of God (with his father’s blessing, no less), you know
that a hundred years too late, the truth has come to collect its revenge.
Soon the facts will prove that William H. Bonney did
not die in 1881 in Fort Sumner, New Mexico. He and
his bloodline lived on. This country has been living in
denial for years. And it is because of this veil of ignorance that nine people are dead, with another young
woman fighting for her life.
If there is any justice in the world, if the truth is
The Guilty
327
regulated at all, then the entire citizenry of New Mexico, Texas and all those who convinced themselves that
the nightmare was over will wake up to the violent reality and confront a demon who manifested himself
right here, today.
Never had Paulina seen such an outraged reaction from a
“concerned” group of citizens. But to her surprise, many of
the protesters were from far outside the delusions of Texas
and New Mexico, and the sandblasted states who perpetrated
the myth. She’d only received about twenty messages from
Fort Sumner, ten or so from Hico and Lincoln County, but the
vast majority were from New Yorkers, Californians. She had
even received harsh rebukes from several members of
Congress, writing to say that at best her article was in poor
taste, and at worst a selfish attempt to discredit one of the most
enduring legends in history.
She didn’t bother to respond to the irony of calling a mass
murderer an “enduring legend,” but therein, she supposed, was
the point.
William H. Bonney, despite his violent history, was now
considered a hero, a vigilante, a romantic icon. And having
read the dozens of articles about William Henry Roberts’s
deadly spree, she knew that more than a fair share of “concerned citizens” considered him the same way. Roberts was
a bandit, an outlaw. And like Bonney’s Regulators years ago,
he was purging the landscape of those who poisoned the well.
Yet unlike other articles she’d written that had stirred up
controversy, there was no joy at the Dispatch at the prospect
of increased circulation. There were no high fives in the hall
or talk about holiday bonuses. Nobody from senior management had stopped by Paulina’s office to congratulate her on
328
Jason Pinter
a terrific story. In fact, nobody had come by at all. And if there
was one thing that frightened Paulina more than anything, it
was silence.
Ordinarily she might respond to one or more complainants, just for kicks. But today she merely forwarded all the
messages to their PR department. They’d be earning their paychecks this week. Then one e-mail popped up in her in-box
that made her forget all the others.
The sender was Ted Allen. The subject heading read We
need to talk.
She took a deep breath before opening the message.
…hurts the credibility of our newspaper…
…true or not the Dispatch had been placed under a mag nifying glass…
…witch hunt…
…my mother grew up in Texas…this is akin to pissing on
the Pope’s grave…
He requested her presence in his office in fifteen minutes.
The Dispatch’ s legal team and PR department would be on
hand. She had no doubt her job would be safe, but this fire
had to be handled with extreme caution.
Henry had gotten away clean. She couldn’t mention his
name. If the public found out she’d received information from
a reporter at a rival paper, the Dispatch would lose its credibility faster than Jack O’Donnell downed a shot of whiskey.
Take credit for your successes, take credit for your mistakes,
hope the former outweighed the latter.
Paulina picked up her phone, dialed James Keach’s extension.
“Ms. Cole?”
“Where is Henry Parker right now?”
The Guilty
329
“I…I don’t know. Work, I assume?”
“Find him. Then call me. You have half an hour.”
She hung up, stood up, smoothed out her skirt and headed
for Ted Allen’s office.
54
There was no stopping it; the juggernaut had begun
lurching forward. Reports stated that the Dispatch was receiving more complaints and hate mail than at any point in
the last ten years. The most since they ran a story about a
presidential candidate paying off a cocktail waitress with
whom he’d had an affair. The complaints weren’t about the
story, of course, but of a photo on page one in which readers
claimed they could see more than fifty-one percent of her
left butt cheek.
Nobody ever said people didn’t have their priorities straight.
The gossip websites and blogs claimed that Ted Allen was
considering canning Paulina Cole. They paid her to piss
people off, under the maxim that controversy created cash,
but now it looked like she’d pissed off too many people who
spent the cash. Challenging an American legend, as well as
asserting that a beloved (and deceased) clergyman had an extramarital affair, was too much to handle.
The story on William Henry Roberts was out. It was public.
And despite the protests and pitchfork-waving townsfolk,
there would be inquiries. There would be investigations. This
kind of scandal could not be covered up.
The Guilty
331
When I got to my desk my voice-mail light was blinking.
I checked it; it was from Largo Vance.
“Hey, Henry, I don’t know how she got it or why, but I have
a feeling I have you to thank for Paulina’s story, you little
devil you. With any luck those pussies in D.C. will have no
choice but to exhume the proper body this time. If they screw
this one up they’ll have more important people than yours
truly to answer to. Anyway, the wool’s been pulled down
long enough. Now catch that Roberts prick and then give me
a call. I have an unopened bottle of Johnnie Walker Blue with
your name on it.”
Before I could hang up the phone I saw a shadow hovering
over my desk.
“Hey, Jack,” I said.
“Hey yourself. So, read any good stories today?”
“I just got in a minute ago. Why, is something breaking?”
“Something already broke,” Jack said. He opened up a leather
valise and pulled out a copy of today’s Dispatch. I’d passed it
on the way to work but didn’t bother to buy a copy. I knew what
would be on the front page, and ignoring some basic sentence
structure I was pretty sure I knew exactly how the article would
read. Jack opened it, spread the paper across my desk.
Looking back at me in a salacious full two-page spread
were the glistening veneers of Mark Rheingold, a faded
family portrait of John Henry and Meryl Roberts with their
two young children, and a photo of Ollie P. “Brushy Bill”
Roberts at the deathbed of the man claiming to be Jesse
James.
The headline read: Sex, Murder, And The Gun That Won
The West.
Not Paulina’s finest hour as far as headlines we
nt, but
she more than made up for it with the story. I scanned it
332
Jason Pinter
quickly while Jack stood there. She covered all the important bases: Mark Rheingold’s affair with Meryl Roberts, the
fact that John Henry likely knew about it and approved.
And their son William’s disgust at the shaming of Billy the
Kid’s legacy.
“You have any idea where Paulina got these leads?” Jack
asked. “Seemed to me you were on top of this story a week
ago, and all of a sudden Jackie Collins is scooping you.”
I held up my hand, still sutured together. “In case you forgot,
I had a bit of an altercation a few days ago. Oh yeah, my ex is
in intensive care. Oh yeah, and I broke it off with Amanda. So
pardon me if I’ve been off my game for a few days.”
“Come on, kid, I don’t buy that for a second. Don’t get me
wrong, I’m not saying you haven’t had, you know, stuff on your
mind, but the day you get scooped on your own story is the
day I start drinking wine coolers and dating British women.”
“What do you want me to say?”
Jack looked me in the eyes. I held his gaze, unsure how to
respond. Then he stepped back.
“You don’t need to say anything. I know what you did.”
“Really? What’s that?”
“Doesn’t matter. I understand why you did it. But if you
ever fucking do it again, I don’t care if you’re Bob Woodward
the second or spawn of Jimmy Breslin and Ann Coulter, I’ll
stuff your body down the trash compactor and make sure you
never work at this newspaper again. Understand me?”
“I don’t know what you’re talking about.”
“Of course not. Glad to see you understand. If Wallace
asks—which he will—tell him exactly what you told me.”
“I will.”
“And Henry,” Jack said, his eyes growing soft. I’d never
seen the man show a tender side, and it unnerved me. “I want
The Guilty
333
you to know I’m sorry about Amanda and Mya. I know I said
some things a while back, I don’t know how much you
actually listened to and how much you passed off as the loony
ramblings of an old idiot, but everyone lives their life differently. I never found the same kind of happiness a lot of others
have, but that doesn’t mean what I did is the right way to live.”
“Right or wrong, you made a career to be proud of.”
A small choking sound came from Jack’s chest.
He said, “You know what I consider the best story I ever
wrote, Henry?”
“It wasn’t Michael DiForio?”
Jack laughed. “No offense to the guy who tried to rub you
out, but not even close. No, it was February third, 1987. Not
just because that’s the day Liberace died—not a lot of people
paying attention to human interest stories that day—but I
wrote a piece about a woman in Nebraska who’d lost her
husband to cancer and her son to a carjacking. Childless and
widowed at forty-one. She’d never worked a day in her life,
and suddenly decided to join the police force, and became a
cadet on her forty-second birthday. Her name was Patti
Ramona, and I remember she told me that if she saved just
one life doing her job, if she prevented one family from going
through what she went through, then their deaths wouldn’t
sting so much.”
Jack coughed into his hand.
“A week after the article came out, I got a letter from a man
in Idaho, Robert something, his name escapes me. Robert had
lost his wife and daughter and had been dying of loneliness
for a decade. Robert told me the moment he finished reading
my story he went out and became a volunteer firefighter. He
said thanks to Patti he knew his life could still have a purpose.
You see what I’m saying, Henry? You don’t need a whole city
334
Jason Pinter
to remember you. If you make your mark on just one person,
change one life for the better, that’s the noblest thing you can
ever do. It’s easy to be a celebrity. It’s harder to actually mean
something.”
He clapped me on the shoulder and left without saying
another word. I watched him turn the corner and disappear.
And then I was alone.
Sitting at my desk, my mind was blank. I didn’t know
what to write about. I stared down at the paper Jack had left
on my desk. My phone was silent. E-mail inbox empty. I had
a sudden and terrible feeling of déjà vu, remembering walking
the streets of Manhattan after Mya had been attacked a year
ago. Getting drunk and hoping the needle in a haystack would
cross my path. I remembered the anger and sadness, a dangerously potent mixture. I felt that way now.
It was easier when there was a story. Something to focus
on, something to prevent my mind from wandering. But right
now all I could focus on was that emptiness. And hope it
didn’t consume me.
And suddenly everything changed.
I saw Wallace running from his office down the hall.
Evelyn followed from Metro, her short legs having trouble
keeping up. Then two more got up and ran after them. Frank
Rourke ran past my desk. I grabbed his shirtsleeve.
“What’s going on? Where’s everybody running to?”
“Anonymous tip just came in, there’s a hostage situation
going down. Some maniac took a girl.”
“Where?” I asked.
“Downtown,” he said. “199 Water Street.” Then he ran
off.
I couldn’t breathe. 199 Water Street. That building housed
the New York Legal Aid Society. Where Amanda worked.
The Guilty
335
But the stringers…there was no police activity.Yet everyone
at the news desk knew about it. What the hell was happening?
My heart racing, I picked up the phone and dialed Curt
Sheffield’s cell phone. He picked up, said, “This is Sheffield.”
“Curt, it’s Henry. Have you heard anything about a hostage
situation down on Water Street?”
“That’s a negative, nothing’s come over the radio, and I’m
downtown right now so I would’ve heard something. Why,
what’s going on?”
“I don’t know,” I said. “Somebody called in an anonymous
tip about a hostage in the building where Amanda works. But
if it hasn’t been reported to the cops yet… I’ll call you back.”
I hung up, dialed Amanda’s number at the office. We hadn’t
spoken in days. I didn’t know how she’d sound, what to expect,
but I needed to know what was happening, that she was all right.
I regained my breath when the line picked up and I heard
Amanda’s voice say, “New York Legal Aid Society, this is
Amanda.”
“Amanda, it’s me.”
“Henry…hi…”
“Listen, is everything okay over there?”
“Of course it is, what do you mean?”
“Are you in trouble? Have you seen or heard anything
strange?”
“Other than your calling me just now, I was having a pretty
&
nbsp; uneventful day.”
“Thank God.”
“Thank God I was having an uneventful day?”
“No, not that at all, I…well, yeah…I’m just glad you’re safe.”
“Safe? Why wouldn’t I be? If there’s something I should
know—”
336
Jason Pinter
And that’s when I heard a woman scream over the phone,
followed by a gunshot so loud it rattled my teeth. I recognized
that sound. I’d heard it this week. It was the sound of a Winchester rifle. William Henry Roberts was in Amanda’s office.
“Amanda? Amanda! What’s happening? ”
“Oh God, Henry, there’s someone here— help us! ”
The line went dead.
I leapt up, heart hammering. I had to get down there.
Everyone was piling out the door, going to the scene of the
crime.
And then it hit me, just what he’d done.
He called us. William Roberts.
You write about history. I am history.
55
At first Amanda thought that the sound of shattering glass
came from outside. A construction crew had been tearing
up the building across the street for what seemed like a
decade, and anything more than a dropped pen in their
office was cause for excitement. But then she recognized
Darcy’s high-pitched voice as she screamed for help, and
Amanda knew that whatever was happening was happening terrifyingly close.
Then she heard the gunshot, a blast so loud it seemed to
shatter the air, and for a moment she heard nothing but ringing
in her ears. When her hearing returned, Amanda heard Henry
on the line.
“Amanda? Amanda, what’s happening? ”
She didn’t know what she said next, or if she said anything
at all, but suddenly Amanda was scrambling away from her
desk, trying to bide her time while figuring out what the hell
was going on.
She crouched down, surveyed the office.
Their suite housed three shared offices and one large conference room, as well as a smaller waiting room by the elevator.
The waiting room door was made of glass. The others were
338
Jason Pinter
metal. She immediately knew that the breaking glass was the
sound of somebody crashing through the waiting room door.
She wondered how he’d gotten past the security guard
downstairs—waited until he’d gone on break? Or something
more horrible?
Oh God…
She heard another scream, someone yelled, “Get away
from me!” and then Amanda heard a loud thud like something
The Guilty (2008) Page 31