"No!" Mary Windsor shrieked. "You can't -"
"What is this?" Dobbs cried out.
Kurlen didn't answer or wait for Roulet to comply. He stepped forward and roughly turned Roulet around. As he made the forced turn, Roulet's eyes came to mine.
"What's going on, Mick?" he said in a calm voice. "This shouldn't be happening."
Mary Windsor moved toward her son.
"Take your hands off of my son!"
She grabbed Kurlen from behind but Booker and Lankford quickly moved in and detached her, handling her gently but strongly.
"Ma'am, step back," Booker commanded. "Or I will put you in jail."
Kurlen started giving Roulet the Miranda warning. Windsor stayed back but was not silent.
"How dare you? You cannot do this!"
Her body moved in place and she looked as though unseen hands were keeping her from charging at Kurlen again.
"Mother," Roulet said in a tone that carried more weight and control than any of the detectives.
Windsor's body relented. She gave up. But Dobbs didn't.
"You're arresting him for what?" he demanded.
"Suspicion of murder," Kurlen said. "The murder of Martha Renteria."
"That's impossible!" Dobbs cried. "Everything that witness Corliss said in there was proven to be a lie. Are you crazy? The judge dismissed the case because of his lies."
Kurlen broke from his recital of Roulet's rights and looked at Dobbs.
"If it was all a lie, how'd you know he was talking about Martha Renteria?"
Dobbs realized his mistake and took a step back from the gathering. Kurlen smiled.
"Yeah, I thought so," he said.
He grabbed Roulet by an elbow and turned him back around.
"Let's go," he said.
"Mick?" Roulet said.
"Detective Kurlen," I said. "Can I talk to my client for a moment?"
Kurlen looked at me, seemed to measure something in me and then nodded.
"One minute. Tell him to behave himself and it will all go a lot easier for him."
He shoved Roulet toward me. I took him by one arm and walked him a few paces away from the others so we would have privacy if we kept our voices down. I stepped close to him and began in a whisper.
"This is it, Louis. This is good-bye. I got you off. Now you're on your own. Get yourself a new lawyer."
The shock showed in his eyes. Then his face clouded over with a tightly focused anger. It was pure rage and I realized it was the same rage Regina Campo and Martha Renteria must have seen.
"I won't need a lawyer," he said to me. "You think they can make a case off of what you somehow fed to that lying snitch in there? You better think again."
"They won't need the snitch, Louis. Believe me, they'll find more. They probably already have more."
"What about you, Mick? Aren't you forgetting something? I have -"
"I know. But it doesn't matter anymore. They don't need my gun. They've already got all they need. But whatever happens to me, I'll know that I put you down. At the end, after the trial and all the appeals, when they finally stick that needle in your arm, that will be me, Louis. Remember that."
I smiled with no humor and moved in closer.
"This is for Raul Levin. You might not go down for him but make no mistake, you are going down."
I let that register for a moment and then stepped back and nodded to Kurlen. He and Booker came up on either side of Roulet and took hold of his upper arms.
"You set me up," Roulet said, somehow maintaining his calm. "You aren't a lawyer. You work for them."
"Let's go," Kurlen said.
They started moving him but he shook them off momentarily and put his raging eyes right back into mine.
"This isn't the end, Mick," he said. "I'll be out by tomorrow morning. What will you do then? Think about it. What are you going to do then? You can't protect everybody."
They took a tighter hold of him and roughly turned him toward the elevators. This time Roulet went without a struggle. Halfway down the hall toward the elevator, his mother and Dobbs trailing behind, he turned his head to look back over his shoulder at me. He smiled and it sent something right through me.
You can't protect everybody.
A cold shiver of fear pierced my chest.
Someone was waiting for the elevator and it opened just as the entourage got there. Lankford signaled the person back and took the elevator. Roulet was hustled in. Dobbs and Windsor were about to follow when they were halted by Lankford's hand extended in a stop signal. The elevator door started to close and Dobbs angrily and impotently pushed on the button next to it.
My hope was that it would be the last I would ever see of Louis Roulet, but the fear stayed locked in my chest, fluttering like a moth caught inside a porch light. I turned away and almost walked right into Sobel. I hadn't noticed that she had stayed behind the others.
"You have enough, don't you?" I said. "Tell me you wouldn't have moved so quickly if you didn't have enough to keep him."
She looked at me a long moment before answering.
"We won't decide that. The DA will. Probably depends on what they get out of him in interrogation. But up till now he's had a pretty smart lawyer. He probably knows not to say a word to us."
"Then why didn't you wait?"
"Wasn't my call."
I shook my head. I wanted to tell her that they had moved too fast. It wasn't part of the plan. I wanted to plant the seed, that's all. I wanted them to move slowly and get it right.
The moth fluttered inside and I looked down at the floor. I couldn't shake the idea that all of my machinations had failed, leaving me and my family exposed in the hard-eyed focus of a killer.You can't protect everybody .
It was as if Sobel read my fears.
"But we're going to try to keep him," she said. "We have what the snitch said in court and the ticket. We're working on witnesses and the forensics."
My eyes came up to hers.
"What ticket?"
A look of suspicion entered her face.
"I thought you had it figured out. We put it together as soon as the snitch mentioned the snake dancer."
"Yeah. Martha Renteria. I got that. But what ticket? What are you talking about?"
I had moved in too close to her and Sobel took a step back from me. It wasn't my breath. It was my desperation.
"I don't know if I should tell you, Haller. You're a defense lawyer. You'rehis lawyer."
"Not anymore. I just quit."
"Doesn't matter. He -"
"Look, you just took that guy down because of me. I might get disbarred because of it. I might even go to jail for a murder I didn't commit. What ticket are you talking about?"
She hesitated and I waited, but then she finally spoke.
"Raul Levin's last words. He said he found Jesus's ticket out."
"Which means what?"
"You really don't know, do you?"
"Look, just tell me. Please."
She relented.
"We traced Levin's most recent movements. Before he was murdered he had made inquiries about Roulet's parking tickets. He even pulled hard copies of them. We inventoried what he had in the office and eventually compared it with what's on the computer. He was missing one ticket. One hard copy. We didn't know if his killer took it that day or if he had just missed pulling it. So we went and pulled a copy ourselves. It was issued two years ago on the night of April eighth. It was a citation for parking in front of a hydrant in the sixty-seven-hundred block of Blythe Street
in Panorama City."
It all came together for me, like the last bit of sand dropping through the middle of an hourglass. Raul Levin really had found Jesus Menendez's salvation.
"Martha Renteria was murdered two years ago on April eighth," I said. "She lived on Blythe in Panorama City."
"Yes, but we didn't know that. We didn't see the connection. You told us that Levin was working separate cases for you. Jesus Menendez and Loui
s Roulet were separate investigations. Levin had them filed that way, too."
"It was a discovery issue. He kept the cases separate so I wouldn't have to turn over anything on Roulet that he came up with on Menendez."
"One of your lawyer angles. Well, it stopped us from putting it together until that snitch in there mentioned the snake dancer. That connected everything."
I nodded.
"So whoever killed Raul Levin took the hard copy?"
"We think."
"Did you check Raul's phones for a tap? Somehow somebody knew he found the ticket."
"We did. They were clear. Bugs could have been removed at the time of the murder. Or maybe it was someone else's phone that was tapped."
Meaning mine. Meaning it might explain how Roulet knew so many of my moves and was even conveniently waiting for me in my home the night I had come home from seeing Jesus Menendez.
"I will have them checked," I said. "Does all of this mean I am clear on Raul's murder?"
"Not necessarily," Sobel said. "We still want to see what comes back from ballistics. We're hoping for something today."
I nodded. I didn't know how to respond. Sobel lingered, looking like she wanted to tell me or ask me something.
"What?" I said.
"I don't know. Is there anything you want to tell me?"
"I don't know. There's nothing to tell."
"Really? In the courtroom it seemed like you were trying to tell us a lot."
I was silent a moment, trying to read between the lines.
"What do you want from me, Detective Sobel?"
"You know what I want. I want Raul Levin's killer."
"Well, so do I. But I couldn't give you Roulet on Levin even if I wanted to. I don't know how he did it. And that's off the record."
"So that still leaves you in the crosshairs."
She looked down the hall at the elevators, her implication clear. If the ballistics matched, I could still have a problem on Levin. They would use it as leverage. Give up how Roulet did it or go down for it myself. I changed the subject.
"How long do you think before Jesus Menendez gets out?" I asked.
She shrugged.
"Hard to say. Depends on the case they build against Roulet-if they have a case. But I know one thing. They can't prosecute Roulet as long as another man is in prison for the same crime."
I turned and walked over to the glass wall. I put my free hand on the railing that ran along the glass. I felt a mixture of elation and dread and that moth still batting around in my chest.
"That's all I care about," I said quietly. "Getting him out. That and Raul."
She came over and stood next to me.
"I don't know what you are doing," she said. "But leave the rest for us."
"I do that and your partner will probably put me in jail for a murder I didn't commit."
"You are playing a dangerous game," she said. "Leave it alone."
I looked at her and then back down at the plaza.
"Sure," I said. "I'll leave it alone now."
Having heard what she needed to, she made a move to go.
"Good luck," she said.
I looked at her again.
"Same to you."
She left then and I stayed. I turned back to the window and looked down into the plaza. I saw Dobbs and Windsor crossing the concrete squares and heading toward the parking garage. Mary Windsor was leaning against her lawyer for support. I doubted they were still headed to lunch at Orso.
FORTY-FIVE
By that night the word had begun to spread. Not the secret details but the public story. The story that I had won the case, gotten a DA's motion to dismiss with no comebacks, only to have my client arrested for a murder in the hallway outside the courtroom where I had just cleared him. I got calls from every other defense pro I knew. I got call after call until my cell phone finally died. My colleagues were all congratulating me. In their eyes, there was no downside. Roulet was the ultimate franchise. I got schedule A fees for one trial and then I would get schedule A fees for the next one. It was a double-dip most defense pros could only dream about. And, of course, when I told them I would not be handling the defense of the new case, each one of them asked if I could refer him to Roulet.
It was the one call that came in on my home line that I wanted the most. It was from Maggie McPherson.
"I've been waiting for your call all night," I said.
I was pacing in the kitchen, tethered by the phone cord. I had checked my phones when I had gotten home and found no evidence of bugging devices.
"Sorry, I've been in the conference room," she said.
"I heard you were pulled in on Roulet."
"Yes, that's why I'm calling. They're going to cut him loose."
"What are you talking about? They're letting him go?"
"Yes. They've had him for nine hours in a room and he hasn't broken. Maybe you taught him too well not to talk, because he's a rock and they got nothing and that means they don't have enough."
"You're wrong. There is enough. They have the parking ticket and there have to be witnesses who can put him in The Cobra Room. Even Menendez can ID him there."
"You know as well as I do that Menendez is a scratch. He'd identify anybody to get out. And if there are other wits from The Cobra Room, then it's going to take some time to run them down. The parking ticket puts him in the neighborhood but it doesn't put him inside her apartment."
"What about the knife?"
"They're working on it but that's going to take time, too. Look, we want to do this right. It was Smithson's call and, believe me, he wanted to keep him, too. It would make that fiasco you created in court today a little more palatable. But it's just not there. Not yet. They're going to kick him loose and work the forensics and look for the witnesses. If Roulet's good for this, then we will get him, and your other client will get out. You don't have to worry. But we have to do it right."
I swung a fist impotently through the air.
"They jumped the gun. Damn it, they shouldn't have made the move today."
"I guess they thought nine hours in interrogation would do the trick."
"They were stupid."
"Nobody's perfect."
I was annoyed by her attitude but held my tongue on that. I needed her to keep me in the loop.
"When exactly will they let him go?" I asked.
"I don't know. This all just went down. Kurlen and Booker came over here to present it and Smithson just sent them back to the PD. When they get back, I assume they'll kick him loose."
"Listen to me, Maggie. Roulet knows about Hayley."
There was a horribly long moment of silence before she answered.
"What are you saying, Haller? You let our daughter into -"
"I didn't let anything happen. He broke into my house and saw her picture. It doesn't mean he knows where she lives or even what her name is. But he knows about her and he wants to get back at me. So you have to go home right now. I want you to be with Hayley. Get her and get out of the apartment. Just play it safe."
Something made me hold back on telling her everything, that I felt that Roulet had specifically threatened my family in the courthouse.You can't protect everybody. I would only use that if she refused to do what I wanted her to do with Hayley.
"I'm leaving now," she said. "And we're coming to you."
I knew she would say that.
"No, don't come to me."
"Why not?"
"Becausehe might come to me."
"This is crazy. What are you going to do?"
"I'm not sure yet. Just go get Hayley and get somewhere safe. Then call me on your cell, but don't tell me where you are. It will be better if I don't even know."
"Haller, just call the police. They can -"
"And tell them what?"
"I don't know. Tell them you've been threatened."
"A defense lawyer telling the police he feels threatened . . . yeah, they'll jump all over that. Probably send out a
SWAT team."
"Well, you have to do something."
"I thought I did. I thought he was going to be in jail for the rest of his life. But you people moved too fast and now you have to let him go."
THE LINCOLN LAWYER (2005) Page 40