by Cassie Cole
“I want you so badly,” he said. “I’ve wanted you since the day I saw you at McCall.”
“I’m yours,” I breathed.
He lifted me in the air like I weighed nothing at all, carrying me to the bed and then lowering me carefully so that I didn’t hit my head on the top bunk. The moment my back hit the comforter he was pulling my pajama bottoms off, revealing the sexy lace panties I’d put on earlier for Foxy.
Derek paused while admiring me, a ravenous look in his eyes. Behind him, Foxy was gently stroking himself in the chair, an audience member to what was about to happen.
“Fuck me,” I breathed. “Please fuck me.”
Derek stripped off his shirt and pants until he was down to just his dog tags and underwear. He was exactly what I had pictured: bulging with muscles in his chest and arms. The Coors Light wasn’t the only six-pack he’d brought with him, and there was a tuft of sandy hair below his flat stomach leading down into his happy trail. I normally thought tighty whities were more amusing than sexy, but the outline of Derek’s cock in his grey underpants was the sexiest thing I’d ever seen in my life.
He glanced behind him at Foxy, hesitated, and then stripped those off too. His dick stood at attention like a good soldier, glistening with pre-come on the tip.
I stripped out of my panties, leaving my sex open and vulnerable for him. That wonderful precipice between two people who had never been intimate, and were about to take the plunge.
I could tell he wanted me as much as I wanted him.
Derek sank into me. I was dripping wet by then, and it took only a few thrusts to coat his cock with my juices and allow him to slide inside. Every nerve ending in my body fired as he filled me with his dick, pushing it until he had nothing more to give me, and then pushing even deeper.
We moaned together on the bed while Foxy watched.
22
Foxy
I’ve always been kind of a voyeur. I’d just never had the chance to put it into practice until now.
There was hardly any jealousy as I watched Haley straddle Derek in the chair and make out with him. Even when they stripped and started fucking, the only thing I felt was arousal. It was like watching porn, except in person. With someone that I was with. It was an interesting mix of emotions and sensations.
And it was totally fucking hot.
Derek slid inside Haley’s pussy with ease, eliciting a long moan from her plump lips. From my angle I had a sideways view of them, with Derek sinking between her legs while she wrapped them around his body. Derek kissed her again, then planted his arms on the bed like he was doing push-ups into her pussy.
Between moans, Haley glanced over at me. I leered back at her, and she moaned even louder while I stroked myself. I had to go slowly. This was the kind of thing where if I wasn’t careful, I’d blow my load within a minute. Yeah, it was that hot watching Haley get fucked, and knowing I was going to get to ravage her next. It was like being at a restaurant and your buddy gets his food before you. He digs into the cheeseburger, and watching him eat it makes your burger taste ten times better when it finally comes.
And mine was going to come pretty soon.
Derek must not have been weirded out either, because he pounded Haley like there was nobody watching. She moaned and clung to his body like she was holding on for dear life. The slow, soft strokes Derek began with turned into long, deep thrusts as he fucked her harder. I’d been with Haley enough times now to know when she was close to climaxing, and right now she was on the edge—without any help from toys or clitoral stimulation. Finally she arched her back beneath Derek’s muscular frame and let out a silent cry of ecstasy. Her fingers raked over Derek’s broad back, leaving pink rends in his skin, and he covered her mouth with his own while crying out with pleasure.
I had to stop stroking myself, or else I would come too from watching Haley get fucked. My chest heaved as I panted, almost out of breath. Damn, that was hot.
I did feel a tiny bit jealous about one thing: how he had made her come so easily. Maybe it was him, and maybe it was the added eroticism of having two of us with her.
Either way, I’ve got my work cut out for me.
I rose from my chair and joined them. Derek stepped aside as I knelt to Haley, kissing her gently and lifting her off the bed. I carried her back to my chair and sat down, then twisted her around so that she was straddling me with her back turned.
She moaned as my cock slid up inside of her from below. I wrapped my arms tight around her body, kissing her back and cupping her full breasts while driving my hips up, fucking her from underneath. She sighed and relaxed in my arms as I made love to her steadily, pacing myself.
Derek had pulled the other chair across the room and was now seated, watching with a pillow in his lap. The modesty made me chuckle since I had just gotten a front-row seat to watch his junk pounding Haley’s pussy, but hey, whatever made him more comfortable.
I took my time with Haley, both because I needed to go slowly to keep from blowing my load and because I wanted to give Derek enough time to recuperate. There was something I wanted to try tonight, and it required Derek to be recharged and ready to go.
If he’s up for that.
Haley and I got into a good rhythm on the chair, and soon she was using her legs to ride me, squatting up and down on my throbbing dick. I wrapped an arm around her body and rubbed her clit, which made her head roll back and her eyes close. This angle felt really good to me, and I soon realized I was close to coming.
I made Haley slow down then pulled her off of me. “Over here, babe,” I said, leading her to the bed. I sat on the edge like I’d been doing on the chair, but this time I pulled Haley onto my lap so that she was forward-facing, so I could kiss her.
I gestured to Derek. “Time to bring some toys into the mix.”
“Toys?” Derek asked, suddenly surprised.
Haley grinned down at me. “Yeah?”
“We’re going to need toys for what I want to do,” I smiled back.
“Okay.” Haley gestured. “There’s a box in the back of my closet. Bring it here.”
Still nude, Derek obeyed and retrieved the box. His eyes widened when he opened it on the floor. “What is this!”
“My box of goodies. Hand me that vibrator. Yeah, the white one.”
Haley took the vibrator and quickly turned it on, then slid it between our two bodies without hesitation. “Ohhhhhhhhh,” she moaned.
“Wow,” Derek said.
“I know, right?” I told him.
I let Haley ride me while using the vibrator until she came again, which didn’t take long. She gazed down at me with lidded, satisfied eyes.
“You ready?” I asked her.
She bit her lip, but nodded.
I reached behind her, taking hold of her firm ass with both of my hands and spreading her wide. Giving Derek a perfect view of her tight little butt.
I hope he says yes, I thought. I’ve fantasized about doing this to a woman.
Haley looked over her shoulder at him and said the magic words:
“Do you want to fuck my ass?”
23
Derek
It was an amazing sight. Haley was riding Foxy on the bed, her plump ass bouncing up and down while I watched. I was hard as a rock at the sight, just as Foxy must have been when she and I were fucking.
And then Foxy spread her ass cheeks, revealing her tight little rear entrance, and Haley glanced back at me and grinned lustily.
“Do you want to fuck my ass?”
I almost fell out of my chair. “I… what?”
“It’s yours if you want it,” she crooned.
I licked my lips, unable to take my eyes off her beautiful behind. I’d never fucked a girl in the ass before, but I’d fantasized about it. I’d watched porn where it happened. There was something taboo and forbidden about it. That’s what made it hot.
“Do you want me to?” I asked.
Foxy took one of her nipples into his mouth and
she arched her back. “Oh, I doooo…” she moaned.
I was unable to resist at that point. I was on my feet and approaching before I knew what was happening, driven purely by my animal desire for her.
She grabbed my dick and pulled me toward her mouth. “Let me get you wet first,” she said, wrapping her lips around me and bobbing up and down on the shaft. Her tongue swirled and slid all over my hard-on, lathering me in natural lubrication. “Okay,” she said when she was done.
I approached her ass. My legs brushed against Foxy’s, but I didn’t care. I had eyes only for Haley’s plump rear end. This time she was the one to reach back and grab her ass cheeks, spreading herself wide for me.
Is this really happening?
I didn’t have the biggest penis in the world, but I knew I was bigger than most. There was no way it would fit inside her ass. Surely it would hurt, and she would ask me to stop, and it would be embarrassing. A thousand doubts ran through my head, insisting this wasn’t going to work. That my fantasy was going to be dashed.
But as I pressed the tip of my cock against her rear ring, Haley seemed to relax. She sighed, and the rim of her ass opened for me. Slowly the head of my cock slid inside. She moaned with pleasure, not pain, so I pushed deeper until my shaft entered.
“You ever done this before?” Haley asked, looking over her shoulder at me with lidded eyes. “Fuck a girl in the ass?”
“First time,” I admitted.
“What do you think?” Foxy asked.
It was different than fucking Haley in the pussy. Tighter, obviously, but grainier too. Similar and different at the same time.
“I like it,” I said truthfully.
“Then give me more,” she commanded. “Give me all you’ve got.”
I grabbed her tiny waist with both hands for leverage and thrust forward. Her body stiffened for a moment, then sighed with pleasure as I plunged more of myself into her. Her ass swallowed my cock wonderfully, her tight little ring expanding and taking the girth of my shaft like she’d done this before.
“I can feel you inside her ass,” Foxy said with a deep chuckle. “Damn, it’s tight.”
“So tight,” I agreed. The sensations in my dick were incredible, like the nerve endings were enflamed with pleasure. I wanted to throw inhibition to the wind and start fucking her wildly, hard and fast and deep like an animal. Somehow I held myself back.
Beneath her, Foxy started thrusting his hips, driving his cock up inside of her pussy. I felt the movement through Haley’s inner walls, like she was contracting her muscles around my cock.
She seemed to understand my reticence because she pointed and said, “Grab the lube.”
Foxy reached a hand into the box on the bed next to him and came out with a black container like a shampoo bottle. It was labeled Anal Lubricant.
“You came prepared,” I said, taking the bottle.
Haley began riding Foxy, moving her pussy up and down on his cock while mine remained deep inside her ass. “A little goes a long way,” she said in a voice thick with tension. “Hurry. I need you.”
I pulled back until only my head was inside her ass, then popped the lid off the lubricant. I drizzled a little bit of clear liquid on the top of my shaft, then spread it around with my fingers until it coated everything, including around the ring of her ass itself. All the while Haley continued riding Foxy, which rubbed the tip of my cock inside her steadily.
If we keep going just like this, I’m going to come.
Haley shifted her riding angle, pushing back against me. The lubricant did its job and my cock slid deeper inside her ass with wonderful ease. “Oh fuck,” I moaned as her ass massaged more of my nerves, spreading new pleasure throughout my body.
“Fuck me,” she begged. “Both of you, fuck me!”
I finally gave in and let the animal inside of me go free. I grabbed hold of her curvaceous ass with both hands and thrust my cock as deep as it would go. Inch by inch I plunged deeper, enough that surely it must be at least a little painful, but Haley’s moans were pure pleasure. Finally my cock was completely buried in her ass, all the way to the base.
“Oh my God,” I moaned. “Haley…”
“Where’s his cock?” Foxy asked Haley. “Say it.”
“Oh, it’s in my ass,” she whispered.
“I don’t think he heard you.”
“It’s in my ass,” she repeated louder. “Every inch of it is in my ass!”
“Good,” Foxy said, drawing it out into three syllables. “Why don’t you be a good girl and fuck both of us?”
Haley obeyed immediately, using her hips to drive her ass back and forth on our dual cocks. I watched with intense pleasure as her tight ass expanded and contracted over the contours of my manhood, while simultaneously devouring Foxy’s dick in her pussy. Haley’s body writhed between us, driven purely by the extreme ecstasy coursing through her body.
Eventually I couldn’t stand it anymore. With my hands on her waist, I started fucking her in earnest. Long, deep strokes that pulled all the way back before plunging inside again. Completely filling her again and again.
“Oh God,” Haley groaned as she let me take over, body slumped onto Foxy’s chest. “Oh God, yes, yes please yes don’t stop…”
It was a sublimely erotic moment as I fucked her ass like there was no tomorrow, fulfilling one of my deepest fantasies. The flesh of her butt cheeks was smooth and firm underneath my palms. Every stroke into her ass was like an orgasm in itself, every nerve ending firing as I gave in to the taboo and forbidden act. My balls tingled and a roar began building in my throat, one that I knew I had to subdue to keep others in the barracks from hearing.
Haley must have known I was close, because her torso rose off Foxy and arched back toward me. She twisted her head and said, “Come in my ass,” then kissed me harder and more desperately than anyone had ever kissed me in my life.
I wrapped my arms around her chest, cupping one of her full breasts while pulling her back against my chest and burying my manhood as deep as it would go inside her ass, all the way to the hilt. I moaned into her mouth as I came and came and came, filling her rear end with my hot, sticky seed.
Somewhere in the mix Foxy was moaning too, and I felt a second shuddering spasm inside Haley even though he was motionless inside of her, but I was too busy savoring the taste of her lips and tongue and the feel of her ass to care.
*
Seconds or minutes or hours later, Haley pushed back on me. My penis had gone soft inside her ass, a sensation that was strange and erotic in and of itself, and it slid out with ease as she stood on shaky legs.
I wrapped an arm around her waist to steady her. “Woah there.”
She smiled sleepily. “I can barely stand.”
“Can’t blame you, after what we just did to you,” Foxy said with a half-smile.
Haley brushed her lips against mine and then disappeared into the bathroom.
Once she was gone, I was acutely aware that Foxy and I were now two dudes naked in a room together. And it was very different than the kind of nudity one was accustomed to in the Army or Navy.
“So…” I said.
Foxy grabbed a pillow and covered his junk with it. “Right?”
He tossed me the other pillow, which I used to cover myself up and sit in one of the chairs. “So you two have been doing that, huh?” I asked, going back to my original question of the night that had started everything.
Foxy nodded. “More or less. Toys are fun. But this is better.”
I’d never had a threesome, much less one with two guys. I thought it’d be weird. Two dudes fumbling around a woman and trying not to touch each other or make eye contact. But everything that had just happened felt totally normal.
“You’re wondering why it wasn’t weird,” Foxy said.
“Yes! I thought it’d be more awkward than this.”
Foxy shrugged one shoulder. “Glad it’s not.”
“Me too,” I said, and meant it.
&n
bsp; Haley came out of the bathroom and then I went inside to clean up next. When I came out, Haley had moved the blankets and pillows from the narrow bed to the floor.
“You hoping for a slumber party?” I asked.
Foxy kissed her and then disappeared into the bathroom. Haley said, “I know you two can’t stay long. But just cuddle for a little bit. Please?”
“How can I say no to that?”
I put on my underwear and then laid down on my back. Haley got under the blanket next to me and draped one leg over my body. Then Foxy came out of the bathroom, still nude, and laid down on the other side of her.
“What’s that I feel between my cheeks?” Haley asked softly.
“I think you know what it is,” Foxy said.
Haley giggled. “If you’re hoping for round three…”
“Hell no!” Foxy quickly replied. “Girl, I couldn’t give it to you if I wanted to. My body is drained. I’m just sliding Little Foxy up between your cheeks for safe-keeping.”
“Okay,” she said, returning her head to my chest. She blinked up at me. “You okay?”
“I’ve never been more okay in my life,” I admitted.
“You sure?”
I’d had a huge crush on Haley at McCall. I’d been too afraid to make a move though, and then we’d come here and I’d almost ruined it by being an asshole about our situation. Then she was with Foxy, and it was clear I had missed my chance.
And then they’d invited me to join them.
Being with just Haley first had helped. Even though Foxy was watching in the corner, it allowed me to be with her emotionally and physically in a way that I think I needed. A foundation that was then built-upon when we double-teamed her.