by Megan Chance
“Did she have control of her impulses?” Mr. Scott asked.
“Yes. Very much so.”
“Could she tell right from wrong?”
“Oh yes. Certainly.”
“Would you say that she would have understood the consequences of her actions?”
“Mr. Scott, she was as sane as you or I.”
“Could she have been clever enough to fool you?” Mr. Scott asked.
Dr. Little reddened. “I am a highly qualified physician, Mr. Scott, and she is only a woman.”
“Yes, of course. You’re saying there is no possibility at all that she could have been insane when she left Beechwood Grove?”
“None at all. I told you, we made excellent progress. When she left, she was in perfect health. I would stake my reputation on it.”
“So, in your considered opinion as a doctor who has treated Mrs. Carelton: Would you say she was in her right mind when she shot her husband?”
Dr. Little stared at me. I felt all the eyes in the jury box following his gaze. “Absolutely. Yes. I believe she knew exactly what she was doing when she killed her husband.”
I waited for Howe to protest. When he did not, I whispered in his ear, “How can you let him say such a thing?”
Howe gave me a quiet smile. Mr. Scott finished his questioning, and Howe’s expression was reassuring as he stood and went to the witness box.
“Dr. Little,” he said. “When Mrs. Carelton first came to see you, what results was she hoping for?”
“What results?”
“Yes. What did she want your treatment to provide?”
“She wanted her health to improve.”
“Would you say she was disturbed by her bouts of hysteria?”
“Oh yes. Very disturbed.”
“And she wanted profoundly to live a normal life as wife to her husband?”
“Yes.”
“Did you see any signs at all that she disliked her husband or was angry with him?”
“Not when I examined her.”
Howe nodded. He turned to the jury, and in a deeply dramatic voice, he said, “I see. So would you characterize Mrs. Carelton as a woman who wished to be rid of her ‘uterine monomania,’ and who wanted to find peace and contentment with her husband?”
“Yes,” Dr. Little said carefully. “That is how I would characterize her.”
“How was it that she came to be at Beechwood Grove, Doctor?”
“By carriage.”
Howe rolled his eyes and smiled. There was a snicker from the jury. “I meant under what circumstances.”
“She was committed for treatment.”
“Committed? Do you mean involuntarily so?”
“Well, yes,” Dr. Little said. “Her husband was very concerned.”
“In your opinion, was Mrs. Carelton happy about being taken to Beechwood Grove?”
“No.” Dr. Little took a deep breath. “But that is not unusual either. Many of our patients are so ill they don’t realize that Beechwood Grove is the best place for them.”
“Do most patients argue with you, Dr. Little?”
Little nodded. “Oh yes.”
“What was Mrs. Carelton’s argument?”
“She tried to tell me that her husband had made a terrible mistake, that she was, in fact, much better.”
“You didn’t believe that?”
“No. Given my previous diagnosis, that would have been very difficult to believe. Such stories are a common tactic among the insane. She also told me that Mr. Carelton had her committed because she embarrassed him.”
“How so?”
“She said he discovered that she was having an affair with her doctor.”
Another loud murmur. I squeezed my eyes shut.
“You didn’t believe her?”
“No sir, I did not. It is not at all uncommon for those suffering from monomania to experience delusions. Mr. Carelton had said she was behaving inappropriately, that there were several instances of reckless sexual behavior. He was very disturbed by it, but I know for a fact that he did not believe Mrs. Carelton was having an affair with her doctor. He told me so himself.”
“Tell me something, Dr. Little: Isn’t it true that Mrs. Carelton did not begin to make progress at your asylum until you brought in another doctor—a specialist who’d had some experience with women’s nervous disorders?”
Dr. Little frowned. “Why, yes.”
“How did Mrs. Carelton respond to his care?”
“Very well. Very quickly. We were all quite amazed.”
“Amazed enough to begin utilizing some of his techniques yourself?”
Dr. Little nodded. “Yes. We’ve had good results.”
“Could you describe this treatment?”
“Hypnosis,” Dr. Little said. He leaned forward as if sensing the need to defend himself. “I know it seems odd, but it’s been remarkable, how well it can be used for cases of Mrs. Carelton’s type.”
Howe nodded. “You told us earlier that Mrs. Carelton was quite sane when she left Beechwood Grove, isn’t that so?”
“Yes, yes.”
“And you would attribute that sanity to this doctor?”
“Why, yes,” Dr. Little said, but warily, as if he had begun to smell something unpleasant.
Again Howe turned to the jury, raising his voice so it echoed against the smoke-stained ceiling. “What was the name of that doctor?”
“Victor Seth.”
There was more than a murmur. There were hushed whispers, nudging, shuffling feet. I kept my gaze on William Howe, on Dr. Little. I didn’t dare turn around for fear of what the reporters might see on my face.
“Were you aware, Dr. Little, that Victor Seth was the same doctor Mrs. Carelton had been seeing previously? The one who was with her in Newport, the one who treated her in New York City, the one she claimed to have had an affair with?”
“Objection!” Scott was on his feet. The judge waved him quiet.
Dr. Little looked genuinely shocked. “No,” he said. “He never said anything. She never said—”
“He had good results, you say?”
“Yes, yes.” Dr. Little was pale.
“She was not insane when she left Beechwood Grove?”
“No.” It was a whisper.
Howe smiled as he turned from the witness box. He made a dismissive gesture. “That is all.”
“Tomorrow it’s our turn,” Howe said, settling into a chair in my parlor. He smiled, and I smiled nervously back.
“Who will you call first?” I asked him.
“Your father,” he said, and then he slanted me an assessing glance. “Are you worried?”
I shook my head. “There’s nothing he could say that I haven’t already heard.”
“After that I’ll call your friend Millicent Wallace.”
I was almost afraid to say the words. “And then . . . Victor?”
“Ah yes, Victor Seth.” Howe sighed. “You must tell me something, Mrs. Carelton, and I want the truth.”
“Of course.” I waved my hand at him. “Whatever you want.”
“Were the things you told Dr. Little true? Were you having an affair with your doctor?”
I couldn’t look at him.
“Forgive my bluntness: Were you intimate with him?”
I nodded.
Howe went still. I felt him watching me. Then he said, “Did your husband know this?”
I took a deep breath. “You remember the ‘incident’ I told you about?”
“Yes.”
“William discovered us . . . together.”
Howe looked so somber—which was hard enough to do, given the bright orange-and-green-checked vest he wore—that I found myself embellishing my story. “I believe now that it wasn’t what William believed. It wasn’t even what I believed.”
“How so?”
“When we first . . . when Victor and I . . . I think he believed that our . . . intimacy was a kind of treatment, that it would help me be hea
lthy again.” I looked at the wall, at the painting that had hung there as long as I could remember, Saint Beatrix with her face turned to the light, to truth, to God. “I may have . . . mistaken things.”
“Is that why you shot your husband, Mrs. Carelton? To be with Dr. Seth?”
I stared at him. “I don’t know why I shot my husband, Mr. Howe, I’ve already told you that.”
He shook his head chidingly. “The truth, Mrs. Carelton.”
“That is the truth,” I lied. “It is the only truth I know.”
My father took the stand with the dignity that had sustained him throughout this entire ordeal. I could spot strands of gray in his hair that had not been there before, and new lines in his face. He was wearing stark black, as if he were in mourning, and I suppose he was. The only question was for whom: me or William.
I tried not to think such ungracious thoughts. He had done everything for me since I’d been arrested. He had hired William Howe; he had defended me staunchly to every paper in the city and to all our friends. But I could not rid myself of the feeling that I would pay for this later, that he would extract his pound of flesh for standing by me.
He spoke slowly, as if his words were weighted, as if his sorrows were too great to be borne. “Lucy was a sensitive child. From the time she was very young, her mother and I worried over her. She formed such quick attachments. It wasn’t normal.”
“Quick attachments, Mr. Van Berckel?” Howe asked. “What exactly do you mean?”
“First there was religion. Now, we went to church, you understand—we’re good Episcopalians, we’ve a pew at Saint Thomas now, and Grace Church before that—but Lucy took it too far. She fancied she would join a nunnery when she was old enough. She wasted away to nothing, praying all the time, fasting. It was distressing.”
“What came of that?”
“Eventually she outgrew it. Then she took on poetry. It was the same thing all over again. And then it was painting. She was delirious with it. I feared for her health, which was always fragile.”
“I see. Your daughter was often ill?”
“Yes. She suffered headaches and aches and pains from the time she was a girl.”
“Even into her marriage?”
Papa’s face was grief-stricken. “It seemed to grow worse then.”
“Why do you think that was?”
“I don’t know.” Papa took a deep breath. “I talked to her often. I urged her to find happiness in her marriage, in her duties as a wife.”
Howe frowned. “She was unhappy being a wife?”
Papa waved his hand dismissively. “No, not as you’d think. It was simply that she was not good at keeping a house. She often had trouble with servants.”
“Why do you think that was?”
“It was due to her health.”
Howe nodded sympathetically. He looked more like a compassionate friend than a lawyer. His voice was somber and quiet when he said, “Were you worried for her, Mr. Van Berckel?”
“Worried? Well, yes, I was.”
“Why was that?”
Papa seemed confused. “She was my daughter.”
“But there was another reason you were worried, wasn’t there, Mr. Van Berckel?”
Papa hesitated, then said reluctantly, “Yes. Lucy was—Lucy is—very like her mother.”
“Is Mrs. Van Berckel still alive?”
“No. No. She died twenty years ago.”
“How was Mrs. Carelton like her mother?” Howe went on.
“Irene was fragile herself,” Papa said slowly. “She was often melancholy. I blame myself for her death.”
“You blame yourself for her death? How can that be?”
Papa lowered his head. “I was not as gentle with her as I should have been. She was unhappy.”
“How did Mrs. Van Berckel die?”
“She drowned,” Papa said.
“How so?”
Papa said nothing. The jury murmured among themselves. The crowd grew restless. Judge Hammond looked up sternly. Howe waited one horrible second before he said, “Isn’t it true that Mrs. Van Berckel—your wife, Mrs. Carelton’s mother—took her own life?”
Someone—Daisy Hadden, I thought—gasped. My father squeezed his eyes shut. For a moment I thought he would deny it; it was too damning, too irredeemable. But he sighed and said, “Yes.”
“When your daughter married William Carelton, did you warn him of this unfortunate defect in her heritage?”
“Yes. I told him he must treat her with the utmost care. As if she were a child.”
“And did he?”
“William was possessed of great energy. I thought he would be good for Lucy. I see now that he couldn’t possibly know how to handle her.” Papa didn’t look at me as he spoke. He knew, as I did, that William had done exactly what Papa had said, that he had treated me just that way: like a child. Papa had finally taken my side against William. I should have been glad, but the truth was, it was too late. I no longer needed Papa, and I felt a bitter sorrow that William should be maligned like this by the one man who had supported him unconditionally. “I was . . . sorry . . . that I had allowed her to marry him.”
“Why was that?”
Papa said, “He didn’t have the right background.”
“You mean he was not of your class.”
“Yes.”
“Hmmm. I’m curious, Mr. Van Berckel. Why did you allow your daughter to marry so clearly beneath her?”
“I made a deal with the devil,” Papa whispered. He clasped his hands together, fat fingers squeezing tight. “I’m not happy about it, but William made me a great deal of money when I needed it. I was . . . grateful.”
“Grateful enough to give him your daughter?”
Papa’s cheeks flushed in anger. “If she had not loved him, I wouldn’t have. But she did.”
“I see.” Howe stroked his chin thoughtfully. “She loved him to her detriment, wouldn’t you say?”
“I’m not sure what you mean.”
“Yes, I’m sure you don’t, Mr. Van Berckel,” Howe said. Before Papa could protest, he went on. “Do you know the circumstances that sent Mrs. Carelton to Beechwood Grove?”
“William told me that she had made a scene in Newport, then had taken an overdose of laudanum. She had done that before, and I was worried. When he said he wanted to commit her to the asylum, I agreed that it would be best.”
“An asylum seems a drastic solution. Wasn’t it?”
“As I said, I was worried. Lucy had been acting strangely. She wasn’t herself.”
“What do you mean by that?”
“She had always been so biddable, and now she was not.”
“Did you discuss this with her husband?”
“Yes.”
“What did he say?”
“That Lucy was under the care of a doctor. That she was improving. The doctor had said she might go through a phase of this kind, and we were not to be concerned.”
“But you were concerned.”
“Yes.”
“Because your daughter was not so frail, or so ill, or so biddable?”
Papa squirmed. I looked down to hide a smile I couldn’t control.
“You haven’t answered the question, Mr. Van Berckel.”
“She was not herself,” he said. “I agreed with William that she should have a rest.”
“In an asylum?”
“Yes.”
“Did William tell you that he feared she was having an affair with the very doctor who said she was going through a phase?”
“No,” Papa said. He looked stonily at me. “He said nothing of the kind.”
When Millie came to the stand, she supported Papa’s contentions. I had been a frail child with an intense imagination; I carried things too far; I made myself ill with my yearnings.
“She fairly threw herself into things,” she said. The peacock feathers in her bright blue hat bobbed against her cheekbone. “For example, when she began decorating for their new
house, she had the clerks at Goupil’s in a frenzy.”
“Their new house? The same new house she didn’t care for?” Howe’s expression was exaggeratedly puzzled.
“Yes, at first that was true,” Millie said. “We were all surprised she didn’t seem to be excited about it. But then that changed. She was intent on finding the right things for it.”
“Why do you suppose that is?”
“Because William asked her to,” she said. “And she was determined to please him.”
“Was this usual for Mrs. Carelton? Did she often attend to her husband’s desires so wholeheartedly?”
Millie hesitated. “In most cases. She did long for William’s approval.”
“Were you at Newport this summer, the same time Mrs. Carelton was there?”
“Yes,” Millie said.
“Did you observe her with Dr. Seth?”
Millie was holding a blue beaded bag. She fidgeted with the clasp. “Yes. I did.”
“Did it seem innocent to you?”
“No.”
“What did you believe was their relationship?”
“In the beginning I assumed they were having an affair.” Millie reddened. “But then I talked to Lucy about it, and she confessed that he was her doctor and had come to attend her during the summer.”
“Did you believe that?”
“I wanted to.”
“Did you have any evidence otherwise?”
“No,” she said.
“Did you think that Mrs. Carelton was better under Dr. Seth’s care?”
“Yes,” she said. “She seemed much better.”
“Mrs. Wallace, did you think that Mrs. Carelton was happy?”
Millie frowned at him. “Happy?”
“Yes, happy. Was she happy with her husband? With her life?”
Millie looked at me, her eyes expressionless. “I think Lucy tried to be happy,” she said slowly. “But I don’t think she was. I don’t think she ever was.”
I breathed a sigh of relief when Millie was done, when it seemed that there would be no real surprises after all. The courtroom was quite warm; I was reaching for a handkerchief to wipe my brow when Howe went to the front of the courtroom. With a flourish of pure showmanship, he said, “Your Honor, I call Mrs. Wilhelm Brock to the stand.”
I abandoned the handkerchief in sudden wariness. Mrs. Wilhelm Brock? I’d never heard the name before; I had no idea who it could be.