Mary, Queen of Scots, and the Murder of Lord Darnley

Home > Nonfiction > Mary, Queen of Scots, and the Murder of Lord Darnley > Page 73
Mary, Queen of Scots, and the Murder of Lord Darnley Page 73

by Alison Weir


  CSP Scottish

  Inventaires

  CSP Scottish

  Ibid.

  Keith; Strickland

  Register of the Privy Seal

  CSP Scottish

  Melville

  McCrie

  Papal Negotiations

  CSP Scottish

  CSP Spanish

  Melville

  CSP Spanish

  Gore-Browne

  CSP Scottish

  Ibid.; Bedford later informed Cecil that this rumour was baseless.

  CSP Foreign

  Buchanan

  Melville

  State Papers in the Public Record Office: Domestic, James I. The elder Anthony Standen was a minor player in the Gunpowder Plot of 1605.

  Ruthven: Narration

  Melville

  Ruthven: Narration

  Melville; Bothwell

  Bothwell

  Ruthven: Narration; Cecil Papers; Wright

  Cecil Papers

  Melville

  Ibid.

  CSP Scottish

  Cecil Papers

  Ruthven describes his illness as “an inflammation of the liver and a consumption of the kidneys”; it could have been cancer, or perhaps the consequence of heavy drinking.

  Ruthven: Narration

  Melville

  Blackwood

  CSP Scottish; Ruthven: Narration; Keith; Labanoff; Knox; Buchanan

  Melville

  CSP Scottish

  Harleian MSS.

  Knox

  Diurnal of Occurrents

  Keith; Tytler: History; MSS. in the National Library of Scotland

  Keith

  Ibid.

  CSP Scottish

  Melville

  CSP Scottish

  Inventaires

  A document alleged to be this dispensation is preserved at Dunrobin Castle, but may not be authentic.

  Knox

  In 1599, Jean married Ogilvy as her third husband.

  CSP Scottish

  Ibid.; Ruthven: Narration; Keith; Buchanan; Knox

  Diurnal of Occurrents

  CSP Scottish; Miscellany of the Maitland Club (3 vols., 1833)

  CSP Scottish

  Ibid.; Cotton MSS. Caligula

  Knox

  CSP Spanish

  Knox; Buchanan

  Knox

  8. “THIS VILE ACT”

  Strickland: Lives of the Queens of Scotland

  There are several accounts of the events that followed. Two were by eyewitnesses: Mary’s version appears in two similar letters, one to Archbishop Beaton (2 April 1566, in Labanoff, hereinafter referred to as Mary to Beaton) and the other to Charles IX and Catherine de’ Medici (CSP Venetian, hereinafter referred to as Mary to Charles IX).

  Lord Ruthven wrote his account in his 6,000-word Narration, which, after being edited by Cecil, was completed on 30 April 1566 in England (hereinafter referred to as Ruthven). It was written for the benefit of the English Privy Council and is obviously an attempt to portray Ruthven and his accomplices in the best possible light.

  On 11 March, in Berwick, Randolph wrote an account of Rizzio’s murder (additional MSS., hereinafter referred to as Randolph), based on information given him by one Captain Carew, an English spy in Edinburgh, who had spoken with Mary, Darnley and others involved.

  On 27 March, Randolph and Bedford wrote a joint letter to Cecil describing the recent shocking events (Cotton MSS. Caligula; Wright, hereinafter referred to as Randolph and Bedford).

  In the 1570s, Claude Nau compiled a detailed account of the murder, based probably on Mary’s own reminiscences; it gives details that only she could have known.

  Melville’s memoirs are those of someone who was well informed but was not actually an eyewitness, although he was at Holyrood at the time of the murder; his record of events is succinct and probably accurate.

  There are very few discrepancies in all these accounts, and together they provide what is probably the truth about the events of 9–12 March, 1566.

  Randolph

  Ruthven; Randolph and Bedford

  Register of the Privy Council; Keith; Pitcairn; Ruthven; Gore-Browne

  Melville

  Ibid. Mary gives the time as 7 p.m.

  Ruthven. Mary gives a similar account of this conversation, although less detailed.

  Mary to Beaton

  Ruthven

  Mary to Beaton

  Ruthven

  The full text is given by Gore-Browne.

  State Papers in the Public Record Office: Domestic, James I

  Ruthven

  Ibid.; Randolph and Bedford

  Melville

  Birrel

  Randolph and Bedford

  Ruthven; Mary to Beaton

  Randolph and Bedford

  Herries says Morton struck the first blow; Paul de Foix (Papiers d’Etat, ed. Teulet) says it was George Douglas.

  CSP Scottish. On 23 March, Drury reported to Cecil that one of Ruthven’s followers had arrived in Berwick with his arm bound up—he had been wounded whilst attacking Rizzio.

  Ruthven; Randolph and Bedford

  Ibid.

  Mary to Beaton

  Ibid. Randolph and Bedford say there were 60 wounds on the body. From 1722 onwards, a supposedly indelible bloodstain was said to denote the place where Rizzio was murdered, a myth that was still current in the 19th century. Today, a plaque marks the spot. In the 18th century, a richly inlaid dagger was discovered hidden in the rafters of Queen Mary’s Bath House; it may have been hidden there by one of Rizzio’s murderers.

  CSP Scottish

  Ruthven

  Randolph and Bedford

  Mary to Beaton

  Herries

  Ruthven

  Mary to Beaton

  Ibid.; Nau

  Mary to Beaton

  Randolph

  Mary to Beaton

  Nau

  Melville

  Ibid.; Bothwell; Ruthven; Papiers d’Etat, ed. Teulet

  Melville

  Mary to Beaton

  Nau

  Ibid.; Ruthven

  Melville

  Nau

  Ibid.

  Ibid.

  Ibid.

  Ibid.; Leslie

  Nau

  Ibid.

  Randolph

  Nau

  Mary to Beaton. It must have been Darnley who informed her of this.

  Nau

  Cited by Sitwell

  Nau

  Ibid.

  Ibid.

  Ibid.

  Ruthven; Randolph and Bedford

  Ruthven; Keith

  Melville

  Mary to Beaton

  Nau

  Mary to Beaton; Randolph and Bedford

  Ruthven

  Ibid.

  Ibid.

  Mary to Beaton

  Cited by Sitwell

  Ruthven

  Diurnal of Occurrents

  Nau

  Ibid.

  Cited by James Mackay

  Nau

  Ruthven

  Ibid.; Melville

  Ruthven

  Mary to Charles IX

  Bothwell

  Nau

  Melville

  Nau

  Ibid.; Ruthven

  Nau

  Lennox Narrative

  Nau. In her letter to Charles IX, Mary states that she and Darnley were attended by Traquair, Erskine and “two other persons only,” one of whom was Standen and the other, according to Randolph, “one gentlewoman,” who was probably Margaret Carwood, one of the Queen’s favourite maids-of-honour. Later that year, Mary got Darnley to knight Standen for his loyal service.

  Nau

  Armstrong Davison

  Nau

  Randolph

  Memoir to Cosimo de’ Medici, in Labanoff

  9. “AS THEY HAVE BREWED, SO LET THEM DRINK”

  Because of its infamous associations with Bothwell, Dunbar Castle was dismantled on the orders of Parliam
ent in 1568. Only ruins remain.

  Bothwell

  Mary to Charles IX

  Randolph to Cecil, State Papers in the Public Record Office

  Nau

  Register of the Privy Seal; CSP Scottish

  CSP Scottish; Labanoff

  CSP Venetian

  Nau

  Register of the Privy Council; Diurnal of Occurrents; Ruthven

  Ruthven

  Nau

  Melville

  Ibid.

  Mary to Charles IX

  Melville

  Randolph to Cecil, State Papers in the Public Record Office

  Melville

  Ibid.

  Randolph says she lodged on the High Street.

  Randolph and Bedford; Nau; Diurnal of Occurrents

  Lennox Narrative

  Mary to Charles IX

  Buchanan

  Register of the Privy Seal

  Nau

  Melville

  Cited by Gore-Browne

  CSP Spanish; Papiers d’Etat, ed. Teulet; CSP Foreign ; Keith

  Mary to Beaton

  Mary to Charles IX

  Diurnal of Occurrents; Papiers d’Etat, ed. Teulet; Buchanan

  State Papers in the Public Record Office

  CSP Scottish

  Cited by Bowen

  CSP Scottish

  Cited by Prebble

  State Papers in the Public Record Office

  CSP Spanish

  Ibid.

  CSP Venetian

  CSP Scottish

  Ibid.

  Bothwell

  CSP Scottish

  Register of the Privy Council; Diurnal of Occurrents; Pitcairn; Keith; Bothwell

  CSP Scottish

  Melville

  Lennox Narrative

  Register of the Privy Council. Darnley continued to sign documents, or they were stamped with his sign manual, but he had no say in the formulation of policy.

  From “Lord Bothwell,” in English and Scottish Popular Ballads

  Nau; CSP Foreign

  Register of the Privy Council; Nau

  During the siege of 1573, King David’s Tower was destroyed. In 1578, the Regent Morton refortified Edinburgh Castle and built the Half Moon Battery on the site of David’s Tower. In 1615–17, the royal lodgings were remodelled for James I, at which time painted decorations were added to the tiny room in which he was born; the panelling was not installed until 1848. The initials of James’s parents were probably placed over the doorway in 1617; they may have come from elsewhere. In 1650, Oliver Cromwell dismantled much of the castle’s fortifications. Since the Act of Union of 1707, Edinburgh Castle has been kept in good repair. The Scottish Crown Jewels and the Stone of Destiny are housed in the former royal lodgings.

  CSP Scottish

  Nau

  Teulet; CSP Scottish

  CSP Scottish

  Lennox Narrative

  Labanoff

  CSP Spanish

  Original Letters

  Inventaires

  CSP Foreign

  Randolph, in CSP Foreign, 13 May 1566

  Diurnal of Occurrents

  Nau

  CSP Foreign

  Nau

  Melville

  Nau

  Ibid.

  Ibid.

  Melville

  Lennox Narrative

  CSP Scottish

  CSP Spanish, 18 May 1566

  Nau

  CSP Scottish; Nau

  Maitland to Randolph, in Cotton MSS. Caligula; CSP Spanish

  CSP Spanish; CSP Scottish

  Barberini MSS., Barberini Library, Rome

  Papal Negotiations

  CSP Spanish

  Ibid.; Papal Negotiations

  Egerton MSS.

  Papal Negotiations

  This had been Pius’s own See prior to his elevation to the Papacy.

  Leslie

  Papal Negotiations

  CSP Scottish

  Ibid.

  Knox

  Additional MSS., Bodleian Library

  Calendar of the Manuscripts at Hatfield House

  Lennox Narrative; Hume: Love Affairs

  Nau

  Buchanan alleges that Mary ignored Darnley in her Will and that Bothwell not only featured prominently but was also appointed Governor of her child and of the realm. Mary’s Will was perhaps destroyed so that the lies in the libels would not be exposed. Moray, under whose auspices Buchanan wrote, must have been aware of the Will’s true contents, as he was to have been a beneficiary.

  Inventaires. Mary’s Will does not survive, but a testamentary inventory of the jewels she meant to bequeath, annotated by herself, still exists in the Register House in Edinburgh.

  Clerk of Penicuik MSS., Register House in Edinburgh

  State Papers in the Public Record Office; Chalmers

  CSP Scottish

  Nau

  Melville

  Nau

  CSP Scottish; Calderwood

  Nau

  10. “AN UNWELCOME INTRUDER”

  Melville

  Bannatyne Miscellany. She was the wife of Sir Arthur Forbes of Reres.

  Nau

  Herries says he was born between 9 a.m. and 10 a.m.; Melville had the news from Mary Beaton between 10 a.m. and 11 a.m. and claims he was the first to be informed. Nau and the Diurnal of Occurrents state that the Prince was born between 10 a.m. and 11 a.m. Buchanan says he was born a little after 9 a.m.

  Cited by William Robertson

  Diurnal of Occurrents; Nau

  Herries

  Strickland

  See Gent, and Antonia Fraser.

  Nau

  CSP Scottish

  Ibid.

  Bothwell

  CSP Scottish

  Ibid.

  Ibid.

  State Papers in the Public Record Office: Domestic, James I

  CSP Spanish

  Ibid.

  CSP Scottish

  Nau

  CSP Scottish

  Ibid. James’s cradle is now at Traquair House, Innerleithen.

  CSP Spanish

  Teulet

  CSP Foreign; Cecil Papers

  CSP Spanish

  CSP Foreign; Cecil Papers

  CSP Scottish

  Ibid.

  Ibid.

  CSP Spanish; CSP Scottish

  Nau says she was at Alloa on 28 July.

  Selections from Unpublished Manuscripts

  Ibid.

  Register of the Privy Council

  Register of the Privy Seal

  Buchanan

  Ibid.

  CSP Scottish; Nau

  Knox

  Alloa Tower is still owned by the Erskines, but is substantially altered from what it was in Mary’s day. In the early 18th century, it was remodelled to match a nearby mansion, and in 1800, a serious fire damaged the roof and consumed many of the family heirlooms, among them what was said to be the only portrait of Mary painted while she was in Scotland. The Tower was restored in the 1990s and reopened by Queen Elizabeth II in 1997.

  Lennox Narrative

  Selections from Unpublished Manuscripts; CSP Scottish

  CSP Spanish

  Nau

  Melville

  Cotton MSS. Caligula; Selections from Unpublished Manuscripts; CSP Foreign; Keith; Illustrations of the Reign of Queen Mary

  CSP Foreign

  Lennox Narrative

  Nau

  CSP Scottish

  Leslie

  Ibid.

  Ibid.

  Papal Negotiations

  Raumer

  Keith

  Inventaires

  CSP Scottish; Nau

  The peel tower in which Mary stayed is the oldest part of Traquair House, and is now attached to the north end of the main block, which was built in 1642. At the end of the 17th century another wing was added. In the King’s Room is a bed slept in by Mary when she stayed with Lord Herries at Terregles Castle in 1568, just prior to her flight to Engl
and; this bed was brought to Traquair in 1890. Also at Traquair are a rosary, crucifix, reticule and purse said to have belonged to Mary, and a document dated 1565, bearing her signature and Darnley’s.

  Nau

  Ibid.

  Papal Negotiations

  CSP Spanish

  CSP Foreign

  Keith

  Nau

  Ibid.

  Cited by Gore-Browne

  CSP Foreign

  11. “NO OUTGAIT”

  Cecil Papers

  CSP Scottish; CSP Foreign

  Du Croc to Archbishop Beaton, in Keith

  Papal Negotiations

  The Privy Council to Catherine de’ Medici, in Keith

  Du Croc to Archbishop Beaton, ibid.

  The Privy Council to Catherine de’ Medici, ibid.

  Ibid.

  Ibid.

  Ibid.; du Croc to Archbishop Beaton, in Keith; Papiers d’Etat , ed. Teulet

  Du Croc to Catherine de’ Medici, in Keith; Papiers d’Etat, ed. Teulet; Labanoff

  Nau

  The Privy Council to Catherine de’ Medici, 8 October 1566, in Keith; Teulet

  Ibid.

  Leslie; Keith

  Papal Negotiations

  Register of the Privy Council

  Melville

  Register of the Privy Council

  Lennox Narrative

  “The Answer of Moray,” 1569, in Keith

  Archibald Douglas to Queen Mary, ibid.

  Diurnal of Occurrents

  Bothwell had shot Elliott in the leg with a pistol before being wounded himself. There are conflicting reports as to Elliott’s fate: some claimed he died of his wounds, but Sir John Forster stated that he escaped and recovered (Additional MSS., British Library). There is some evidence that he continued to pursue his lawless existence until 1590, when he may have died.

  Buchanan

  Cited by McKechnie

  Nau

  Keith

  Cited by Gore-Browne

  Teulet

  CSP Scottish

  Keith; Papiers d’Etat, ed. Teulet

  Labanoff

  Du Croc to Catherine de’ Medici, in Keith; Papiers d’Etat, ed. Teulet; Labanoff

  Report of 12 November, in Papal Negotiations

  Keith; Teulet

  Cotton MSS. Caligula

  Diurnal of Occurrents; CSP Foreign; Register of the Privy Seal ; Tytler: Scotland

  Hermitage Castle still stands today, its courtyard in ruins but its outer walls intact. Although extensively restored in 1820, it is perhaps the best preserved example of a Border fortress.

  CSP Scottish; Nau

  A French 16th-century pocket watch and case were unearthed by a mole and found on this spot by a shepherd in the early 19th century. Both are now on display at Mary, Queen of Scots’ House in Jedburgh.

  Lennox Narrative

  Chalmers; Tytler: Scotland

  Nau, writing in the 1570s, states she fell ill on the day after her ride to Hermitage, i.e., on 16 October; on 18 October 1566, the Council informed Beaton that the illness came on two days after the ride, i.e., on 17 October. As their account was written only a day later, the Council are more likely to be correct.

 

‹ Prev