To her surprise, Tori abruptly frowned. “Yeah, but she has this thing about letting anybody in.”
A shadow fell over Holly’s plate and the next thing she knew a long-limbed brunette was sliding into the booth next to her, not so gently using her hips to bump Holly farther in to make room. “Hey, Tori. How’s tricks?”
“Murphy.”
In the prolonged silence that followed, Holly was aware that Murphy was studying her, but Holly looked anywhere but at the woman. Tori was obviously not pleased to see her and Holly didn’t want to interfere.
“Still holding a grudge? I don’t know why.”
Tori sipped her coffee, then resumed eating the last of her gnocchi.
“Who’s this?”
Holly looked Murphy in the eye, at first because she found the woman’s tone overly familiar, and then because Murphy’s hand was on her knee. She did not like being pawed by men and saw no reason not to resent it just as much from a woman. “Remove your hand.”
The hand retreated, but Murphy winked.
“Leave, Murph,” Tori snapped. “I mean it.”
“Your new squeeze. Did you finally leave Geena? I’d almost respect you if you have.”
“Do the right thing, for once, and just go.”
Murphy turned in the booth toward Holly, leaning toward her with an air of shared intimacy. “She was crazy about me once.” She made a leisurely examination of her right hand, flexing and curling her fingers and examining her cuticles. “Make that twice.”
Tori flushed and turned her head away.
“Whereas you obviously disliked and disrespected her,” Holly observed, as congenially as if they were discussing the weather. She had always hated conflict, but apparently she was getting over that. “Otherwise you would never go out of your way to embarrass her in front of a friend in this manner. Or is this a schoolyard thing, where you punch the one you love?”
For just a moment Murphy looked nonplussed, then her mocking smile returned. “The mouse that roared, I see. Catch you later, T.” She slid out of the booth with a graceful push and went back the way she had come.
“I am so sorry about that, Holly.”
“It’s no big deal,” Holly answered, though she was miffed. Mouse that roared, indeed.
“Geena and I called it quits once, about three years ago. I was miserable and let Murphy too close one night”
“You don’t have to explain. I’m not judging you. I just didn’t know lesbians could be boors.”
“I just didn’t want you to think I’m something I’m not.”
Remembering Clay’s comment that no one looked like their sex life, Holly tried to put Tori back at ease. “It isn’t really any of my business, is it? To each her own. I sincerely believe that.”
“I know you do.” Tori hesitated, then said slowly, “Alpha rewarded people who worked hard, and we both worked pretty damned hard. I think if we’d spent a little more time away from our desks, we might have been friends, you know what I mean?”
“Yes, I do. I was thinking that myself, just a few minutes ago.”
Tori was still choosing her words with care. “And part of my feeling is that we have some values in common, impressions I have of the kind of person you are and you must have of me. Like I said, I just don’t want you to think I’m something I’m not. Murphy was such a mistake. I knew it at the time, but I was so unhappy. She taught me something about myself I didn’t know, but that wasn’t worth the trouble she’s been since.” Tori flushed. “Geena knows it happened. I told her everything Murphy” She broke off, but her color continued to rise. “Anyway…”
Eager to turn the subject away from sex, Holly asked, “What did you fight about, if you don’t mind my asking.”
“Money. Long and short of it.” Tori grabbed at the subject as if it were a lifeline. “I made more of it than she did at the time, and we were both pigheaded about it. She would always make a point of telling me when something she bought me had come from her money. I always said that we were a couple and what was mine was hers. But then I would decide to do something extravagant and excuse it by saying it was with my money. We had a knockdown drag out about buying a new car. I wanted to spend more than she did and acted like my higher salary ought to be the tiebreaker. Things were said that we both resented.”
“But you patched it up.”
“Yeah.” Tori’s color was back to normal and she scooped up her last spoonful of gnocchi and sauce. She swallowed quickly and added, “After I was with Murphy I realized that I had been playing house with Geena. Pretending to commitment. We lived together and slept together and said that we loved each other, but except for my body I’d never really given her anything I valued. Not my absolute trust, and not my future. I had to stop being so self-reliant and lean on her some if I was going to really let Geena into my life. And vice versa.”
Every word struck a chord in Holly, and she was aware, again, of how distant she had felt from Clay yesterday. His failure to leave his perspective for even a moment in order to empathize with her decision had left her faith in his judgment badly shaken. “Did she feel the same way?”
Tori nodded. “She did, and since I think that of the two of us she’s far wiser, I knew I was on the right track. We pool all our money now, and we have to decide together on something major. We started planning our retirement discussing really long-term issues. Where we want to live in another ten years, if we want to have kids. All those things. We’d avoided them before.” She shook her head with a self-deprecating sigh. “Damn Murphy anyway. She’s such an arrogant shit because she’s good in bed, and it was, well, an eye-opening night for me. But it didn’t matter. As soon as my head cleared I wanted Geena. I wanted it to be Geena loving me like that because I wanted her with me forever.”
“I understand,” Holly murmured. Try as she might, she could not picture herself some thirty years in the future and still enduring lectures about the decisions she made. She could not imagine another fifteen years of hiding her lapses into food that was bad for her, or even five years of doing the household work that Clay found too disruptive to his search for inner peace. She could not, she knew with a heartsick shudder, imagine even another night of digging down deep and pretending. Tori had experienced something with Murphy and for years with Geena some physical bond Holly could not fully understand. Eight years with Clay and she had no way of appreciating what a night of pure passion might be like.
It was all seeping away from her, her certainty that she had chosen well, that she was living a good life, that Clay’s path was worth her commitment and support.
God, she thought, what am I considering?
She had been fine this morning. That she had calculated it would take seventeen boxes in two carloads to remove her clothing and belongings from Clay’s house was irrelevant in the morning light. What exactly had he done to warrant her leaving him?
Jo’s voice or was it her own? He’s done exactly what he’s done to make you stay: nothing.
“Are you okay?”
“Yes,” she said automatically. “I was just remembering something I forgot to do.”
“I’ve been jawing your ear off.”
“No, I was really interested. Money is a tricky subject.” How could she explain that she made very few of the decisions about how they would spend their earnings, that is, when they spent it on anything other than the basics. Her savings account was substantial. She was putting money down on the mortgage over and above the payment to pay it off sooner. That was just common sense when they could afford it. It occurred to her, now that she had to face some sobering realities, that she had not cared at the time that her name wasn’t on the title to the house. Fine. Clay’s name wasn’t on her savings account.
God, she thought again. Is it going to come down to this? Am I this petty? When did I get this angry?
Tish dropped off their check and Tori scooped it up.
“Let me, please. As a thank you for what you did
yesterday.”
“You don’t have”
“I know. But I want to.”
Holly hesitated, then said, “Next time I’ll buy.”
Tori smiled brightly. “It’s a deal.”
Tish had lingered after delivering the check. “I really could use the extra hands, sweets, if you were serious.”
“I was,” Tori said. “You know I’d scrub pots for a week for you.”
“In that case, I’ll take care of the check.” Tish snapped the paper from Tori’s hand.
Tori muttered, “Just keep me away from Murphy.”
“I did try, but you were deep in your cups at the time.”
Tori laughed at that. “Okay, let me rephrase. Keep Murphy away from me unless you want a homicide on the premises.”
“She’s about ready to leave,” Tish said. “I’m sure she has to get her beauty sleep before she goes to Jack’s tonight.”
“I was thinking about asking Geena if she wanted to dance the night away, since it’s the first Friday of the month. But you think Murphy will be there, huh?”
“Yeah, when isn’t she? I’m going to work your butt offyou’ll deserve a night on the town.”
“Jack’s is not exactly the Ritz.” Tori turned to Holly. “It’s the nearest gay bar and on first Fridays they have Ladies’ Night. It’s pretty much a dive, but it beats fighting traffic all the way to West Hollywood or Laguna Beach. Though the bar where Melissa Etheridge used to play is very nice.”
“You should treat yourself to whatever you want,” Holly advised. “I have to be in Ventura by eight.”
Tori glanced at her watch. “You have to leave by, what, three? You’d better hit the road.”
“Fortunately it won’t take me long to get ready.”
“Yeah, I’ve always admired your natural look. I take way too long to get ready in the morning.”
Holly took in, for the first time with more than a passing interest, how lovely Tori was. Her eyebrows were gracefully arched, and her eyelids dusted with a delicate mixture of browns and oranges that enhanced her bright brown eyes. Her olive cheeks were smooth and soft and Holly knew they would not burn her throat…
Aghast, she floundered for something to say and came up with, “I’m too lazy.”
Tori shrugged and picked up her purse. “It suits you and Geena both. I have flaws to cover. Show me where to put my stuff, Tish.”
Holly left with a promise to call soon and drove away with a sensation of escape. When she pulled into her driveway she was glad Clay wasn’t there. She turned off the engine and sat for a minute, her head on the steering wheel.
It was too much to take in. She could hardly wrap her mind around the idea that Clay was not the man she had thought he was. Her opinion of him, formed at sixteen, had been based on his persona as a teacher. It had not changed in all the years since, not until yesterday, when her image of him as a man and a partner fragmented like a smashed mirror. That alone made her feel as if she was walking a spit of land between the yawning chasms of past and future.
But there was more, more to bear, more to fear. More she could not even comprehend. Murphy with Tori, doing something to her that three years later still made Tori blush. Holly could imagine Tori whispering what it was to Geena, asking Geena to do it, too. Their bodies merged in a midnight glow. What was it? Did it matter? Something wonderful, something she, Holly, had never had. And would never have with Clay. Might never have… with a man.
The car seemed suddenly airless and she hurried inside, trying to turn her mind to immediate needs. She needed to change for the wedding, and pack a few edibles for the long drive. It would take more than four hours to go a little over a hundred miles in rush-hour traffic, but not even half that to return home any time after nine.
She showered, the water as hot as she could stand it, shampoo suds cascading down her shoulders and stomach.
She was lost, abruptly, in the feel of her breasts under the slick lather.
A question formed. An equation wanted to be solved.
You could not even know what a thing was, she had thought only yesterday, and mathematics could express it. How to express this? The sensation of skin, the prickle of her nipples and the question is this how other women feel?
Her fingertips felt alive. She turned off the water at last and toweled her hair. She looked at her body in the mirror, then gently touched her lips, her hips, at last her breasts. Is this how other women feel?
She had no way to solve the equation. The principles of mathematics demanded that an equation be solved by logical reduction, not trial and error. She could not logically approach this question. She could not substitute values when she had no idea of the variables and constants for the equation. It was beyond her mental grasp. But trial and error led to thoughts of Murphy and Tori… Tori and Geena.
She felt nauseous and grabbed the sink, striving for some semblance of calm.
The front door opened and closed, and she dug down very, very deep, to pretend. This pretense was far more important than anything she’d had to do before. She smiled at Clay and spoke and watched herself going through the motions of asking after his day and listening to the answer as if she cared.
While he showered she rooted around in the back of her drawer for lingerie she’d bought years ago, thinking it might… might change the way she felt when Clay touched her. She’d bought it for herself, but Clay had thought she’d meant to titillate him. He had been disappointed with her.
And like a fool, she railed at herself, you set aside how you felt. She wiggled into the cleavage-creating black bra. It fit since she still had not lost those fifteen pounds she’d been perpetually fighting. Black pantyhose, they had to be there somewhere. She carefully struggled into the hose, then put on the black pantsuit made of raw silk, her one item of evening wear. It had served her well for years at faculty parties and family holidays. They went out so rarely she did not need more, even though tonight she wanted more than she needed.
She wished she had something shocking red, with hair to match. She wanted to feel alive. The mouse that roared? Yes, she wanted to roar, mouse or not. Her simple haircut offered no real opportunities for change it was wash and wear so as not to need a blow dryer. Then she remembered her grandmother’s jewelry, the only thing she had of her grandmother’s. The rose pendant and earrings. They would suit her mood.
Clay did not approve of jewelry. It distracted from the natural state of the human body, was spawned by consumerist notions of appearance and allowed for the casual flaunting of wealth.
Screw Clay, she thought. Or rather, she admitted, studying herself in the mirror, don’t. And she smiled at her reflection. These pieces weren’t the same thing as a Rolex these were family heirlooms. They were her heritage, such as it was. She felt self-assured and attractive, and she liked the feeling.
She watched him come out of the bathroom and felt a surge of the same courage she had found yesterday, facing Jim Felker and his petty bigotry. She could tell him now that she was going to leave him. She almost did. But she would let this idea grow for a little while, to prove it wasn’t a mere brainstorm.
The last time had last night been the last time she’d feel him inside her and count the minutes until it was over?
In life’s equation of what mattered, how had she thought her physical relationship with Clay could substitute for the value of love? How had she thought that was worth bearing? How could she discover what would make her happy, at least physically? Trial and error… Murphy and Tori… Tori and Geena…
The equation she could not solve seemed to have women as constants. And then she understood at least a piece of the puzzle. She was the variable for now. She was the thing that was changing and would change, until she found her own answers.
4
What made it hard, from the moment they got in the car, was that Clay was in a good mood. His semester was shaping up with interested students and he’d been asked to co-teach a graduate semin
ar under the aegis of the department head.
“I think I might try to get the all-important Ph.D.,” he admitted. “I know it’s just a piece of paper, about what you can research and not what you truly understand, but not having it is an unfortunate barrier.”
“One of those necessary evils that rob you of your essential humanity?” She took advantage of an 18-wheeler’s lag in acceleration to cut over a lane. The 405 was, as usual, a parking lot.
He didn’t seem to notice the ironic edge to her tone. “Just that. Of course, I’d feel like I could really go for it if your situation were settled.” He threw her a charming glance and all at once she remembered the way he had been the first time she had seen him. Profound and compassionate, he had been dedicated to helping his students escape from the relentless message of a consumerist society. His first question for the class, that first day, had been, “So, what did you buy today?” The follow-up had been, “Why did you buy it?”
It seemed ages ago, before he’d given her the presence of mind to accept herself. She amended her thoughts. To accept herself as he saw her. She had never accepted herself as she was. That much was clear. Of course, to accept herself as she was she needed to understand who she was. That equation was too complicated and frightening to approach rationally, so she put it away.
“My situation? Oh, you mean job. I’m going to look into the master’s degree I turned down. I haven’t kept up on the field, at least not much, and a lot changes in four years in the sciences. There may be opportunities I never foresaw. Certainly, there may be developments I can’t follow or understand.” It was an unsettling thought.
“So you really are going to do it? What are we going to live on? I don’t think my paycheck will cover the mortgage.”
“It does, you know,” she said softly. She wanted to explain to him that he would have to figure it out from now on. She felt as if she was being a little unfair to him. She knew a part of his future and he had no clue. “And we live so cheaply.” She felt a fraud to say “we.”
Substitute for Love Page 6