by Alfie Kohn
12. John T. Lanzetta and Basil G. Englis, “Expectations of Cooperation and Competition and Their Effects on Observers’ Vicarious Emotional Responses.”
13. David A. Wilder and Peter N. Shapiro, “Role of Competition-Induced Anxiety in Limiting the Beneficial Impact of Positive Behavior by an Out-Group Member.” In this experiment, subjects were told that they would work on projects in small groups and that their work would be evaluated by members of another group. Some subjects were told that the other group was cooperating with them; others, that it was competing. When asked to describe one member of the other group (who had made mostly positive comments about their own group’s efforts), those who thought they were competing responded more negatively to that person and were also somewhat more likely to see that person as similar to the other members of that group.
14. Kenny Hill quoted in Frank Litsky, “Aggression Necessary, Hill Says,” p. D30.
15. William Zimmerman, “On Negative Ads.” That was in 1986. Six years later, Susan Estrich, who had been Michael Dukakis’s campaign manager, delivered an even more rousing endorsement of dirty campaigns. “You can’t really blame the candidates. . . . They’re doing what works” (“Let the Mud Fly”).
16. Gary Edwards quoted in Paul Wilkes, “The Tough Job of Teaching Ethics,” p. 24F.
17. Sheila Widnall quoted in Fox Butterfield, “Scandal Over Cheating at M.I.T. Stirs Debate on Limits of Teamwork.”
18. See my brief essay on this topic, “Competition vs. Excellence.
19. Richard A. Knox, “‘Free-choice’ Rhetoric Isn’t the Answer.”
20. James C. Robinson and Harold S. Luft, “Competition and the Cost of Hospital Care, 1972 to 1982." Their study of nearly 6,000 hospitals found that these institutions competed for patients (and doctors) by providing fancy amenities rather than by lowering their rates. A hospital admission was 26 percent more expensive (and the average patient cost per day was 15 percent higher) in hospitals located within fifteen miles of more than ten competitors. Another result of competition, the researchers suggested, is a lower patient load and therefore, in the long run, less expertise-building experience for the clinical staff. Competition in this field, therefore, may actually provide lower-quality care at higher cost for fewer people who really need it.
21. In the last few years, deregulation has bankrupted several more airlines, throwing tens or even hundreds of thousands of employees out of work, increasing the market share of the three or four remaining giants, reducing the quality of service, and raising prices on most routes. (The Department of Transportation claims that airfares, adjusted for inflation, actually have declined since the industry was deregulated in the late 1970s. But a 1990 study by the Economic Policy Institute pointed out that this change was due to a drop in the price of jet fuel. When this variable, obviously unrelated to competition, is held constant, prices increased through the 1980s.) Furthermore, airlines are free to sell their excess takeoff and landing slots at airports, but some refuse to do so, effectively reducing the number of flights available to the public just so rival carriers will not benefit. (See Bob Kuttner, “Air Fares That Reach to the Sky.”) Such is the logic of competition.
22. Dean T josvold, Working Together to Gel Things Done, pp. 29, 70. Tjosvold’s studies appear with remarkable frequency in journals of psychology, management, and organizational studies.
23. The task was a video game with a joystick that could be performed either individually or at cross-purposes with another player. In the latter condition, speed went up and accuracy went down. See David A. Washburn et al., “Effects of Competition on Video-Task Performance in Monkeys.”
24. Deming’s comments are included in an introduction to his work on videotape, a series called “The Deming Library.” See volume 18, “Competition Doesn’t Work, Cooperation Does.”
25. For a description of the parallel deprivation of substantive opportunities for workers in the United States and the USSR to participate in making decisions, see Thomas H. Naylor, “Redefining Corporate Motivation, Swedish Style,” pp. 566, 568.
26. See, for example, David Warsh, “A Financial World in Dark Until It Finds Bottom Line.”
27. For welcome exceptions to this rule, see Samuel Bowles, “Economic Justice—For Us and Them,” and David M. Gordon, “Do We Need to Be No. 1?” Another economist, Bob Kuttner, framed the issue well: “The need is to restore American productivity, but not at other nations’ expense. . . . [We must put] the world back on a high-growth path where every economy can prosper” (“A Time for Shared Trade Growth”). This is easier said than done, of course, but first we must convince our leaders that it is a goal worth saying.
28. Teresa M. Amabile, “The Motivation to Be Creative,” pp. 242–43.
29. Robert J. Vallerand et al., “Negative Effects of Competition on Children’s Intrinsic Motivation.”
30. Edward L. Deci and Richard M. Ryan, Intrinsic Motivation and Self Determination in Human Behavior, p. 85.
31. Joan L. Duda, “The Relationship Between Goal Perspectives, Persistence, and Behavioral Intensity Among Male and Female Recreational Sport Participants.” Indeed, teenagers are dropping out of organized sports in sizable numbers—partly because of the pressure to win—as is confirmed by the work of Martha Ewing and Vern Seefeldt at the Youth Sports Institute of Michigan State University.
32. UCLA Sport Psychology Laboratory, “Playing On,” p. 39.
33. Deci and Ryan, Intrinsic Motivation, p. 325.
34. Bil Gilbert, “Competition: Is It What Life’s All About?”
35. Laura Fraser, “Super Bowl Violence Comes Home.”
References
Ackerman, Nathan W. The Psychodynamics of Family Life. New York: Basic Books, 1958.
Adams, John C., Jr. “Effects of Competition and Open Receptivity on Creative Productivity.” Catalogue of Selected Documents in Psychology 3 (1973): 16–17.
Adorno, T. W., Else Frenkel-Brunswik, Daniel J. Levinson, and R. Nevitt Sanford. The Authoritarian Personality. New York: Harper, 1950.
Agnew, Spiro. “In Defense of Sport.” In Sport and Contemporary Society: An Anthology, edited by D. Stanley Eitzen. New York: St. Martin’s, 1979.
Ahlgren, Andrew, and David W. Johnson. “Sex Differences in Cooperative and Competitive Attitudes from the Second Through the Twelfth Grades.” Developmental Psychology 15 (1979): 45–49.
Allee, W. C. Cooperation Among Animals. New York: Henry Schuman, 1951.
Allport, Gordon W. Becoming: Basic Considerations for a Psychology of Personality. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1955.
Amabile, Teresa M. “Children’s Artistic Creativity: Detrimental Effects of Competition in a Field Setting.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 8 (1982): 573–78.
——. “The Motivation to Be Creative.” In Frontiers in Creativity, edited by S. Isaksen. Buffalo, N.Y.: Bearly, 1987.
Amabile, Teresa M., and Judith Gitomer. “Children’s Artistic Creativity: Effects of Choice in Task Materials.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 10 (1984): 209–15.
Ames, Carole. “Children’s Achievement Attributions and Self-reinforcement: Effects of Self-concept and Competitive Reward Structure.” Journal of Educational Psychology 70 (1978): 345–55.
——. “Competitive Versus Cooperative Reward Structures: The Influence of Individual and Group Performance Factors on Achievement Attributions and Affect.” American Educational Research Journal 18 (1981): 273–87.
——. “An Examination of Children’s Attributions and Achievement-Related Evaluations in Competitive, Cooperative, and Individualistic Reward Structures.” Journal of Educational Psychology 71 (1979): 413–20.
Ames, Carole, and Russell Ames. “Competitive Versus Individualistic Goal Structures: The Salience of Past Performance Information for Causal Attributions and Affect.” Journal of Educational Psychology 73 (1981): 411–18.
Archer, Dane, and Rosemary Gartner. “Violent Acts and Violent Times: A Comparative Approach to
Postwar Homicide Rates,” American Sociological Review 41 (1976): 937–63.
Aronson, Elliot. The Social Animal. 2d ed. San Francisco: W. H. Freeman, 1976.
Associated Press. “Students Blame Stress Problems on Competition.” Boston Globe, 19 November 1987: 41.
Atkinson, John W. An Introduction to Motivation. Princeton, N.J.: Van Nostrand, 1964.
——. “The Mainsprings of Achievement-Oriented Activity.” In Motivation and Achievement, edited by John W. Atkinson and Joel O. Raynor. New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1974.
Augros, Robert, and George Stanciu. The New Biology: Discovering the Wisdom in Nature. Boston: New Science Library, 1988.
Austin, James R. “Competition: Is Music Education the Loser?” Music Educators Journal, February 1990: 21–85.
Axelrod, Robert. The Evolution of Cooperation. New York: Basic, 1984.
Azrin, Nathan H., and Ogden R. Lindsley. “The Reinforcement of Cooperation Between Children.” Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology 52 (1956): 100–102.
Bachrach, Judy. “Rivalry in the Sisterhood.” Boston Globe, 18 January 1984: 57–58.
Bandura, Albert. Social Learning Theory. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall, 1977.
Barber, Benjamin. Strong Democracy: Participatory Politics for a New Age. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1984.
Barnes, Hazel. An Existentialist Ethics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1967.
Barnett, Mark A., and James H. Bryan. “Effects of Competition with Outcome Feedback on Children’s Helping Behavior.” Developmental Psychology 10 (1974): 838–42.
Barnett, Mark A., Karen A. Matthews, and Jeffrey A. Howard. “Relationship Between Competitiveness and Empathy in 6- and 7-Year-Olds.” Developmental Psychology 15 (1979): 221–22.
Bateson, Gregory, Don D. Jackson, Jay Haley, and John Weakland. “Toward a Theory of Schizophrenia.” Behavioral Science 1 (1956): 251–64.
Bateson, Patrick. “Cooperation and Competition.” World Press Review, August 1984: 55.
Battaglia, Carl. “Piano Competitions: Talent Hunt or Sport?” Saturday Review, 25 August 1962: 31–33, 39.
Baum, Julian. “Friendship No Longer Ranks Ahead of Winning for Chinese Olympians.” Christian Science Monitor, 26 July 1984: 1.
Baumeister, Roy F. “Choking Under Pressure: Self-Consciousness and Paradoxical Effects of Incentives on Skillful Performance.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 46 (1984): 610–20.
Beane, James A. “Sorting Out the Self-Esteem Controversy.” Educational Leadership, September 1991: 25–30.
Beisser, Arnold R. The Madness in Sports: Psychosocial Observations on Sports. New York: Appleton, 1967.
Belkin, Lisa. “Young Albany Debaters Resolve Who’s Best.” New York Times, 29 April 1985: A1, B4.
Bellah, Robert N., Richard Madsen, William M. Sullivan, Ann Swidler, and Steven M. Tipton. The Good Society. New York: Knopf, 1991.
——. Habits of the Heart: Individualism and Commitment in American Life. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1985.
Benedict, Ruth. The Chrysanthemum and the Sword: Patterns of Japanese Culture. 1946. Reprint. New York: New American Library, 1974.
Bennett, William J. “In Defense of Sports.” Commentary, February 1976: 68–70.
Benware, Carl A., and Edward L. Deci. “Quality of Learning with an Active Versus Passive Motivational Set.” American Educational Research Journal 21 (1984): 755–65.
Berger, Peter L. The Sacred Canopy: Elements of a Sociological Theory of Religion. Garden City, N.Y.: Anchor Books, 1969.
Berger, Peter L., and Brigitte Berger. Sociology: A Biographical Approach, ad ed. New York: Basic, 1975.
Berkowitz, Leonard. Aggression: A Social Psychological Analysis. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1962.
——. “Experimental Investigations of Hostility Catharsis.” Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 35 (1970): 1–7.
Berlage, Gai Ingham. “Are Children’s Competitive Team Sports Socializing Agents for Corporate America?” In Studies in the Sociology of Sport, edited by Aidan O. Dunleavy et al. Ft. Worth, Tex.: Texas Christian University Press, 1982.
Bettelheim, Bruno. The Uses of Enchantment: The Meaning and Importance of Fairy Tales. New York: Vintage, 1977.
——. “Violence: A Neglected Mode of Behavior.” 1966. Reprinted in Surviving and Other Essays. New York: Knopf, 1979.
Birch, Leann Lipps, Diane Wolfe Marlin, and Julie Rotter. “Eating as the ‘Means’ Activity in a Contingency: Effects on Young Children’s Food Preference.” Child Development 55 (1984): 431–39.
Blau, Peter. “Cooperation and Competition in a Bureaucracy.” American Journal of Sociology 59 (1954): 530–35’
Block, Jeanne Humphrey. “Conceptions of Sex Role: Some Cross-Cultural and Longitudinal Perspectives.” American Psychologist 28 (1973): 512-26.
Blotnick, Srully. Otherwise Engaged: The Private Lives of Successful Career Women. New York: Facts on File, 1985.
Boffey, Philip M. “Rise in Science Fraud Is Seen; Need to Win Cited as a Cause.” New York Times, 30 May 1985: B5.
Bok, Sissela. Lying: Moral Choice in Public and Private Life. New York: Vintage, 1979
Bonime, Walter. “Competitiveness and Human Potential”Journal of the American Academy of Psychoanalysis 14 (1986): 149–66.
Boslooper, Thomas, and Marcia Hayes. The Femininity Game. New York: Stein and Day, 1973.
Bowles, Samuel. “Economic Justice—For Us and Them.” Harper’s Magazine, December 1988: 29–32.
Branden, Nathaniel. The Psychology of Self-Esteem. New York: Bantam, 1971.
Brandt, Ron. “On Cooperation in Schools: A Conversation with David and Roger Johnson.” Educational Leadership, November 1987: 14–19.
——. “On Cooperative Learning: A Conversation with Spencer Kagan.” Educational Leadership, December 1989/January 1990: 8–11.
Bredemeier, Brenda Jo, and David L. Shields. “Values and Violence in Sports Today.” Psychology Today, October 1985: 23–32.
Breer, Paul E., and Edwin C. Locke. Task Experience as a Source of Attitudes. New York: Dorsey Press, 1965.
Brody, Jane E. “Heart Attacks: Turmoil Beneath the Calm.” New York Times, 21 June 1983: C5.
Brownmiller, Susan. Femininity. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1984.
Brubacher, Mark, Ryder Payne, and Kemp Rickett. Perspectives on Small Group Learning: Theory and Practice. Oakville, Ontario: Rubicon Publishing,
Bryan, James H. “Prosocial Behavior.” In Psychological Processes in Early Education, edited by Harry L. Horn, Jr., and Paul A. Robinson. New York: Academic Press, 1977.
Bryant, Brenda K. "The Effects of the Interpersonal Context of Evaluation on Self- and Other-Enhancement Behavior.” Child Development 48 (1977): 885–92.
Buber, Martin. The Knowledge of Man: A Philosophy of the Interhuman. New York: Harper Torchbooks, 1966.
Butt, Dorcas Susan. Psychology of Sport: The Behavior, Motivation, Personality, and Performance of Athletes. New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold, 1976.
Butterfield, Fox. “Scandal Over Cheating at M.I.T. Stirs Debate on Limits of Teamwork.” New York Times, 22 May 1991: A23.
Caillois, Roger. Man, Play, and Games. Translated by Meyer Barash. New York: Free Press, 1961.
Campbell, David N. “On Being Number One: Competition in Education.” Phi Delta Kappan, October 1974: 143–46.
Caplow, Theodore. Principles of Organization. New York: Harcourt, Brace & World, 1964.
Carroll, Lewis. Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland. New York: New American Library, 1960.
Chira, Susan. “Prominent Educators Oppose National Tests.” New York Times, 29 January 1992: B9.
Chodorow, Nancy. The Reproduction of Mothering: Psychoanalysis and the Sociology of Gender. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1978
Christy, Pauline R., Donna M. Gelfand, and Donald P. Hartmann. “Effects of Competition-Induced Frustration on Two Classes of
Modeled Behavior.” Developmental Psychology 5 (1971): 104–11.
Clarke, Judy. “The Hidden Treasure of Co-operative Learning.” Cooperative Learning, October 1991: 2–3.
Clarke, Judy, Ron Wideman, and Susan Eadie. Together We Learn. Scarborough, Ontario: Prentice-Hall Canada, 1990.
Clifford, Margaret M. “Effect of Competition as a Motivational Technique in the Classroom.” American Educational Research Journal 9 (1972): 123–37.
Cobb, Paul, Terry Wood, Erna Yackel, John Nicholls, Grayson Wheatley, Beatriz Trigatti, and Marcella Perlwitz. “Assessment of a Problem Centered Second-Grade Mathematics Project.” Journal for Research in Mathematics Education 22 (1991): 3–29.
Cobb, Paul, Terry Wood, Erna Yackel, and Marcella Perlwitz. “A Follow-Up Assessment of a Second-Grade Problem Centered Mathematics Project.” Educational Studies in Mathematics. In press.
Cohen, Elizabeth G. “Continuing to Cooperate: Prerequisites for Persistence.” Phi Delta Kappan, October 1990: 134–38.
——. Designing Groupwork: Strategies for the Heterogeneous Classroom. New York: Teachers College Press, 1986.
Cohen, Joshua, and Joel Rogers. On Democracy: Toward a Transformation of American Society. New York: Penguin, 1983.
Coleman, James S. “Academic Achievement and the Structure of Competition.” Harvard Educational Review 29 (1959): 330–51.
——. The Adolescent Society. New York: Free Press of Glencoe, 1961.
Combs, Arthur W. “The Myth of Competition.” Childhood Education 33 (1957): 264–69.
——. Myths in Education. Boston: Allyn and Bacon, 1979.
Cowie, Helen, and Jean Rudduck. “Learning from One Another: The Challenge.” In Children Helping Children, edited by Hugh C. Foot, Michelle J. Morgan, and Rosalyn H. Shute. Chichester, England: John Wiley and Sons, 1990.