by Logan Chance
She didn’t acknowledge me until I practically stood right next to her.
“Oh, it’s you,” she slurred as she placed a hand on her friend’s shoulder to steady herself. “Don’t bother me. I’m trying to have fun, something you know nothing about.”
“I know how to have fun. But you’re right, I only came over here to chat with your friend.” I took her friend’s hand in mine and laid a kiss on her yellow polished nails. Margo? Marlo?
“Hi there, again,” her friend giggled.
“Margo.” Penny slapped her friend’s hand from mine, and I smiled at the jealous expression on her beautiful face.
“What’s wrong, Penny? Don’t want me having fun with your friend here?”
“There are a million women in here. Take your pick of any of them, and leave us alone.” Her feet were unsteady as she waved a hand in my face.
With a quick snap, I gripped her wrist and yanked her body closer. “Let’s get one thing straight. I’m the boss, stop telling me what to do,” I hissed never breaking eye contact.
“Ok, on that note, I’ll see you two later. Penny, I’ll be right over there at the bar if you need me,” Margo said as she left Penny and me standing toe to toe with my hold on her tightening.
“How dare you speak to me that way,” Penny said with a fiery passion in her voice.
It turned me on—fucking fierce.
She taunted me, made me feel stupid for not knowing as much as she did, and I wanted to let her know I wouldn’t stand for it any longer.
“How dare I? Do you know who you’re talking to?”
“Yeah, my jerkface boss.” Her words fanned across my lips, and I could taste the liquor on her breath.
Her pulse quickened, and it throbbed under my fingertips. Without thinking, I turned around and kept a hold of her as I led her through the dance club. A dark hallway to the restroom was lit by one tiny pink neon light and I slammed her against the wall. “You want me to kiss you, don’t you?” I asked, gripping her waist with both hands. I pressed my cock into the spot between her legs so she could feel how hard I was for her.
Her arms flew around my neck as she clung to me tighter. She rocked her hips and I knew this affected her as much as me.
Her eyes were heavy with desire as I brushed my hand along her shoulder, finally feeling her soft silky skin. “This little black dress is fucking slutty. Why would you wear this? Do you like to tease, Penny?”
Her mouth opened and I could see the rage on her face. She took a deep breath and before she could speak I raised my finger, pressing her lips closed and shook my head back and forth. “You stay quiet, and stop teasing me.”
She sucked my finger into her mouth and my eyes fell closed. Fuck, it felt surreal until I felt her teeth clamp down around my skin, drawing blood.
“What the fuck, Penny.” I pulled my finger from her bite, examining it.
“I’m not teasing you. I hate you,” she spewed her venom and my heart raced harder.
“You’re a fucking tease. You don’t see the way you’re flaunting your tight little body for every man to see tonight?” I pulled her harder against me as my throbbing cock needed attention. “Do you want to see how it feels to be teased, Penny?” Oh, I’ll give her a taste of her own medicine.
“Are you kidding me? Every woman here tonight is dressed like me, some even worse.”
“I won’t allow you to dress like a little tramp and turn me on. Jesus, your tits are spilling out of the top of your dress,” I said with my lips inches from hers.
“Allow?”
I backed away slightly as I gazed at her dress one more time and licked my full hungry lips. Teasing her as bad as she teased me these past few weeks was the only thing on my mind.
“Yes. You look so fuckable right now, Penny, and I don’t like it.”
“Fuck you, asshole,” she said as her fingers tightened on my neck, her nails digging deep as she pulled me closer.
“Fuck me? No, fuck you.” I ran my nose along her soft skin, breathing in the tasty smell of her body.
What was I doing? This was insanity.
“Oh God, Theo.”
My name tripped from her lips and I angled closer to whisper in her ear. “Are you wet, Penny? I bet if I ran my fingers along your pussy, you’d be soaked.” She gasped at my words. “Would you like it if I pressed on your clit and pumped my fingers so deep in-fucking-side you? I bet you’ve never come as hard as I can make you.”
“No,” she said as she rocked her hips against me, grazing her teeth along her bottom lip.
“I bet if I finger fucked you, your pussy’s so tight. So sweet, dripping down my hand.” Her head fell back against the wall and she let out a breathy moan. A low growl rumbled from me feeling her sweet cunt grind against my dick. Oh God, I was so fucking hard.
“And then after you come on my hand, I’d smear it all over your tits and suck it off. You want me to, don’t you? Tell me how bad you want me to suck your wet nipples into my mouth and bite down, making you scream my name,” I demanded, my heart racing.
“Please, stop,” she begged, rocking herself against me. Her words said one thing, but the hunger in her eyes told me she wanted this as badly as I did.
“Penny, you fucking tease me. I bet you smell so good and I bet you taste even better.” Drunk from the want pouring through my veins, I needed to bury my thick cock in her, balls deep.
“Do you want your little pussy to come all over me? My fingers. My face. My fucking cock.” I braced both hands against the wall beside her, boxing her in. My lips brushed hers lightly as I spoke, “Do you like it when I tease you, Penny?”
“Oh God yes, I mean no,” she whimpered, her fingers twisting through my hair.
“You need to stop. I can’t handle it,” I whispered. She needed to learn she couldn’t tease me anymore.
“I’m sorry,” she murmured.
She groaned as her body arched into me. It was too intense, my senses overloaded as I made the mistake of gazing at her face. Her eyes squeezed shut, her cheeks flushed from arousal, and the god damn freckles along the bridge of her nose were too much. I stepped back and her eyes flew open. Her chest rose and fell as she stared back at me. What the fuck happened?
I lowered my forehead to rest along hers, whispering, “Penny, I’ve never been a good guy, and I can’t handle what you do to me.”
“I have a boyfriend,” she cut me off.
My heart beat through my disbelieving ears. Disappointment washed over me, drowning me. I couldn’t believe the words she spoke which stabbed me with their jagged meaning.
“Fuck.” I squeezed my eyes shut, punching my fist at the wall.
Shaking my head, I walked away from her, beelining straight for the exit.
Run, was the only thing on my mind as I raced to my car.
Run from this girl and her beautiful eyes and her cute fucking freckles.
Once seated inside I took a heavy breath.
I slammed my hand on the steering wheel.
Fuck, I wasn’t expecting any of that.
I needed to eighty-six Penny once and for all.
I almost went too far, I was ready to take her right then and there, fuck her up against the wall in Mekka, a few nights before, until she mentioned a boyfriend and shell-shocked my entire system. Which lucky for me she stopped things, because wanting her should be the furthest thing from my mind.
Now, Operation Get Rid of Penny’s Ass was my only mission.
By the time Friday rolled around, I called Blair to tell her I was on my way over. She lived not too far from South Beach in a quiet neighborhood.
I climbed the brick steps leading up to her front porch and stopped, steeling myself, before I could knock. Blair was a touchy subject for me, and the thought of seeing her never got any easier. She’d been beautiful to me a lifetime ago, but now when I looked at her I only saw lies and deceit. After knocking on the bright red door, I thrust both hands into the pockets of my jeans and rocked on my h
eels as I waited.
“Hey, right on time,” Blair said with her smile lighting up her hazel irises. Her long black hair was swept up into a bun, and she glanced over her shoulder as our daughter came running down the hallway behind her.
“Daddy, Daddy,” Lucy called. Her brown-haired pigtails bounced with every step. Pushing past her mother, she leapt into my arms. Blair leaned against the doorway watching as I hugged her tight.
“Hey, Boo Bear,” I said, calling her the nickname I created the moment she was born.
At three years old she held my heart in her tiny innocent hands.
Blair and I dated a few years back, and when she found out she was pregnant I wanted to marry her. I loved her, or so I thought.
On the day I planned to propose, I found her in our apartment fucking my half-brother and my heart shattered into a million pieces.
The worst part of the whole fiasco was the fact my daughter was inside her as she fucked him.
I blew up and never spoke to my brother again. Blair, however, was a different story. We shared joint custody of our daughter and I remained pleasant whenever I saw her, for Lucy’s sake. Even though Blair tried desperately to creep back into my good graces ever since I left her, I would never forgive her betrayal.
“She just ate, so she’s ready to go,” Blair said, handing me Lucy’s red backpack.
“Have fun, see you on Tuesday.”
We waved goodbye, and I kissed Lucy’s bright red cheeks as I carried her to the car.
“Ready to get out of here?” I asked as I buckled her into the car seat
“Ready,” she squealed.
We were off and I couldn’t wait to get her home. I missed her when she wasn’t around.
Being a father changed my life, and my daughter was everything to me. Somedays, I didn’t know how I would make it from one day to the next. Was I scared? Fuck yeah, I was. I worried about everything. Life was good as a real estate investor, and the bills were always paid. But the dream of one day owning a bar wasn’t going away, and I wanted to give it a go. Living in South Beach the clubs along Ocean Drive were the pulse of the city. I wanted a piece of it.
And now at thirty years old, I sank most of my money into the Goat, and I needed this to work.
Life was hard though, finding love and companionship was a no-go.
Chaos, headaches, and utter madness were a part of my regular routine and I wouldn’t have it any other way. The life of a single father left me little time for love.
EIGHT
PENNY
“I bet no one could make you come as hard as I can.”
“You did,” my mind screamed.
For the next two days after the club incident I never left my apartment. I cleaned, and cleaned some more. Sweeping, mopping, and scrubbing every part of the tile floors—anything to keep my mind occupied. Anything to not think about the look on Theo’s face when I told him about my boyfriend. When he slammed his hand against the wall I felt the devastation pour off him.
I avoided Dex’s phone calls. He called a few times over the past few weeks, and every time I asked about coming home he would have to rush off the phone. Confusion over everything took up residence deep within me. As much as I tried to think about anything else, Theo’s hurt expression kept rolling through my overactive mind. I was a bitch for not stopping it sooner.
Having his hands on me was something I never thought I’d experience again. Or want, to be honest, after the way he treated me at the bar. My body pulled to his, fucking traitor, and I needed to stay far away.
I was the worst girlfriend ever.
When Saturday morning arrived, work was on the agenda.
As I finished getting ready, smoothing lotion down my legs, Margo threw herself on my bed.
“Fuck my life,” she complained as she covered both arms over her eyes. Her blonde curly waves splayed over the bright orange pillowcase.
“What’s wrong?” I asked, looking over at her.
She propped up onto her elbows and glared. “Hottie fighter has a whore girlfriend.”
I sat down on the bed and wrapped an arm around her shoulder. “I’m sorry, Mar.”
“It’s ok. I’ll figure it out or find someone new to stalk.”
“Yeah,” I whispered, barely listening.
“What’s wrong? What happened with Theo at the club the other night?” She sat and waited for my answer.
“Nothing happened. Nothing at all.” Part truth. He didn’t touch me, but I felt the ghost of his hands everywhere.
I hated myself, completely hated myself. I hated how turned on I was. It was wrong. Dex should have been on my mind, but I couldn’t focus with Theo’s hot breath saying those things to me.
His filthy mouth I loved on the beach, now dripped with poison.
Once I arrived at work my stomach filled with butterflies. Dread set in at seeing Theo. Saturdays were busy, and I couldn’t wait to drown all my nervous energy with tending to the happy guests who would need some liquor to enjoy their day further.
“Ready for a hot day?” Seth asked as I set up the bar.
“I heard it’s going to be a scorcher.” I threw my hair into a low ponytail.
“Yeah.”
“Wish we had some fans.” I felt the heat of the pending afternoon looming in the air.
The crowd picked up as we sweated to the sounds of Jimmy Buffett’s ‘Cheeseburger in Paradise’ over and over.
What was it with Jimmy Buffett being the epitome of tiki bar music?
I worked the outside bar while Seth took care of the guests inside. Around three o’clock I went on my lunch break.
I decided to stroll the beach while I let the salty air flow across my skin. I stopped at a few of the vendor booths lined along the large sidewalk on Ocean Drive. Glancing at the jewelry for sale, I saw a beautiful turquoise bracelet with little turtle charms. The silver and blue sparkled in the sunlight. After purchasing the bracelet and slipping it onto my wrist, a squeal of laughter caught my attention.
Down by the water, I saw Theo chasing a small brown haired child in a pink swimsuit and knew instantly he wasn’t lying the night we first met. I moved away from the jewelry booth and tried to get a closer look. He laughed as he grabbed her and lifted her above his shoulders.
What really made my jaw drop was the sight of him without a shirt. His shoulders were broad and his muscles lean. His sun-soaked body was lickable, and I remembered the one fateful night we shared when his body pumped inside me. A shiver skated across my arms and down my back.
After kicking off my tennis shoes and socks, I took a few steps onto the sandy beach. Theo and his daughter sat plopped down in the sand close to the shore, the waves crashing beyond them. He picked up a yellow shovel as she picked up a purple one and together they dug into the sand. I laughed quietly to myself as she tossed a shovel-full of sand in his lap and squealed with little girl giggles. Watching the carefree way he played with her made me doubt him to be the asshole I pegged him for.
I stalked closer as I watched. He lurched forward, picked her up, and tickled her.
I could hear her this time as she squawked and laughed calling out “Daddy” which in turn rooted me to the spot, I was too close.
It was sweet the way they played together and I smiled as I noticed the carefree expression on his gorgeous face. Without knowing it, my feet moved of their own volition until I stood mere inches away. I blocked his sun, casting a shadow over his ripped chest, and he glanced up.
His smile vanished as soon as the recognition dawned on his face. “Penny, are you stalking me now?”
“I…I didn’t mean to.” My attention flitted to the little girl covered in sand, who looked curiously at me. “I should go,” I said. Feeling like an intruder encroaching on his time with his daughter, I took two steps back.
“You don’t need to,” he whispered. “Penny, this is my daughter Lucy.”
With a wide grin, I sat down in the sand next to her.
“Hi,�
�� Lucy said, not stopping her task of filling her bucket with sand.
“Lucy, do you want to be the pretty princess who lives in the castle?” I asked.
She thought about it for a moment and glanced at her Dad. “No, this castle will be too small.”
I laughed. “Then we better make sure we build it really big.”
“Bigger than my daddy’s house?”
“Hey now.” Theo laughed, grabbing his daughter around the waist and tickling her down to the sand.
She squealed with laughter and I tried to remember why I was there.
What was I doing? You hate him, leave.
He handed over his yellow shovel as Lucy showed me the method of their building plans. We were building a castle with a huge moat around it.
She laughed and scooted in next to me as I dug out the moat. Theo sat across from me with his long legs criss-crossed, leaning back on his palms behind him as he watched us. I tried to focus on the moat and not the way his swim trunks rested just below a perfect v.
I took a moment to gaze at the tattoos on his chest and arm. An intricate ink pattern wove over his pectoral muscle and wrapped around his shoulder. The koi fish swimming up his arm, intertwined with the pattern.
It was sexy, and I wanted nothing more than to trace the pattern with my tongue.
What the hell, Penny? Stop.
Adoration filled Theo’s eyes as he watched Lucy. Was this the same man who taunted me daily? I felt I was in the twilight zone.
“I have to get back to work,” I said to Lucy, as I stood and wiped the loose sand from my shorts.
“Bye,” Lucy said with a bright smile.
“Bye, sweetie.”
“Penny.” Theo hardly acknowledged me as I stood there saying goodbye to his daughter.
“Goodbye, Theo.” I walked away without a second glance to him.
I felt his gaze on me the entire way back to the bar. It’s funny how you know when someone’s staring at your ass as you walk, and right now I didn’t care. Let him stare. He would never touch it again. Or any other part of me.