by John Flynn
The victim’s severely beaten body hung from shackles in the center of the room over a pool of blood. Not only had his throat been cut, but the man’s penis had also been severed at the base of the shaft and shoved into his mouth. His lips were crimson with blood. The horrible and degrading image seemed less like a crime scene, and more like a glimpse of Dante’s lowest circle of Hell.
“Christ almighty!” Kate blurted out, unaware of what she had said until she realized that everyone in the room had stopped what they were doing and looked right at her. She straightened up, brushed the folds out of her Versace blazer, and tried to pull herself together.
Without a moment’s hesitation, Frank came to her defense. “Okay, so what we got?” he demanded, the senior detective’s words summoning everyone back to work.
All at once, the basement dungeon was a flurry of activity. The forensics team returned to picking over the room, searching and probing for clothing fibers or single strands of hair that may have fallen to the floor. The coroner’s crew returned to scouring the body for clues, including lacerations that may have revealed something about the murder weapon. Their boss, Dr. Edgar Brogan, the portly medical examiner with the windblown cheeks and bloodshot eyes, did not waste any time plunging what looked like a large meat thermometer into the victim’s abdomen before checking his watch.
Mikhail Jawara, one of the two Homicide detectives who had the bad fortune to pick up the crime at the end of their shift, obviously struggled to stay awake by downing the last few drops of his coffee, while his partner William Clark checked over his notes. A couple of uniformed cops stood around, talking, taking in the sights. They didn’t seem to be in much of a hurry to return to their beat.
In the shadow created by the Iron Maiden, just beyond the hustle and bustle of the scene-of-the-crime boys, Miller spotted two plain-clothed men that looked like they would have been more at home on the golf course than at a homicide investigation. Lt. Roberts and Captain Aguilar didn’t seem like they were in much of a hurry to go anywhere. Roberts, as the head of the Homicide Bureau of the San Francisco Police Department, had every reason to be there—even though it pissed Miller off that the death of some big mucky-muck rated a visit from the boss when the life of a five-year-old child cut short by a stray bullet from a gangland slaying would have been totally ignored by him. The attendance of Aguilar, assistant chief of police, and the mayor’s personal hatchet man, meant that something big was going down. Something, Frank knew, that had very little to do with murder and a lot more to do with San Francisco city politics.
“People, we really need to focus,” Miller said loudly, over the noise of the room. “I know it’s early, and most of us haven’t had our morning coffee. But we need to focus on the particulars of the crime scene at hand.” He waited for them all to settle down. “Now, what have we got?”
Clark waved his notebook in the air. “The victim’s name is Stephen Collins,” he said, reading from the page. “Thirty-six years old, divorced, no children. Chief Executive Officer, Westmore Real Estate Development Corporation.”
“Westmore?” Jawara repeated. “That’s the group the mayor hired to tear down the last of the public housing in the Mission District. Wanted to make room for more of those yuppie restaurants and nightclubs—”
Aguilar cut him off. “That’s the last I want to hear about Westmore,” he said firmly, without discussion. “The City of San Francisco awarded that contract to Westmore fairly, and with all due transparency, in a competitive bid process which selected their sealed bid as the cheapest from among three higher bids. We all must be clear on this.”
Jawara nodded, and crossed to the other side of the room where his partner was taking notes. “Christ! What did I say?”
“Just don’t say anything more,” Clark whispered.
“You guys know Captain Aguilar?” Roberts asked the two detectives.
“We’ve already had the pleasure.” Kate scowled, remembering what a sonuvabitch he had been during her reinstatement hearing. If Aguilar had had his way, she would have been busted down to file clerk and banished to Records for the rest of her natural-born life.
“Be nice,” said Roberts.
“What’s the chief’s office doing here, Lieutenant?” Miller asked casually and far more diplomatically than Kate would have.
“The mayor is concerned by the way in which we have been handling this case,” replied Roberts. “Especially with the press.”
Aguilar folded his arms across his chest and his gaze swept the room, sizing up his men. “Due to the potentially explosive nature of the crime, the chief of police felt a senior member of his staff should take the lead in this investigation,” he said, evidently awash in his own fantasies of patriotism and flag-waving. “From now on, there will be a total news blackout about this so-called ‘Angel of Death,’ and no one but me will talk to the press about developments related to this case. I will also expect regular reports about your progress. Is that understood?”
Kate flashed raised eyebrows at Miller as she crossed to join Jawara and Clark on the opposite side of the room.
Miller hunched down over the pool of blood, and regarded the victim. “How long has Collins been dead, Dr. Brogan?”
“The skin turns white when I press it. This kind of discoloration is about right for six to eight hours,” the medical examiner replied. He looked down at the dial on the thermometer he had placed in the victim’s abdomen and checked his watch. “Ninety-two degrees . . . give or take an hour for each degree . . . that places the time of death around two a.m., plus or minus.”
“Cause of death?” Miller asked.
“Massive hemorrhage,” Brogan answered. “When the carotid artery in the victim’s throat was severed, probably by a very sharp knife or instrument, he bled to death in a matter of moments.”
Frank stood up and walked around the body. “Doesn’t look like he put up much of a struggle.”
Brogan shook his head. “The cut to the throat is clean, indicating a limited struggle. It’s consistent with the fact that we found the victim completely immobilized,” he said. “No, I don’t think he even saw it coming.”
Kate stared hard at the body “So, the victim willingly allowed himself to be shackled and beaten?”
“Take a look around,” Jawara replied. “This guy was into some pretty kinky shit.”
Kate looked around at the Iron Maiden, the thumb screws and branding irons, and trembled. She tried to rub away the creeping cold sensation that ran up and down her body, but it continued to hold her captive.
“What can you tell us about the killer?” Miller asked Dr. Brogan.
“Not much,” he replied with a shrug. “Could be a male. Could be female. But I’d definitely be looking for someone left-handed. Possibly with connections to some BDSM group.”
At the chorus of soft chuckles and snickers, Aguilar frowned, evidently annoyed by their juvenile behavior. He spoke evenly, calmly, with the authority of his office behind his words. “Not a word of that leaves this room! Do you hear me? The last thing we need is the press triggering a witch-hunt in the gay community that would tear this city apart.”
“Gay community?” Clark asked, confused, thumbing back through his notes. “Who said the killer was homosexual?”
“That’s not what Brogan said . . .” Kate interjected.
“I specifically heard him say—” Aguilar spoke over the top of her.
“I said BDSM,” the medical examiner corrected him, saying it loud enough that everyone heard him. “That’s an acronym for bondage and discipline, dominance and submission, and sadomasochism. Simply put, it refers to activities between consenting adults that contain sadistic and masochistic elements.”
The room went suddenly quiet as members of the law enforcement personnel regarded each other with curiosity.
Frank never took hi
s eyes off the body. He frowned slightly, but felt more thoughtful than condemning. In his forty years of service to the San Francisco Police Department, he had never had a case that involved sadomasochism nor had he had much experience with the subculture. He had handled more than his fair share of perverts and prostitutes back in the day when he’d walked a beat in the Tenderloin, but his understanding of BDSM was little more than that of the average layman’s. He would have been hard-pressed to explain why anyone in their right mind would have submitted willingly to such a beating.
“Sounds pretty twisted,” Clark said, breaking the silence.
“Not at all,” Brogan replied. “Many people practice some element of BDSM in their sexual lives without even being aware of it. They may think of S&M as that sick stuff that people do with whips and cattle prods, yet still blindfold one another from time to time and break out the whipped cream . . .”
“Doesn’t sound like my idea of fun,” added Jawara.
The medical examiner adjusted the glasses on his face with his right index finger. “Maybe not, but it’s still practiced by more people than you know, and not just homosexuals.”
Aguilar looked like he was about to explode, but he managed to keep it all in. “All this talk about bondage and cattle prods and M&Ms stays right here in this room,” he said, dead serious. “I don’t want to hear one mention of this to the press. They’re already going to have a field day when they learn our third victim was connected to the mayor’s redevelopment project.”
Everyone nodded, reluctantly.
Miller focused his attention back on the body. “Dr. Brogan, you said the perpetrator was left-handed. What makes you think so?”
“He, or she, reached around from behind the victim, and cut his throat from right to left,” Brogan replied, then pantomimed the actions of the killer, holding an imaginary knife in his left hand and drawing it across the victim’s throat. “The angle and depth of the injury is consistent with a strong left-handed person.”
“And what about that whole ‘Lorena Bobbitt’ thing?” Jawara asked.
Dr. Brogan shook his head. “Your guess is as good as mine,” he replied. “But I can tell you the victim was probably already dead when it happened.”
“Thanks, Edgar,” Lt. Roberts said, dismissing the medical examiner. He reached up and scratched the stubble on his face absentmindedly. The patches of stubble matched the salt-and-pepper color of his hair. “So, what does that give us? Three victims, three identical crime scenes, no suspects.”
Kate thought about his question for a moment, then asked, “Was Collins connected in any way to the other two victims?”
Clark checked his notes. “No,” he replied. “Victim number one was a thirty-nine-year-old stockbroker who had just moved here from Detroit. Victim number two was a forty-seven year-old retired rock-’n-roller named Dr. Zee.” The detective glanced up from his notepad with the look of recognition on his face. “I think I still have one of his early albums on an eight-track tape.”
“That’s likely to become a collector’s item now,” said Jawara, his tongue firmly planted in his cheek. “You may want to save that one for eBay.”
Detective Clark was a pack rat and spent most of his downtime buying and selling at online auctions. He had enough junk—from beer cans, Civil War medals, and comic books to sports collectibles, toy trains and everything in between—to fill several warehouses. He’d financed his way through college by selling off less than a dozen of his favorite comic books, including Superman #1 and DC Showcase #4. At thirty-nine years of age and unmarried, Clark had it all—he was rich, white, and successful. Frank wondered why he continued to work.
“All three men were rich, white, and successful. That’s about as far as it goes,” Clark concluded, snapping his notebook closed.
“You forgot to mention kinky,” Kate added, unable to resist commenting.
The assistant chief of police rounded on her. “Now, listen to me, Dawson,” Aguilar said, at point-blank range. “I’m tired of your bullshit. I’m tired of the attitude you get every time a superior officer looks at you cross-eyed. You seem to think this is all some kind of game meant for your personal amusement. Well, I can assure you, Detective, that it is not. I’m going to get a lot of heat on this from the press. I don’t want any mistakes.”
Mistakes, from the captain’s perspective, were costly. They tended to reduce the amount of good will and political capital the mayor had built up with the public, and that translated into fewer votes at the ballot box. Kate knew exactly what he meant, and the thought filled her with enough rage to kill anyone above the rank of lieutenant. The reassuring nod from Miller helped her to push it back down inside.
“Hear that, Clark?” whispered Jawara, “No mistakes.”
“I wasn’t planning on making any mistakes, but then, with you as a partner, who knows?” Clark replied.
The forensics team had just finished unpacking the Leica ScanStation C-12, and was preparing to deploy the three-dimensional laser scanner. Kate often thought that it was one of the most useful forensic tools the SFPD employed for processing a crime scene, and she wondered how the department had gotten along without it all these years. She knew this next-generation device allowed investigators to capture trace evidence like fingerprints, hair and skin totally and completely in about a third of the time that it used to take before. It stood about six feet high on a tripod, and looked like a souped-up motion picture camera.
Annoyed by the unprofessional byplay, Miller picked up one of the threads of the investigation, and asked, “Were there any witnesses?”
“None of the neighbors heard or saw anything,” Lt. Roberts responded. “My men are still out canvassing the neighborhood, but I seriously doubt they’ll turn anything up. People live in the Heights for a reason. Their privacy.”
“Who discovered the body?” Miller persisted.
“The housekeeper,” said Clark, referring to his notes. “She came in about an hour ago, and found him.”
“Do you think we could have a word with her?” Dawson asked, finally joining the investigation. “She may have seen or heard something that might be useful.”
“She’s not a live-in,” Clark reported.
Lt. Roberts shook his head. “You’ll have to talk to her later. She was so hysterical when she found the body, the EMTs had to sedate her and take her down to County for observation.”
“Probably a dead-end anyway,” Dawson said, sighing.
The laser scanner was ready to run. “Could I get all of you to move to one side?” asked one of the crime-scene boys.
Aguilar led his men over to the stairs, took a few steps up, and turned to look down on them. “Well, if that’s all you and your men have for me, Roberts, then I’d be remiss in my duties wasting any more of my time here,” he said, sounding overly pompous. He brushed off his suit and straightened his tie. “I’ll do what I can to save your miserable jobs by saying something brilliant to the press about the investigation. But you and your men had better come up with a suspect, and fast, or I’ll be demanding your resignations by the end of the month.”
The assistant chief of police turned back around and headed up the stairs to the living room and the waiting press. After a moment of silence, Dawson, Clark and Jawara all breathed a collective sigh of relief.
“What an asshole,” Jawara exclaimed.
“I’ve always wondered what happened to cops who couldn’t cut it in Homicide,” said Clark, hitting the stairs.
“They get a degree in criminal justice, and end up playing eighteen holes of golf with the mayor and the chief of police,” Dawson replied, right behind him.
“More like losing eighteen holes of golf,” Jawara corrected her, following. “His head couldn’t be any further up the mayor’s ass.”
“And what about the way he jumped all over you wh
en the name Westmore was brought up?” Clark said.
“He’s definitely hiding something,” Dawson concluded. “I don’t know what it is, but I’ll almost bet it has something to do with this case.”
A voice echoed down from above. “Are you finished . . . ?”
They all turned their gaze upward to see Aguilar standing at the top of the stairs, nostrils flaring, hands on his hips. The three detectives sheepishly marched by him in single file, and then fell into formation. Frank suppressed a smile. Whatever Aguilar had to say to them was inconsequential next to the humiliation of being overhead while talking about him. They were like three schoolboys who had been caught by their righteous headmaster with their pants down around their ankles, pissing in the wind. No punishment in the world was worse than getting caught doing something wrong.
At the bottom of the stairs, the lieutenant reached across the width of his body, and took Frank’s arm. “This is a really bad one,” Roberts said. “We’ve got some maniac out there who thinks he’s the Marquis de Sade, and we’re going to have to put our differences aside and work together if we plan to stop him before he kills again.”
“Agreed,” Miller said.
“I was thinking about having Ramirez work with the lab boys running a trace on Collins’s phone records, computer files . . . you know, see what comes up.”
“Put Clark on it,” Miller suggested. “He’s far more detail-oriented than Ramirez, and he has a much stronger background with computers and technology, in general, than anyone else in the department.”
Lt. James Roberts made a note.
“Besides, that’ll free up Ramirez to get more face time talking with witnesses and potential suspects,” Miller continued. “I’d partner him with Jawara, and send them out to get statements from the ex-wife, co-workers, employees, friends . . . You know, beat the bushes, and see what crawls out.”