her say softly, “Thanks for coming. And thank Deirdre.” Another trip wire Rose stepped over neatly. On her way back to her chair Rose said to Mary, “Where’s Mom?”
Mary said, “She probably got stuck in the hall with Jack. Let’s go see.” She took Rose by the shoulders. Rose was stiff as a board, her eyes heavy. Mary said, “Come with me for a minute. Is there another door out of this madhouse? We’ll just step outside for a breath of air.”
They walked single file behind the stage along a narrow corridor made narrower by a cluster of ropes and pulleys, and down a staircase and out onto a loading dock. Mary said, “Aw, Rose, you should feel like a bottle of champagne.”
“Yeah, right. Are you blind? Are you so dumb you can’t see how fucked up it all is? Everything. There’s not one normal person in my whole life. Not one. Mom should have given me up for adoption.”
Mary said, “Aw, Rose,” and held her arms out.
Rose batted them aside. “Why didn’t you tell her? You were her big pal back then. Never mind—you wanted a baby, too. Except when you finally saw how fucked up it is, you moved out.”
“And not a minute too soon.” As quick as the words were out of her mouth, Mary wished them back. She closed her eyes. She’d been stung so fast in so many ways—her forearm still hurt where Rose had swatted it, and yes, she’d come to want Rose to be hers but not the way Rose said it, and yes, she’d moved out, she’d moved out for all their sakes, but try explaining that to Rose when she was spitting out every drop of poison in her. At the same time she saw Rose in the corner of the greenroom in the middle of the Pierces, as if posing for a family portrait—Rose putting on as stiff a face as she could—and all the while she must have been wondering what sort of a picture the other kids were seeing, what sort of curious or clever remarks she’d hear or overhear the next day. Mary had seen enough of this smart set as they lolled about on the porch at Sawtooth, making comments about someone’s pathetic tennis game or someone’s too-cute name for a boat. Maybe the whole school wasn’t like the Sawtooth bunch, but from the sound of them they were the ones who were good at games, who could shrivel the son of the owner of the Dodge dealership in Wakefield or mock the dutiful straight A’s of the Tran girls. And here came Rose, the new girl in the tenth grade—or whatever they called it here—and who was she? She was Jack Aldrich’s niece; she was the music teacher’s pet, and so she got a starring role—did she think that made her hot stuff? But there was the rest of the story. And now Mary saw what the cousin soprano was up to, taking a picture of the Pierce family and the bastard daughter.
The light from the building reached as far as the edge of the woods, where it blurred into the night mist. Mary said, “I don’t mean that, Rose. I miss you something terrible. I miss being in our house together. It was just that I thought I was only making things worse between you and your mother—the pair of you as fierce as you are.”
“You know what Mom’s doing now? She’s going to work here. You could have talked her out of that. If Uncle Jack wanted to help he should have helped some other way. And he is so full of shit. He thinks this place is like happy valley. In his dreams.”
Mary said, “I’m not sure it would be different anywhere else, you coming in as a new girl and all. I went to parochial school, and the top girls there got after me. It’s the girls, isn’t it? But it can change as fast as the weather. It’s just a shame you had your cast party spoiled. But that white-haired baritone got it right, you know. I knew you could sing, but you played the part as if you were her. And that little tenor—not a big voice but a sweet voice. You did right by him in your duets, you sang it piano so he could keep in the game but a piano that has some sauce in it. And your quartet! You were flying there, Rose, just opened up and soared. It’s a nice piece of music, that, and the timing’s tricky. All of you, your sweet boy tenor, and the baritone …” Mary touched her shoulder. “So, Rose, darling, you’ve had your say out here, and now it’s time to go back in—never mind the jealous ones, but have a word with the ones who helped. There’s the musicians in the band. They’re not schoolboys, so you thank them. I’ll be right with you.”
Rose had listened with her head down but at the last looked up. “Okay. But you won’t talk too much, right? I mean, it’s nice what you just said, but let them—”
“Don’t worry, I’ll be—”
“—finish a sentence.”
The greenroom was still a swirl. The actors had taken off their costumes and makeup but weren’t letting go of a party. May and Dick got up when they saw Rose. May said, “Time for us
to get home. I’ll have this costume done by the afternoon. I can drop it by your house.”
Rose said she’d walk them out to the parking lot. Mary was about to hold her back but then thought that since the band wasn’t in the greenroom, they might be putting their instruments in their cars.
Just as they got to Dick’s pickup Elsie swooped down and took Rose’s arm. She said, “I have something to say to you.” She led Rose off, three cars away. Mary didn’t like Elsie’s look and went after them.
Elsie, still holding Rose’s arm, hissed at her, “How could you? How could you do that to her? And to Dick?”
“Mom! What are you talking about? What?”
“That accent you put on. That swamp-Yankee accent. You made fun of them. It’s an insult.”
Rose was silent. Mary said, “Oh, for God’s sake, Elsie. It’s a comedy. She could have done Irish. And I wouldn’t—”
Elsie said, “You stay out of this.”
“Is that all you have to say?” Rose said. “That’s it?”
“Yes,” Elsie said. “Except maybe this playacting, maybe this whole school, is a big mistake.”
“Come with me,” Rose said. “Come right now. We’ll see if you’ve gone crazy.” She pulled on Elsie’s arm. Elsie pulled it free. Rose marched to Dick’s truck, went up to the passenger window. May rolled it down. Elsie came up behind Rose. Rose said, “May, tell me honestly—what did you think?”
“Of your play? It’s good. I told you it’s good, and I think you were the best one. You sing even better than you did at Sylvia Teixeira’s wedding. Of course, this time I could understand the words.”