by M C Beaton
“And you’re convinced of this?”
“Absolutely.”
When Hamish left her cottage, he felt the bonnet of her car. It was warm. He turned back and looked thoughtfully at the cottage. Caro’s white face glimmered back at him through the small window. But the day was unusually warm. That might explain it.
♦
Hamish parked the Land Rover on the waterfront and was going to the police unit when he was accosted by Elspeth.
“So what’s your explanation for last night?” she demanded.
“Elspeth, I’m right sorry. I forgot.”
“You were seen driving off with Betty Barnard.”
“Oh, all right, Elspeth. But I don’t need to explain my movements to you.”
She studied him thoughtfully and then said, “Do you know what your problem is? You’re afraid of love. You’d rather settle for companionship. Does Betty know she’s got serious competition?”
“Like who?”
“Like your cat and your dog. You know what you are? You’re nothing more than an old maid.”
“Get the hell away from me,” raged Hamish, his highland vanity cut to the quick. Then he gave a malicious smile. “So don’t you think there’s something up with you, hanging around and nagging someone who doesn’t want you?”
Elspeth slapped him full across the face and walked off.
Hamish became aware of the curious eyes of villagers. He glared back and went into the police unit to be told that Mr. Daviot had arrived and was up at the castle with Robin and Jimmy.
He decided to go back to the police station and take Sonsie and Lugs for a walk so he could think in peace. “And if there’s some woman waiting for me,” he muttered, “I’ll strangle her.”
But he could hardly strangle his boss’s wife.
With a sinking heart, he recognised the matronly figure of Mrs. Daviot waiting for him on the doorstep.
He had always considered the Daviots the very picture of a contented marriage. Mr. Daviot with his sleek grey hair, impeccably tailored suits, and smoothly shaven cheeks looked more like a successful businessman than a police superintendent. Mrs. Daviot was small and trim with dyed-brown hair in neat, permed curls and large blue eyes in a carefully made-up face.
“Come in, Mrs. Daviot,” said Hamish. “Are you looking for your husband?”
“No, I’m looking for you.” Her voice trembled on the edge of tears.
Oh, dear, thought Hamish. She suspects something.
“Would you like some tea?”
“No, yes…well, maybe.”
“I’ll take that as a yes. How can I help you?”
She sat down at the table and clasped her handbag on her lap. “I think Peter is having an affair.”
“What makes you think that?”
“He says he’s going out to some police function or other, and then I find out there was no such function. He smells of perfume. He looks excited, elated. He mutters into the phone, and if I walk into the room, he hangs up.”
“It could all just be police business, after all,” said Hamish awkwardly. He poured tea and told her to help herself to milk and sugar.
“I want you to investigate. I want you to find out who she is.”
“Its right difficult,” said Hamish. “He is my boss. I think he’d fire me like a shot if he even guessed what I was doing.”
“Please, Hamish.” Her eyes swam with tears. “I’m begging you.”
He sighed. “I’ll do my best.”
She opened her handbag and took out a card case. “Here’s my mobile phone number. Phone me night or day if you find out anything.”
“What will you do if it turns out to be true?”
“I’ll divorce him.”
“That’s a wee bit extreme. If there is something, it could just be a passing fancy.”
“My husband,” she said grimly, “is not allowed passing fancies.”
♦
After Mrs. Daviot had left, Hamish went out towards the police unit. Back from the Tommel Castle, Superintendent Daviot was standing outside, smoking a cigarette.
“Sir,” said Hamish.
“Ah, good morning. Isn’t it a glorious morning, Hamish?”
“Yes, indeed, sir.”
“We must get these murders solved. I’m giving a press conference up at the hotel this evening. The press are becoming very strident.”
“Maybe some other big story will happen to take them away,” said Hamish. “They’re really more interested in political scandal than anything else these days. Do you remember that foreign minister last year who was found to be having an affair with a researcher? What a carry-on that was, and for once, the wife didn’t stand by him but demanded a divorce. It was the end o’ his career. You know, sir, I often wonder what makes important men throw their careers away all because of a fling.”
“Maybe he was deeply in love with her,” said Daviot, staring at Hamish.
“Not if you remember the aftermath. Because he was out of a job, he suddenly looked at her and wondered what he had ever seen in her. Of course, if he’d been philandering up here in the Highlands, everyone would have known about it from the word go. Everyone knows everyone else’s business up here.”
“Except when it comes to witnessing a murder,” said Daviot.
“Now, that’s what’s so odd,” said Hamish. “Normally you can’t even take a walk across the moors without someone having seen you. I can only conclude the murderer was extremely lucky. Has Detective Mackenzie arrived?”
“Yes, she’s inside the unit. What do you think of her?”
“I think she is keen and ambitious. She’ll rise right to the top. Only trouble is she might not be too nice about how she gets there.” Hamish touched his cap. “I’ll just go inside and get my briefing. Give my best to your good wife, sir. Splendid woman.”
After the door of the unit had closed behind Hamish, Daviot stood for a long moment before angrily crushing out his cigarette. He was damn sure Hamish Macbeth had just given him a warning.
But his obsession for Robin gripped hard. He started guiltily when the door of the unit opened and she came out.
“Peter, darling,” she whispered. “A word with you.”
“What is it?”
“This press conference this evening. I was thinking the press can be very aggressive. I thought it might be a good idea if I fielded the questions for you.”
For the first time, Daviot wondered whether she was using him. The television cameras would be there. She was really too low in rank to even suggest such a thing.
“No, I do not think that’s a good idea at all. I am surprised you should even suggest such a thing. Please go back to your duties and remember to call me ‘sir.’ We are, after all, in the middle of a murder investigation.”
“But Peter…”
“Detective Mackenzie, please remember our relative positions.”
“Like the missionary one?” snapped Robin.
He took a deep breath. “I have made a bad mistake. Either get a transfer or get on with your work here. I do not want to see you outside work again.”
♦
“Hamish!” shouted Jimmy. “I’ve been trying to talk to you, and you’ve been glued to that window.”
“Sorry,” said Hamish, turning round.
“I want you to go and see Jock’s ex-wife again. I find it odd the way she’s hanging around.”
Robin came into the unit. Her face was red, and her eyes were angry.
“Take Detective Mackenzie with you,” said Jimmy.
Robin and Hamish walked in silence along to Sea View. Mrs. Dunne said Dora Fleming had left earlier, saying she was going up to the hotel to see Jock.
“We’ll take the Land Rover,” said Hamish. “It’s almost as if our Dora had something on Jock.”
They found Dora and Jock at a corner table in the bar. They were holding hands and talking urgently, their heads together.
They broke off when they saw Hamish and
Robin. “What now?” asked Jock truculently.
“I really wanted to talk to Mrs. Fleming here,” said Hamish.
Jock rose to his feet. “Right. I’m off.”
They waited until he had left and sat down opposite Dora. Dora was picking a beermat apart with long red nails. Prostitutes are always terrible fidgets, thought Hamish.
Hamish looked at Robin, but she seemed lost in her own thoughts, so he began the questioning.
“I was wondering, Mrs. Fleming, why you’re still in Lochdubh. You must miss your children.”
“I was telt not to leave, and the children are just fine with my mither.”
“You and Jock appear to have patched up any differences.”
“What’s that to you?”
“Did you know that Hal Addenfest, the dead man, took notes of what everyone was saying?”
“No.”
“I find it hard to believe that you didn’t. Everyone in Lochdubh knew about it.”
“They don’t talk to me.”
“Come on. Mrs. Dunne gossips to everyone. I can ask her.”
“She may have said something. Wasnae important anyway. Nothing that goes on in this arsehole of the world is important.”
“I tell you what I’ll do for you,” said Hamish. “I’ll have a word with my boss and get you permission to leave.”
“I’ll leave when I’m good and ready.”
When they left her, Hamish saw Priscilla and Betty talking in the reception area. Betty gave him a wink and a cheeky smile. Priscilla’s face was smooth and expressionless.
“Where now?” asked Robin, jerking herself out of her thoughts with an effort.
“Back to Sea View. I wonder if Mrs. Dunne heard anything.”
“As far as I remember from the reports, she said she hadn’t.”
“Nonetheless, I would like to try again. I wonder if Dora Fleming was in her bed all night.”
♦
Mrs. Dunne complained she was too busy to answer any more questions. “That’s a pity,” said Robin, and then trotted out her usual compliment. “You see, people often do hear or see something and only remember it later. And you, being such an obviously quick-witted and intelligent lady, might just have remembered something.”
“What we’re after,” put in Hamish, “is whether you are sure that Dora Fleming spent all night in her bed.”
Mrs. Dunne stood frowning. She had been flattered by Robin’s compliment. “There was one thing,” she said slowly. “I thought I heard a wee noise at the back of the house.”
“Like what?”
“A sort of bang. I’ve got Mrs. Fleming here and a couple from Glasgow and three of the forestry workers. They were all in their rooms when I locked up. Och, I mind the days when I wouldn’t have bothered, but it’s a wicked world now.”
“Don’t the guests have their own keys?”
“I don’t trust anyone with the keys. I wait until they’re all indoors.”
“So how would anyone get out?”
“There’s the fire door at the back on the first.”
“Show it to us.”
She led the way upstairs and along a corridor on the first landing. Hamish studied the fire door, and then his sharp eyes noticed a small square wad of paper lying on the floor. He took out a pair of tweezers, lifted the paper, and put it in a cellophane envelope.
He thanked Mrs. Dunne and went back outside the building, followed by Robin.
“Why did you pick up that paper?” asked Robin.
“It could have been used to wedge the door so that someone could get back in again. Let’s get back to the unit and examine it properly.”
He explained to Jimmy what he had found. Then he took out the envelope and, putting on gloves, extracted the wad of paper. He laid it on Jimmy’s desk and gently opened it up. “It’s out o’ a film magazine,” Hamish said. “See, there’s a bit from the top of the page – Hollywood World. I’ll go over to Patel’s and see if he sold a copy to anyone.” Robin went with him.
Mr. Patel said he only ordered two copies a month, the locals being more interested in magazines that dealt with television soaps than anything to do with the movies.
“Who bought them?”
“Mrs. Wellington bought one.” Hamish blinked in amazement. He’d never have guessed that the tweedy minister’s wife would want to read about movie stars.
“And the other one?”
“Oh, it was that wee woman who was married to the artist.”
They hurried back to tell Jimmy. “Good work,” he said. “Bring her in.”
♦
They found Dora Fleming crossing the humpback bridge on her way to the boarding house. They marched her back to the police unit and took her inside.
“What’s this all about?” she demanded.
“This,” said Jimmy, pointing to the piece from the film magazine. “This was lying by the fire door at Sea View. We think you used it to wedge the fire door when you crept out so you’d be able to get back in again.”
“Don’t be daft. It’s just a piece of paper.”
“It’s from a film magazine which you bought. The papers glossy, and we should get your prints off it. In fact, we’ll fingerprint you now.”
“I want a lawyer,” she screeched.
“You’ve already got her fingerprints,” interposed Robin. “We took the fingerprints of everyone who might be concerned right after Mr. Addenfest’s murder.”
“So we did,” said Jimmy with his foxy grin. “Right, young woman, where did you go, when, and why?”
“I didnae go anywhere!”
“We’ll look at the steps down from the fire door,” said Jimmy. “I’m sure we’ll find some footprints.”
She stared at him in mulish silence.
“Right,” said Jimmy. “I am taking you into police headquarters for questioning. Hamish, you and Robin go back to Sea View and have a look at the steps down from the fire door. See if you can find anything.”
As two policemen escorted Dora out to the car which was to take her to Strathbane, Jimmy phoned Daviot, who was up at the hotel arranging a room for the press conference. He told him of Hamish’s find. “It was a right smart piece of work on Macbeth’s part,” said Jimmy. “You can at least tell the press we’ve got a suspect.”
♦
Mrs. Dunne took Hamish and Robin round to the back of the house where an iron staircase led down from the fire door. “We’d better not add our own footprints,” said Hamish. The stairs led down to a weedy back garden. “We’ll just need to search through the garden and see if we can find anything.”
He knelt down and began to feel his way through the rough grass with his fingers. Robin was wearing a skirt and did not want to ladder her tights by following Hamish’s example.
“I’ve got to go to the loo,” she called. “Be back soon.”
She went round to the front of the house, knocked, and asked Mrs. Dunne if she could use her bathroom.
“Don’t leave a mess,” said Mrs. Dunne. “I keep a clean house.”
Robin carefully reapplied her make-up. Daviot’s rejection of her request to be at the press conference rankled, and she knew she would feel more confident if she brushed her hair and made up her face.
When she went out again, she saw Daviot’s car heading along the waterfront and eagerly flagged him down.
Daviot lowered the window. “What is it, Detective Mackenzie?”
“I had a marvellous piece of luck,” said Robin. “I found a piece of a magazine by the fire door at Sea View which had been used to wedge the door. I found out Dora Fleming had bought that magazine and – ”
He interrupted her, his voice cold and measured. “I have already heard of Hamish Macbeth’s detective work. Do not try to take credit from another officer again.”
The car window rolled up in her face, he tapped his driver on the shoulder, and the car moved on.
Robin felt miserable. She had dreamt of taking over Blair’s job one day. She tr
ailed back to the garden to find Hamish putting something into an envelope.
“What have you found?” she asked.
“A used condom.”
“So what’s special about that? The local lads probably use this garden for a bit of nooky.”
“No, they don’t,” said Hamish. “I’ll take this straight over to Strathbane. Are you coming?”
But Robin did not want to run into Daviot.
∨ Death of a Dreamer ∧
10
O what a tangled web we weave,
When first we practise to deceive!
—Sir Walter Scott
Hamish did not have any hope of a speedy DNA analysis of the used condom, but for once, Daviot was really desperate for answers. Forensic swabs were taken from Jock and the men living in the boarding house and sent to the forensic laboratory in Aberdeen along with the condom.
While he waited for the results, the investigation seemed to have temporarily ground to a halt. Mrs. Daviot phoned him in high excitement to say that her husband, once the case was closed, was going to take her on a second honeymoon. Robin came into the police station just as Hamish was putting down the phone.
“That was Mrs. Daviot,” said Hamish.
Robin eyed him warily. “If she’s looking for her husband, he’s on his way from Strathbane.”
“She just wanted to tell me that they are going on a second honeymoon once this case is over. Now, isn’t that romantic?”
“Oh, sure,” she said sarcastically. “I’ve got some news about Mrs. Addenfest.”
“What’s that?”
“She said she arrived at Glasgow airport after she had been notified of Hal’s death. But she was in the country before Hal died. She arrived at London airport two days before his murder. I don’t know how she hoped to conceal it. Checked with New York police, and they said they got the number of her cell phone – that’s American for mobile – and called her on that with the news because she was out when they visited her flat and her maid gave them the number.”
“He can’t have left her that broke if she had a maid. Didn’t the maid tell the police she had gone to Britain?”
“The maid has about two words of English. Mrs. Addenfest’s over at the unit. I’ve come to fetch you.”