"No, we used to see him all the time on the eleven o'clock news. He was the guy who was always blah-blah-ing about taxes. Hey, I'm against taxes like anybody else. But how else are you going to pay for the fire department and so forth? Are we all supposed to put our own fire out?"
"And Greg acknowledged to you that he was in fact having an affair with Assemblyman Louderbush?"
"Yeah, when I said Janie and I recognized him, Greg was cool with that. He said don't tell anybody, that Louderbush would just deny it, but that Louderbush was his boyfriend.
29
Red White and Black and Blue
by Richard Stevenson
Louderbush came to one of Greg's econ classes one time, and then he came onto him afterward, and they got started. Greg said he really admired the guy, and the fact that he was this big Republican was a real turn-on. I guess he thought Louderbush was attractive, too. I know if I was into guys, I wouldn't want some fifty-year-old old fart like that getting all over me."
"Sure."
"I'd want a young athlete. One time Janie and I tried a three-way with this college wrestler we met at a club, and that was kind of a turn-on for me. But the woman would've had to be there. Otherwise, what's the point?"
"How long did the relationship last between Louderbush and Stiver?"
"From fall till Greg killed himself in April. Greg was getting more and more upset and worried that he wasn't getting a teaching job or anything else coming down the pike. Then he had this asshole pounding on him every time Louderbush came over and they had a few drinks, and I guess he just cracked. You'd have to be pretty much at the end of your rope to get you to jump off of a building. I don't know how anybody could make themselves do that. It goes against all your instincts."
"So alcohol was an important part of the relationship between Stiver and Louderbush?"
"I think it was more Louderbush. He'd have to have a drink to loosen up, Greg said. Then they'd get it on, and then Louderbush would have another drink or two, and that's when he'd go off and get physical. At first, when we asked him 30
Red White and Black and Blue
by Richard Stevenson
about the crashing noises and the yelling, Greg would just say, no, there was no problem, that they just fell or something. Later on, he admitted what was really going on, and he said he tried to get Louderbush to cut it out. But he also said that deep down he was only getting what he needed. He said his old man beat him when he was a kid, and now apparently there was something in his psychology that made him like getting hurt by some man. He admitted that this was true."
"Was Greg in psychotherapy? It sounds as if he had some real understanding of why he put up with the way Louderbush treated him."
"Janie actually tried to get him to go, but he never would, I don't think."
The waitress arrived with our taco salads, and the old woman in the next booth said to her, "We would like to order now. We have been waiting for quite some time."
"Sorry. I'll be right with you."
"We got here before those two men did, and they already have their food."
The waitress, a squat, buxom young black woman, carefully ignored this. "I can take your order now. What would you like to order, ma'am?"
The couple proceeded to order eggs Benedict. The waitress explained that Denny's didn't have any of those, so then the couple decided to make do with a single grilled cheese sandwich served on two plates. After that was settled, I asked Jackman more questions.
31
Red White and Black and Blue
by Richard Stevenson
"Both you and your former girlfriend have told the McCloskey campaign that you believe Kenyon Louderbush drove Greg Stiver to suicide. That's a serious charge to make against anybody. Stiver was a grown-up. He was free to make choices. He could have told Louderbush to take a hike.
He could even have called the police and charged Louderbush with assault. He could have done a lot of things to get out of the mess he was in. Louderbush did not in fact shove Stiver off that building. You can attest that this was an abusive relationship, but that's a far as you can go, I think, when it comes to pinning anything on Kenyon Louderbush.
"If you are going to go public with this—as Tom Dunphy says you're willing to do—you might want to describe what you saw and heard, and you can of course relay what Greg told you about the relationship. But you can expect people to challenge your contention that Louderbush drove Greg Stiver to take his own life— drove is the word you seem determined to use—and you'll have to be ready for disagreements and other interpretations coming at you from many directions.
And a lot of people who disagree with you are going to act very hostile."
Jackman was cracking off portions of taco shell and gathering up little heaps of meat, lettuce, sauce, and sour cream, and shoveling it all into his large face. Through a mouthful of this stuff, he said, "I saw the suicide note."
"You did? How?"
"It was on the kitchen table. Mrs. Pensivy, the landlady, let us into Greg's apartment before the police came over.
32
Red White and Black and Blue
by Richard Stevenson
Somebody at SUNY called her. There was a note in Greg's handwriting on the table, and it said, 'I hurt too much.'"
"That's all it said?"
"Janie started to cry. Mrs. Pensivy, too."
"It didn't mention Kenyon Louderbush?"
"It didn't have to."
"What happened to the note?"
"The cops must have taken it."
"Did anyone else see it?"
"I wouldn't think so."
"Did Mrs. Pensivy know about the abuse?"
"Not as far as I know. She lived next door with her sister."
"Who else knew about the beatings?"
Jackman mulled this over. "Greg never said. But other people must have figured it out. At school, or his family. You could see the marks and what have you. He had a big shiner one time. Janie gave him a cube steak to press against it."
"Did Greg ever seek medical treatment that you know of?"
"Just from Janie and I. The cube steak."
"I thought people only treated black eyes with steak in the comics. Dagwood, or Nancy and Sluggo."
A puzzled look. "What are those? You mean like in newspapers?"
"Yes."
"My granddad still reads the Times Union most of the time.
Sports and what have you."
I supposed the couple in the next booth could have explained what the funny papers used to mean in American life, but the old man and the old woman were busy staring 33
Red White and Black and Blue
by Richard Stevenson
intently at each other's sagging midsections, and I didn't break their reverie and bring them into our discussion.
* * * *
[Back to Table of Contents] 34
Red White and Black and Blue
by Richard Stevenson
Chapter Three
"And I was like, I have to say something, and Kev was like, no you don't have to say anything, just let Virgil do it, cuz nobody's going to give him any shit, cuz he's a guy. But it just didn't seem right that if I know about this guy, I should just let him get elected governor of New York, and anyway maybe he still beats up on people. He could, you know, go after some young guy who works in his office—put the moves on him and then beat on him the way he did with Greg. My conscience would bother me if I didn't speak out, although I don't want my name mentioned, and I think you can understand the reason why."
"Tom Dunphy said it was for family and professional reasons."
"That's right. My parents would shit burritos if I did anything to mess up Kenyon Louderbush's chance to win the election. They think he's Jesus Walks on Water, and they don't know about the gay stuff or any of that. Also, at work it would not be appreciated if I got into some political thing.
That is strictly, like, no way."
"Where do
you work, Janie?"
"Walmart. I'm an assistant shift supervisor. I keep the associates happy and productive."
"I see."
We were seated in a booth at the bar at the Outback Steakhouse not far from the Wolf Road Denny's where I had my late lunch with Virgil Jackman. Insinger had gotten off 35
Red White and Black and Blue
by Richard Stevenson
work at four, and she was sipping some wacky concoction: half a tumbler of Red Bull, a shot of rum, and a cocktail onion bobbing in it. I was nursing a Sam Adams and eating too many peanuts coated with corn syrup shellac.
It was hard to imagine Insinger supervising the impoverished geezers and laid-off math teachers at Walmart who wandered the aisles hanging red sale tags of $7.99 on garments sewn on the outskirts of Kunming for twenty-five cents each. With her croaky voice and cuzes and was likes, Insinger seemed like an implausible boss lady at a company famed for both cracking the whip and inspiring near-religious awe in its employees. Her deficiencies may have been compensated for to some extent by her appearance. Insinger was a knockout, both svelte and sweetly busty, with a pert nose, large hazel eyes and a lower lip the size of a kielbasa.
She was done up in the tart-wear that the young routinely leave home in now, making little distinction between going to work and attending a backroom sex club. It had been a while since I had generated a physical response to a body of the opposite sex, but there was something about Insinger's appearance and her perfume—peony bloom?—that combined to have me shifting in my seat. Until, that is, she opened her mouth again.
"So I was like, hey, if I can't personally screw over this dickhead senator and keep my job, I can at least make sure somebody else does it. After all, the guy's practically a murderer. Don't you agree?"
36
Red White and Black and Blue
by Richard Stevenson
"In a sense, yes, if what you say is true. What is it exactly that you are saying? What did you see and hear that led you to make this accusation?"
She hesitated. "First, I have to ask you something."
"Okay."
"Are you, like, recording this conversation?"
"No, I'm not."
"I'm only asking because my boss says to be careful about that type of situation. You can never be sure, she says. You should always just figure that somebody might be wearing a wire."
"Your boss at Walmart told you this? Or do you also work for the Central Intelligence Agency?"
"No, of course not. But it could be the government or some lawyer who's gonna sue the company."
I said, "Even if I was recording our conversation, might that not actually be helpful to you? In case there's any confusion later on about what you said to me."
Insinger slurped up some of her scarlet refreshment and glanced around the room. No one was seated nearby, and the few people in other booths and at the bar seemed to be taking no notice of us.
"It's just that...this whole thing is making me kind of nervous. Oh, I know, I know. This was my idea. I was the one who called up. But, like, this guy is a senator. Those people do not appreciate getting screwed over."
"Assemblymen don't have their own militias or goon squads. I wouldn't worry about that."
37
Red White and Black and Blue
by Richard Stevenson
"No, I mean they can just pick up the phone. And then all of a sudden your income tax is overdue or your car insurance is no good. I know a girl who crossed this dude who works for the Albany water department, and now she gets speeding tickets all the time."
"It's up to you whether or not you want to go ahead with this, Janie. I've already got Virgil's version of events. It would be helpful, though, if you would just confirm or maybe add something to what I've already been told. I understand that you and Virgil were Greg Stiver's neighbors on Allen Street."
She nodded.
"And you knew Greg casually?"
"Yeah."
"You rode out to SUNY with him twice a week?"
"Yeah. But wait a minute. I have to ask you something."
"Go ahead."
"Did Virgil badmouth me?"
"No, he spoke of you with tender affection."
She laughed. "You're a freakin' liar."
"Okay. He said you left him for a woman, and that you were a lot of trouble."
"I did not leave him for a woman. I left him because he was always trying to get another guy into bed with us. I did it one time, and then I got creeped out. I think Virgil has some issues he hasn't worked out. Anyway, Lori Wroble is my friend, not my girlfriend."
"Either would be okay in my book."
"I've tried gay sex, sure, but something was definitely missing. Not with Lori, I don't mean. I prefer guys, and I 38
Red White and Black and Blue
by Richard Stevenson
started to wonder if maybe Virgil does too. God, should I be mentioning this?"
"Up to you. But I'm mainly interested in Greg Stiver and his relationship with Kenyon Louderbush."
She rolled her eyes. "Now Greg, that poor guy was totally gay. What I didn't get was, a guy that attractive, why didn't he have a nice boyfriend his own age, somebody who treated him with respect? Greg was kind of straight—I don't mean sexually—but very sort of... serious. He was very political.
Very conservative. He had a lot to say about that stuff if you gave him half a chance. Sometimes in the car I would just, like, tune out. It was blabbedy-blah, blabbedy-blah. Bush was driving the country into an economic ditch. Bush was! And Bush was a Republican! I hate to think what Greg would say about Obama. Oh my God."
"Apparently it was Louderbush's and Greg's politics that were part of the attraction the two had for each other. Was that your impression?"
"I guess so. Why else would Greg get involved with an older man? Especially a guy who was married with kids? But it was also, like, low self-esteem. Greg told us about how his dad used to beat on him when he was a kid. And when Mr.
Louderbush pounded him around, this was just what he was used to and even had it coming. It was really sad. Greg was one mixed-up puppy."
I asked Insinger about the pattern of abuse as she had heard it through the walls of her adjoining apartment and as Greg had described it to her and Jackman.
39
Red White and Black and Blue
by Richard Stevenson
"It was always kind of late," she said. "Virgil and I would be studying or chilling out or whatever, and we'd hear them going at it. Yelling and banging around and breaking stuff.
Sometimes we talked about going over or even calling the cops. We waited, though—we decided to mind our own business—and then we asked Greg about it one day, and at first he said oh no, nothing was going on, don't get your thong in an uproar. Then later he finally did admit they were fighting, but he told us to never mind, he would be okay. He was afraid of getting Louderbush in trouble, I could tell."
"Afraid?"
"Well, yeah. I mean, Louderbush was this extremely successful big hotshot. If Greg ruined his life or told his wife or put it on Facebook or something, who knows what might happen?"
"Did he say Louderbush threatened him?"
Insinger picked up a shiny peanut and popped it into her mouth. "No. He never said that straight out." She glanced around the bar, and so did I. Nobody was within earshot of us, and nobody seemed to be paying us any attention.
"When the two men were yelling at each other, were you ever able to make out anything anyone said?"
"Hmm. One time somebody screamed, 'You can eat shit!' I think it was Louderbush. It was a lot of that kind of drunk yelling. They'd get liquored up and start in. I have to say, I'm a little surprised Greg didn't defend himself more. Senator Louderbush was big and strong, Greg said, but he was older, too. Virgil asked Greg one time if he ever hit Louderbush back, and Greg just said no, it was a sin to hit a Republican.
40
Red White and Black and Blue
<
br /> by Richard Stevenson
He was being funny, but I think he really was, like, kind of scared to get in this guy's face. Maybe he'd get Greg kicked out of SUNY or his degree would be a blank sheet of paper or something."
"Did Greg ever talk about taking his own life?"
Insinger grew thoughtful. "I don't know."
"I mean to you or Virgil."
"Sometimes he said he was worn out."
"Uh-huh."
"He'd be really, really tired, and he'd have this kind of what's-the-use? attitude. But then a couple of days later he'd be, like, oh-fine. Right before he died, Greg was really down in one of his moods. A total mope-head. But that was mainly because he got turned down by two colleges for teaching jobs. One in Connecticut, one out near Rochester, which was his first choice. He didn't know what he was going to do after he got his master's, and he had these huge student loans. I was a senior then, and I knew how he felt, though this was before Obama fucked up the economy, and five years ago there were still jobs in retailing, thank God. Virgil and I both got jobs right after we graduated and got into management career tracks. Today we'd both be, like, out selling our butts on a street corner in Arbor Hill."
"Assemblyman Louderbush represents a district near Rochester. Was Greg hoping to live near him?"
"Oh. He didn't say. But he wouldn't have said anything.
Not to Virgil and me. He knew we disapproved and that we thought the relationship was self-destructive for Greg."
I said, "I understand you saw the suicide note."
41
Red White and Black and Blue
by Richard Stevenson
"Yeah. It was so sad. I cried. Even Virgil teared up. Mrs.
Pensivy cried her heart out."
"The landlady."
"She lived next door, but she let us in before the cops came. Somebody called her who she knew at SUNY."
"And the note said—what was it?"
"'I hurt too much.' So sad, so sad."
"And you recognized Greg's handwriting?"
"Yeah."
Red White and Black and Blue Page 3