“Holding his own, I’d say.” Gooding leaned nearer to Cork. “If you haven’t heard, you soon will. Arne Soderberg came into the office yesterday afternoon with his attorney. Gave a full statement. He admitted to an affair with Charlotte Kane. Said it began last summer, but he broke it off when he got himself elected sheriff. When she took up with Winter Moon, he got jealous, went back to seeing her. He admitted he was at Valhalla, but swears she was alive and unharmed when he left. He’s got a receipt and a witness that place him in town in the time frame we believe she was attacked. Looks like a pretty solid alibi. He also admitted that the rose petals were his doing. Said the last promise he made to her was that when he was a free man, as in divorced from Lyla, I guess, he’d give her a bed of roses to lie in.” Gooding looked down. “Soderberg. I should have been suspicious. He had money, transport, and a key to the cemetery. Pretty sloppy police work.”
“Give yourself a break. You couldn’t have known he had a motive. Who would have thought it?”
Gooding looked up again. “You did.”
“What about the blood tears? Did he know anything about that?”
“Swore he didn’t have anything to do with it. Doesn’t know a thing about it.”
“You hear anything yet from the BCA on the samples you took from the angel?”
“Mostly water and a little blood. Type O-positive, most common blood type. Nobody actually saw the angel weeping. The tears had already streamed down the monument when the crowd started to gather, so I suppose they could easily have been put there earlier by almost anyone. Somebody, maybe, who just wanted to add to the mystique. You could figure it any number of ways that have nothing to do with miracles.”
Gooding’s toast arrived. He opened a packet of honey.
“Cork, I’ve got to tell you, we still like Winter Moon for the girl’s murder. Too much evidence against him. The CA’s going ahead with the prosecution. You still believe he’s innocent?”
“I do.”
“You really care about that kid, don’t you?” Gooding said as he spread the honey over his toast. “I wonder if sometimes we want to believe something so much that the truth can smack us right between the eyes and we don’t even notice.”
Cork sipped his coffee and ignored the comment. “You said you’d have a talk with Kane. Did you?”
“I went to his place yesterday. It was like talking to a lamp-post. I don’t know where Winter Moon is, but if I were you, I’d tell him to lie low right now. I think you’re right about Kane. He’s right on the edge of doing something stupid.”
From the Broiler, Cork headed straight to Sam Winter Moon’s old cabin. As he passed through Alouette on the rez, he saw Dot’s Blazer parked outside LeDuc’s general store. Solemn was in it, alone behind the wheel. Cork pulled up on the passenger side and got out of his Bronco. He walked around the back of the Blazer to the driver’s side, and noticed the old pickup parked not far away, and the two men who occupied the cab. He went to the pickup and leaned in the window.
“Junior,” he said. “Phil. What’s up?”
The smell of beer came from inside the cab where Junior and Philbert Medina sat. The two men were relatives of Dorothy Winter Moon, her mother’s sister’s husband’s children from a first marriage. They were both mechanics in their father’s garage in Brandywine, the other rez community. Junior wore a ball cap over his long black hair. Phil kept his own hair in a buzz cut. Both men cradled rifles on their laps and each had a can of Budweiser clamped in a free hand. They gave Cork big, stupid grins.
“Just getting ready for a little deer hunting,” Junior said.
“Deer?”
“Yeah,” Phil put in. “Waiting for a fat buck to come strolling onto the rez.”
“Helping Dot out, are you?”
“That’s what family’s for, cousin.” On the reservation, everyone was cousin.
“You know, I’d feel a lot better if you’d put away either the beer or the rifles.” Cork paused a moment, then added, “You ought to put away both.”
“What are you going to do? Arrest us?” Junior laughed.
Cork turned away and walked to the Blazer.
“Morning, Solemn.”
“Hey, Cork.” Solemn kept his eyes straight ahead.
“I’m guessing you already heard that Kane’s looking for you.”
“I heard.”
“And Tweedle Dum and Tweedle Dee over there are your answer?”
“Phil and Junior were my idea.”
Dorothy Winter Moon had come from LeDuc’s store with a sack of groceries in her arms. She wore sunglasses against the glare of the bright morning sunlight. She stepped around Cork and opened the Blazer’s back door.
“This isn’t a good idea, Dot.”
“You got a better one?” She set the grocery bag on the backseat and shut the door.
“Go to Henry Meloux, Solemn,” Cork said. “You’ll be safe with him, and maybe he can help in other ways.”
“I can take care of my son,” Dot said.
Cork looked at Solemn. “Is this what you want?”
Solemn didn’t seem to hear. The two Medinas laughed at something, a loud and grating sound.
“Don’t let go of it, Solemn,” Cork said.
Solemn slowly turned his head, and Cork saw the hardness in his eyes.
“Let go of what?” Solemn said.
“What you found out there in the woods. That feeling. That belief.”
Solemn regarded him for a long time. “What if it wasn’t real?”
“Sometimes believing is all it takes to make a thing real.”
“That boy in the wheelchair, his folks, they believed.”
Dot scanned the street as if any moment she expected that Kane would leap out of the shadows in ambush. “We need to get back to Sam’s cabin.” She circled around the front of the Blazer and got in on the passenger side. “Let’s go, Solemn.”
Cork reached through the window and put his hand on the young man’s arm. “Go to Meloux.”
Solemn didn’t answer. He started the engine and, when Cork withdrew his hand, backed onto the street and headed north out of Alouette. The Medinas followed in their truck.
Cork looked at the dust kicked up in Solemn’s wake and wondered about the comment Gooding had made earlier. Maybe he did believe in Solemn’s innocence simply because he wanted to believe. Was that enough to make it so?
31
AT NINE O’CLOCK THAT EVENING, Cork said, “Let’s close ’er up, Annie.”
It was Friday night, and they’d had a steady stream of customers for hours. Cork was tired.
Annie turned from the serving window, which was empty at the moment. “You know, you’d make a lot more money if we stayed open late, Dad.”
“I don’t want to work late. Do you?”
“Not especially.”
“Well there you are. We’d both rather be poor but happy. Let’s get the place cleaned up.”
Half an hour later, Annie walked to the door of the Quonset hut. “See you at home.”
“I’m going to put the night deposit together. If you wait a few minutes, I’ll give you a ride.”
“It’s a nice night,” Annie said. “I think I’ll walk.”
“Suit yourself.”
The evening sky was sapphire. Cork walked to the door and watched Annie head toward town, following the path along the lakeshore toward the copse of poplars that enclosed the ruins of the old foundry. The trees were dark against the fading light, and Annie, against the horizon, was dark, too, and small and lovely. There were moments like this when Cork felt absolutely full, overflowing with love for his life, his family, his friends, this place he called home. He felt all that was familiar wrap around him like an old, comfortable quilt, and he didn’t know how a man could be any luckier.
When he’d finished preparing the deposit, he locked up Sam’s Place and headed into town. After the money was safely in the bank’s keeping, Cork drove Center Street for a while. It was a busy evening. The
streets were alive with traffic, teenagers and tourists and locals taking advantage of the summer night. Cork was looking for Kane’s El Dorado, but he didn’t see it, and in a way he was relieved.
He’d just turned on Olive Street to head home when his cell phone chirped.
“Cork, it’s Jo. Where are you?”
He heard the concern in her voice.
“On my way home. What is it?”
“It’s Annie. She’s pretty upset. She’s sure someone stalked her after she left Sam’s Place.”
“I’ll be right there.”
They were in the kitchen, the three O’Connor women, Jo, Jenny, and Annie. Annie sat at the table with a glass of milk in front of her and an uneaten cookie. Jenny had pulled up a chair next to her. Jo sat across the table. They all glanced up when Cork came in. Jo and Jenny looked worried. Annie looked scared.
“Hey, sweetheart, how’re you doing?” He bent and kissed the top of Annie’s head. Her hair still smelled of hot fry oil.
“Dad, some creep followed me home.”
Cork pulled out a chair and seated himself. “Tell me everything from the beginning.”
It was dark outside. The bulb over the sink was on. Night insects bumped against the screen trying desperately to get at the light.
Annie played with her cookie, turning it round and round on the table. Occasionally, her eyes flicked toward the bump and brush of the bugs at the window.
“I saw him the first time in the trees where the old foundry is. He was, like, crouching behind part of that brick wall that’s still there.”
“Why do you think it was a him?”
“I guess I didn’t then. When I saw him the next time, I was pretty sure.”
“Where was that?”
“In Randolph Park. I was walking along the trail that cuts through the ball fields and over the culvert. He was there in the trees along the creek.”
“You got a better look this time?”
“Yeah. But it was also darker, so I couldn’t really see much.”
“Tell me what you saw.”
“I think he was tall.”
“Taller than me?”
“I’d say so, yes.”
“Fat, skinny?”
“Kind of medium.”
“What was he doing?”
“Just standing there, watching me.”
“How do you know it was the same person you saw by the old foundry?”
“I just know it was.”
“Okay. Go on.”
“I started running then, kind of like I was jogging home. I just wanted to get out of there.”
“Sure. That was smart, honey.”
“Then I saw him again. He was waiting in the alley just before I got to Gooseberry Lane. There’s a streetlamp there, but he stayed in the shadow of the Kaufmanns’ big lilac hedge.”
“Did you get a better look this time?”
She shook her head. “I only saw him because he coughed.”
“Did he say anything?”
“No.”
“Did you?”
“No. I ran. I mean I really ran this time.”
“Is there anything you remember about him? Any detail? His clothing?”
“No.”
“Did he wear glasses?”
“I don’t know.”
“Face hair?”
“I couldn’t see.”
She seemed distressed that she had no answers, and Cork decided to let it go for now.
“That’s okay, Annie. You did just fine.”
“This is Aurora,” Jenny said. “We shouldn’t have to worry about pervs here.”
Cork said, “Until we know better what’s going on, you both ride home with me at night, okay?”
“What if Sean gives me a ride?” Jenny said, speaking of her boyfriend.
“Fine. But he sees you to the door.”
“Which he ought to be doing anyway,” Jo said.
Annie held herself as if she were cold. “I think I’m going to take a shower.”
“A good long hot one,” her sister advised. “Wash that creep away. Come on. I’ll go up with you.”
Cork stood up and hugged her. “It’ll be all right, I promise.”
She seemed to believe him. “Thanks, Dad.”
When the girls were gone, Cork sat with Jo at the table. He picked up Annie’s uneaten cookie and began breaking it into pieces.
“What do you think?” Jo said.
“Annie’s as sensible as they come. If she says she was followed, she was followed.”
“Why would someone do that?”
The cookie lay in crumbs on the table in front of Cork. “Jo, there’s something I haven’t told you. I didn’t think much about it until now. The other day when Kane was out at Sam’s Place, he asked me how I’d feel if it were my daughter who was dead.”
“And you don’t think it was just a rhetorical question?” Jo was quiet a moment. “You think it might have been Fletcher?”
“Annie said the guy was tall. Fletcher’s tall. He’s always been odd, but he’s way beyond odd now. I’m not saying absolutely it was Kane, but I’d be a fool—no, worse; I’d be negligent—if I didn’t check him out. Jo, if he did have something to do with Charlotte’s murder, who knows what he might be thinking now.”
Jo’s eyes drifted to the door through which her precious daughter had just passed. She nodded once. “Start checking.”
32
NEXT MORNING, Cork stopped by the YMCA early. He found Mal Thorne in the weight room, wearing finger gloves and working a heavy bag. The priest worked out this way several mornings a week, keeping himself in shape. He might not have been the athlete he was when he’d boxed at Notre Dame, but for a man in middle age, he was all right. He wore a sleeveless T-shirt, and his biceps were hard and round as river stones.
Mal stopped when he saw Cork watching him. He smiled and, with the back of the leather glove on his big right hand, wiped sweat from his brow.
“What’s up, Cork?”
“Got a minute?”
“Sure.”
The room smelled of warm weights and hot bodies and bench cushions that went too long between cleanings. Except for Mal and Cork, the place was empty.
“I’ve been thinking, Mal. About the graffiti Solemn spray-painted on the wall of St. Agnes. That Latin word.”
“Mendax.”
“Right. Liar. I’m pretty sure it was Charlotte Kane who put him up to it.”
The priest showed no surprise.
“Why do you suppose she did that?”
Mal laid a hand on the heavy bag, as if to keep it from swinging, which it wasn’t. “Search me.”
“Not even a guess?”
“Some people feel as if God has let them down, as if the promises of the Church are empty. I encounter that a lot.”
“Did you encounter it with Charlotte?”
“Maybe.”
“You’re hedging.”
“I was her priest, Cork.”
“And her confessor.”
“It’s the nature of the job.”
“Mal, Charlotte Kane exhibited behaviors that, in my understanding, are classic for a young woman who’d been sexually abused, probably on a long-term basis.”
The priest tugged off one of his gloves, and started on the other.
“It occurs to me that you’re also Fletcher Kane’s confessor.”
“I’m not going there with you, Cork. You know that anything told to me in confession is a sacred confidence.”
“I’m concerned. If he was sexually molesting his daughter, he may be trapped in a behavior pattern that threatens other young women.”
“I can’t help you, Cork.” A drop of sweat hung on the priest’s brow. It gathered weight, plummeted, splattered soundlessly on the wooden floor.
“Someone followed Annie home last night. Stayed to the shadows where she couldn’t see him clearly.”
“You think it was Kane?”
“Is there a re
ason I should?”
The priest looked away and didn’t answer.
“You know something about him and about Charlotte, don’t you?”
“Charlotte’s dead, Cork. Let the dead rest in peace.”
“I don’t think there’s going to be much peace here until we know the truth about her murder.”
The priest took a deep breath. “There’s only one truth of which I’m absolutely certain. That none of us is without sin.” He gave a final, ungloved blow to the heavy bag. “We’re done here.”
He walked away, leaving Cork wondering what it was the priest knew but wouldn’t say.
* * *
At the sheriff’s department, he found Cy Borkmann sitting in the chair that only a few days before had been occupied by Arne Soderberg.
“You look good there, Cy.”
“Hey, Cork,” Borkmann said, rising. “Come on in.”
They shook hands.
“How’s it going?” Cork asked.
“No complaints so far. Have a seat. By the way, that was some nice piece of work, connecting Arne with Charlotte Kane.”
“You know how it is. Sometimes you get lucky. Any idea how Arne’s doing?”
“Heard Lyla kicked him out. Me, I wouldn’t necessarily consider that punishment. Gooding told you about the rose petals.”
“Yeah.”
Borkmann shook his head and his wattle wobbled. “Swear to god, you could give Arne a bucketful of wishes and he’d find a way to turn it into a handful of horse crap.”
Cork smiled, then got serious. “Cy, somebody followed my daughter home last night. Scared her pretty bad.”
“Attacked her?”
“No. Stalked is more like it.”
“Did she see who?”
“It was too dark.”
“Let’s write up an incident report.”
“Hold on a minute. I’d like to run something by you. Just between you and me. Off the record.”
“Shoot.”
Cork told him about his discussion with the school psychologist. “From what I gather, Cy, behavior like Charlotte’s may well have been the result of long-term abuse. In all likelihood, it predated her involvement with Arne. I’m wondering about Fletcher Kane. I’m wondering what kind of relationship he really had with his daughter.”
Borkmann’s eyes saucered. He picked up a pen and made a brief notation on a scrap of paper on his desk.
The William Kent Krueger Collection 2 Page 23